Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WTF has happened to Mumsnet?

267 replies

Humblebottomous · 29/10/2023 08:45

First we had troll posts, then massive influx of posters from the US (frankly I found it annoying negotiating the different reference points) and now all these ridiculous AI threads which seem to consist of long winded posts about non-problems.

I’ve been on and off MN for years but does anyone else feel it really has had it’s day.

OP posts:
Copperoliverbear · 31/10/2023 07:25

I can't stand it that you have to write want they want from a long list in the bar to post,and mostly I can't find what I want to talk about so have to write 30 days.
Please get rid of this nonsense and let us write our own topic

Yellowishstone · 31/10/2023 07:17

I've been here on and off since 2012 and some things have changed but that's going to happen in a decade.

There were always complaints about how nasty posters were and how it used to be so different and it was never massively different. And posters always have someone or something to blame for MN being shit at times and seeming to get shitter.

It was penis beaker, then MRAs, then the Daily mail, the TRAs, name changing, Americans.. Truth is, a lot of people just like a fight and to be unpleasant online.

I never saw a wealth of hilarious threads. A handful maybe that were quite funny. One change I have noticed is that you didn't used to have to say you were joking or being 'lighthearted' as most people generally got the jist. Now even if it's states lighthearted, people still jump on to take offence and attack. There did used to be at least some sense of humour.

An excellent example is a post a few weeks back from someone very obviously being tongue in cheek asking if she was U to be offended that when she buys wine on the self-service checkout, the worker comes over and only glances as her before pressing the 'clearly over 25 button'.

And received replies along the lines of 'get over yourself, they're only doing their job, "well you obviously look over 25, stop being so vain" and several people ignoring the AIBU completely to instead make comments implying the OP had a drink problem because she posted a thread about buying wine and the time she posted was around 9am 🙄

I think that's another thing I see more of than in the past. The posters who ignore the majority of the OP to start being bitchy about an irrelevant detail. A poster can start a thread about their DCs school anxiety and get a bunch of snarky orthorexic comments about the fact they mentioned their DC had cocoa pops for breakfast.

ManAboutTown · 30/10/2023 21:54

ChocAuVin · 30/10/2023 21:20

“More joyful and less savage” — yes, that really does seem applicable to MN and the world in 2007 (when I started posting in earnest too after prior occasional lurking)

I think this is true not just of MN but many other sites as well. Back 15 or 20 years ago I used to post on the Evening Standard, Comment is Free, Guido Fawkes plus a few blog sites

There were differences of opinion for sure but with the moderation it seems a lot less free form now and sites seemed to become echo chambers. Certainly GF and the Guardian are like that. I only post on here and one other site where the moderation is fairly loose

There used to be some really good blogs back then as well - in particular I remember one by a copper and one by someone who worked in a care home that were very illuminating. Think the the chances of being outed as the author have gone up so doesn't seem to be as much of that stuff around

SunlightOverBamburgh · 30/10/2023 21:51

There is a huge difference between bullying a poster and someone trolling harmlessly about something daft. 99% of troll threads don't cause harm, and yes there is too much actual troll hunting going on these days , whilst at the same time a lot of nasty piling on of genuine vulnerable posters.

LindorDoubleChoc · 30/10/2023 21:46

The trolls have been around for years and I've git used to that.

The ChatGPT bots are something else though! The whole place is infested.

ChocAuVin · 30/10/2023 21:20

Squirrelsnut · 29/10/2023 09:11

It is different, yes. I started here in 2007 and used to literally cry with laughter (if not spitting out my tea) at some threads. It was more joyful and less savage.
But maybe that's a reflection of the world..

“More joyful and less savage” — yes, that really does seem applicable to MN and the world in 2007 (when I started posting in earnest too after prior occasional lurking)

SlatternIsMyMiddleName · 30/10/2023 21:17

I have been on Mumsnet for years, though rarely post. It’s just not as fun as it used to be. You can predict how virtually every thread is going to go and, quite frankly, I just can’t be arsed reading the same old thing.

there is not the sense of community that there used to be, now posters just seem to want to get one over on someone. It’s tiresome.

ilovesooty · 30/10/2023 21:05

Princessandthepea0 · 30/10/2023 20:41

Oh the claxon has gone off.

What's that supposed to mean?

Goldenbear · 30/10/2023 20:56

phoenixrosehere · 30/10/2023 20:17

Again, it is not about the U.S posters but more about not having to prefix everything with, 'I am in Britain' which is a shame as its relatability is what attracted many to begin with. British outlook on politics, social issues is very different to the U.S and much more akin to European politics in that respect so having those reference points is useful. You are not starting from scratch all the time e.g many of us grew up with an understanding of the IRA and the corresponding issues, many in the U.S do not have a clue about it and not do they need to but in that respect there is little commonality in reference points. Leaving the EU again. Most Americans didn't understand the gravity of that for many British people and the economic issues that have followed from that referendum. Even outlook is more religious, more conservative in the US, I mean people aren't allowed to drink until they are 30 or something like that but can own a gun under 21! Even parenting is much more conformist, naughty step, grounding, time out, all concepts British people had never heard of before the 00s so yes that advice is not always going to coming from a place of common ground. For example, many teenagers will drink at 16/17 here and the parents will not go bananas about it.

Some is true and some are based on stereotypes. Also, your issue with the prefix of saying “I am in Britain” has little to do with Americans when funny enough it is usually British posters who are always referencing the States unnecessarily and/or comparing the systems while rarely ever referencing the European ones. We don’t want the American healthcare system yet no one has ever said that that is the one that should be adopted in the first place and nothing is stopping the British people from looking to Europe or other countries. It is typically other posters in the UK constantly pointing out that “so-called” Americanism came from the UK itself through immigration to the States. Heck, some posters can’t even help themselves with automatically assuming that something must be an “American thing” if they have never heard of it and don’t like it.

Many Brits here know little about the US too including its history and ignoring that the 50 states and territories have its own laws. Many Brits also didn’t understand the gravity of the referendum so not sure what kind of point you were trying to make there. The US federal drinking age may be 21, but unless you’re caught doing it in a public establishment, no one bats an eye or goes as bananas as you want to assume especially parents.

The States is more religious and conservative in some parts more than others but not overall.

The whole reality tv thing is neither here or there and using that example when we had Boris here is not exactly better.

I am sure your correct that many don't know about the legal and political system of the US but that's because this is a UK based site.

More Brits are going to appreciate the issues around Brexit than Americans as it directly impacts us.

The U.S is more conservative that is reflected in their politics, they would never in a million years have a Corbyn running as Opposition for example. The reality TV is relevant as it demonstrates how politics is really about populism in the US.

Princessandthepea0 · 30/10/2023 20:41

Oh the claxon has gone off.

ilovesooty · 30/10/2023 20:38

Princessandthepea0 · 30/10/2023 20:07

MN allow it though. I could not believe this vocal pensioner on another thread; tearing apart another poster because they were American. It was allowed though because as mod said “American exceptionalism is a thing.” It’s shocking. MN is a bit of a pit now. Many posters are on here pretending to be vocal left wingers. All the while bleating about “their day and those bloody Americans.” It’s disgusting. Challenge them - you’re ageist and should shut up and pay your taxes. It’s becoming so awful at the moment. That’s because the vocal majority on here don’t work - xenophobia has no place in a modern society. You’d be fired for it at work.

How do you know people are "pretending to be vocal left wingers"?

Goldenbear · 30/10/2023 20:24

The irony!

It is not xenophobia to declare you have a cultural identity that isn't American - what a bizarre logic.

phoenixrosehere · 30/10/2023 20:17

Again, it is not about the U.S posters but more about not having to prefix everything with, 'I am in Britain' which is a shame as its relatability is what attracted many to begin with. British outlook on politics, social issues is very different to the U.S and much more akin to European politics in that respect so having those reference points is useful. You are not starting from scratch all the time e.g many of us grew up with an understanding of the IRA and the corresponding issues, many in the U.S do not have a clue about it and not do they need to but in that respect there is little commonality in reference points. Leaving the EU again. Most Americans didn't understand the gravity of that for many British people and the economic issues that have followed from that referendum. Even outlook is more religious, more conservative in the US, I mean people aren't allowed to drink until they are 30 or something like that but can own a gun under 21! Even parenting is much more conformist, naughty step, grounding, time out, all concepts British people had never heard of before the 00s so yes that advice is not always going to coming from a place of common ground. For example, many teenagers will drink at 16/17 here and the parents will not go bananas about it.

Some is true and some are based on stereotypes. Also, your issue with the prefix of saying “I am in Britain” has little to do with Americans when funny enough it is usually British posters who are always referencing the States unnecessarily and/or comparing the systems while rarely ever referencing the European ones. We don’t want the American healthcare system yet no one has ever said that that is the one that should be adopted in the first place and nothing is stopping the British people from looking to Europe or other countries. It is typically other posters in the UK constantly pointing out that “so-called” Americanism came from the UK itself through immigration to the States. Heck, some posters can’t even help themselves with automatically assuming that something must be an “American thing” if they have never heard of it and don’t like it.

Many Brits here know little about the US too including its history and ignoring that the 50 states and territories have its own laws. Many Brits also didn’t understand the gravity of the referendum so not sure what kind of point you were trying to make there. The US federal drinking age may be 21, but unless you’re caught doing it in a public establishment, no one bats an eye or goes as bananas as you want to assume especially parents.

The States is more religious and conservative in some parts more than others but not overall.

The whole reality tv thing is neither here or there and using that example when we had Boris here is not exactly better.

Princessandthepea0 · 30/10/2023 20:07

ColleenDonaghy · 30/10/2023 19:35

I've reported this thread, twice. Cannot believe it's still standing. If complaining about an "influx of nationality X" isn't xenophobic...

Anyway, another thread has now been completely derailed because troll hunters insisted on picking apart the OP's description of her DC's school holidays. Fucking wonderful.

MN allow it though. I could not believe this vocal pensioner on another thread; tearing apart another poster because they were American. It was allowed though because as mod said “American exceptionalism is a thing.” It’s shocking. MN is a bit of a pit now. Many posters are on here pretending to be vocal left wingers. All the while bleating about “their day and those bloody Americans.” It’s disgusting. Challenge them - you’re ageist and should shut up and pay your taxes. It’s becoming so awful at the moment. That’s because the vocal majority on here don’t work - xenophobia has no place in a modern society. You’d be fired for it at work.

ColleenDonaghy · 30/10/2023 19:35

Princessandthepea0 · 30/10/2023 18:35

It’s allowed now on MN - didn’t you get memo? I reported a poster for out and out xenophobia. Imagine something along the lines of xyz because she’s American. MNHQ let it stand after two complaints with the response “American exceptionalism is a thing.”

I was honestly disgusted - in plain sight. Funnily enough: it was a prolific poster who screams ageism on every thread. Xenophobia is ok though. Who knew.

I've reported this thread, twice. Cannot believe it's still standing. If complaining about an "influx of nationality X" isn't xenophobic...

Anyway, another thread has now been completely derailed because troll hunters insisted on picking apart the OP's description of her DC's school holidays. Fucking wonderful.

Goldenbear · 30/10/2023 19:27

Deathwillbebutapause · 30/10/2023 18:44

The Dutch should feel deeply relieved that the US is taking all the heat over "eventing" [sic] reality TV here.

Who cares who the previous American president was? Why should that make us hostile to Americans posting on Mumsnet? The Ukrainians elected a TV comedian, Zelensky. Should we have closed our borders to them on cultural grounds?

I mean you are proving the OP's point, where did anyone propose hostility? So much hyperbolic overreaction. The reference points are different due to a different set of cultural values (a reality TV star being elected as the US president is an example of that), there is something sad about the loss of quiddity that arises due to this desire for everyone to be the same and If you are not in agreement with that outlook, you are lambasted for it.

itsmyp4rty · 30/10/2023 19:08

I'm so sick of people constantly troll hunting, they think they're so clever and are so desperate to prove they're right demanding all sorts of details. It's by far the most tedious thing about MN right now.

There's a lady whose dd was excluded from a party and had to go home from school swimming alone - and even though the post had already been taken down, checked by MN and the OP made to jump through hoops there were still posters telling her it couldn't possibly be true.

Unless it's someone selling something or a sex pest I wish all the troll hunters would just fuck off

Princessandthepea0 · 30/10/2023 18:54

Goldenbear · 30/10/2023 18:42

Genuine question - how is it xenophobic to point out that British people have different reference points? Why would you want everyone to be the same, why do we all need to be the same?

I’m talking about a post which was very out and out xenophobic (not on this thread).

willowthecat · 30/10/2023 18:46

ChatGPT generating nonsense questions and 'dilemmas' ?

Deathwillbebutapause · 30/10/2023 18:44

The Dutch should feel deeply relieved that the US is taking all the heat over "eventing" [sic] reality TV here.

Who cares who the previous American president was? Why should that make us hostile to Americans posting on Mumsnet? The Ukrainians elected a TV comedian, Zelensky. Should we have closed our borders to them on cultural grounds?

Goldenbear · 30/10/2023 18:42

Princessandthepea0 · 30/10/2023 18:35

It’s allowed now on MN - didn’t you get memo? I reported a poster for out and out xenophobia. Imagine something along the lines of xyz because she’s American. MNHQ let it stand after two complaints with the response “American exceptionalism is a thing.”

I was honestly disgusted - in plain sight. Funnily enough: it was a prolific poster who screams ageism on every thread. Xenophobia is ok though. Who knew.

Genuine question - how is it xenophobic to point out that British people have different reference points? Why would you want everyone to be the same, why do we all need to be the same?

ManAboutTown · 30/10/2023 18:38

Deathwillbebutapause · 30/10/2023 18:09

Yep. After Mumsnet threads started being highlighted on the Daily Mail, we had an influx of these posters.

Their doctors must make a fortune treating their spleens.

It's an interesting comment this.

I've had a look at a few DM MN articles - it's really lazy journalism designed to fill up their website cheaply.

Maybe it has attracted a few headbangers but the website is very successful and although it takes a centre right position on most political issues the biggest demographic is centre left early middle aged women. Suspect the sidebar of shame has something to do with this plus they are quite avid on gossipy shit involving the Beckhams or Kim Khardashian or Love Island

To be honest I've seen far more derogatory comments about the Tories and Brexit on here than anything else although I don't go looking for threads with a political bent

Princessandthepea0 · 30/10/2023 18:35

Locutus2000 · 30/10/2023 18:00

This thread took a very xenophobic turn.

It’s allowed now on MN - didn’t you get memo? I reported a poster for out and out xenophobia. Imagine something along the lines of xyz because she’s American. MNHQ let it stand after two complaints with the response “American exceptionalism is a thing.”

I was honestly disgusted - in plain sight. Funnily enough: it was a prolific poster who screams ageism on every thread. Xenophobia is ok though. Who knew.

riversidepub · 30/10/2023 18:35

It has gone downhill. And it's not unusual for old threads with a few pages to be in trending. It doesn't seem like there are many people here anymore.

I disagree on Americans though. They're really polite and almost always mention they're from another culture, so posters know to take that into consideration. Some nationalities (won't name) not only fail to do this but have a habit of making anti-British threads and posts frequently too. I honestly don't get why they're here. Wish we had an ignore button!

Goldenbear · 30/10/2023 18:15

EtiennePalmiere · 30/10/2023 15:55

You certainly know a thing or two about lazy stereotypes.

Please explain what is stereotyping, did the U.S not elect a president who was in a reality TV programme? Did America event the reality TV concept and export those shows? Are people allowed to buy arms before alcohol? In terms of parental techniques are the naughty corner, time out, Grounding originally American concepts?

In terms of politics and social issues, if you haven't grown up with them, how would you have that average insight.

This is not an issue of stereotypes or right and wrong, it is about difference and the two cultures are different, does that matter, why is it an issue? Lets be happy that we are not all the same.

Swipe left for the next trending thread