Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No cash gift this Christmas?

37 replies

Arbutusflower · 29/10/2023 01:11

A few years ago we we feeling flush, were able to give adult children some chunky cash gifts for Christmas ( four figures) as well as wrapped presents over the next few years. Fast forward and I've retired, but invested inheritance is in a big dip rn and I'm using all the income to tide us over for some big house expenses. Foolishly perhaps we hinted back then to dc that the cash gifts could now be pretty regular after getting the inheritance. Didn't reckon on COL issues and house stuff (total replacement all windows e.g.).
Would it be totally mean to apologise and say sorry lads bit tight this year or should we just dip into capital and keep up the chunky subsidies? Both are in employment no kids.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
labamba007 · 29/10/2023 15:52

Ignore social media. I tend to find that millennials/gen z say this sort of stuff when boomers say they should stop spending money on Netflix so they can buy a house. But not giving thousands of pounds in cash at Christmas is nothing to worry about and if you're children do complain...well, they aren't very nice! But I'm sure they won't based on the things you've said here.

Arbutusflower · 29/10/2023 15:40

Let me be clear, they aren't at all grabby. This is my hesitation. But thanks to all the posters whose immediate response was to think the worst of us and our children. Really empathetic and encouraging...

OP posts:
Arbutusflower · 29/10/2023 15:38

Chagnedname · 29/10/2023 11:22

You’re a show off

You have no manners.

OP posts:
shivawn · 29/10/2023 13:19

Arbutusflower · 29/10/2023 01:37

Because that's the narrative here, on sm, the Graun, everywhere. We don't think we are but that doesn't stop the feeling of being in the camp of wrong as it were.

That's the narrative online but I would never think of my parents that way and honestly don't know anyone in real life who does.

No obligation to give cash gifts, cost of living impacts everyone. I suppose you could just explain you have extra unexpected expenses if as you say you hinted these could be regular gifts but really you don't have to apologise.

TotalOverhaul · 29/10/2023 13:02

Tell them early. Say: We are really sorry but this year we won't be able to give you cash on top of presents. House repairs and CoL rise means that for now, we don't have anything like as much spare cash as we had before. We want to give to you when we can and I hope we'll be able to in the future, but this year, we can't.

As long as they are not anticipating it, it's fine.

Loubelle70 · 29/10/2023 12:39

I used to spend a heck of a lot on mine, even when adults but now i dont. I spend on grandkids £150 each. Adult DD £100. shes reasonable and said thats too much but she gets off no one else. I spent thousands too but savings dwindle and if youve done a gd job raising your adult kids, theyll understand.

fluffypotatoes · 29/10/2023 12:36

If your kids are the sort to kick up a fuss over this they don't deserve it and I'd be reassessing my relationship with them if I were you.

nowordsforthis · 29/10/2023 12:28

Of course you aren't obliged to give them cash gifts and should feel no obligation to do so. Given that you had created an expectation that the gifts would continue, I think it would be fair of you, though, to be upfront with them about your intentions sooner rather than later for their own financial planning as it's always helpful to know about changing in income in advance.

Britneyfan · 29/10/2023 11:48

I’d never regard my parents as selfish boomers! Let society think what it wants. It would be different if your children and grandchildren were utterly destitute to the point of not being able to eat or have the heating on etc. if you’re able to help I think but I don’t know any boomer who hasn’t helped out their kids financially if they’re able to when they’ve really needed it.

Britneyfan · 29/10/2023 11:46

Just explain to your kids that your financial situation has changed and so you’re not in a position to give cash gifts this year, if a precedent has been set. I’m sure they will understand.

I have boomer parents who have done well financially, and I’d hate them to feel obliged to bankroll our generation, having said that they do recognise that as well as having worked incredibly hard all their lives, they also did benefit from economic circumstances at the time. And that my siblings and I, despite also working hard, have less fortunate in the background economic environment we have had as adults so far (and it looks unlikely to change anytime soon!).

My parents did give me an early inheritance as a house deposit to help me get on the housing ladder after I split up from my abusive ex husband and became a single mother. I’m very grateful to them for that. I also know that if I ever was in desperate need of money, my parents would give me it. They are kind, generous and loving parents and I can only repay them in love at the minute! But I didn’t and don’t expect them to hand money out just because they have it, and definitely wouldn’t want them feeling under financial pressure as a result of doing it.

Chagnedname · 29/10/2023 11:22

You’re a show off

LlynTegid · 29/10/2023 11:21

I think it would go down a bit better if you decided instead to make a charity donation. The amount of which is private.

Neriah · 29/10/2023 11:05

I find it interesting that us "boomers" are considered selfish by some, and it's supposed to be our fault that young people today can't afford retirement or mortgages, so we are supposed to leave them chunky inheritances as gratitude for them being born.

I was born in poverty in 1957. My parents had no indoor bathroom or toilet, no central heating, no double glazing. We had very little, and had to make do with what we had. At that time you couldn't even get proper bank accounts (that what the Post Office or building societies were for), no credit cards, and no mortgages. It was deregulation of the banking interest that made those things available to most of the working class - under Margaret Thatcher.

Yes, we got grants (and I have never supported student loans) but we still had to work to get to and through university. There were fewer employment rights (and many more ways around them), no free nursery care at all, no real maternity leave (and certainly pretty much no pay), no paternity leave, no adoption leave, no flexible working, no equal pay.... etc etc.

You know how you got those things? We bloody fought for them. They were not free gifts from a generous government who cared deeply - we fought for those rights that the younger generations have. I don't expect any gratitude for that - it was the right thing to do. It would be kind of nice if some of the younger generations stopped whining about what they don't have or how unfair it is that they don't have more rights, and did some organising and fighting for themselves - but if the legacy they want to leave their children and grandchildren is spinelessly trekking towards labouring until you die, that's up to them.

If there was a "boom" it was on our backs that things boomed, and just like today, it is the rich and powerful who made the really substantial gains. Nobody owed us a living, and we knew that. Nobody is ever owed a living, then or now.

OP, if your kids are of the belief that you owe them anything and are that entitled, then you've led them to a sad place when all they see their parents as is cash cows. If they are decent human beings then they will be more than capable of understanding that you need your money and cannot impoverish yourselves or put your future at risk so that they can have big cash gifts. If they aren't decent human beings then perhaps the dogs home would be a more worthy recipient of your largesse?

theduchessofspork · 29/10/2023 08:35

No just tell them it’s a skip for this year but hopefully it will be back when the economy bobs up (as long as your health holds up, haha)

You need to stick caveats in there because knee ops etc are expensive

MintJulia · 29/10/2023 08:35

Start by cutting out the 'selfish boomer' nonsense.

Your retirement income is for you first. Your children are grownups and can stand on their own two feet.

Lagershandy · 29/10/2023 08:32

Not in the four figure league, but I have always given a cash gift to along time friends two sons for birthdays and Christmas. It seems totally daft now they are both working, so I am going to tell my friend due to us retiring and col I will no longer be doing this.
It will be a relief for her as she doesn't have to rack her brains and dash around having to reciprocate gifts for us.

Heyhoherewegoagain · 29/10/2023 08:26

You just need to have a conversation with them very soon to manage their expectations…although not quite thousands at Christmas we’ve done the same with our adult kids and we’re saying just yesterday that we just can’t do it this year for pretty much the same reasons as you

KateyCuckoo · 29/10/2023 08:24

Wow the stealth boasts are getting stealthier Grin

DappledThings · 29/10/2023 08:24

You don't need to. And if they don't understand that that's on them.

My parents give my brother and I £3k each year as the maximum IHT relief. Every year we are really grateful and say so. If there was ever a year they decided not to I wouldn't think anything other than wanting to know they were oknand hadn't been overly dipping into their savings so far. Mum hinted once she was going to get cheaper bathroom tiles for their new bathroom so as to protect the amount coming to us and I was very clear I did not want to be part of the consideration that way and she should get the expensive ones.

LuckOfTheDrawer · 29/10/2023 08:23

And yes, just tell your DCs that your circumstances have changed.

LuckOfTheDrawer · 29/10/2023 08:22

Arbutusflower · 29/10/2023 01:17

@EvilElsa

You hear it all the time, the younger generations will not be able to afford to retire because they'll have huge mortgages and rubbish pensions.

I believe that's just hyperbole, and it's not a particularly useful thing to believe anyway - no one would bother saving anything for retirement if that was the case.

I hope your DCs are planning for their retirement now.

handyandie · 29/10/2023 08:21

@Arbutusflower will your children be getting your inheritance? It's quite normal for adults to struggle through the early part of life, you don't need to bank roll them.

Chasingsquirrels · 29/10/2023 08:18

My parents give me £5k every year, if they didn't want to one (or every) year that's up to them.
If they felt squeezed by doing so I'd be horrified if they felt they still had to.

IncompleteSenten · 29/10/2023 08:14

I guess you need to ask yourself how well you raised your children.
Did you raise them to be decent people or entitled, selfish ones?

You seem like a loving and caring person so I suspect the former so don't feel bad. Give what you can and if you raised decent people, they'll be grateful.

EvilElsa · 29/10/2023 08:10

In that case wouldn't you be better putting some money away for them every year for a lump sum at some point in the future when they need it rather than a few thousand every year that they probably spend on clothes or going out? If you are wealthy will you not provide for them in your will? My mum retired after receiving her inheritance.