Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be bothered by what MIL said?

68 replies

Mastmw7g · 29/10/2023 00:51

My MIL has a special bond with my 10 year old. She told DD that she'd have her live with them if we'd let her. She even said she'd put DD in the school nearby. Now DD keeps referring to MILs as "home" and our home as the place she "visits"

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Maray1967 · 20/01/2024 12:16

And tell your DH that he will have a big problem on his hands if it carries on.

Maray1967 · 20/01/2024 12:14

QWERTYoutside · 29/10/2023 01:12

I’d sit privately with mil and gently tell her that she corrects this, now. Or contact will lessen. A lot. Mil is driving a wedge between a mother and daughter and that is a sign of control on mil part.

This. Say it quietly but firmly and look her straight in the eyes. Make it very clear that you will not tolerate her trying to come between you and your daughter.

WinterisaComingIn · 20/11/2023 13:33

PumpkinFence · 20/11/2023 10:37

I’ve read your threads before about your eldest DD and rent and your 10yr old wanting to live with your MIL and of course I was on your side.

But having read your thread about your 10 year old being on the verge of a possible eating disorder and you happy to let her go hungry has me reading this thread in a whole new light. Sorry but I can now see why your DD is clinging to her MIL if that’s where she is getting love and affection from.

I agree with this. I've reread all three threads and there's definitely a scapegoat in the family and it's not the dh. I feel so sorry for your younger dd.

PumpkinFence · 20/11/2023 10:37

I’ve read your threads before about your eldest DD and rent and your 10yr old wanting to live with your MIL and of course I was on your side.

But having read your thread about your 10 year old being on the verge of a possible eating disorder and you happy to let her go hungry has me reading this thread in a whole new light. Sorry but I can now see why your DD is clinging to her MIL if that’s where she is getting love and affection from.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 05/11/2023 07:40

Very much what @Sugarfree23 put, are you going to have a 13 yo running away because grandma allows her out all the time? Or will she go an mil can't cope with a stroppy teen who doesn't worship her and wants to be with her friends?

Sugarfree23 · 05/11/2023 07:35

I honestly don't think you are over reacting.
There is something very unsettling about your DD saying your house isn't her real home. Someone must have put that idea in her head. There is something unhealthy in the relationship. Your older daughter is also seeing it.

I can't help wonder is MIL seeing your DD as the Daughter she never had. Is she using her to fulfill her own dreams?

I'd worry that in 2/3 years as you try and draw boundaries DD will decide that she'd rather live with granny with zero rules and boundaries and they'd be sod all you can do.

Mastmw7g · 05/11/2023 07:23

I feel nervous. What if I'm overreacting and MIL is just a kindly grandmother with a poor filter? Then any efforts I make to limit their time together is actually interfering with a beneficial relationship.

OP posts:
Darkandstormynite · 04/11/2023 18:25

Make sure your DH supervises calls going forward.

Do not let them stay with her for 2 weeks unsupervised

Tell MIL this kind of talk is inappropriate and that you need her help to stamp it out because it's obviously wrong and you're absolutely sure this isn't coming from her because that would be so silly and would result in her not having unsupervised contact. So you know she wouldn't be that daft.

Call her out in a passive aggressive way, but keep it friendly with a warning of what will happen if she doesn't knock it off.

Sugarfree23 · 04/11/2023 18:00

Op you have to listen to your oldest DD. The relationship between you younger DD and MIL is not healthy.

DD is getting fed ideas from somewhere most likely MIL. Drawing comparions between Mum and Gran, and where is home vs visiting is not a normal thing for a 10yo to be doing.

I'd cut the phone calls but you need DH on board.
What would you or he do if in a year or twos time DD said she wanted to move? He needs to help knock the idea out her head that living with Granny is possible or in any way a good idea

Mastmw7g · 04/11/2023 15:13

DD was again going on about how MIL is a hundred times better than either of us and she wants to live with her until she dies. My oldest said my MIL was a narcissist, and it reminded me of this thread. She said children's minds are malleable and I shouldn't allow the kids to be with my MIL until they're much older. I'm sure she's getting some if not all of this from watching videos online, but it really impacted me because I had no idea she felt this way.

OP posts:
electriclight · 29/10/2023 16:54

"There is no reason on this earth why anyone should be telling a child their real home is with them..."

Luckily nobody told dc that. That is something that dc has decided for themselves and started saying to op.

electriclight · 29/10/2023 16:51

"It sounds like MIL has little interest in the other children, hence their apparent reluctance to engage for long."

Does it, where has op said that? All dc spend time with mil. One dc asks to call mil. Other dc are invited to the call but wave and go. What has mil done wrong or are we just guessing?

electriclight · 29/10/2023 16:50

"There is no reason on this earth why anyone should be telling a child their real home is with them and they only visit their parents (outwith a foster arrangement when the child visits the parents)."

What if the child says 'if anything happened to mum and dad could I live with you?' or 'one day when I'm older can I live with you?' OP said it was a comment likely in response to a question from dd. What is a grandparent supposed to say to that? No you can't?

BreatheAndFocus · 29/10/2023 15:52

electriclight · 29/10/2023 15:12

How is MIL ignoring the other children? OP said they join the calls but wave and go. How is that MILs fault?

It sounds like MIL has little interest in the other children, hence their apparent reluctance to engage for long.

Sugarfree23 · 29/10/2023 15:30

electriclight · 29/10/2023 15:10

Does MN hate MILs so much that even when op comes on to say that the calls are initiated by dd and that MIL probably said it in response to a question from dd, pp are still so certain that MIL is doing something wrong.

There is no reason on this earth why anyone should be telling a child their real home is with them and they only visit their parents (outwith a foster arrangement when the child visits the parents).

That's an incredibly unsettling thing to tell a child. Why would anyone do that?

electriclight · 29/10/2023 15:12

BreatheAndFocus · 29/10/2023 14:57

Two week’s visit? No way. Cut that right down. Your MIL is messing with your DD’s head and hurting your other children by ignoring them. This isn’t a special bond. There’s something off about it all.

Tell your DH not to let your DD phone your MIL so much. He can say that his mother is busy/out/tired, etc. Maybe even instigate a weekly family call to Gran where you, then all children speak briefly, before your DH takes over the phone and speaks to them. Show you’re a family unit.

How is MIL ignoring the other children? OP said they join the calls but wave and go. How is that MILs fault?

electriclight · 29/10/2023 15:10

Does MN hate MILs so much that even when op comes on to say that the calls are initiated by dd and that MIL probably said it in response to a question from dd, pp are still so certain that MIL is doing something wrong.

BreatheAndFocus · 29/10/2023 14:57

Two week’s visit? No way. Cut that right down. Your MIL is messing with your DD’s head and hurting your other children by ignoring them. This isn’t a special bond. There’s something off about it all.

Tell your DH not to let your DD phone your MIL so much. He can say that his mother is busy/out/tired, etc. Maybe even instigate a weekly family call to Gran where you, then all children speak briefly, before your DH takes over the phone and speaks to them. Show you’re a family unit.

Conkersinautumn · 29/10/2023 14:45

This sounds really destabilising for your DD. Non parents shouldn't be asserting themselves as the 'better' option. My exMIL kept this up. For my oldest DD this has been really difficult emotionally (her grandma saying I wasn't as good at parenting etc) and it eventually left my dd turning against the manipulative digs and finally she turned her back on the grandma. But it's been really distressing for her along the way and all because of exMIL and her need for validation

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 29/10/2023 14:28

I’d speak to MIL and tell her to correct this or there will be no visit this year. Your DD is loving being the one singled out and is reacting to that. I’d cut down on the phone calls as well. Sorry not right now, you can tomorrow.

Sugarfree23 · 29/10/2023 14:12

I don't blame you for feeling uneasy about it.
I'd certainly correct any comments about your house not being 'home'.
Maybe even a chat on what the meaning of 'home' is.

Not sure how you cut the calls down, without getting DH on board, but he does need to see the issue.

Mastmw7g · 29/10/2023 14:05

I do have another daughter, but she's from my first marriage and an adult. She hasn't seen MIL in years and doesn't call her like my 10 year old does, who tells my husband she wants to call MIL and then he gives her his phone. So MIL isn't making these calls. I am only sending the kids to MIL for two weeks this year. They didn't see my PILs during 2020-2021, so I sent them for a long time in 2022 and it set a precedent so I felt guilty if I didn't do the same in 2023. I've already said it will only be a visit for two weeks this upcoming year.

I wasn't there when MIL said it, but I could see it being said in response to DD saying she wished she could stay with MIL forever. I still felt uneasy about it.

OP posts:
Ibravedaflood · 29/10/2023 09:19

My dd would he seeing a lot less of dgm.

Sugarfree23 · 29/10/2023 09:17

Op I'd be concerned about this too. It's like weird grooming by MIL and undermining you both as parents.

Any more mentions of this not being her real home I think you need to call out. "What do you mean by that, of course this is your home" "what gives you that idea".

Not sure how you do it, esp as DD is calling Gran, but I'd cut the number of phone calls. No you can't call Gran just now we are going to play a game, doing something etc

Does DD have her own phone? Or is she using the house phone blame the cost of calling.

Delt · 29/10/2023 09:08

I think giving the child consequences will backfire immensely. Just say - awww it's lovely you're so close to Grandma and move on. The more you fight it the bigger the issue will get.

But also, I'd be examining my own relationship with my child if they were genuinely feeling they had a better relationship with another mother figure.

OP, I'm sure this is really hurtful for you. I'm sure her saying this deep down is causing you pain but taking that pain and turning it into discipline and punishment is not the answer.

Your DD is 10yrs, it's likely a phase for a start and you have to be the bigger person. Spend some quality time with her, do things that she enjoys.

Is your DD favouring Grandma because she listens more, pays more interest in things that are important to her, builds her self-esteem? Or simply gives her some 1-2-1 time that she craves? Etc etc.

Having multiple kids can make it harder to give one child that individual treatment and some kids, perhaps like your son's don't need it. But perhaps your DD is a bit more sensitive and she does and I can imagine a young girl just on the precipice of puberty with two younger brother racing around - could justifiably need some more maternal attention.

Grandma is important to her - it's quite frankly pretty bitter, manipulative, controlling and really mean to start to drive a wedge between them deliberately as some of the advice here suggests.

Why not just sit down and having a loving conversation with your 10yr old about it instead? She'll be in senior school soon, she's perfectly capable of having an age appropriate conversation and hearing some of your feelings on this all - if that conversation is honest and like, I say, loving and comes from a good place.

Honestly some of the advice on here is really dark. She has a grandma she loves so all this 'take that bitch away this child is mine.....' is just awful given the very limited information you've provided.

Swipe left for the next trending thread