Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to run for the hills from this guy

289 replies

Amysunsure · 29/10/2023 00:26

This year will be my first Christmas with DP, who I’ve been seeing for about 10 months. Everything has been going great, we get on amazing, met each other’s families, and have been on holiday together not long ago. We even talked recently about moving together in around a years time if things carry on going well. My colleagues have been saying how much happier I’ve looked this year and I know it’s all because of him.

except this past few days I have felt things might be about to crash down around me, and I honestly do not know what to do and I’m here for some advice.. I feel so upset, but don’t know if I’m overreacting,

DP and me are both huge fans of Christmas, and earlier in the week we were at his place, listening to Christmas songs (lol yes I know, in October) , talking about our favourites songs,
he was playing me a playlist he had put together.

I was horrified when the Gary Glitter song “another rock ‘n’ roll Christmas” started playing. As a child of the 80s, this one would always come on around Christmas time, but obviously very abruptly stopped when things were revealed about him.

I told DP to turn it off, and he asked why??! I said I’m not listening to any music by him, do you not realise what he did??

DP reply by saying “yes, I know, I feel very guilty saying this, but it is a good song isn’t it!! I don’t see why I should stop listening to the song!“

I literally stopped in my tracks and said to him, what do you think of what GG did? He said “well he’s disgusting, obviously, but it doesn’t change the fact it’s a good tune.”

so I have gone from feeling on top of the world and feeling like I had met the person I saw a future, to I don’t know if I can carry on being with him! All in the space of a couple days!

am I crazy to think of ending things with him over this?

Please be kind, I’m upset!

OP posts:
Lovemusic82 · 29/10/2023 08:30

I think you are being a bit dramatic over a song. I do agree that I wouldn’t want to listen to anything by GG or RH due to their convictions but I don’t think I would end a relationship over it, I would just ask them to remove it from the playlist as I find it offensive. To be fair there are probably lots of artists that have done things to women (possibly kids) that we don’t know about. I don’t listen to MJ because it makes my skin crawl but I was at a family event earlier this year where they played MJ and it did make me feel a bit ick.

just ask him to remove it from the play list and move on.

THisbackwithavengeance · 29/10/2023 08:29

You would be off your head to dump this absolute keeper over this.

It's October lol and you are listening to Xmas playlists together??? Do you realise how few men would tolerate let alone enjoy that?

Honestly you need to apologise for overreacting. And you need to consider that he might dump you, I wouldn't be impressed if someone accused me of supporting paedophilia just because I played a Gary Glitter song. I've got a playlist somewhere on Spotify with Rock and Roll part 2 on; cracking song.

itsallnewnow · 29/10/2023 08:28

Some people can separate the art from the artist, some can't.
If it helps he likely had help writing it and producing it by loads of people

Notamum12345577 · 29/10/2023 08:28

Amysunsure · 29/10/2023 00:26

This year will be my first Christmas with DP, who I’ve been seeing for about 10 months. Everything has been going great, we get on amazing, met each other’s families, and have been on holiday together not long ago. We even talked recently about moving together in around a years time if things carry on going well. My colleagues have been saying how much happier I’ve looked this year and I know it’s all because of him.

except this past few days I have felt things might be about to crash down around me, and I honestly do not know what to do and I’m here for some advice.. I feel so upset, but don’t know if I’m overreacting,

DP and me are both huge fans of Christmas, and earlier in the week we were at his place, listening to Christmas songs (lol yes I know, in October) , talking about our favourites songs,
he was playing me a playlist he had put together.

I was horrified when the Gary Glitter song “another rock ‘n’ roll Christmas” started playing. As a child of the 80s, this one would always come on around Christmas time, but obviously very abruptly stopped when things were revealed about him.

I told DP to turn it off, and he asked why??! I said I’m not listening to any music by him, do you not realise what he did??

DP reply by saying “yes, I know, I feel very guilty saying this, but it is a good song isn’t it!! I don’t see why I should stop listening to the song!“

I literally stopped in my tracks and said to him, what do you think of what GG did? He said “well he’s disgusting, obviously, but it doesn’t change the fact it’s a good tune.”

so I have gone from feeling on top of the world and feeling like I had met the person I saw a future, to I don’t know if I can carry on being with him! All in the space of a couple days!

am I crazy to think of ending things with him over this?

Please be kind, I’m upset!

Stairway to Heaven will always be a classic song, whatever we think of Rolf Harris!

ClaireEclair · 29/10/2023 08:25

There are so many examples of bands and singers that are just as bad but for some reason it’s acceptable to listen to them. Steve Tyler from Aerosmith actually adopted a 14 year old girl so he could have a relationship with her! Jimmy Page from Led Zepplin had a 14 year old “girlfriend” who he actually kidnapped at one point.

Moveoverdarlin · 29/10/2023 08:18

You are mental to end things over this. It’s a great Christmas tune, I’ve kept one particular Christmas compilation CD purely because of this song as you can’t play it on Spotify. I don’t condone what he did, he’s a repulsive man, but the song is good. Me listening to a song doesn’t change anything. I wouldn’t play it at a Kids party and it’s right that his music has been erased, but you’d seem beyond rational to fuck up your whole life because of a Gary Glitter song! FWIW after watching the Jimmy Savile drama recently I found the theme tune on YouTube to Jim’ll Fix It and played it, again it’s a great little tune. No one was harmed.

RosaMoline · 29/10/2023 08:16

It’s obvious it’s the last day of half term.
Christmas songs in October? GG? Really? 🙄🙄🙄

KittensandPerverts · 29/10/2023 08:16

I was thinking about this the other day. There's a little known Brit band that had some fame in the 90s. I listen to their music still, constantly. They are exclusively my favourite band, even though the lead singer clearly has all kind of issues. I was thinking that if something similar came out about him/them could I suddenly stop listening to the music that has got me through some of the roughest days? I'm not sure I could.

However, I'd be happy to remove one random song from someone I don't totally love from a playlist though. I mean, I'm sure he can cope with not listening that crappy song anymore.

Burnoutwhat · 29/10/2023 08:10

It's ott. Also if you've been together 10 months and don't live together I think calling him your partner is a bit much too.

flaxentoad · 29/10/2023 08:10

This link is worth a look.

Better check he doesn't have Frank Sinatra's Christmas songs though...

"Frank Sinatra was iconic on stage, but there was a lot of shady stuff that happened off-stage. Let's talk about one part of that: his temper. According to The Telegraph, it was so bad that one of his wives once described him as a sort of Jekyll-and-Hyde character, and there's a whole list of physical altercations he was involved in. First, the ones where someone got seriously hurt.

He punched a reporter in 1948, eventually settling the assault and battery charges filed against him. He was staying at the Beverly Hills Hotel when he threw a phone at a random businessman who was also there, and cracked the man's skull. He nearly killed his then-wife Ava Gardner by throwing a champagne bottle at her so hard it cracked the bathroom sink.

Sinatra destroyed an insane amount of stuff, too, usually in fits of rage. He took a knife to a Norman Rockwell painting and shredded it, threw a malfunctioning TV out a window at Sands Hotel in Las Vegas, and smashed a car radio when The Doors' "Light My Fire" came on. GQ says some of the stuff that met an untimely end under his boot was pretty priceless, too, like the Ming vase he destroyed at a Hong Kong hotel after someone missed a lighting cue. That's what happens when you get too used to having things your way."

Read More: https://www.grunge.com/110681/respected-musicians-actually-terrible-people/

Respected Musicians Who Were Actually Terrible People - Grunge

Geniuses or not, plenty of music artists have won the respect of many, sometimes undeservedly. These are respected musicians who were actually terrible people.

https://www.grunge.com/110681/respected-musicians-actually-terrible-people/

GilberMarkham · 29/10/2023 08:08

very few of these people are / were angels

Yes, but prolific child sex abuse is kind of in a league of its own. Not sure why that needs pointed out.

MsRosley · 29/10/2023 08:06

You're completely bonkers, OP. Perhaps your DP would be better off without you.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 29/10/2023 08:06

As PPs have said, you can divorce the art from the artist as long as the evil is not within the art. That's why Disney remains such a massive and successful business, but they no longer show Song of the South. (Though they will play Zip a Dee Doo Dah.)

If you don't want to listen to GG, you don't have to, but personally I wouldn't break up over it as long as it's very clear it's the art he likes, not the artist.

GilberMarkham · 29/10/2023 08:06

I would be so turned off by some who liked Gary Glitter's music ..... That I couldn't think about shagging them again.

That is totally aside from the fact that it is the music of a convicted child sex abuser.

It's just so shit.

It would be among the songs that I'd pay a subscription to stop being played.

Buffypaws · 29/10/2023 08:04

I had no idea that song was by Gary Glitter. but anyway yabu - I mean what exactly are you suggesting? Your partner is ok with paedophiles because he enjoys an ancient tacky Christmas song? I’m listening now and it is quite good. Gary Glitter however should be mulch.

Fran2023 · 29/10/2023 08:04

YABU.

Have you any idea how many very, very talented artists and musicians were abusers and/or racists/misogynists?

Charles Dickens was extremely cruel to his wife, and had her confined to an asylum.
William Golding tried to rape a 15 year girl.
Norman Mailer tried to kill his own wife.
Ezra Pound was racist.
Virginia Woolf was an antisemite.
V.S.Naipaul was a misogynist.
Caravaggio was involved in several violent attacks, and murdered a man.
Picasso was a misogynist.
Gaugain had sex with teenage girls.
Edward Hopper was a violent abuser to his wife.

And that’s just a tiny sample.

flaxentoad · 29/10/2023 08:04

If you go down this road, it leaves out a lot of music, art, literature etc

If you are serious about this though, you will have to thoroughly investigate everything you have an interest in, just to make sure.

Technically, I would argue it rules out watching anything on the BBC since they have harboured several dodgy TV presenters.

You could go one step further and do some sleuthing on every single person who has had a hand in making a movie for instance, not just the producer, director and so on. That will keep you busy!

Start Googling anything you are into and you may be in for a surprise!

If this becomes a break-up with your partner, you will have to have this conversation from Date 1 with a new man to ensure you are on the same page. No point in investing in a relationship only to break up over a pop song that's played once a year.

Dibbydoos · 29/10/2023 08:02

Talk to him about how you feel, don't hide it, but you are over reacting @Amysunsure
He can listen to what he likes so ask him not to play and Michael Jackson, R Kelly, Boy George, Rolf Harris, Prophets etc in your presence.

It's awful that these deviants had musical air time, but they did.

I really try hard not to play any of them. GG is an absolute no no for me, he was a creepy looking man when he found fame and as a child, he gave me the ick, but I do succumb to a bit of MJ and R Kelly ocassionally.

FlamingoQueen · 29/10/2023 08:02

If he has a GG shrine, then I would say run for the hills, but really? This cannot be for real.

Pyramintdreamer · 29/10/2023 08:00

Yabvu and controlling

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 29/10/2023 07:59

Blondebutnotlegally · 29/10/2023 06:58

Everyone going on about MJ (and I'm not interested in being controversial) but I thought it had been made clear a number of people just wanted money out of him? Didn't one of the 2 boys come out and say that his mum made him lie? And another allegation came from a dentist who drugged one of the kids and asked him for info? So pretty baseless?

It has. If you look carefully both accusations were all about getting money, nothing else.

CranfordScones · 29/10/2023 07:59

It's difficult. If you were to apply this to all art, you'd end up cancelling half the great composers and artists whose behaviour didn't match modern standards of propriety.

I'm in the 'retain and explain' camp. Because the alternative is a Maoist, statue-toppling rabbit hole.

YABU to leave someone over a difference of opinion. He's hardly endorsing anyone's actions, is he?

Remona · 29/10/2023 07:56

Yes, run for the hills OP. You’ll be doing him a massive favour. You’re being completely ridiculous. I dread to think how you’d react if he genuinely did something wrong.

OopsaDazy · 29/10/2023 07:56

No don't run for the hills.

Stay in the valley and carry on with this sensible guy.

Honestly you come over as a drama queen. And a bit immature.

If we were never to enjoy art, literature, music, because the person behind it had done something wrong, we'd be left with next to nothing.

For example, should people not read Dickens because he was unfaithful to his wife? Or other great artists, writers and musicians who took drugs, were addicts, wife beaters, you name it?

GabriellaMontez · 29/10/2023 07:56

Do you do this to all artists?

Yabu.

Swipe left for the next trending thread