Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed at friend “remembering “ everything

118 replies

Bellavida99 · 28/10/2023 09:50

I know I’m being completely unreasonable but my friend must keep an amazing diary of all birthdays , significant dates etc. I remember her birthday, her kids birthday and sometimes her wedding anniversary which I think is a normal level for a good friend. But she messaged me on the anniversary of my mother’s funeral, on my sisters birthday who she’s met once, and some dates I didn’t know myself like my work anniversary. I now picture her writing down everything I ever mention and adding it to her diary. It’s strange as instead of making me think she’s caring and thoughtful I think she’s a bit odd and it’s a bit much so end up just messaging back something half hearted. Am I being a bitch?

OP posts:
Testina · 28/10/2023 11:21

@WeeStyleIcon “Like you tell me your birthday is the 3 April. I scare you by remembering that FOREVER, but it's nothing to do with you, it's because it's my cousin's birthday too. Ykwim?”

But if you stuck my sister’s birthday on your peg because it was your man’s birthday too, or the day I started my last job because it was the house number of your American pen pal in 1986, would you then actually act on being unable to forget that - and message me?

WeeStyleIcon · 28/10/2023 11:20

Following up with the comment that mostly I keep quite about the fact that I know your birthday and phone number off by heart Grin I'm always trying not to come across weird even though i feel like the normal one and I feel like other people can react to such normal way sin a weird way. Comprende?

DisforDarkChocolate · 28/10/2023 11:19

I could do with someone like this in my life.

Testina · 28/10/2023 11:17

SpinningOutWaitinForYa · 28/10/2023 11:09

Yeah you are. I'm autistic and do things like this. It comes naturally to me and I'm trying to be thoughtful. Just because you're feeling inadequate doesn't make her weird.

It absolutely does make her weird. Highlighting the anniversary of a date that a friend started a job? Intrusive.
Mentioning a friend’s sibling’s birthday? Too much.
If you do this, I suggest you get someone to run through your list of “things” and highlight which are nice and which are over the top.
And saying people are “feeling inadequate” here is just rude. So if you’re into “trying to be thoughtful” - try harder!

WeeStyleIcon · 28/10/2023 11:16

Im like this. It wouldn't mean I was OBSESSED with you, it would just mean that when I firt heard your birthday or other detail, like house number, I connected it to overlap on a peg in my brain that was already etched well in. Like you tell me your birthday is the 3 April. I scare you by remembering that FOREVER, but it's nothing to do with you, it's because it's my cousin's birthday too. Ykwim?

Rainbowshine · 28/10/2023 11:14

I’m all for a supportive message but this sounds like it’s an invasive reminder without empathy or consideration of what impact it might have on the recipient.

@Bellavida99 when your friend sends you a message about something you prefer not to remember or be reminded of, I would be tempted to reply, “thanks but I was trying to distract myself from thinking about it, to be honest”.

Or just tell them, please can you please not message me about the anniversaries that are related to bereavement? I try to carry on like it’s a normal day as a way of coping. I know that we all cope differently with grief and this is how I manage it.

Testina · 28/10/2023 11:13

I don’t think it’s odd that she has a memory for these things (if so she can’t help that) or even if she chooses to keep a diary to enable her to send messages on specific occasions.

It’s the occasion choice that’s intrusive.

A short note on the first anniversary of a parent’s death is OK from a close friend I think, though more the death than funeral I personally think. But I’d actually tell her that I found the sister birthday and work anniversary too much.

Bellavida99 · 28/10/2023 11:12

Thanks everyone. To be honest I thought I was being horrible and ungrateful to feel like this, so I’m glad a lot of you understand how I feel. I think intrusive and uncomfortable describe it well. I feel like she wants to somehow get an emotional reaction from me in some way. Thinking about it she is the same when I see her almost asking difficult, journalistic interview questions about small things that don’t need a deep dive into. We’ve been friends for decades I feel sad that I want to withdraw from her a bit

OP posts:
SpinningOutWaitinForYa · 28/10/2023 11:09

Yeah you are. I'm autistic and do things like this. It comes naturally to me and I'm trying to be thoughtful. Just because you're feeling inadequate doesn't make her weird.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 28/10/2023 11:09

I said YANBU even though she probably means well

Ive got a good memory for these things but I don’t send people messages like this as I know it’s annoying and others find it a bit intense.

She can’t help it if she does remember but she lacks social awareness but always messaging you

WotNoUserName · 28/10/2023 11:05

One of my sons has a phenomenal memory for dates. He remembers everyone's birthday, he can tell me what we were doing on this date many years ago etc. He's autistic so that may explain why.

I am also autistic and can remember the most random facts about people, though I don't often mention it as it can sound stalkerish when I remember something people have said in passing, though that's come with age and experience. I spent a lot of time when I was younger being seen as weird for knowing things about people.

I wish my brain remembered more useful things, like how to do maths, or housework, and what events I and my kids have coming up!

pictoosh · 28/10/2023 11:05

I'd find this cloying.

WhatWhereWhenHowWhy · 28/10/2023 11:00

Bellavida99 · 28/10/2023 09:50

I know I’m being completely unreasonable but my friend must keep an amazing diary of all birthdays , significant dates etc. I remember her birthday, her kids birthday and sometimes her wedding anniversary which I think is a normal level for a good friend. But she messaged me on the anniversary of my mother’s funeral, on my sisters birthday who she’s met once, and some dates I didn’t know myself like my work anniversary. I now picture her writing down everything I ever mention and adding it to her diary. It’s strange as instead of making me think she’s caring and thoughtful I think she’s a bit odd and it’s a bit much so end up just messaging back something half hearted. Am I being a bitch?

This has made me think...

I am one of these people! Dates are important to me and I note down things like that - although I won't go so far as to note work anniversaries!

I do it because I don't have much time to commit to people atm due to uni, parenting, caring for an elderly relative and work full time. It's to show I care

mouldyfalafel · 28/10/2023 10:59

I think there is a difference between remembering stuff (which just cant be helped- if you have a good memory, then you have a good memory) and transmitting that info to others.

I remember a lot of useless info, I dont do it on purpose, it just stays in my brain. That said, what I dont do is text everyone the moment I remember something because I recognise that would be annoying.

Remembering a death anniversary and checking in on the person is actually a lovely thing to do and I appreciate it when friends do that for me. But texting about the birthday of someone she met once is just weird. This is where social cues come in- just because you remember something, doesnt then mean you need to tell all and sundry about it otherwise, where does it end? you'd be texting people every damn week about some event that happened 5 years ago or whatever.

IthinkIsawahairbrushbackthere · 28/10/2023 10:58

I'm like that. I can forget the time of my hair cut but I have very specific memories of particular dates/happenings and often I can tell roughly when something happened because I remember what I was wearing.

I always find an excuse to message my mother in law on the anniversary of fil's death -so that she knows I'm thinking about her.

Highlandsprocker · 28/10/2023 10:58

Isthisexpected · 28/10/2023 10:51

I'll have her as a friend. How ungrateful to refer to her messaging on your the anniversary of your mum's funeral in a post complaining about her!

Oh give over.
Op can feel how she likes, it's making her uncomfortable .

One message fine but work anniversaries,sisters birthday ?
It's OTT
What do you even say " Congratulations you have been working at shitjobsUK for a whole year now"
" Congrats it's your sisters birthday "🙄

theheadband · 28/10/2023 10:57

If she forgot, you'd be posting about that 🤷🏻‍♀️ in a very selfish world having a friend like that would be a blessing. Some people are more sentimental and appreciate small things like that. Its obviously a bit wasted on you because ive personally never heard of a friend who is 'too thoughtful'.

Isthisexpected · 28/10/2023 10:51

I'll have her as a friend. How ungrateful to refer to her messaging on your the anniversary of your mum's funeral in a post complaining about her!

Thebigblueballoon · 28/10/2023 10:48

My ex could remember everything on any specific date you gave him. Pluck a date and he’d recall it like he was reading a book. It was really unsettling, but impressive.
I think it’s just how your brain works. Some people can remember so many dates/numbers/events than others.

TheYear2000 · 28/10/2023 10:48

I can see this from both sides. I agree with posters saying the friend is being (or trying to be!) thoughtful. However, I had a friend who messaged me on significant (sad) dates and I actually found it upsetting as I hadn't really been paying attention to it being the anniversary of a particular event in my life, more generally reeling- so the focus was unwelcome. However, I know my friend may have thought I could feel sad and isolated if no one remembered the event. It's a tricky one!

Itsnotchristmasyet · 28/10/2023 10:45

YABVU

She’s obviously not doing it to be nasty, so why would you be offended over it.

All you have to do is say thanks. That’s it.

She may be writing it down, as she thinks that’s what a good friend does.
Or she may have a great memory for dates, like some people do.

I am awful with numbers and dates but I can tell you the name and breed of every single pet any of my friends of family have ever had.

I work with autistic kids and some of them have the most incredible brains.

You can name any film and they’ll tell you every single actors name and DOB and if they’ve died their DOD and how they died.

There are some that you can say a specific date and they can tell you a fact about that date.

One knows every single thing about the royal family, going back centuries and remember every single DOB, DOD, how they died, what date they got married or became queen etc.

Several of them will know that it’s one of our birthdays or my dogs birthday or my dogs death anniversary etc without being reminded.
Some things we just mention in passing and they can memorise it.

It truly is amazing (I just have to watch what I say knowing they’ll remember it forever lol).

I was taken back a bit when one boy said it’s your cat X’s birthday today, he’s 15 today - I was like WTH and asked how he knew it and apparently the year before someone asked if I had a cat and how old and I said I have a cat called X and he’ll be 14 in 2 days.
I didn’t even realise this boy was in the room.

MrsSkylerWhite · 28/10/2023 10:42

She’s very thoughtful.

Babyroobs · 28/10/2023 10:41

I have a couple of friends like this who I have been friends with since aged 15 ( we are 55 now ! ). One has an excellent memory for anything remotely embarrassing anyone in our group has done and loves to bring things up 30+ years later, usually things/ embarrassing moments you just want to forget. Another is highly irritating reeling off exact figures / football game results/ winners of strictly/ masked singer from years ago, the exact song that was sung or danced to.

Tonight1 · 28/10/2023 10:37

I do this (remembering dates) and it does freak people out sometimes.

I'd only remember birthdays and medical stuff though. I was at doc A&E recently and he asked when I last saw GP and I crossly said 20 August. Only cross because I wasn't expecting to be asked.

AlmondCherry · 28/10/2023 10:36

I would find it intrusive too. It's just too much. Whether she has remembered with or without tech. As @Highlandsprocker puts it - unboundaried behaviour.

If I notice the date when it hits the anniversary of one of my parents death or their birthday I have a moment of quiet reflection but that is it. I would absolutely hate someone to message (certainly beyond the first year) or mention it to me. Just typing this I've realised that I 'missed' my dad's death anniversary - even though I did register the date on that day, I didn't register the significance until now.

I've got a few couple's anniversaries in my birthday app - but only so I know when it is their 1st, 10th, 25th, 40th and so on, and even this is only with very close friends and family. On a 'normal' anniversary I don't send a card or even mention it.