Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel like I'm always engaging new 'SIL' in conversation and not getting much back..

57 replies

kitchensinksers · 28/10/2023 09:35

Hear me out, this is a weird one.

My BIL has a new girlfriend who seems absolutely lovely. I love my BIL and I'm really happy he's happy and has found a lovely girl.

We've met her a number of times now and she really does seem lovely but I always feel like I'm making a massive effort to get to know her and engage with her and somehow I'm getting a weird vibe back from her that it's not reciprocated.

When she's around I literally have to try to stop myself from starting another conversation because I just don't feel like it's a two way thing.

I don't struggle with social interactions at all usually but find my reaction a bit strange. She's usually very much focused on talking and playing with my two DDs. Which is super cute of course. Or she's focused on talking to BIL. But somehow I feel like she gives me the cold shoulder a bit, it's hard to explain !

I feel like if I didn't start a conversation, we could easily be together for a few hours and not speak a lot to each other. She usually comes to my house, so it just feels strange. I guess only time will tell or maybe she thinks I'm annoying or something. But I'm quite tactful usually and I don't overdo trying to engage her, especially because it feels a bit one way. I read her cues and go with that.

OP posts:
wizzywig · 28/10/2023 11:20

Maybe your brother has built you up to be really important to him (which you are) and that has made her nervous ?

WestwardHo1 · 28/10/2023 11:17

My SIL was like this the whole time I was married to her brother. She most definitely didn't have social anxiety or autism - she just had no manners. In time I realised that it was because her/their parents were the same - absolutely zero interest in other people. Some folk are like that.

Makethemostofit · 28/10/2023 11:14

I agree you aren’t being unkind. You are making the effort.

Another thing is the difference between men’s and women’s conversation styles, some women prefer what is more common to men and vice versa.

Its stereotyping, but men will usually speak about less personal stuff - tech, politics, sport, money, opportunities, music, gently mocking one-another and cracking jokes - and they socialise around an activity- eg they meet to play five a side and go to the pub afterwards to talk about football.

Stereotyping again, but women tend to be much more open and intimate in their conversations, discussing personal things like health issues, personal grooming, trouble with the kids, and their relationship foibles and also be more gossipy, potentially creating drama.

Lots of people see a woman with a more ‘masculine’ social style as aloof, and see a man with a ‘feminine’ social style as over-familiar and intrusive.

I suppose, what I am saying here, is that if it were three men at your home, not a man and two women (plus kids) there would be a bit of inconsequential impersonal conversation about politics and then some sort of activity, like “Shall we get out the PlayStation?” or “Do you want to have a look at this vintage organ I am dismantling that I told you about?”, etc, etc. There wouldn’t be an expectation to sustain conversation for the duration of time everyone spent together. Some women find that much more comfortable too.

Its just another thought.

kitchensinksers · 28/10/2023 10:29

That was an extreme case but it sounds to me like you have different personalities, she is being perfectly pleasant and polite but not behaving like you would and you are judging her for it. You say you are picking up her cues, perhaps she is doing the same, feeling judged and withdrawing…

Honestly I've been nothing but nice to her and trying to make her feel welcome.

I've been picking up on her cues to make her feel more welcome and have gone with her flow, by purposefully not bombarding her with lots of questions. I don't think I have judged her. I don't think it's fair what you've said.

OP posts:
Bearsinmotion · 28/10/2023 10:26

This all reminds me of ex DH’s family. My family is smaller and much quieter than his. I used to find it incredibly difficult visiting as their way of making me feel comfortable was constantly talking and asking questions, which I found exhausting. When I tried to get time to myself it was frowned upon - going out by myself was “strange”, reading my book was “rude,” and I ended up focusing on my children to try and avoid constant barrage. I felt I was constantly being judged for not behaving like them. He was also coercive and when we ended up in cited in court he included in his statement that I was an introvert and saw this as a reason for justifying his abusive behaviour!

That was an extreme case but it sounds to me like you have different personalities, she is being perfectly pleasant and polite but not behaving like you would and you are judging her for it. You say you are picking up her cues, perhaps she is doing the same, feeling judged and withdrawing…

kitchensinksers · 28/10/2023 10:25

Thanks everyone. Yes it's probably that she doesn't like too much chit chat and is shy and also probably trying to feel us out before putting too much of herself out there.

I could chit chat for England. I have to stop myself in fact and hold myself back, to not be over bearing. I also over share sometimes which is something I also try to hold back on. Everyone is different socially. Like I said, she seems lovely and my feelings are probably about my own hang ups.

OP posts:
Moveoverdarlin · 28/10/2023 10:19

Some people are crap at chit-chat. My in-laws are due here in a minute and they do not speak a word unless we ask them a question. I have been asking the same questions for 15 years ‘journey down ok?’ How’s the cat? Got much on this week? It’s painful, but it’s just how they are.

Similarly I think I’m fairly chatty but there are a few Mums at school I struggle with. Sometimes I can not think of one thing to say to them. Sometimes I just find myself grinning inanely, while I think of something to say.

She wouldn’t come round if she didn’t like you, but it could be anything, she could be shy, crap at chit-chat, intimidated.

WeightoftheWorld · 28/10/2023 10:18

This is me! I'm autistic and struggle with anxiety. It takes me a long time to warm up to/get to know people such that I feel 'at home' with them. I am absolutely rubbish at small talk and my mind literally goes blank. I am always grateful for people who keep the conversation going and ask lots of questions that I can just respond to!

saraclara · 28/10/2023 10:14

I'm glad you're more reasonable than some!

The person IL I'm talking about also finds it really difficult to ask people anything about themselves. As she's quite a private person, she says she can't get past thinking that askng someone about themselves is nosy. I've tried to explain that actually people would like her to show interest in them, but she just can't get over that barrier.

NeedToChangeName · 28/10/2023 10:14

My BIL is kind, thoughtful and caring. But not chatty in social situations. I used to think it was a bit rude. Now, I think he probably finds these occasions quite difficult, so I'm just glad he makes the effort to come at all

Fifteenth · 28/10/2023 10:12

I also hate conversation.

AnnaMagnani · 28/10/2023 10:09

Am not sure exactly what she is doing wrong as when I met my ILs, I showed an interest in their kids, had a go at conversation, but was pretty nervous so probably did spend most of my time talking to my DH to be.

Also at 6 months in to the relationship, DH was pretty much all I was interested in, so yes, I would have gone back to talking to him as I was in lurrrve.

crumblingschools · 28/10/2023 10:08

How often do you see her? What is she like with other family members?

Iknowthis1 · 28/10/2023 10:06

Have you seen what she's like around any other women?

kitchensinksers · 28/10/2023 10:06

saraclara · 28/10/2023 10:00

This is so sad. You could easily be talking about someone I love dearly. She is such a good person, but finds it very difficult to initiate conversation. She can respond to other people initiating it, but just find it hugely difficult to come up with conversation starters. Hence she's another person who'll keep herself busy with helping out in the kitchen or playing with children. She needs a role to help her manage social situations. She's not being rude. She's really trying her best.

So it really bothers me that at least one pp is telling OP to cut off her SIL for this.

Don't worry I am not coming at this question from a nasty point of view at all. I won't be ' cutting her off ' or being mean to her.

I'm just trying to understand it from different points of view.

OP posts:
Makethemostofit · 28/10/2023 10:05

The other this is that your brother could have set you up in some way, which makes you come across as more of a cartoon than a real person, so she isn’t empathising with your need for social reciprocation. ‘My sister’s so amazing, she is so clever, never gets anything wrong!’ totally intimidating, or ‘My sister always acts like she should get the best of everything - she’s such a spoiled brat’, a caricature of a manipulator.

kitchensinksers · 28/10/2023 10:04

You sound really socially confident.

There is also a thing that some (introvert/anxious) people feel uncomfortable answering questions about themselves, because they feel they need to be truthful and don’t like the rejection. If you ask them something innocent like “Have you got any plans for the weekend?” they may panic, thinking ‘ah no, I am probably going to sit around gaming, I never plan anything, they’re going to judge me for not making plans’. Because that question stresses them out, they don’t ask you.

The only real solution is to try to find out about their interests, which is hard work, especially if you aren’t interested in it, and they’ll sense you faking it. The other thing is to talk about your own anxieties and screw ups to put them at ease, and they would open up about their own. But you might not feel comfortable talking about that stuff in front of your brother though.

You know it's so funny you mention the weekend question, I hate the weekend question myself. I don't like to have too many plans ( even pre kids ) and always hated it when people asked in the office. I used to make stuff up sometimes or embellish it a bit because saying that I'll probably watch Netflix all weekend and get a take away just doesn't sound good to most people. And yes it's also not something I love to ask others, but I do ask sometimes just for something to say.

To your second point I have already made fun of myself in front of her in a lighthearted way a few times and let some vulnerabilities shine through to make her feel more at ease and able to open up. I am quite down to earth and approachable. At least that's how I think I am, maybe I'm totally wrong and I come across like a complete dick. More likely !

I'm sure we we get to know each other more, we will get to understand what we are like and a friendship might grow or not. Whichever is the case, it will be fine.

OP posts:
saraclara · 28/10/2023 10:00

This is so sad. You could easily be talking about someone I love dearly. She is such a good person, but finds it very difficult to initiate conversation. She can respond to other people initiating it, but just find it hugely difficult to come up with conversation starters. Hence she's another person who'll keep herself busy with helping out in the kitchen or playing with children. She needs a role to help her manage social situations. She's not being rude. She's really trying her best.

So it really bothers me that at least one pp is telling OP to cut off her SIL for this.

kitchensinksers · 28/10/2023 09:57

AnnaMagnani · 28/10/2023 09:52

Maybe she just feels differently about family relationships to you?

You think your BIL's GF is a very significant person in your life.

It's also reasonable to feel this is a pretty tenuous relationship that you needn't put much effort in to.

No I don't think it's that. We have similar family expectations due to similar backgrounds. She talks about her family a lot and how close they are and she also knows how close BIL is with his family.

These are definitely important relationships to all parties involved, including her.

OP posts:
Makethemostofit · 28/10/2023 09:56

kitchensinksers · 28/10/2023 09:43

Maybe it's all in my head ? I can't make sense of it. I'm in two minds if it's in my head. I noticed to my H and he has since noticed it too.

Maybe she's anxious indeed. She seems very confident but it can be intimidating when you're new in a family. But when I was new in my H family I made a massive effort to get to know everyone and pretty much ignored my H whenever we went round and just spent time with his parents and siblings, getting to know them.

She's not that young. Early 30s.

You sound really socially confident.

There is also a thing that some (introvert/anxious) people feel uncomfortable answering questions about themselves, because they feel they need to be truthful and don’t like the rejection. If you ask them something innocent like “Have you got any plans for the weekend?” they may panic, thinking ‘ah no, I am probably going to sit around gaming, I never plan anything, they’re going to judge me for not making plans’. Because that question stresses them out, they don’t ask you.

The only real solution is to try to find out about their interests, which is hard work, especially if you aren’t interested in it, and they’ll sense you faking it. The other thing is to talk about your own anxieties and screw ups to put them at ease, and they would open up about their own. But you might not feel comfortable talking about that stuff in front of your brother though.

Delphigirl · 28/10/2023 09:55

Maybe she just doesn’t have very much to say for herself - is a bit boring or not very bright. Could be as simple as that really. The type who, once she has kids of her own, is unable to talk about anything but them. I would t worry about it. Just see her less or manage your expectations downwards of what you might get out of her.

kitchensinksers · 28/10/2023 09:55

Aquamarine1029 · 28/10/2023 09:49

I wouldn't be having her around, personally. I couldn't be bothered with someone who won't even show minimal politeness to me in my own home.

Off she pops somewhere else.

I've made it sound worse than it is I think.

It's just not as fluid as it is with other people and I find myself holding back starting the engagement. Which is unusual in a normal interaction for me as I don't even think about it usually.

However of course she's polite and says hello when she comes in and ' how have you been ? '. But then she's just focused on everyone else, unless I specifically engage with her and she often loses focus to the kids and BIL when we are talking. The kids love her though and they do try to pull our focus when speaking etc. so it could be partly that.

Maybe she's just a bit shy. But we actually have quite a bit in common, but again unless I start a convo about it, there's not much coming back.

I think she's really nice and things will be fine. Maybe it's just some kind of insecurity in me or it's just the circumstances we meet under or something like that.

OP posts:
Didimum · 28/10/2023 09:54

I would assume she is socially awkward/can’t think of much to say. As long as everyone is pleasant, I don’t see a huge issue.

AnnaMagnani · 28/10/2023 09:52

Maybe she just feels differently about family relationships to you?

You think your BIL's GF is a very significant person in your life.

It's also reasonable to feel this is a pretty tenuous relationship that you needn't put much effort in to.

Aquamarine1029 · 28/10/2023 09:49

I wouldn't be having her around, personally. I couldn't be bothered with someone who won't even show minimal politeness to me in my own home.

Off she pops somewhere else.

Swipe left for the next trending thread