Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be offended by GP comment?

280 replies

Macadamia1976 · 28/10/2023 08:04

I have severely injured my lower back. I'm in agony and can't move without pain.
I bent down, lifted a heavy double buggy up from the ground, twisted round whilst bending over to lift it into the boot of my car then overstretched to position it in properly. I did this really quickly and something snapped in my lower back and I suddenly felt searing agony.
After initial urgent care treatment and being diagnosed with a torn ligament, I had a follow up with GP for pain management.
Never seen him before.
He was in his late 30s, maybe 40.
He said "I fail to see how lifting a buggy into the boot has caused this."
I said "Well I was told in hospital it was a combination of bending and twisting my lower back whilst lifting a heavy object. Plus I have an old injury in the same area of my back so I think maybe it was a weak area..."
He said "No, I think this is wrong. It's not possible to be in as much pain as you say you are in from putting a buggy into your car."
At this point I was confused by why he was challenging my injury. I was in pain, and was there for a pain relief medication review.
He said "It's because you need to lose weight."
I said "Pardon?"
He smiled for a few seconds, then said "Yes, you need to lose a stone from your tummy area, if you don't mind me saying" whilst really smiling. "Then your back pain will resolve. You have done this to yourself by eating too much and the stone in weight that sits on your tummy is putting a strain on your lower back. It wasn't lifting the buggy. I'll give you more painkillers but you need to get rid of that stone of weight on your tummy".
I didn't even realise he had even noticed my tummy.
I was wearing trousers and a top.
I am 5ft 7 and weigh 11 stone.
I wear size 12 to 14 clothes.
I've had 2 emergency c-sections so I admit I do have a tummy overhang, but I hadn't thought of this as a problem, I just see it as a result of having emergency abdominal surgery 2 times to save my 2 DC's lives when they were born. I don't really think about it, I'm too busy looking after my DC and working hard in my job.
I was almost crying in pain during this appointment.
AIBU to be upset by his comments?
Or am I in so much pain that I'm feeling oversensitive.
(Edited typos)

OP posts:
Honeyandwine · 28/10/2023 09:44

I don't normally say this but I think you need to complain. He sounds like a total prick. Even if you were overweight- which you are not, the way he said it was insensitive and unkind. He sounds like he enjoyed saying it you.

3luckystars · 28/10/2023 09:43

So thin people can’t hurt their backs?

you obviously have been doing a lot of lifting and the wear and tear damaged your back, the pram was just the final straw. Are you going to complain?

Foxblue · 28/10/2023 09:42

Formal complaint - people do their backs in getting out of bed, and at 11 stone at 5.7 you are within NHS guidelines for a healthy weight, he has NO leg to stand on and any decent doctor would be horrified. Definitely ask to see a different doctor.

Disorganisedmess2023 · 28/10/2023 09:42

I've had so many appointments where they've said things are weight related. Honestly I think I could go in with a broken finger and they'd somehow bring it back to weight.

Balloonhearts · 28/10/2023 09:41

What a twat. You absolutely can put your back out like that. My mum did it by turning and bending to reach the remote control and she's never been more than 9 stone in her life.

jadey1991 · 28/10/2023 09:40

Op the doc u saw is a twat.

How dare he say anything about how u look.
B4 being pregnant with baby no 4 I have a overhang. I'm 5 ft 9 and weigh probs same amount as u ot slightly more.

I would make a complaint babes. Don't feel any type of way because that man said something to you. Personally I would have told him to shut the f**k up and not to analyse me like that.

Dedo get his name and complain

WonderingWanda · 28/10/2023 09:39

Please make a complaint about this twat of a man. At that weight and height your bmi will be well within the normal limits. I am an inch taller and a stone heavier. He is completely out of order.

stayflufft · 28/10/2023 09:36

What an ignorant prick of a man. Of course you can put your back out lifting a heavy buggy! Re his comments about your stomach - how dare he.

AdalineStephen · 28/10/2023 09:36

The smiling while telling you that is chilling. I wouldn't be surprised if he has some sort of personality disorder.

Do put in a complaint. If enough complaints build up, it might build a picture of someone who shouldn't be in such a position of trust/authority.

Noicant · 28/10/2023 09:32

My DH is a healthy weight, his back is fucked from lugging DD around. Your GP is an idiot.

Stillwaitingfor · 28/10/2023 09:31

To play devil's advocate, perhaps he could have been genuinely trying to help. He may be trying to find the root cause of your issue rather than simply patch with painkillers. He may really believe that you losing weight will reduce your pain in future.

However, weight is such a sensitive topic, it needed to be handled better than this. And he was outright wrong to say you couldn't do your back in in the way you said (I did it putting my toddler down in an awkward way).

But to be honest, the more GPs I've seen, the more I think the system they operate in encourages them to dehumanise their patients. I am also puzzled as to why so many of them have chosen a people-facing career when they appear to have a serious deficit of emotional intelligence.

twattydogshavetwattypeople · 28/10/2023 09:31

That doctor needs to lose at least a kilo of fat from his head.

Mamma2017 · 28/10/2023 09:30

I’m actually struggling to believe this is real tbh because firstly he’s medically incorrect-loading the spine while twisting is a classic cause of injury…whether that is ligament tear or disc or nerve root injury……..and also because your bmi from the statistics does not put you in the overweight category…….and also because……a small amount of extra weight around your middle would not create sudden, acute searing pain…..and also because to tell a patient they don’t believe what they are saying and they doubt and discount their level of pain (which is obviously subjective) would be not only a dreadful bedside manner and rude and unprofessional but also actually an act of negligence. He’s is not referring you for the investigations and care you need. I’m not saying you have made this up OP or exaggerated or that this is a wind up but it’s just so shocking, it is possible this individual is an extreme misogynist to the level he has compromised his professional standards and duty of care. He needs reporting asap.

(it’s perfectly fine obviously for a GP to tell a patient they need to lose weight under the appropriate circumstances but this instance for the reasons above is not and is not acceptable).

Justwrong68 · 28/10/2023 09:29

He's an idiot. He should've talked about pain relief only and then referred you for physio/ core strengthening. He sounds like a sadist.

WindUpBird · 28/10/2023 09:29

The Gp is an ignorant condescending twat.
I put my back out by sitting down in a chair and standing up again. Excruciating agony ensued for weeks. FWIW I’m a size 10.
Hope your back gets better soon, regular Pilates has helped mine - find some YouTube videos if you can’t get to an instructor. The NHS site has links to lower back Pilates videos but I haven’t tried those.

C8H10N4O2 · 28/10/2023 09:28

Change GP and tell them why or say why you are unhappy. A GP who tells someone with a normal BMI that their problem is weight despite that report from the hospital with orthopedic input isn't worth seeing.

wesurecouldstandgladioli · 28/10/2023 09:28

Complain. He wouldn’t say that to a man.

Cantdoitallperfectly · 28/10/2023 09:26

Came on to stay exactly what @Ginmonkeyagain said. I’ve got recurrent back pain, I once had an episode triggered by putting my shopping in the car. I would say you will have weak core muscles and once you strengthen them, it’ll make a huge difference. See a physiotherapist for advice.

I would complain and provide feedback for the Dr, he gave you unsolicited and BAD information. Just Losing weight will not help, strength and conditioning will. Hope it improves soon, for me it usually take 2-3 weeks to settle.

NoraLuka · 28/10/2023 09:25

Please complain and try to see a different doctor or physiotherapist, there might be exercises that would help.

I am a similar height and weight as you and it’s almost exactly in the middle of the healthy BMI range, there’s no way it’s solely a weight issue.

PersephonePomegranate23 · 28/10/2023 09:25

He's a dick and it sounds like he enjoyed being a dick by your description of events.

These things can happen very quickly. I've caused myself endless grief with a careless twist of my knee!

You don't sound overweight, I'd be more inclined to say that being a mum in a hurry caused this. Also, after 2 C sections, did it not occur to him that maybe your core is weaker than usual?

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 28/10/2023 09:25

When I was a teenager my super fit, toned, energetic dance teacher slipped a disc by twisting to throw a tea bag in the bin.

That doctor is talking absolute bollocks.

LorW · 28/10/2023 09:24

Please put in a formal complaint OP, and never see him again, absolutely horrendous!

LunaTheCat · 28/10/2023 09:24

What an idiot.
E mail practice manager and ask for another opinion.

Ginmonkeyagain · 28/10/2023 09:24

Going forward I would also look at glute and leg strengthening exercises as it is better and safer to pick up heavily things squatting with a straight back so your thighs take the weight, but that requires practice and strong core and legs.

We all rely too much on our lower backs when lifting and turning and get injured.

NalafromtheLionKing · 28/10/2023 09:21

Are you able to change GPs? If so, you definitely should.