Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I have a nut allergy and colleague eating nuts in office.

466 replies

Yewdontknowme · 28/10/2023 02:29

I’ve been working with this company since June. It’s with a small company with two open plan rooms in the same building. There is no HR department just the owners and the general manager and supervisors. One room is nut free as myself and an intern are severely allergic, the other room is ok for nuts. We never have to go into the other office. We are allocated space based on what we do within the company and wfh isn’t an option. For the past few months everything has been great.

A supervisor has returned to our office this past fortnight after maternity leave. It seems she is really popular among the other women in the office. She has ignored all the signs and warnings and has been eating nuts at her workstation, which is making me wheeze and my throat and mouth are itching until I get away home. I’m working dosed up on piriton and with fingers crossed I don’t need to use my epipen.

Our manager is a bit of a coward so has been trying to deal with this woman calmly including offering her a space in the other room but she’s refusing to swap rooms as she wants to be with her friends and likes the bigger workspace she has. She is claiming it’s discriminating against her as a returning mother and a vegetarian and so she will continue to eat what she wants, as in her words “they’re not eating the nuts themselves so they’ll be ok”. For what it’s worth I too am a vegetarian. She also told us to get epipens. Myself and the intern can’t go into the other room as the work in there is totally different to what we do. We need the facilities in this space. Our manager has told us we need to sort it out among ourselves.

I appreciate this is a management problem but what am I supposed to do in the meantime? I’m still on probation and this woman is a long standing staff member. It took me a long time to find this job after redundancy in lockdown and I’m terrified I’ll be laid off after my probationary period runs out because of the drama this causes. I can start looking for another job but I fear it will take me over a year again.

AIBU to expect the manager to deal with this woman instead of having to sort out a ‘compromise’ myself?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Triplixate · 29/10/2023 16:57

I had a similar issue (not involving an allergy but a disability related issue). My union were nothing short of cowardly with dealing with it and just wouldn’t put their foot down. Anyway, I arrived at work one day, was presented with the issue and just thought “fuck it” and left. I drove off to a local car park and called HR, told them why I wasn’t in work. Anyway, 30-45 mins later I arrived back on site and everything was resolved and I never had another issue. I think sometimes with things like this you just have to stamp your feet a bit because being nice just doesn’t get through people’s thick skulls when they’re this way inclined.

cultureplanet · 29/10/2023 16:45

most people wouldn’t want to see any harm come to a colleague and will happily comply.

agreed

but my point is - In large open plan offices, of which there are many ie call centres, insurers, banks etc - you have hundreds on one open plan floor. Multiple teams side by side who barely interact with one another.

cultureplanet · 29/10/2023 16:44

pam290358 · 29/10/2023 15:34

Doesn’t make a jot of difference how large or small the organisation is. The Equality Act covers all employers. And if the OP’s allergy is serious enough to be covered as a disability under the Act, then the employer needs to show they’ve made every effort to provide a reasonable adjustment. Banning the eating of nuts in the office where she works is an easy adjustment - as previous posters have pointed out, most people wouldn’t want to see any harm come to a colleague and will happily comply.

But reasonable adjustment is NOT the same for all companies irrespective of size and finances. Thankfully the HSE acknowledges different standards apply

cultureplanet · 29/10/2023 16:42

Rosscameasdoody · 29/10/2023 15:26

Reasonable adjustment isn’t enforced by HSE. It comes under the Equality Act 2010 which was designed to ensure fair treatment at work for disabled people. If the OP’s allergy qualifies as a disability under the Act (and from what’s she’s said, it sounds as though it does) once she makes her employer aware of it, they then have an obligation under the Act to make ‘reasonable adjustment’ in order to make sure that she is not disadvantaged at work by her condition.

In the OP’s case it’s an easy adjustment. No-one eats nuts in the office where she works. The employer has already done this and put up warning signs to that effect. One employee is disregarding it, and the employer needs to ensure that they understand the severity of the allergy and the possible consequences. The employee then has two choices, either stop introducing a dangerous allergen into the presence of someone vulnerable to it, or move to the other office.

That may well be a “reasonable” policy in a very small company

Not in a large open plan offices with teams working alongside us.

cakes, bars, cereal, snack packets of nuts,

CornishClott · 29/10/2023 16:05

She's a selfish cow . She could eat those nuts at home . She's doing this on purpose.

Zanatdy · 29/10/2023 15:58

Sort it out between yourselves? No, your manager needs to get a backbone and tell this woman she’s putting people at risk. I’d just ban all eating at desks if she didn’t listen. Who does she think she is?

Riola · 29/10/2023 15:57

@twostraws i agree. In my first year of uni there was a girl with a severe peanut allergy in my halls of residence. I didn’t understand that she wasn’t allowed to be exposed to nuts at all and made the mistake of making a peanut crunch thing which led to a stray nut being left on the worktop. I was horrified when another flatmate saw it and spoke to me about it and told me exactly how allergic she is.

Once I’d checked with her and she confirmed that yes, it could have caused a reaction, I just apologised and made sure I didn’t eat peanuts in our flat again. She was really gracious about it too.

It wasn’t a problem for any of the other students on our floor either. We were all aged 18-20. It’s remarkable that this mother/ working woman, who I assume is at least in her 20s if not older, can’t show the same regard in a professional context as a bunch of teenagers living away from home for the first time.

pam290358 · 29/10/2023 15:37

twostraws · 29/10/2023 13:49

I'm not sure you're reading any of my words.

It's perfectly normal to mention a nut allergy in passing before formally starting somewhere and for the staff to take it upon themselves to make an adjustment, especially if it's a small team.

The OP might have worked in a nut-free environment before due to their colleagues taking it upon themselves to create that environment, rather than being told by HR that they should.

Most people don't want to kill the new joiner, especially if the new joiner is there to pick up some of the slack, thus making their life easier!

It is incredibly rare to come across someone who doesn't give a damn about a colleague's life threatening allergy. Most people are considerate. It's completely plausible this is the first time the OP has encountered someone with such a selfish attitude and is at a loss as to how to resolve this.

This.

pam290358 · 29/10/2023 15:34

cultureplanet · 29/10/2023 13:44

I presume then the op has only ever worked in very small organisations

Doesn’t make a jot of difference how large or small the organisation is. The Equality Act covers all employers. And if the OP’s allergy is serious enough to be covered as a disability under the Act, then the employer needs to show they’ve made every effort to provide a reasonable adjustment. Banning the eating of nuts in the office where she works is an easy adjustment - as previous posters have pointed out, most people wouldn’t want to see any harm come to a colleague and will happily comply.

Rosscameasdoody · 29/10/2023 15:30

cultureplanet · 29/10/2023 12:29

And I would think that if this is life or death - the OP would mention this before accepting the role.

why? Because it is clearly a very small business with limited office space

Well she clearly has hasn’t she ? So what’s your point? The employer is aware that two employees have allergies and has made her office a nut free environment, with signage to that effect. The only fly in the ointment is a returning employee who appears to be hell bent on sabotage.

Rosscameasdoody · 29/10/2023 15:26

cultureplanet · 29/10/2023 12:28

they have an obligation to make ‘reasonable adjustment’ wherever possible so that the employee is not disadvantaged in the workplace.

a very small company with a total office space comprising of 2 rooms

not a chance that the HSE would think it unreasonable for an employer not to be able to provide this. 50% of the office guaranteed as nut free is not a “reasonable adjustment”

Reasonable adjustment isn’t enforced by HSE. It comes under the Equality Act 2010 which was designed to ensure fair treatment at work for disabled people. If the OP’s allergy qualifies as a disability under the Act (and from what’s she’s said, it sounds as though it does) once she makes her employer aware of it, they then have an obligation under the Act to make ‘reasonable adjustment’ in order to make sure that she is not disadvantaged at work by her condition.

In the OP’s case it’s an easy adjustment. No-one eats nuts in the office where she works. The employer has already done this and put up warning signs to that effect. One employee is disregarding it, and the employer needs to ensure that they understand the severity of the allergy and the possible consequences. The employee then has two choices, either stop introducing a dangerous allergen into the presence of someone vulnerable to it, or move to the other office.

cultureplanet · 29/10/2023 14:01

It's perfectly normal to mention a nut allergy in passing before formally starting somewhere

your nut allergy is not as fraction as serious as the OP’s by the sounds of it. I imagine one’s approach to nuts is a bit more than a “mention in passing” if it’s life or death

cultureplanet · 29/10/2023 14:00

You haven’t worked In big open plan offices then. With multiple teams. In the same very large room

twostraws · 29/10/2023 13:49

cultureplanet · 29/10/2023 13:43

This may well be the first time that the OP has needed an employer to formally do anything!

Unless this is the op’s first ever job, then this is very unlikely. Nuts are… everywhere

I'm not sure you're reading any of my words.

It's perfectly normal to mention a nut allergy in passing before formally starting somewhere and for the staff to take it upon themselves to make an adjustment, especially if it's a small team.

The OP might have worked in a nut-free environment before due to their colleagues taking it upon themselves to create that environment, rather than being told by HR that they should.

Most people don't want to kill the new joiner, especially if the new joiner is there to pick up some of the slack, thus making their life easier!

It is incredibly rare to come across someone who doesn't give a damn about a colleague's life threatening allergy. Most people are considerate. It's completely plausible this is the first time the OP has encountered someone with such a selfish attitude and is at a loss as to how to resolve this.

cultureplanet · 29/10/2023 13:44

I presume then the op has only ever worked in very small organisations

cultureplanet · 29/10/2023 13:43

This may well be the first time that the OP has needed an employer to formally do anything!

Unless this is the op’s first ever job, then this is very unlikely. Nuts are… everywhere

twostraws · 29/10/2023 13:42

cultureplanet · 29/10/2023 13:40

In your case not necessary

but the op says in her case it is necessary

You're completely missing my point. The OP may have worked with colleagues before who have voluntarily declared the whole workspace a nut free zone without HR having to tell them.

This may be the first time the OP has encountered someone who had decided their wish to eat some nuts is more important than the OP's wish to stay alive.

I've rarely had to formally request reasonable adjustments because my previous colleagues have just made adjustments.

cultureplanet · 29/10/2023 13:40

twostraws · 29/10/2023 13:38

TBF, maybe there's been no need.

I can be around people eating nuts as long as they are considerate with disposing of the remnants and washing up. In my case, it's a contact allergy - I will react if my skin touches the nuts or worse, if I ingest the nuts.

Pretty much everyone I've ever worked with has been more paranoid about my allergy than me. Several have refused to bring nuts into the workplace even though I've explained they can eat nuts in my presence without me getting sick.

It's rare to encounter some as pigheaded as the OP's colleague who just doesn't believe in allergies. Most humans are decent, and on realising they can take some simple steps to avoid killing a peer will take those steps.

This may well be the first time that the OP has needed an employer to formally do anything!

In your case not necessary

but the op says in her case it is necessary

twostraws · 29/10/2023 13:38

cultureplanet · 29/10/2023 11:51

So all your previous employers to date have provided you with a nut free office?

TBF, maybe there's been no need.

I can be around people eating nuts as long as they are considerate with disposing of the remnants and washing up. In my case, it's a contact allergy - I will react if my skin touches the nuts or worse, if I ingest the nuts.

Pretty much everyone I've ever worked with has been more paranoid about my allergy than me. Several have refused to bring nuts into the workplace even though I've explained they can eat nuts in my presence without me getting sick.

It's rare to encounter some as pigheaded as the OP's colleague who just doesn't believe in allergies. Most humans are decent, and on realising they can take some simple steps to avoid killing a peer will take those steps.

This may well be the first time that the OP has needed an employer to formally do anything!

Hipnotised · 29/10/2023 13:34

Hopefully all your concerns are in writing to your manager.

If not, start a paper trail.

TheSandgroper · 29/10/2023 13:18

Off topic and I am sorry to hijack but Hello to @SandGroperNomad . There are three sandgropers on MN now that I know of.

cultureplanet · 29/10/2023 12:29

Rosscameasdoody · 29/10/2023 11:57

There is no legal obligation for a disabled person to disclose a disability to an employer, and employers are not allowed to ask about disability/health conditions at interview. Once the employer is made aware of an issue, they have an obligation to make ‘reasonable adjustment’ wherever possible so that the employee is not disadvantaged in the workplace. It sounds as though this has been done if the office is nut free and there are signs up to that effect - that being the case, the employer should now be enforcing the protected workspace they’ve created for the employee and her colleague.

And I would think that if this is life or death - the OP would mention this before accepting the role.

why? Because it is clearly a very small business with limited office space

cultureplanet · 29/10/2023 12:28

they have an obligation to make ‘reasonable adjustment’ wherever possible so that the employee is not disadvantaged in the workplace.

a very small company with a total office space comprising of 2 rooms

not a chance that the HSE would think it unreasonable for an employer not to be able to provide this. 50% of the office guaranteed as nut free is not a “reasonable adjustment”

DotAndCarryOne2 · 29/10/2023 12:09

Yewdontknowme · 29/10/2023 11:28

Sorry I haven’t managed to return to read through everything I’ve been unwell (unrelated to post). Thank you to those who have been helpful with your advice.

I should probably have said I have made her aware previously of the severity of my allergy and asked that she went elsewhere to consume her nuts but as someone on the early pages of the thread highlighted in their own situation where their colleague didn’t believe in anaphylaxis, I think this is maybe similar. I’m now worrying she’s trying to see what will happen but my rational head will kick in again soon.

I’m going to contact ACAS first thing and I’ve looked at the health and safety website but it relates predominantly to medical situations so harder to wave in front of my manager.

I will try to read through the whole thread and answer anything that pops up but it might take me a while.

pam290358 · Yesterday 09:24

Your manager, and consequently the company, are in breach of the Equality Act 2010 and they need to be made aware of that and the possible consequences if they don’t step up and tackle your utterly ignorant and self centred colleague - who, by the way, is not being discriminated against either as a vegetarian or a mother. This would only be the case if she was the only one being asked not to eat nuts in the office.

OP your allergy qualifies as a disability under the Equality Act 2010 and as such your employer has to make reasonable adjustment so that your condition does not put you at a disadvantage in the workplace. It seems as though they have already done this for you and another colleague and the reasonable adjustment here is simply making your office nut free and putting up warning notices to that effect. This is protected in law and therefore your colleague can’t simply rock up and eat nuts in a protected workspace.

Apart from the obvious consequences to your health, which I think breach health and safety at work laws, there are consequences under the Equality Act if your employer does not resolve the situation - your manager has a responsibility to do this, he can’t simply leave it for you to ‘sort out among yourselves’.

You have what’s called ‘protected characteristics’ under the Equality Act, by reason of your disability, and that means that you do not need to have worked for your employer for the statutory two years to be able to take action if they refuse to resolve a problem directly related to your disability. You should also know that a probation period has no meaning in employment law - it doesn’t absolve the employer of the responsibility to treat you fairly, or of the obligation to honour notice periods.

Your employer cannot dismiss you for anything disability related unless they can show that they have tried their best to make reasonable adjustment to accommodate it. In this case it’s blindingly simple - they keep the office nut free and the problem is solved. By allowing an employee to breach the protected workspace created for you and your colleague, they have broken the agreement and must put it right. Dismissing you because they don’t want to upset another employee, isn’t an option and if they were to give you notice you would potentially have a case for unfair dismissal.

If they refuse to resolve the situation and the working environment continues to cause you problems to the point where you have to leave, this is called constructive dismissal - they have made it impossible for you to continue working there. Again you would potentially have a case for unfair dismissal on those grounds.

The simplest way to resolve this is to ask for a meeting with your manager, and ask for someone to accompany you - a union rep or colleague - to take notes. Then make the manager aware of their responsibilities under the Act and ask formally for the situation to be resolved. You can find a copy of the Equality Act 2010 online here https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2010/15/contents. I would suggest specifically familiarising yourself with the sections on reasonable adjustment and protected characteristics. ACAS can also advise you accordingly but they won’t approach an employer on your behalf. If your manager is willing, they can approach ACAS who will advise directly in those circumstances.

You do not need a formal diagnosis of a condition to qualify as disabled under the Act - the disability or health condition just has to meet the eligibility criteria for you to receive the protection described above. Obviously if you have medical evidence to support what you’re saying then it’s a good idea to take it along and have it noted in the meeting. Good luck.
Equality Act 2010
An Act to make provision to require Ministers of the Crown and others when making strategic decisions about the exercise of their functions to have regard to the desirability of reducing socio-economic inequalities; to reform and harmonise equality law...
https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2010/15/contents

OP, this is what you need to do. From what you’ve said, it appears that your allergy qualifies as a disability under the Act, and that your employer has already complied with their obligation to make ‘reasonable adjustment’ by making your workspace nut free. If this is the case, it’s easier to use the Equality Act, as the employers’ obligations under it are simpler and clearer cut than Health and Safety legislation, and confers the protection you and your other colleague need. When you contact ACAS, ask about your rights, protected characteristics, and also the employers obligations under the Act. Best of luck, I hope you get it sorted.

Equality Act 2010

An Act to make provision to require Ministers of the Crown and others when making strategic decisions about the exercise of their functions to have regard to the desirability of reducing socio-economic inequalities; to reform and harmonise equality law...

https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2010/15/contents