Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I have a nut allergy and colleague eating nuts in office.

466 replies

Yewdontknowme · 28/10/2023 02:29

I’ve been working with this company since June. It’s with a small company with two open plan rooms in the same building. There is no HR department just the owners and the general manager and supervisors. One room is nut free as myself and an intern are severely allergic, the other room is ok for nuts. We never have to go into the other office. We are allocated space based on what we do within the company and wfh isn’t an option. For the past few months everything has been great.

A supervisor has returned to our office this past fortnight after maternity leave. It seems she is really popular among the other women in the office. She has ignored all the signs and warnings and has been eating nuts at her workstation, which is making me wheeze and my throat and mouth are itching until I get away home. I’m working dosed up on piriton and with fingers crossed I don’t need to use my epipen.

Our manager is a bit of a coward so has been trying to deal with this woman calmly including offering her a space in the other room but she’s refusing to swap rooms as she wants to be with her friends and likes the bigger workspace she has. She is claiming it’s discriminating against her as a returning mother and a vegetarian and so she will continue to eat what she wants, as in her words “they’re not eating the nuts themselves so they’ll be ok”. For what it’s worth I too am a vegetarian. She also told us to get epipens. Myself and the intern can’t go into the other room as the work in there is totally different to what we do. We need the facilities in this space. Our manager has told us we need to sort it out among ourselves.

I appreciate this is a management problem but what am I supposed to do in the meantime? I’m still on probation and this woman is a long standing staff member. It took me a long time to find this job after redundancy in lockdown and I’m terrified I’ll be laid off after my probationary period runs out because of the drama this causes. I can start looking for another job but I fear it will take me over a year again.

AIBU to expect the manager to deal with this woman instead of having to sort out a ‘compromise’ myself?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Adam1630 · 30/10/2023 17:38

Gcsunnyside23 · 30/10/2023 16:58

Are you the dickish workmate?? In the same reference if the work colleague can't eat nuts at her desk so someone in the office doesn't need to use medication then big deal, she's not going to die of starvation. She also needs to grow up and stop being an inconsiderate cow. I have both hay fever and allergies and it's not the same. Hay fever can't kill you actual allergy can or it can cause severe medical complications so yes being in the same room is dangerous to her especially constant exposure to it and u washed surfaces

Try reading Anaphylaxis UK guidance. They do not recommend an allergen free environment, nor indeed a nut free environment. So no I’m not the :“Dickish workmate” I’m the person who can see the light of day and recognises the sensible course of action

Adam1630 · 30/10/2023 17:35

cultureplanet · 30/10/2023 17:03

@Adam1630

You should always call 999 if someone is seriously ill or injured, or their life is at risk

not your made up definition of “life threatening emergency”

Perhaps you should all read the guidance from Anaphylaxis UK who do I not advocate nut free environments “We don’t typically recommend complete nut bans because they are very difficult to enforce and can lead to a false sense of security. Children can be allergic to other common food allergens, for example milk and egg, and it would be impossible to ban them all. We recommend a whole school allergy awareness approach of all allergens. Settings should carry out an individual risk assessment for any child with an allergy and put appropriate measures in place to reduce the risks as far as possible. Every setting is different, but this may include extra cleaning measures or adjustments of the timings and locations of meals and snacks if necessary.”

the following is the official guidance of when you should call an ambulance, note it does not include the first signs of an allergic reaction

  • signs of a heart attack
  • chest pain, pressure, heaviness, tightness or squeezing across the chest
  • signs of a stroke
  • face dropping on one side, cannot hold both arms up, difficulty speaking
  • sudden confusion (delirium)
  • cannot be sure of own name or age
  • suicide attempt
  • by taking something or self-harming
  • severe difficulty breathing
  • not being able to get words out, choking or gasping
  • choking
  • on liquids or solids right now
  • heavy bleeding
  • spraying, pouring or enough to make a puddle
  • severe injuries
  • after a serious accident or assault
  • seizure (fit)
  • shaking or jerking because of a fit, or unconscious (cannot be woken up)
  • sudden, rapid swelling
  • of the lips, mouth, throat or tongue
cultureplanet · 30/10/2023 17:05

Life threatening doesn’t mean you are minutes away from death

It means that the situation is such as to present a threat to life

cultureplanet · 30/10/2023 17:03

@Adam1630

You should always call 999 if someone is seriously ill or injured, or their life is at risk

not your made up definition of “life threatening emergency”

Gcsunnyside23 · 30/10/2023 16:58

Adam1630 · 30/10/2023 08:19

So you have to take piriton at work, big deal! How many people have to work dosed up on piriton throughout the summer months because they suffer with hay fever. No one is forcing you to eat nuts, no one is exposing you to “nut dust” let’s face it nuts don’t create dust. Non ingestion allergic reactions to nuts doesn’t really happen, certainly not enough to cause anaphylaxis. https://www.wsh.nhs.uk/CMS-Documents/Patient-leaflets/PaediatricDepartment/6438-1-Nut-allergy.pdf

it sounds to me like to are being overly sensitive, of course you must be careful not to ingest nuts, but that does not extend to a nut free zone around you.

Are you the dickish workmate?? In the same reference if the work colleague can't eat nuts at her desk so someone in the office doesn't need to use medication then big deal, she's not going to die of starvation. She also needs to grow up and stop being an inconsiderate cow. I have both hay fever and allergies and it's not the same. Hay fever can't kill you actual allergy can or it can cause severe medical complications so yes being in the same room is dangerous to her especially constant exposure to it and u washed surfaces

Adam1630 · 30/10/2023 16:46

pam290358 · 30/10/2023 11:48

Try quoting the post you are replying to, as otherwise no one knows to whom your comments are addressed. So no one here - apart from the completely batshit posters who advocate faking a seizure to get the point across - is advocating calling an ambulance if unnecessary. But from my own experience, I worked with a colleague who had a very severe allergy that sometimes went from the the first signs to a choking response in a very short space of time. Would you advocate waiting until someone’s reaction is life threatening before calling for help, because that ‘s how you’re coming across.

To a point, yes i would advocate waiting until the reaction is life threatening, because that is exactly what 999 is for, “life threatening emergencies”. No one should be calling for an ambulance at the first signs of an allergic reaction, ie an itchy throat. Yes they should call for an ambulance if the reaction proceeds to anaphylaxis but not because they have an allergic reaction. I was at work once when i had an epileptic seizure and the first aider called an ambulance, when i came round I went bat shit at them for wasting resources, it was not life threatening, they were just protecting their liability and that is wrong

jbuggy86 · 30/10/2023 16:37

My suggestion is to email the selfish coworker, also cc manager and the owner letting them know that you need a nut free work area as being around nuts affects your health op. If it continues and you need to go to the hospital for a reaction to said allergy you will send the company and said selfish employee the bill for said hospital visits and may move forward with legal action for endangering your health. Unfortunately the threat of legal action is one of the few things that spark fire under somes bottoms.

StaunchMomma · 30/10/2023 15:50

This is nothing short of outrageous!

Your employer has a duty to keep you safe and they can't really claim they are doing so wen they have allocated you a nut-free space that they know is not nut free!

They need to send her on an allergy awareness course. She is clearly ignorant of the harm she could be causing. If you are wheezing due to the airborne particles then this could turn nasty very quickly. I agree with a previous poster that calling an ambulance would send a clear message.

I'd also be quoting employment law to your managers as this dumb ass of a woman is seriously compromising the Health & Safety of several members of staff.

Can you join an independent union? Or afford to see a solicitor?

Glasgowgal200 · 30/10/2023 15:42

Could you and your fellow nut allergy colleague do some sort of presentation on how dangerous a nut allergy is - she may not fully understand it or set up a first aid training including what to do if someone has an anaphylactic shock. Otherwise agree with other posters and think about suing her

Adam1630 · 30/10/2023 14:51

I’m not a denier, and the article i quoted was produced directly by the NHS which I think you will agree carries just as much weight as a BMJ article. I specifically said that the risk of non ingestive anaphylaxis was extremely low. Whilst it was possible to have mild allergic symptoms from airborne nut particles, the risk of full blown anaphylaxis was vanishingly low. The article you quoted referred to an increase in the number of food induced anaphylaxis cases, which is specifically different to non ingestive anaphylaxis as i mentioned.

DD1963 · 30/10/2023 13:26

A serious nut allergy would be recognised as a disability under the Disability discrimination act. Your employers are are failing in their duties towards you if they fail to make 'reasonable adjustments'. You have done all you can and been more than reasonable. You now need to ask for an 'informal' meeting to discuss the situation (which needs to be documented). If your employers fail to act you then need to ask for a formal meeting (again fully documented). Hopefully this matter can be resolved informally. In terms of resolving the matter it is very easy for managers to address. The fact they won't speaks volumes about the organisation. Basically they are failing in their duty of care towards you and your colleague. Ultimately if they fail to address you will have no option but to leave. However, if you were forced down this road a solicitor would have no problem in putting together a case under the Disability discrimination act. In conclusion my view is from the other person's point of view it has nothing to do with your nut allergy. It is about her positioning and status, on return from leave, as the most popular and powerful member of the team. She is obviously the 'Alpha male' of the group and the rest of you have to fall into line and bow to her superiority, regardless of the cost to your health. Good luck with resolving, the Citizens advice bureau would be a good organization to contact for advice and support.

Crafthead · 30/10/2023 13:14

I worked with a woman like this when I had a colleague with a severe nut allergy. Selfish and entitled.
Can you organise epipen training for all staff? Once she knows she may be personally responsible for administering someone's EpiPen, and had it from the horse's mouth so to speak that a) the effect only lasts 10 min and a further dose then must be administered which you won't have as only one EpiPen has been prescribed and b) the tiniest particle of nut protein in the air or on her hands and transferred to a door handle could cause a reaction it might change her opinion.

This is a matter of serious health and safety and your manager should do a risk assessment showing clearly that there is a risk to you and your colleague from nut eating in the room and what the company are doing to address and control that risk.

I am sure there would a be a template online for this and the HSE can be contacted by individuals for advice if no joy.

Jaimiej · 30/10/2023 13:07

I wonder if she would be this selfish if one of her kids had a nut allergy.

Your manager needs to grow a pair and tell her move to the other room or leave altogether. It's putting yours and your colleagues lives at risk for something so selfish and completely avoidable.

I would put your concerns in writing to your manager, his manager and advise them that unless you feel safe in the office you will need to escalate this via ACAS.

JoanOfAllTrades · 30/10/2023 11:57

bruffin · 30/10/2023 11:19

So why do schools ban nut products if one child has an allergy? If it’s all bunkum?
Yes,, they are going against advice from Anaphylaxis UK etc who do not believe nut bans are necessary or effective

from Anaphylaxis UK

We don't typically recommend complete nut bans because they are very difficult to enforce and can lead to a false sense of security. Children can be allergic to other common food allergens, for example milk and egg, and it would be impossible to ban them all

People die from accidental ingestion not from being in the same room as nuts,seeds, milk etc
It is bad labeling or not checking labels because they have had it before but there has been a change in the recipe etc that are the problem.

The problem is that too many people think peanuts are more dangerous than other allergies because of threads like this which is full of misinformation about allergies.

Well, I’m currently undergoing desensitisation for an allergy so no, I don’t think nut allergies are worse than milk or egg allergies.

As a nurse with anaphylactic reactions to penicillin (lifelong, after having a dose as a baby but luckily in hospital) and erythromycin (since the age of 30 and it was scary AF), I always double glove when administering those meds and I’m not allowed to administer them as IV meds!

I’m a proud cat mum of 2, one of which I was fine with despite being allergic to cats, and one of which I had a horrific 4 or so weeks with before I settled down, despite taking antihistamines twice a day.

I’m allergic to bananas, kiwi, latex, alcohol rub, and peppermint as well. I also have an auto immune disease, eczema and psoriasis amongst other things.

So no, I don’t think nut allergies are worse than any other allergy, but I don’t think you should put yourself in harms way either!

pam290358 · 30/10/2023 11:48

Adam1630 · 30/10/2023 10:37

So you are one of the selfish idiots who will call an ambulance to make a point and waste the resources of the ambulance service who could have been attending to someone who really was seriously ill. There are far too many people in this country who call for an ambulance when they are not needed, oh dear I’ve cut my finger, oh dear I’ve bumped my head, oh dear I’ve got a temperature. For Gods sake, ambulances are for life threatening emergencies only

Try quoting the post you are replying to, as otherwise no one knows to whom your comments are addressed. So no one here - apart from the completely batshit posters who advocate faking a seizure to get the point across - is advocating calling an ambulance if unnecessary. But from my own experience, I worked with a colleague who had a very severe allergy that sometimes went from the the first signs to a choking response in a very short space of time. Would you advocate waiting until someone’s reaction is life threatening before calling for help, because that ‘s how you’re coming across.

bruffin · 30/10/2023 11:19

JoanOfAllTrades · 30/10/2023 10:49

So why do schools ban nut products if one child has an allergy? If it’s all bunkum?

That doesn’t make sense does it?

And why do some people die from nut allergies if it’s all bunkum?

https://www.bmj.com/company/newsroom/uk-hospital-admissions-for-food-induced-anaphylaxis-triple-over-20-year-period-but-death-rate-falls/

And the BMJ (a real medical journal) says that whilst the death rate has fallen, people do actually die! Not to mention the cost to the NHS because people are deniers!

So why do schools ban nut products if one child has an allergy? If it’s all bunkum?
Yes,, they are going against advice from Anaphylaxis UK etc who do not believe nut bans are necessary or effective

from Anaphylaxis UK

We don't typically recommend complete nut bans because they are very difficult to enforce and can lead to a false sense of security. Children can be allergic to other common food allergens, for example milk and egg, and it would be impossible to ban them all

People die from accidental ingestion not from being in the same room as nuts,seeds, milk etc
It is bad labeling or not checking labels because they have had it before but there has been a change in the recipe etc that are the problem.

The problem is that too many people think peanuts are more dangerous than other allergies because of threads like this which is full of misinformation about allergies.

Freshstart78 · 30/10/2023 11:00

pam290358 · 30/10/2023 08:48

Perhaps if you stopped googling in an effort to seem knowledgeable and engaged with some of the posters commenting from actual experience you would learn something useful. The company I worked for had a policy of 999 as soon as a colleague with a severe allergy showed any sign of discomfort. Why ? Because the timescale between the first signs of an allergic reaction and life threatening symptoms was often only a minute or two. Do you have a specific reason for trying to minimise these issues ?

Edited

Thanks @pam290358 appears we are on the right page. And 999 decide for themselves whether they are coming so as long as OP or anyone else doesn’t lie then I don’t see the issue ringing 999 as soon as someone presents with potential allergy anaphalixs

Superscientist · 30/10/2023 10:52

Make sure you have a risk assessment in place. I last had an anaphylaxis is 2010 and my work place wanted to put one place. I don't have the risk of accidental exposure so I'm ok
Sort out legislation and in what order to use it
Keep a diary
Sort out your CV

This company would rather you endangered your health rather than have a difficult conversations I would be starting to put the feelers out for other employment. I know it is hard as you are during your probation period. I quit 3 weeks into a job after being unemployed after a period of time. I was denied first aid for a chemical burn because I was a woman and the first aider was a man. It was at the same time as I was having the allergic reactions of unknown causes and I would have been working nights. I couldn't trust them with my health so I had to go

JoanOfAllTrades · 30/10/2023 10:49

Adam1630 · 30/10/2023 08:53

I didn’t acknowledge that the OP “had to take piriton” I acknowledged that she “felt she had to take piriton” medical opinion is that non ingestion anaphylaxis doesn’t happen as per the attachment I posted. A total ban on nuts and nut products from the vicinity of the allergy sufferer is an over reaction. Whilst there has been one case where a nut allergy was defined as a disability under the EA, it was in respect of a chef and in particular circumstances, I’m not convinced the tribunals would follow it through to airborne transmissions in an office environment, particularly where NHS advice is that not ingestion anaphylaxis isn’t a thing

So why do schools ban nut products if one child has an allergy? If it’s all bunkum?

That doesn’t make sense does it?

And why do some people die from nut allergies if it’s all bunkum?

https://www.bmj.com/company/newsroom/uk-hospital-admissions-for-food-induced-anaphylaxis-triple-over-20-year-period-but-death-rate-falls/

And the BMJ (a real medical journal) says that whilst the death rate has fallen, people do actually die! Not to mention the cost to the NHS because people are deniers!

UK hospital admissions for food-induced anaphylaxis triple over 20 year period but death rate falls | BMJ

Cow’s milk is the most common cause of fatal anaphylaxis amongst school children, warn researchers The rate of hospital admissions in the UK due to a serious allergic reaction (anaphylaxis) caused by food has more than tripled over a 20-year period. De...

https://www.bmj.com/company/newsroom/uk-hospital-admissions-for-food-induced-anaphylaxis-triple-over-20-year-period-but-death-rate-falls/

Adam1630 · 30/10/2023 10:37

So you are one of the selfish idiots who will call an ambulance to make a point and waste the resources of the ambulance service who could have been attending to someone who really was seriously ill. There are far too many people in this country who call for an ambulance when they are not needed, oh dear I’ve cut my finger, oh dear I’ve bumped my head, oh dear I’ve got a temperature. For Gods sake, ambulances are for life threatening emergencies only

Andrea87 · 30/10/2023 10:36

She is either extremely inconsiderate or ignorant or both.

Ask her to breathe through a straw for a while (peg on nose ) so she realises what a effort it is when the air tubes constrict . Explain that this could / will happen to you with a nut allergy (although I don’t know if these are your symptoms) and see if she can now understand the discomfort and danger you face when she eats nuts.
Some people need educating!
I hope it gets resolved quickly for you.

Gcsunnyside23 · 30/10/2023 10:06

What an asshole that woman is. And anyone defending her right to eat nuts is an asshole too, ffs she's not a toddler. If you're that desperate to eats nuts that you can't leave a room to do it and wash your hands as it might cause severe harm or even discomfort to someone then you're an absolute asshole of the highest order. People defending it or saying it's not airborne etc are all the same sort or entitled bullys who think the world revolves around them. I bet that woman isn't as well liked as op thinks and if I did work with her or like her and this occurred I would not be friends with her any longer.

pollymere · 30/10/2023 10:03

I'd explain to the manager that you will expect to go home on full pay every time nuts are eaten in the office. Say your happy to have an Occupational Health Assessment for yourself and the Intern. This Supervisor is endangering the lives of colleagues. I'd mention things like Duty of Care.

I worked in an office where the Aircon kept breaking down. As I was pregnant with other health issues, if the temperature got over a certain amount it was deemed unsafe so I was sent home on full pay (later we figured out work I could do from home).

pam290358 · 30/10/2023 09:53

Adam1630 · 30/10/2023 09:09

If you’re going to dissect my language skills then fair enough, however in context the point I was making is very clear. NHS advice is that non ingestion anaphylaxis doesn't happen at the very worst it may cause some discomfort (read the attachment I posted), hence likening it to hayfever. The OP carries an Epipen and society has an obligation not to put her at unreasonable risk. However that does not extend to creating a vacuum around her. In the case of the Chef who had to work with nuts, then of course reasonable adjustments had to be made, but unless we are talking about an extreme case of hypersensitivity (boy in the bubble type thing) then what we are looking at here is an over reaction

Likening it to hay fever suits your narrative because hay fever isn’t covered under the EA unless it exacerbates another condition. You are missing the point. In the workplace the employer has to make a reasonable adjustment if the condition meets the definition under the EA.

If, as stated the OP was affected by way of physical symptoms and anxiety by the presence of nuts in close proximity, enough to warrant taking medication that otherwise wouldn’t be required, and clearly affecting the ability to work, then I would argue that she meets the EA definition of disabled. The reasonable adjustment had already been made - the office was nut free with signage to that effect. One employee threw a spanner in the works because of an attitude of disbelief much like your own. If the employer continues to do nothing then employment tribunal looks a likely outcome. In which case there may or may not be additional supporting case law for the circumstances.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 30/10/2023 09:37

Adam1630 · 30/10/2023 08:53

I didn’t acknowledge that the OP “had to take piriton” I acknowledged that she “felt she had to take piriton” medical opinion is that non ingestion anaphylaxis doesn’t happen as per the attachment I posted. A total ban on nuts and nut products from the vicinity of the allergy sufferer is an over reaction. Whilst there has been one case where a nut allergy was defined as a disability under the EA, it was in respect of a chef and in particular circumstances, I’m not convinced the tribunals would follow it through to airborne transmissions in an office environment, particularly where NHS advice is that not ingestion anaphylaxis isn’t a thing

You are incorrect in saying that only one case of a nut allergy has been defined as a disability under the Equality Act 2010. It’s more accurate to say that only one case has been defined as such at tribunal. Wheeldon v Marstons PLC was the case you refer to and covered a specific circumstance. The definition of disability under the Act is that the condition is sufficient to have a significant impact on daily life - the sufferer doesn’t need a formal diagnosis even. They just have to show that their condition meets this definition. And if the OP were to need to go to tribunal and could show evidence that the presence of nuts in the working environment was enough to cause the kind of discomfort she describes, and require her to take medication she wouldn’t otherwise need, then the tribunal would have to consider and rule accordingly. That’s how case law is made.