Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Completely Joint finances - weird or normal?

255 replies

WoodworkingDad · 27/10/2023 22:54

Chatting at work recently I have discovered that sharing finances completely even when married puts me in the minority of.... well just me and DW!!!

I work full time and earn £50k wife works part time and earns from two jobs about £15k. We have two daughters 4 and 1 years old.

When we were married and both working FT we opened a joint account and paid similar amounts in for mortgage and household bills (excluding food and fuel) I think I paid slightly more as I earned more.

After number 1 child came along and wife went went back to work PT after MAT leave it became far too complicated to work out financially every month. With the drop in income, nursary fees and us getting paid at different points in the month I suggested having a joint spending account. So now we get paid into our own accounts, I then fund the old joint account for bills and pay remaining money into separate joint (spending) account. Wife pays all wages into same joint spending account so we know exactly how much joint money we have. We effectively don't have private money (own accounts left with £1 in each month). All savings/investments are now pooled for tax purposes. To be fair I manage all our money as DW has zero interest, I know it's not ideal but that's how it is, she however has access and passwords to view and manage all accounts if needed.

Does anyone else completely share all finances with there partner? Or are we genuinely weird? It seems no one else I work with really trusts there OH!!!

Thoughts?

OP posts:
WoodworkingDad · 27/10/2023 23:34

ArborealArdour · 27/10/2023 23:25

YABVVU and weird on two counts.
a) Assuming that people having their own accounts means 'not trusting' their partner.
b) Assuming that having private money means you don't pool everything.

DH and I switch current accounts to get the bonuses, each have ISA's (so we have a 40K total allowance). Have accounts in international currencies. Among other things.

We also never keep lots of money in a debit account as someone could swipe the lot if card stolen. All into savings and then dripfed in.

We pool our money and keep some for personal spends but it's all in various places.

That aside though if you're a regular on MN seeing the amount of people who can't believe what their once loving husband turned into I'd never advise people to have zero access to an account or some money of their own. Also, if there's an issue with fraud, and your joint is frozen , or cards declined that's both of you screwed. Unless you have a stockpile of cash sitting around somewhere.

Edited

It was a guess as to why they don't pool money? I genuinely didn't understand stand it hence wanting to ask a wide range of people, it seems some people are just keen to keep independence which I totally understand.

The second point you misunderstood, Or I wrote badly, we have old accounts in our own names which I still class as pooled money and understand others do this as well. Just anything new is jointly held as it's easier for both to access. Obviously investment ISAs are in individual names as well, I just meant generically pooled as opposed to you don't know what your partner has

OP posts:
BooBooBaloo · 27/10/2023 23:32

We pay into the joint account proportionally for all joint expenditure (including food etc) plus a bit more. The rest is in our own accounts

Fillybuster · 27/10/2023 23:32

Exactly the same as @BalletBob : one joint account, shared savings, mortgage, investments etc but total privacy on credit card spend, which for both of us is paid in full every month from our shared account. We have a handful of other accounts in our own names, which we occasionally use for travel or other purposes (for example, my starling account is quite good when abroad), but don’t really keep anything in them the rest of the time. Total trust and shared values, and we tend to discuss any big purchases.

Bedazzling · 27/10/2023 23:31

We do not have a joint account but we have access to each others accounts and have state of the nation money meetings. We have both dabbled with investments since before we met. There was no way I was running to DH or him to me to ask do you mind if I move X to Y. So it’s not distrust it’s about our own attitudes to investing. He is more of a risk taker and was looking at potential moves every day for years.

Thepeopleversuswork · 27/10/2023 23:31

I don't think it's unusual at all: I'd say the majority of people who are married have completely or mainly joint finances.

I would never do it myself and in my (non married) relationship I'm the higher earner with a child who is not my partner's child so pooled income would be financially insane, but even if I was the lower earner I probably wouldn't.

I think as a general principle you should never become wholly reliant on, or intertwined with, another person in terms of money. It's just always a good idea to have something that's just yours.

gotomomo · 27/10/2023 23:30

I had one account throughout my marriage, I really don't understand why people don't. If I didn't trust my partner with money I wouldn't marry them, end of.

In fact I still have one joint account with my ex husband

cocksstrideintheevening · 27/10/2023 23:30

We have a joint account we pay into to cover bills, food, kids expenses. After that our money is ours. We earn similar and it all comes out in the wash. Works for us.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 27/10/2023 23:29

We have a joint account. We both actually have separate accounts too but not for any particular reason, just historic, and money for any one offs will come out of whichever has most cash in at the time (eg my new laptop came out of huabands, last holiday came out of mine, most things come out of joint though). I thought sharing everything was kind of the point of marriage - and legally its jointly owned anyway.

It helps that we have a similar attitude to money though and have always discussed any bigger purchases without agreeing any rules around this, it just happened naturally

Fionaville · 27/10/2023 23:28

Me and my DH are the same. All money goes in and out of one joint account. We've got kids, but we did this as soon as we bought our first home together. I'd worked with a woman who used to talk about her DH eating more than her from the shopping she bought and her having to pay towards his car tyres because he drove her to work. I just couldn't have been doing with all that.
At various times we've each earned more than the other. At the moment he's the main earner. We've never once argued about who's money it is. It's all our money and everything is ours. We've been together over 20 years, so it's worked.

montysorry · 27/10/2023 23:28

@Hbh17,
If you’ve both continued to work f/t throughout without one parent stopping or reducing their working hours in favour of childcare then it’s probably always worked fine to do it your way.
For me, I became a SAHP for quite a few years. There was no way I would have agreed to this if I did not have access to all household income. Anything other than joint in these circumstances seriously affects the dynamics of your marriage.
I’m now back to work and the kids are all teenagers but I certainly wouldn’t want anything other that a joint account. Apart from anything else, it just makes everything so much easier to keep track of.

WoodworkingDad · 27/10/2023 23:27

I've also realised reading that my own situation is way too complicated, I have just got used to doing it that way every month.

The reason for keeping a separate account for bills is so you know to the penny exactly how much money is left to spend and all direct debits are excluded. We also leave a decent float in the joint bills account for things like insurance/car service etc and other one off things that are cheaper to pay annually than monthly

OP posts:
pizzaHeart · 27/10/2023 23:26

Cookerhood · 27/10/2023 23:04

One account for everything & have had for 30 years or so. Anything else seems overly complicated!

The same.

sunshineandshowers40 · 27/10/2023 23:26

@Covidiokilledtheradiostar Same here, Joint account, we have savings accounts but the only one with anything in is a joint account.

Slipslidinginthefray · 27/10/2023 23:26

One current , one savings plus various investments all of them joint And have been since before we even married when we started living together 30 years ago.

We have gone from me earning much more than DH to me earning much much less since children and a career change although I had a large inheritance some years ago also. All completely shared.

As per previous posters we share the same values and habits around money and spending which makes this kind of set up possible.

ArborealArdour · 27/10/2023 23:25

YABVVU and weird on two counts.
a) Assuming that people having their own accounts means 'not trusting' their partner.
b) Assuming that having private money means you don't pool everything.

DH and I switch current accounts to get the bonuses, each have ISA's (so we have a 40K total allowance). Have accounts in international currencies. Among other things.

We also never keep lots of money in a debit account as someone could swipe the lot if card stolen. All into savings and then dripfed in.

We pool our money and keep some for personal spends but it's all in various places.

That aside though if you're a regular on MN seeing the amount of people who can't believe what their once loving husband turned into I'd never advise people to have zero access to an account or some money of their own. Also, if there's an issue with fraud, and your joint is frozen , or cards declined that's both of you screwed. Unless you have a stockpile of cash sitting around somewhere.

WoodworkingDad · 27/10/2023 23:24

Interesting, consensus seems to be that married with children most people do in various different ways fully share finances. Perhaps my colleagues are the anomaly after all!

I guess a lot depends on income, attitude to spending and saving, children and the disparity of income between partners. Everyone's situation really is completely different.

Thanks for your insights into your financial affairs 👍

OP posts:
MuchTooTired · 27/10/2023 23:22

We have a joint bills account where all monies get paid in to, and a joint spending account. Our savings are mainly in my name purely because he leaves me to deal with them, but he has a savings account I set up for him, and there’s also a couple of joint ones kicking about too.

Aquamarine1029 · 27/10/2023 23:21

I wouldn't have married my husband if he didn't agree to joint finances. We are a team, what's mine is his and what's his is mine. There is absolutely none of "this is my money", "this is your money" nonsense. In 26+ years, we have never once had a disagreement as to who pays for what or what money belongs to who. I would find that very toxic and tedious.

Meadowdog · 27/10/2023 23:21

Everything is joint for us. I'm by far the higher earner but DH basically sacrificed his career for mine by moving to another country so I could accept a job with a big step up in pay and the potential for advancement. The only fair way for us to have been able to make a decision like that was for everything to be shared equally between us I think.

Letsgoroundagain101 · 27/10/2023 23:21

If you were to divorce, all the money is pooled (financial disclosure) and divided as equitably as possible. “Individual” savings and pensions included. In the typical marriage ceremony the vows say “all that I am I give to you. All that I have I share with you” That’s the way the law sees it too.
me and dh have always had joint accounts, we never question the other on what they spend but always run large purchases past the other. We have very similar attitudes to money though, I imagine it would be difficult if we didn’t.

QueenOfHiraeth · 27/10/2023 23:20

Our finances are totally shared although I have always worked PT since having DCs and DH earns far more than I do. I think if you share a marriage, home and children with someone, you should share money too

Ponderingwindow · 27/10/2023 23:20

Completely shared finances in our house. There are some accounts in my name or his name just for practical reasons like pensions through work, but we operate on a joint finances philosophy.

Bibbitybobbitty · 27/10/2023 23:19

DH & I have same set up as usual, again just haven't got round to closing original.separate accounts. We have 3 late teens.

Goldmember · 27/10/2023 23:19

We shared finances after we married. It completely works for us as we have similar spending attitudes. It's seen us through his redundancy and my Mat leave where we've both been the breadwinner. Now we earn the same and are still completely joint.

DramaAlpaca · 27/10/2023 23:19

Married over 30 years, all earnings go into one joint account.

I also have my own account which I've had since before we were married. I jokingly call it my 'running away fund'.

Swipe left for the next trending thread