Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Completely Joint finances - weird or normal?

255 replies

WoodworkingDad · 27/10/2023 22:54

Chatting at work recently I have discovered that sharing finances completely even when married puts me in the minority of.... well just me and DW!!!

I work full time and earn £50k wife works part time and earns from two jobs about £15k. We have two daughters 4 and 1 years old.

When we were married and both working FT we opened a joint account and paid similar amounts in for mortgage and household bills (excluding food and fuel) I think I paid slightly more as I earned more.

After number 1 child came along and wife went went back to work PT after MAT leave it became far too complicated to work out financially every month. With the drop in income, nursary fees and us getting paid at different points in the month I suggested having a joint spending account. So now we get paid into our own accounts, I then fund the old joint account for bills and pay remaining money into separate joint (spending) account. Wife pays all wages into same joint spending account so we know exactly how much joint money we have. We effectively don't have private money (own accounts left with £1 in each month). All savings/investments are now pooled for tax purposes. To be fair I manage all our money as DW has zero interest, I know it's not ideal but that's how it is, she however has access and passwords to view and manage all accounts if needed.

Does anyone else completely share all finances with there partner? Or are we genuinely weird? It seems no one else I work with really trusts there OH!!!

Thoughts?

OP posts:
Dodie66 · 28/10/2023 10:43

We both have our own accounts which are joint accounts too so that we can access either if we need to. I pay a monthly amount into DHs account for bills and we spend what we like out of our own accounts. No secrets here we both know what each other has etc

Munchyseeds2 · 28/10/2023 10:42

Just one account here, has been that way forever
You do need to have a similar attitude and trust each other ....I COULD spend on a flash car today but I wont.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 28/10/2023 10:40

Except for my savings accounts (in my name only, since higher-income dh would have had to pay more tax) all money from whatever source has always been ‘ours’. Including the interest on ‘my’ savings.
We just took it for granted from the word go.

WitchyFingers2 · 28/10/2023 10:39

God no, we have one joint acc for bills, and then separate accounts in our own names. Putting all our money into one account makes me break out in a cold sweat! His money is his, my money is mine. Just because we're married doesn't mean we have to totally merge into.one person! I was never a sahm though (because I always wanted my own money)

I wonder if upbringing has a bearing on how you divide finances in a relationship? I was brought up to be independent so giving access to my money to anyone even dh is a bit of a no go. I value my privacy too much, yes even within my marriage! I'm still me! Not just part of a partnership.

I just spent £400 on a dyson hair styler thingy, didn't have to run it past him or anything though, it's my money thatcame oit of my account. The thought of having to have a conversation about spending before I can actually buy what I want Is just so foreign to me.

Friends of ours have joint money and she's always questioning him.about why did you buy that? Where did you spend that? Would do my nut in!

Each to their own though 🤷‍♀️

Thepeopleversuswork · 28/10/2023 10:37

AnnaMagnani · 28/10/2023 10:22

To me, it's normal.

Either you are a team, or you aren't.

My parents did joint account, it was pretty dysfunctional but they were a team with shared responsibility.

My ILs did not and their relationship was all kinds of fucked up, mainly due to bitterness about money.

First thing we did after the honeymoon was get our joint account and close our personal accounts.

I always hear this "we're a team" but for me this doesn't really justify pooling all income.

Yes a good relationship, particularly one with children, is based on trust and relies on working as a team, pulling together, contributing together, planning and having transparency. I certainly think people in committed relationships with children should have visibility into one another's incomes and assets. But I don't think just because you trust someone you are automatically required to share everything you own with them. It seems quite a blunt instrument.

In no other sphere of life would you suggest putting all your eggs into one huge financial pot. Any financial adviser will recommend against doing this. If you're married obviously assets are ultimately considered to be shared and will be split accordingly in a divorce.

But I do think its important, particularly for the partner in a relationship who generates less income (historically usually the woman) to have a pot of money which she and she alone has access to. Call it a "fuck off fund" or a rainy day fund or whatever. Yes in the event of a divorce it may be a drop in the bucket but its incredibly useful to have access to a bit of money that's yours and yours alone.

Also this "we're a team and we share everything" narrative works where you have traditional marriages: working father, SAHM mother -- basically it solidifies the assumption that the non productive spouse needs to have equal access to money. But it doesn't really reflect the increasingly complicated nature of modern families. Families these days are much more likely to be blended, or non cohabiting, or include situations where one partner has children and the other doesn't (as in my own). In this scenario the financial protection of the chilldren needs to take precedence over pooling of money between the partners and sometimes this means children having access to money that is ring-fenced from the partner.

W0tnow · 28/10/2023 10:33

Yes. It happened very quickly but sort of organically within 6 months of meeting, and years before marriage.

MunchkinExpress · 28/10/2023 10:31

Joint account. Everything in and everything out. We share everything. No financial secrets. Couldn't imagine it any other way. We have both been main income providers at one time or another.

Loopyloooooo · 28/10/2023 10:30

We used to share for years with one account but then DH became a high earner and I got into spending money just because I had it 🙈🙈. So I now have a separate account and DH pays me an allowance (SAHM).

My name is still on the other account in case of emergency or whatever but I don't access it and see it as DHs account /money. I know some people will probably be clutching their pearls at this but I actually feel much more relaxed knowing what I actually have to spend and DH is much better with all the financial stuff and saving than me as numbers are his thing.

bingbongbang23 · 28/10/2023 10:24

Lieblingsessen · 28/10/2023 02:42

I'm amazed about the responses, about having complete trust in your partners.

Isn't it the case that most people are completely surprised and didn't see it coming, when their partner announces they are leaving.

Therefore, shouldn't you keep your own accounts with a reasonable amount in it, in case you are that person who had complete trust in your partner, until the day they leave you, after first clearing out the joint accounts, leaving you with nothing?

If it gets to stage of leaving and divorcing, finances would need to be sorted as part of this. Regardless if single account or joint, both parties would be owed some of this.

Worst case, husbad cleared out full savings, I still have shares I could sell if absolutely needed (although, as above, he would be entitled to a portion of the money from this). Then I am paid monthly anyways, so I suppose I would just start building it up again.

Don't get me wrong, wouldn't be happy about it but it wouldn't be the distaster you mention. And I prefer we pool all family money so no one feels they have more/less than other person.

Only time we ever discuss spending is for big ticket items (ie. New car), however my husband is on a boys weekend currenlt. His flights/hotel/all spending money will come from our joint account- things like this we wouldn't even discuss. So I don't feel worried about it 🤷‍♀️

AnnaMagnani · 28/10/2023 10:22

To me, it's normal.

Either you are a team, or you aren't.

My parents did joint account, it was pretty dysfunctional but they were a team with shared responsibility.

My ILs did not and their relationship was all kinds of fucked up, mainly due to bitterness about money.

First thing we did after the honeymoon was get our joint account and close our personal accounts.

Goldmember · 28/10/2023 10:20

Saracen · 28/10/2023 01:11

All of our money has always been joint. As you say, OP, it probably works because our attitudes toward spending are similar. We rarely argue about money.

It has occurred to me that IF it seemed to me that DH was "squandering" money (spending more than I'd like on things I wish he wouldn't buy), then it would make sense to have separate pots of spending money for each of us. Likewise, it has crossed my mind that having separate spending money might prevent a bit of occasional bickering which happens when I donate to a charity he dislikes. If we had separate spending money, I'd just reply, "It's MY money to spend and I'll give it to whoever I want!"

Our finances are completely joint but we introduced separate spending money this year, it's worked out great. He no longer judges my ebay and amazon deliveries that come through the door and I no longer 🤔 the 100s he spends on tech.

Ragwort · 28/10/2023 09:35

It's important to remember that just as one partner could go off with all the money if you have a shared account ... if you have separate accounts and one of you dies it is not always easy to access the individual bank account. I volunteer at a Food Bank and we are currently supporting a widow who cannot access her deceased husband's money .... I am sure it will be resolved eventually but it's a horrible position for her to be in.

BrightGreenMoonBuggy · 28/10/2023 09:26

I don’t really understand the poster who described having separate accounts as having ‘financial secrets’ which they don’t have in their marriage. It comes across as a slightly smug view but I think it has unnecessary paranoia of deception and it’s as silly as me claiming that having a joint account is the sign of an untrusting couple. There are no secrets in our marriage either. We have separate accounts simply because we both had separate accounts and it was easier to just keep them that way. Has worked perfectly for over twenty years and we never argue about money, nor are we secretive and untrusting!

I think a good idea for a lot of couples is a personal account each for some independence and a joint one for bills. But if a fully joint one suits you both, who is anyone else to interfere?

CollagenQueen · 28/10/2023 09:20

Brilliant. 👍👍👍👍

caringcarer · 28/10/2023 09:19

DH and I have separate accounts but pay an equal amount into a joint account. It works because we get roughly equal income. We pay all household bills and food out of our joint accounts. Only personal spends like lunch out with friends or gifts to each other come out of personal accounts.

Strugglingcareer · 28/10/2023 09:16

i wonder if age does play a huge part and also where someone is in their stage of life. With my DP, we get paid salaries into our individual accounts and then transfer X about into the joint account to pay for our mortgage and bills.

The rest we can spend or save freely and this works well (he likes cars and I like holidays). We are very open generally about our finances though and agree that we will shift things if we have children etc and I am earning a much lower amount. As it is, I’m actually the higher earner and offered to pay more in but he refused.

I think I would feel suffocated at the thought of not having control of my own wages or having to discuss an expensive haircut etc as day to day I spend more than my DP but then he will buy bigger tickets items.

romdowa · 28/10/2023 09:13

We just have one joint account. All money goes in and out of that. We are in Ireland though where the banks charge fees for use of the account. No way where we paying fees for 3 accounts 🤣

HaplessRhombus · 28/10/2023 09:04

I think having literally one account for everything is quite unusual among people I know. We have a joint account that all our money goes into but we still send "fun money" to our separate personal accounts which we spend or save without consulting the other.

Tangled123 · 28/10/2023 08:55

My husband and I both work full time and we earn similar salaries. That salary is paid into our own separate current accounts, and we contribute the same amount to a joint account for the mortgage, childcare etc. I don’t see the point in sharing when we have the same amount anyway.
I bore the financial costs of my maternity leave myself without help from him 2 years ago though, and since I’m likely to start out earning husband when I finish my course next year, I won’t be joining finances with him at least until I have my savings back up to where they were before maternity leave.

PinkRoses1245 · 28/10/2023 08:49

All couple I know have some element of separate money even if most joint. It works for us to have a joint account for all shared expenses and individual accounts for our personal spending. But we do earn similar.

CreeperBoom · 28/10/2023 08:48

I think your way of doing it works if either:
a) you have so much money you can spend without thinking
b) you have very little money, and can't spend without discussion

And also - one partner is happy to take control, and one partner doesn't care.

However, if you have a chunk of spare money, and both want to spend on unbudgeted items each month, then not being able to do that without checking how much your partner has spent is a pain. Also, if you both want to feel a level of control over savings and investment decisions and have different risk appetites, then it's asking for arguments.

Zebedee55 · 28/10/2023 08:47

DH and I always had joint accounts. No secrets between us, and no arguments about money.🙂

CeeceeBloomingdale · 28/10/2023 08:45

Separate current accounts, joint savings. We each pay a proportional amount of bills. It's worked OK for 30 years, we are transparent and trust each other.

Pineapplefish · 28/10/2023 08:39

The way it works for us is that our salaries get paid into our separate current accounts. The bills come out by direct debit - some from his account and some from my account. We both spend whatever we like from our own accounts (plus bigger purchases on the joint credit card). Then whatever is left at the end of the month we both transfer to joint savings. So we have autonomy (own personal current account) but at the end of the day everything is completely shared (both have access to the joint savings account).

I think maybe this only works because we have similar attitudes to money - we're both careful with money and natural savers. I guess it wouldn't work if one person was spending a lot more on themselves while the other was transferring more to the savings account, or if money was very tight and we needed to keep track of every penny. We've been married for 20 years and have never had an argument about money.

Leighdown · 28/10/2023 08:35

Similar to a lot of others - all wages into a joint account and then equal amounts of spending money transferred to our private accounts, even though DH is the higher earner.

But I had friends who kept finances completely separate, even after kids. They would have to transfer money across for their half of the kids dinner if they went out to eat or bought a magazine on the weekly shop, which I thought was madness!