Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you have unpacked your shopping and repacked?

262 replies

SweeetFemaleAttitude · 27/10/2023 18:53

Just did a huge weekly shop at Tesco and as I was leaving I was asked for my receipt, that was fine. Then after a pause the shop assistant and security explained they were doing random trolley checks, and asked to check the receipt against the shipping.

I wasn’t impressed, but calmly stood back and said ‘please ensure everything goes back in the correct bags, I’ve sorted it for a reason’.

They then said they expected ME to unpack items as they ticked it off the receipt.

I just laughed a bit inside at the idea. I’d just done a big shop and pissed around with a self service machine wasting a lot of time compared to a human scanner. Red lights for no reason, waiting for tag removal, waiting for another random fault, waiting to weigh my own bags and check them before I started. The idea of then standing there and unpacking for their pleasure was not something I was prepared to do! I’m talking a big trolley load of stuff, and a big job to stand there bending over it lifting. Not like a Costco check for the big items, loads and loads of tiny bits and cans.

I just calmly said ‘no’. I was told it was a policy to do random checks and I wasn’t suspected of theft. I said they may have a policy, but I didn’t work for Tesco and therefore they were unable to direct me to complete any tasks. I’d fulfilled my contract, paying for goods. If they had reason for concern then I’d wait for them to check it themselves, or go through cctv but I expected it to not delay me unreasonably or my shopping to be left unpacked or manhandled.

Ended up with ‘permission’ from a grumpy manager to leave, who had been watching from a distance and came over. I was honestly calm and kept my tone polite, I was quite annoyed by the self check out already and was making an effort to remain calm knowing I was a bit irate. Never been to this store before, not planning to go again! My usual store always has a open checkout to use with a person.

aibu- you’d have stood there and unpacked, it’s policy

yanbu- nope, you don’t work there and it’s not your job to facilitate their security checks.

OP posts:
21ZIGGY · 29/10/2023 07:47

They are ridiculous. Id have said no and just asked for a refund and left my shopping

sep135 · 29/10/2023 07:46

I’ve always understood self-checkouts to be for small loads, otherwise a manned checkout should be used.

I do my big shops with scan as you go, not the self scan at the till. You pick up a handset as you enter the shop and scan items as you pick them off the shelves and put them in the trolley.

Not sure where it's offered, but you can do it in our local Tesco, Waitrose and Asda. That said, my local Asda has a self scan at the till for larger shops with a conveyor belt rather than the space for one bag.

pumpykins · 29/10/2023 07:45

If you have a massive trolley full, don’t use self check

Skodacool · 29/10/2023 07:14

Cosyblankets · 28/10/2023 18:24

How much stuff did you have?
I only go through self ones if i only have a few bits not loads of bags that need sorting

It sounds as though this was a supermarket that has done away with manned checkouts.

Skodacool · 29/10/2023 07:10

I’ve always understood self-checkouts to be for small loads, otherwise a manned checkout should be used. However, if the store has no manned checkouts then it’s a pain putting a large shop through a self-checkout and I hope I would do what OP did. I feel cross that supermarkets are cutting manned checkouts.

LalaPaloosa · 29/10/2023 04:00

That’s age discrimination surely?!

LalaPaloosa · 29/10/2023 03:59

I didn’t even know this was something they do. But as others have said, you are often in a hurry when shopping. I wouldn’t agree to this either if I were ever stopped. It seems bizarre being told what to do like this by supermarket staff.

IamMoodyBlue · 28/10/2023 23:08

Good for you! I'd never shop there again and make sure Tesco knew it.

Cheesecakefiend · 28/10/2023 22:44

Good for you. If they want to ensure no one is stealing, employ more actual humans and open more flipping checkouts !

Toomuchtrouble4me · 28/10/2023 22:39

You handled that brilliantly. I Wish you’d been in Aldi with my mum! The checkout lady got out from her chair, came around and frisked my 91yr old mothers empty carrier bags for no reason whilst she was waiting to pay. Then she announced that it was ‘store policy’ as “old people often put things in their bags without realising, they don’t mean to, they just take things and we have to check”. Her bags were just reusable Waitrose bags ready to put her shopping in. Mum does not have any signs of dementia but she is a bit deaf so wasn’t sure what was going on and just said “they are not Aldi bags, they’re my own”. Her 13yr old grandson was with her but he didn’t say anything.
Bloody cheek!
You were FANTASTIC.

Majesticalling · 28/10/2023 22:35

Quite right OP. Unpack and repack?!?!? You're a customer not a bloody prisoner!!!!

Give your head a wobble Tescos - and while you're at it give us humans on the tills!!!

Well done for keeping your composure👏

Robotalkingrubbish · 28/10/2023 22:34

Well done @SweeetFemaleAttitude!

Danielle9891 · 28/10/2023 22:30

Its happened to me twice. It's so embarrassing with people walking past as well. Both times that same manager stood a good few metres away and instructed one of the newer/younger lesser paid staff to do it all. I think it's embarrassing for them as well but the manger looked like she was enjoying herself. I've not been back, as I had my toddler with me both times and she was crying and I was getting frustrated and was shaking, even though I've never stolen anything in my life.
I think I've just got a guilty face as I'm always the one that gets stopped at airports too.

LadyRoughDiamond · 28/10/2023 22:29

I’ve taken a screenshot of your response to refer to if I’m ever in this situation. I’m in awe!

ACGTHelix · 28/10/2023 21:27

very impressive op, its true it may be there policy, but unless that policy also states that the public need to un pack the items, then i would guess thats the duty of the store manager or staff member @SweeetFemaleAttitude

mumda · 28/10/2023 21:06

I think that you have to leave with items unpaid for before it's theft ... So they can't be accusing you of that inside the store.
If they want to check their machines then let them do that.

Tigger1895 · 28/10/2023 20:37

The new tesco shop/pack as you go are hit and miss.
I use two stores, 1 you need to be admitted to the till and 1 you need to be allowed out off. I’ve often had a random 5/10 items rechecked but staff pick the items. There’s a different store I use that does random checks on the whole shop, but they scan each bag and repack for you.
Tesco claims it to stop shoplifting. I’d just say to tesco, if you don’t trust your customers, hire the staff to work the tills and pay them a decent wage

222DaisyDo · 28/10/2023 20:37

Brilliant response! I sometimes shop in Tesco and if this happens to me I will be assertive like you, very well done 😊

MindfullyAmazedHorse · 28/10/2023 20:26

I would’ve done the same as you, OP. Fair enough if they want to do random checks, but they should do the work.

it would be interesting to know if this sort of thing actually stops shoplifters. It must piss off a lot of honest regular customers.

Milliemoo6 · 28/10/2023 20:24

No issue with the random checks per se but totally unreasonable to expect you to unpack then repack your shopping so they can do that. I'd make a complaint to Tesco to be honest, many people wouldn't be as assertive as you

ambr · 28/10/2023 20:20

You are absolutely not being unreasonable! And I love your comment about it being their policy, not yours! Unless you agree to a policy before you shop, you are quite right to have refused to unpack! I would have done the same! Good for you for standing your ground!

Snippit · 28/10/2023 20:17

Well done you!!! I’ve had a similar incident in my local Next store, not many items but felt like a ruddy criminal.

If I’m ever stopped again I’ll ask what evidence they have to make them think I’m shop lifting. I have never ever stolen anything in my life.

RagzRebooted · 28/10/2023 20:09

Excellent response. I too get overly formal and polite when I'm seething with rage (in public).

None of our local Tesco have these, as they're smaller, rural ones so I've never had this happen. I also get my big weekly shopping delivered because I'm lazy (and it's cheaper than a nearly hour round trip in the car costs). But I've used self service on small checkouts in other places and never had a check. Maybe Aldi/Lidl don't do this? Sounds infuriating!

GellerYeller · 28/10/2023 19:59

@sep135 Thankyou! This can’t be much fun for the staff either, I imagine.

sep135 · 28/10/2023 19:55

Apologies if this has been covered already-what happens if you haven’t scanned something (either through a genuine error or to evade payment), and this is discovered through a spot check?

I can answer this as it happened to me. Totally unintentional, I think I scanned a couple of items with my handset while I'd unknowingly pressed the remove item button. I thought I'd added them but they won't add in that screen. The old handsets in our Tesco had really quiet volumes so it wasn't obvious.

If they find unscanned items during a scan as you go random check, they'll add them to your basket which you go ahead and pay. If it happens more than once or twice, you're then flagged for enhanced security and pretty much have 10-30 items scanned on most subsequent scan as you go shops.

Eventually you revert to non shoplifter status, breathe a sigh of relief and count your lucky blessings. Again, I understand their position. Yes it wasn't deliberate but they have to have safeguards for scan as you go.