Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It shouldn’t be this hard to get antibiotics!

57 replies

JemimaTiggywinkles · 27/10/2023 15:40

I have tonsillitis. I’ve had it before loads of times, so know what it is. I also know that with antibiotics I’ll be better within a couple of days and back in work on Monday. The last time I delayed getting antibiotics (because I couldn’t face a 4hr+ wait standing in the walk-in when sick) I ended up with complications requiring a hospital stay and an operation.

This morning I tried getting an urgent appointment at the GP and they told me to fill in a form, which then said they’ll get back to me by the end of Monday! It did say there was a triage though so I gave it about 4 hours before giving up on getting a quick response from them.

So an hour ago I tried 111 - they said a clinician will call me back but they can’t say when because they’re really busy. Having been through this process before I know I’ll be waiting (probably) a few hours for a call back only to be told that I need to be seen face to face to get a prescription. If I’m lucky I’ll get seen and a prescription at some point tonight via a walk-in centre (which on a Friday night means waiting for hours with drunk people).

I get that I’m not a life and death case. I get that the NHS is underfunded and the staff are overworked. But there really must be a more efficient way of accessing fairly basic medical care.

OP posts:
PawsisShady · 28/10/2023 00:06

It's hard. I've never had viral tonsillitis in my life, it's always bacterial
Think I've had it maybe 22 times or so? They won't remove them. Immunocompromised so also had around 75 courses of antibiotics in my life and I need them fairly quickly when I get tonsillitis

TheSpikySpinosaurus · 28/10/2023 00:00

LauraNorda · 27/10/2023 15:47

If you are getting tonsilitis on a regular basis, why have you not requested their removal?

You have to have tonsillitis requiring antibiotics ten times in 12 months to qualify. It's ridiculous.

LighthouseTheme · 27/10/2023 23:55

I have a Cash Plan with Simply Health (not an ad I promise). Lowest level is now £14.30 a month, and I'm not sure if it would help if needing antibiotics, but last month I had what seemed like an idiopathic reaction (to a hamster would you believe), and had a phone appointment later that day - time was decided pretty much by me. Video call was an option, as was uploading photos in advance.

Afterwards, I was sent a link for a prescription that I picked up form my "usual" pharmacy - but could have selected any other I think. Paid £10 for the prescription, that's all.

And of course, there are the other benefits. A couple of years ago I had private consultation (no further treatment), and was able to claim back 75% of the cost through the plan.

KidsDr · 27/10/2023 23:51

The thing is in a world without effective antibiotics as a result of poor antibiotic stewardship, almost every episode of sepsis would result in death. Your body will make do without antibiotics (which if you get to the point of having sepsis, it hasn't), or you will die.

So almost every person with an anecdote about having to go into hospital with a severe infection is instead a dead person. Hugely increased postpartum death of mothers and infants. What we now consider to be fairly low risk routine surgeries such as joint replacement becoming a life and death roulette. Bowel problems like appendicitis, diverticulitis, IBD etc becoming much more likely to result in death. Many currently curable cancers becoming completely unsurvivable. Children, older people and those with weaker immune systems (eg diabetics, those reliant on steroids or other drugs to manage auto-immune conditions), dying from what would once might have been serious but very survivable and relatively common infections.

That's the cost of overly liberal use of antibiotics. So there is a very careful balance to be struck for when antibiotics should be used, it's not something the public should be allowed to decide.

(Of course, there are lots of clinical scenarios in which antibiotics are completely appropriate. UTI is an example where there is a decently specific and very rapid test for bacterial infection (urine dip) and where the antibiotics used are often very narrowly targeted (eg trimethoprim, nitrofurantoin are not broad acting but very good at reaching the urine and treating UTI) and need only a brief course. Tonsillitis is a different kettle of fish).

Frankly, it's an area in which HPs themselves badly need to get their act together (in terms of prescribing fewer antibiotics). Obviously it's not only healthcare contributing to this but also antibiotics in our food chain... And it's a global problem. But still, antibiotics on the whole should be harder not easier to obtain.

Blueggsandham · 27/10/2023 23:50

Antibiotics shouldn't be handed out like sweets, but there are conditions which need them, where a delay can cause significant problems - I've had UTIs which have turned nasty without prompt antibiotics. Over the counter pharmacy provision would be perfect for this.

LyndaLaHughes · 27/10/2023 23:44

I disagree with the posters who are arguing that it's probably viral. This is really unhelpful for those of us who have suffered with chronic bacterial tonsillitis and know when we need antibiotics. Thankfully I've had mine out now- but on the occasions I took a wait and see approach or was made to do so, I ended up on IV antibiotics every time. It got to the stage where my GP gave them to be on every bout without hesitation.

olderbutwiser · 27/10/2023 23:42

My last uti - online triage message via website to gp at 4pm; prescription waiting at pharmacy 5 mins later. Picked up and course started at 4:30.

we have fab GPs where I live.

QueenOfHiraeth · 27/10/2023 23:35

mrandmrsrobinson · 27/10/2023 21:59

If you live in the far east you would be able to get OTC antibiotics. It's only the controlling UK NHS that are paranoid about it.

...and this is why, worldwide, we are seeing more antibiotic resistant infections.

Antibiotics are restricted for good reason and the UK is being responsible

Onabench · 27/10/2023 23:34

Tonsillitis is almost always viral. If it is recurring for you then it is unlikely to be bacterial. Seems like you just have a weakness to it. Tonsillitis almost always improves from day 3 onwards, antibiotics or not. It sounds like you were just unlucky last time. I say this as someone who has had it more times than I can count.

Nicole1111 · 27/10/2023 23:29

I recently got mastitis and my gp surgery told me my only option was to call every day at 8am to try and get a same day appointment. I gave up on day 3 of playing pot luck after the gp surgery couldn’t suggest an alternative way for me to get antibiotics prescribed. Later that day I got to the walk in well before opening time and by the time they opened the doors there were 17 people behind me, and I was third in the queue. A couple of weeks later my friend was hospitalised with sepsis from untreated mastitis after failing to get an gp appointment. The nhs is on its knees and politicians don’t care, likely because they can afford private healthcare.

Letsgocamping67 · 27/10/2023 23:28

relative is a biomedical scientist says we are walking into antibiotic resistance without realising that literally millions will die in the future if this is not tackled in a more effective manner. GP’s should be doing swaps/dips etc instead of issuing antibiotics needlessly or just saying a blanket no to everyone.

KidsDr · 27/10/2023 23:28

You have my sympathies as tonsillitis is horrible but I think YABU.

It is absolutely right that you can't just get antibiotics without a proper assessment. Antibiotic resistance is a major public health menace, and antibiotic stewardship is absolutely essential with the potential to save many future lives and enable things like routine surgery to continue safely.

The thing is that both viral and bacterial tonsillitis will tend to get better in a couple of days with antibiotics. It's just that the viral (and potentially a decent proportion of the bacterial) would have also gotten better without them. As antibiotics are so routinely over prescribed even by qualified doctors, your previous experience is not good evidence by itself that you've had multiple previous bacterial tonsillitis episodes, or that this episode is bacterial. Only positive throat swabs could do that.

You've certainly been unlucky with that one severe complicated episode and what a horrible thing to happen. But it may never happen again. You shouldn't be able to access OTC antibiotics for this reason, noone should... and the practice of allowing this in other countries is a bad practice.

Waiting a few hours on a Friday night to be seen by an OOH GP is inconvenient and unpleasant and ideally the system would work better than this. But it isn't going to endanger your health, and it's worth it for the benefits (to everyone) of good antibiotic stewardship. Bring a folding chair.

DoubleFunMum · 27/10/2023 23:18

It shouldn't be this difficult to get seen by a medical professional so I sympathise there. It SHOULD be difficult to get antibiotics. I know GPs who give them out like sweeties, with a complete disregard to the medical evidence that antibiotic resistance is becoming a real problem. Antibiotics should be for PROVEN infections (which tonsilitis rarely is) that are not being fought off naturally (which generally healthy, not immuno-compromised people can usually do). As someone who has had both premature babies and cancer in my family, I've seen the REAL need for antibiotics - the difference between life and death. These are the people who will die due to the over use of antibiotics. They are not so someone can get back to work quicker.

sproutsandparsnips · 27/10/2023 23:17

I'm afraid I agree with Rudolphthefrog and think YAB a bit U.
Most tonsillitis is viral and will get better with or without antibiotics. They should not be prescribed for everyone. There is no foolproof way to know without a swab. Pus/yellow spots/white spots on the tonsils is not an indication of bacterial infection, just of infection whether that is viral or bacterial.
Antibiotics can have impact on the individual, predisposing to opportunistic infection such as clostridium difficile, and on the wider community, contributing to antibiotic resistance which will affect everyone.

Rudolphthefrog · 27/10/2023 23:09

mrandmrsrobinson · 27/10/2023 22:33

@Rudolphthefrog

Yes. Lets not adult human beings be responsible for the management of their health.
Lets treat them all like three year olds.
8 billion people in the world and how many are under the jurisdiction of the system?
It's bullshit and everyone knows it.
I wonder how much time is spent by the patient and the Dr to eventually get round to prescribing something that both parties know what is required.
It's a system that is flawed.

The vast majority of adults do not have the education to be responsible for the management of their health in the way you are talking about without appropriate guidance from an actual qualified professional. Both parties do not “know what is required” because only one party is a doctor (or other appropriately qualified prescriber). I’m a fairly well educated person who can Google with the best of them, I’m not going to pretend I can self diagnose my illness, differentiate between different types of infection, understand which antibiotic would be more appropriate for which ailment, or indeed whether or not a particular medication interferes with the other medications I might be taking. Plus if it’s not prescribed or on people’s records, who flags up when the patient’s already had half a dozen rounds of antibiotics for something and maybe some further investigation is warranted?

And on top of protecting individuals from themselves there’s also a societal issue because people unnecessarily taking antibiotics has an impact on antibiotic resistance and thus, indirectly, other people’s health.

PinkRoses1245 · 27/10/2023 23:08

YABU. Antibiotics should be last resort. You wil benefit from letting your body fight the infection itself. There a massive risk of antibiotic resistance in the world. And they’re awful for your digestive system and gut bacteria

adomizo · 27/10/2023 23:07

I know exactly how you feel. I get tonsillitis at least once a year. Nothing but antibiotics will clear it. Absolutely not viral. Similarly ended up in hospital before with it. Why can't they look back over your history and see you have had this before? Tonsillectomy very difficult to get according to my GP. Need to have tonsillitis at least 3 times a year. Such an unnecessary process just to get antibiotics...Hope you feel better soon.

NamelessNancy · 27/10/2023 23:04

You should absolutely be able to be quickly assessed by a HCP able to prescribe antibiotics if indicted. They cannot and should not be prescribed without that assessment

New antibiotics have not been discovered for decades now and resistance to the ones we have is an increasing problem. Do you want to go back to a time where bacterial disease cannot be effectively treated? I don't, and it's a very real risk.

Vinrouge4 · 27/10/2023 22:47

mrandmrsrobinson · 27/10/2023 21:59

If you live in the far east you would be able to get OTC antibiotics. It's only the controlling UK NHS that are paranoid about it.

Ridiculous comment. Most people do not have the capacity to self diagnose whether they need antibiotics or not, and for sure this would lead to antibiotics being taken unnecessarily.

mrandmrsrobinson · 27/10/2023 22:33

@Rudolphthefrog

Yes. Lets not adult human beings be responsible for the management of their health.
Lets treat them all like three year olds.
8 billion people in the world and how many are under the jurisdiction of the system?
It's bullshit and everyone knows it.
I wonder how much time is spent by the patient and the Dr to eventually get round to prescribing something that both parties know what is required.
It's a system that is flawed.

Blarn · 27/10/2023 22:10

Tonsillitis can be viral. I had it loads as a child and was given antibiotics each time and still was ill for about a week, as long as I was as an adult when I didn't bother getting the antibiotics. As so much bacteria is becoming immune to antibiotics it is right that they are limiting its use.

Goy my tonsils removed in late 20s. So much better.

coronafiona · 27/10/2023 22:06

Some pharmacists can now prescribe antibs.

Rudolphthefrog · 27/10/2023 22:05

mrandmrsrobinson · 27/10/2023 21:59

If you live in the far east you would be able to get OTC antibiotics. It's only the controlling UK NHS that are paranoid about it.

Yes, how dare they be responsible and try to avoid antibiotic resistance and people using them inappropriately?!

OP should be able to more easily access an appointment with someone who can prescribe them if needed, but making them available OTC is not the answer.

Icannoteven · 27/10/2023 22:04

Yanbu.

I’m currently here with a kidney infection that I’ve had for a month before I was prescribed antibiotics.

it was picked up by a medic at a work wellness check, who advised me to see my GP. GP appointment took 3 weeks, lab results took a couple of days, getting a gp appointment to discuss a prescription (the GP had seen the results and written ‘book appt to discuss results but then the receptionist couldn’t get me a bloody appointment!) then took another few days 🫤 Couldn’t get OTC because it was a recurring upper uti.

mrandmrsrobinson · 27/10/2023 21:59

If you live in the far east you would be able to get OTC antibiotics. It's only the controlling UK NHS that are paranoid about it.