Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my GP was useless and I should complain?

34 replies

Connected1 · 27/10/2023 11:51

My asthma is normally well controlled, but yesterday while recovering from a chest infection (treated with antibiotics and oral steroids) I had an asthma attack. I improved after multiple ventolin doses, but still was breathless on moving or talking so I phoned my GP for advice on whether I needed more treatment.

I was breathless on the phone, and the receptionist seemed concerned and said she'd get me a call back. I thought it would be urgent, but the GP phoned back well over 2 hours later.
She suggested oral steroids but I explained I was already taking them.
She seemed at a loss then, apart from raising the dose, so I asked if I could come in for a nebuliser treatment. She said no they didn't offer nebuliser, but I queried that as I had it at the surgery before (she's new to the surgery).

She then went to ask the nurse and in the process we got cut off. She called me back to say that the surgery did offer it,......but I would have to hang up and call back to reception so they could make an appointment! At this stage I was so breathless and felt so poorly that I just said 'OK' and hung up.

I couldn't believe the lack of urgency, as it was costing me an effort even to talk. My husband came home & called an ambulance. The ambulance medics said to always call 112, (or go direct to the hospital as I live quite close to it) in the event of another attack. I know this is the official advice but because I had improved a bit initially, I wasn't sure if I should follow through. I got treatment and I'm recovering at home.

I think the doctor, or even the receptionist, when they heard how poorly I was, should have advised me to ring 112 or go straight to A&E. And I especially couldn't believe that they expected me to call back to make an appointment again. When you're feeling so ill, it's very hard to get the proper help you need and you just want someone else to take over for you.

I am of course going to complain to the surgery, but wanted to hear what people, especially with a medical background, think about this treatment. I can't quite believe it was as bad as it was!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Anna8089 · 03/11/2023 14:43

A lot of negative blaming here. GPS and hospitals don't give a stuff about asthma sufferers. An action plan is just useless as the nhs don't follow it. You are supposed to call the doctor when unwell. Victim blaming much.

Connected1 · 28/10/2023 10:13

Thanks so much for taking time to reply.
I thought that because I could breathe reasonably well when sitting quietly/not talking meant I'd be wasting time calling emergency services.
I'll be more aware in future

OP posts:
Connected1 · 28/10/2023 10:09

Thanks so much for your reply, I appreciate it 😊

OP posts:
Datafan55 · 27/10/2023 20:41

I feel for you and you are getting a bit of flack for not doing the right thing ...So I will add that I didn't know what to do when I had a bad attack a couple of years ago, despite having had asthma on and off for 40 years and having been seen for reviews regularly at the GP surgery ... Simply as it's never normally out of control when they see me, so 'emergency action if needed' (and being wheezy v having an actual attack) had never been mentioned. Very scary. I also considered going to A&E for example, but felt it wasn't serious enough.

I just don't think everyone with asthma would know what to do and this is an issue.

The GP action in itself though - not an issue.

Remember what you did for next time, and mention it in passing to anyone who has asthma (this is what I try and do now).

Pineapplesnowbells · 27/10/2023 20:18

Try the Asthma Society of Ireland OP.
They're advertising a webinar at the moment. It's on Nov 1st and will have tips for managing asthma. You can also book a call with asthma nurses and they talk a lot about asthma plans. They have plan templates to print out. You will need to go back to the gp to be assessed for any prescription changes though.

I want to thank you for your post. It's given me a reminder to ensure I'm up to date on the kids asthma plans and also a reminder of what to do in an emergency.

Difficulty breathing is obviously an emergency and your call to your gp should have been prioritised and you should have been advised to contact the emergency services I think. Or they should have contacted them as you were in obvious distress (breathless). I would mention it to them. People in the UK may not be aware there is no option of 111 here in Ireland so perhaps gps do have to assume that role somewhat?

I've found I do have to chase things myself.
My gp surgery have never mentioned asthma plans. The last time I asked about a nebuliser (salbutamol) the gp said the thinking now is that the Ventolin inhaler does the same job. I know they did used to give them to the kids when they were smaller (they are younger teens now).

Connected1 · 27/10/2023 15:01

Thank you, that's useful. I need to chase up a plan with my GP.

OP posts:
SympatheticCrooner · 27/10/2023 14:55

Connected1 · 27/10/2023 13:00

@SympatheticCrooner
Thanks for the good advice. I'm in Ireland so it's a bit different, the options are either GP or A&E.
My practice has no asthma nurse, and the Asthma Advice line isn't for emergencies here. But I take on board what you're saying. I'll have to educate myself more.

You're welcome🤗

I must say the Asthma & Lung UK line isn't for emergencies as such either, but they have specialists nurses and can help if you're really struggling. In my opinion the specialist nurses are miles better than the GP. If the Asthma helpline in Ireland has dedicated nurses it is still worth calling if you're not getting anywhere with doctor.

I know what you mean. Sometimes you think the emergency services is too dire and stretched, so want another professional to 'greenlight' you using emergency services. But you're better off calling them.

MoserRothOrangeandAlmond · 27/10/2023 14:49

As a Nurse Practitioner who treats asthmatics in the community, the only time we can give an oxygen driven nebuliser to an asthmatic is when we dial for an ambulance to take them into hospital.

If you were Short of breath and unable to speak in full sentences despite taking steroids and taking your salbutamol then it's hospital.

It's best practice for asthmatics to have at least yearly reviews, to review inhalers, inhaler techniques, peak flows and management plan etc so I would query with your practice if they do this and you aren't on their radar? It's in the British thoracic guidelines. Or that they don't do this in Ireland.

I'm always really careful/have a low threshold with Asthmatics as it can change so quickly. All of this should have been in your plan.
Definitely not a GP job as the on call GP will be working through phone calls and other emergency appointments and the receptionist isn't medically trained to say call an ambulance.

MyCircumference · 27/10/2023 13:22

I was told blue lights in similar scenario

Connected1 · 27/10/2023 13:04

Bluevelvetsofa · 27/10/2023 12:56

Maybe it’s different in Ireland, but in England, I have an annual review, with peak flow readings. I’m surprised you haven’t had continuing reviews of your condition.

No, I'm only seen if I'm unwell. The doctor's never asked me to come for a review.

OP posts:
Connected1 · 27/10/2023 13:00

@SympatheticCrooner
Thanks for the good advice. I'm in Ireland so it's a bit different, the options are either GP or A&E.
My practice has no asthma nurse, and the Asthma Advice line isn't for emergencies here. But I take on board what you're saying. I'll have to educate myself more.

OP posts:
Neriah · 27/10/2023 12:57

Connected1 · 27/10/2023 12:13

In hindsight maybe, but as I said, I had improved after the Ventolin, so I wasn't sure if I should call112. I felt OK if I did nothing, but moving or talking made me worse. So I needed advice.
GPs are busy but the ambulance service and A&E are more stretched surely.

Sorry but I do think you are being somewhat unreasonable here. Nobody expects an immediate call back from a GP - to be honest waiting only 2 hours was actually pretty quick. You did know what to do if you had a bad attack, but you didn't do it. Hindsight shouldn't have been involved. So perhaps they might have handled the conversation better, but I don't think you have much to complain about.

Bluevelvetsofa · 27/10/2023 12:56

Maybe it’s different in Ireland, but in England, I have an annual review, with peak flow readings. I’m surprised you haven’t had continuing reviews of your condition.

2inabed · 27/10/2023 12:47

100% if the receptionist told you to ring 999 you would be on here complaining that she told you that and gate keeping appointments and wouldn't let you speak to the doctor. The receptionist did her job and did absolutely nothing wrong. I'd like you said you could barely speak I would of rang 999 or the NHS advice line.

SingingSands · 27/10/2023 12:46

To answer the question in your title: no.

Your GP was working - presumably with a full clinic list. Why are you complaining that it took 2 hours for her to call you back - she can't stop seeing her booked patients for every phone call.

If you were capable of phoning your surgery, you were capable of phoning 112, which is what you should have done.

If you complain you'll be adding to everyone's workload with having to investigate and respond to you. GP surgeries are not for emergencies. You sought help from the wrong resource and now you're blaming them for not helping you?

I think you need to take ownership of your own health condition and that means accessing the appropriate channels at the appropriate times. Make a GP appointment to increase your steroid dose, make an appointment with the asthma clinic for a monitoring and treatment plan, use 112 for emergencies.

SympatheticCrooner · 27/10/2023 12:32

When you are seriously (dangerously) out of breath for any reason call 999 for an ambulance or if you're unsure 111 who.will make an assessment and send one if necessary or book you at an emergency walk-in. GP surgeries are no longer good to go to in such emergencies and haven't been in the case of Asthma for a good 15 years. Back in the day you could walk in and use the nebuliser, my understanding is this is either discouraged or not a service available in many surgeries anymore. And frankly as an Asthmatic of over 40 years now I am sad to say the knowledge about Asthma has diminished amongst GP's that's just fact. A lot of them still cling to beliefs like asthma = wheezing. Therefore if you are not wheezing, but are struggling to breathe with inflamed airways and using your inhaler chronicslly, you are not having an asthma attack. I stick to the Asthma nurse for all asthma appointments, not just reviews. They often make an assessment and doctor just follows through.

You can also ring Asthma & Lung UK if you feel your asthma is out of control. They are excellent (though expect to be told off if you haven't been doing all the things you should do) and got me emergency steroids following a severe attack once and can suggest a different inhaler if necessary.

You were naive, but hopefully now you know better.

Wolfiefan · 27/10/2023 12:30

The receptionist won’t be medically trained and a GP can’t assess asthma over the phone. You just need a plan.

Connected1 · 27/10/2023 12:21

Cheeesus · 27/10/2023 12:20

But what does 112 equate to? Emergency or not. Ah, I’ve googled and it’s emergency.

Edited

Oh yes sorry - 112 is 999

OP posts:
DailyEnergyCrisis · 27/10/2023 12:21

You have to take responsibility for your health- the GP surgery can’t be expected to adequately assess you over the phone when you actually need faster access to emergency medicine.

Cheeesus · 27/10/2023 12:20

Connected1 · 27/10/2023 12:18

Yes, 112. I'm in Ireland so there's no 111

But what does 112 equate to? Emergency or not. Ah, I’ve googled and it’s emergency.

Connected1 · 27/10/2023 12:18

Cheeesus · 27/10/2023 12:17

Do you mean 112=999 or 111? I am trying not to be pedantic, but struggling to get my thoughts straight without knowing.

In any case, yes you need a management plan, so maybe get on with getting that in place, then it will be clearer another time.

Yes, 112. I'm in Ireland so there's no 111

OP posts:
Cheeesus · 27/10/2023 12:17

Do you mean 112=999 or 111? I am trying not to be pedantic, but struggling to get my thoughts straight without knowing.

In any case, yes you need a management plan, so maybe get on with getting that in place, then it will be clearer another time.

Connected1 · 27/10/2023 12:17

RuthW · 27/10/2023 12:14

You should have rang 999. GPs are not an emergency service.

Thank you. That's what I'm thinking now. I'm also thinking the receptionist should have given me the same advice.

OP posts:
Hbh17 · 27/10/2023 12:16

The GP has many, many other patients - you are not going to be top of her list. It's also not an emergency service, and you had other options in that regard. If you have had this condition for a while, it's up to you to take some responsibility and it would be ridiculously unfair to complain about the GP.

RuthW · 27/10/2023 12:14

You should have rang 999. GPs are not an emergency service.

Swipe left for the next trending thread