Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is being unreasonable me or DH? Shared children and stepchildren issue

183 replies

GarlicOnEverything · 27/10/2023 10:07

I have recently inherited some money, not a ridiculously massive amount but a decent amount.

There are a few things I'd like to do it, inc saving some, but one of the things is wanting to take out our child and get them some nice things / take them on a day out or weekend away with me.

I work full time and don't get as much time as I'd like to go and do fun things with our child (7). So to have a mummy and DC day is something I really want to do and having the opportunity to spoil them a little makes me happy.

DH thinks I'm being unreasonable to give money to DC (was thinking of giving them X amount to spend whilst we are on our day / weekend trip or to buy something they really want) and not give the same to his older DC who are 11 and 13.

Fwiw, I am using some of the money to do some renovations on our house that we all live in and to put toward a family holiday for next year. I think if I want to spend a few hundred pounds on our child then it's my business?

aibu?

OP posts:
Santibbz · 30/10/2023 08:24

I have a stepchild, but also was a stepchild growing up. And I can tell you that it was awful being in the house knowing that I was not the same. 🙃 My stepmum would forever refer to me as “his daughter” to people. I wasn’t expecting to be called “her daughter” obviously but would have nice to be treated as if I wasn’t in the way. Which I was. All the time. My mother became an alcoholic and I moved in permanently with my dad and stepmother and it just spiralled from there. I would never allow my stepdaughter to feel the same as I did so she is treated the same as the rest of them, because they are all our children.
The words “I wish you weren’t here” were never used obviously, but they didn’t have to be because it was very clear that I wasn’t wanted.
my stepdaughters mother has sadly gone down the same route as my mother, and that is why she moved in with us full time with no contact with her biomum. Therefore my role is more pivotal than ever, and another reason why I make sure she always feels equal and loved the same.

ianthes · 30/10/2023 08:08

Honestly I'm baffled why you wouldn't just treat them to something small, £50ish It's nice to treat people you love. It doesn't have to be the same amount as your DD but if I was your husband I'd definitely feel uncomfortable with this.
Fwiw I'm a step mum to two girls also.

FortheBeautyoftheEarth · 30/10/2023 07:56

Stepchildren aren't stupid. It they have a half sibling they are going to understand that while they are absolutely still an integral part of the family, just in the same way their relationship with their DM is special and important, same goes for that half sibling and their mum. Doesn't mean the step mum is being 'nasty' or always excluding them..step mums are constantly reminded not to overstep, we're not the real mum etc but it seems that even when we give birth to our own biological child, conditions are being placed on that as well. It's insulting to the intelligence of all concerned. And actually pretty callous to the bio child of stepmum.

Stepkids have two parents and they also have a bonus parent, which provided it works well, is a great village of support both material and emotional to have around them. You'd hope that if a good relationship was fostered between them and their other siblings, that they wouldn't want to see the other sibling always overlooked and living a half life when their r step sibling isn't there just because they are fortunate enough that both their parents are still together.

SunshineAutumnday · 30/10/2023 07:46

Depend on the relationship you want with your DSC and how important the feelings of your DSC are to you.

If it were me, I'd include the DSCs in the day out -something that suits all tastes. Cinema, fun meal. Or crazy golf etc and each child would get the same amount. As I'd see that we're a whole family.

GoodToBeHome · 30/10/2023 07:44

Santibbz · 29/10/2023 23:07

My stepdaughter is very much a huge part of my life, I have known her since she was 5 and she is now 13. She was 7 when her first sibling from me was born so I was her stepmother before I had biological children. Perhaps that is why I feel more strongly to them all being treated the same. I have a life insurance policy and all 4 children are named on it, I don’t care that she is not my “biological child” I have watched her grow and been a part of it. She has lived with me full time since she was 10 but even before then, I never planned anything without her. When my children got new things, so did she. If she ever walked into the house and ever questioned her worth because she is not “mine” I would truly be heartbroken. So if I ever came into any inheritance, blood or not it would be split evenly. She just so happens to be lucky enough to have 3 sides of the family, her dads, her mums, and mine. 😊 if me and her dad ever split, I would be devastated if my children were treated differently as they were “step-children”

I don't understand people being devastated that SC are treated 'differently' to biological children.
My kids are older now but if I had split from my husband when they were younger I certainly wouldn't expect the woman that got with my husband to treat my children as their own.
I would expect her to treat my children kindly and depending on the length of the relationship with my (would be ex) husband take care of their basic needs but beyond that they are my children not hers!!!
I would find it difficult enough packing my children off every weekend to see their dad without some random woman playing happy families and taking over the mothering role for 2 days.
Blending families is difficult, I just don't see the need for people to treat their SC exactly as they would their own. The SC already has two parents and so do biological children, taking your own child for a day out shouldn't be seen as a huge insult to your partners other children.

Santibbz · 29/10/2023 23:07

My stepdaughter is very much a huge part of my life, I have known her since she was 5 and she is now 13. She was 7 when her first sibling from me was born so I was her stepmother before I had biological children. Perhaps that is why I feel more strongly to them all being treated the same. I have a life insurance policy and all 4 children are named on it, I don’t care that she is not my “biological child” I have watched her grow and been a part of it. She has lived with me full time since she was 10 but even before then, I never planned anything without her. When my children got new things, so did she. If she ever walked into the house and ever questioned her worth because she is not “mine” I would truly be heartbroken. So if I ever came into any inheritance, blood or not it would be split evenly. She just so happens to be lucky enough to have 3 sides of the family, her dads, her mums, and mine. 😊 if me and her dad ever split, I would be devastated if my children were treated differently as they were “step-children”

Backagain23 · 29/10/2023 22:08

As usual, some posters seem to think "equal" means one set of children having 3 (or potentially 4) adults providing for them and another set having only 2.
It's a very peculiar logic.

AnneLovesGilbert · 29/10/2023 21:24

Have people missed she’s already paying for everyone to go on a holiday? She’s not swanning off to Disney with her child leaving her step kids eating old bread under the stairs. The hyperbole is ridiculous.

sugarsherbet · 29/10/2023 21:21

This is a tough one, my step father came into money after selling a asset that had nothing to do with my mum but split the money equally between me and his own children. I think you should give them something so they feel included.

gotomomo · 29/10/2023 21:06

Do people not understand that marrying means sharing these days? Honestly I couldn't come into money and buy things for my dd and not dsd

ArborealArdour · 29/10/2023 21:02

Sundownmemories · 29/10/2023 21:00

Probably not the answer you want but if you are married and all your household money is shared then I think your stepchildren should be treated equally to your biological child. Blended families are never black and white but I think money can really complicate things and cause problems. Make everyone equal and it simplifies things.
My stepdad raised me as his own and there was no separate money despite having 3 of his own children from a previous marriage who never stayed with us as they were adults.
When my grandma (my mum’s mum) passed away my mum shared her inheritance between me and my 3 stepsisters equally. My stepsisters were not related to my grandma but my mum married their dad so we are family.
There’s nothing wrong with having a nice day out with your daughter. You can do that whether you inherit money or not and I’m sure your husband would never begrudge that. The problems begin when you start saying you’re going to treat her to something the other children aren’t getting.

The OP has already stated that they have separate finances!

Sundownmemories · 29/10/2023 21:00

Probably not the answer you want but if you are married and all your household money is shared then I think your stepchildren should be treated equally to your biological child. Blended families are never black and white but I think money can really complicate things and cause problems. Make everyone equal and it simplifies things.
My stepdad raised me as his own and there was no separate money despite having 3 of his own children from a previous marriage who never stayed with us as they were adults.
When my grandma (my mum’s mum) passed away my mum shared her inheritance between me and my 3 stepsisters equally. My stepsisters were not related to my grandma but my mum married their dad so we are family.
There’s nothing wrong with having a nice day out with your daughter. You can do that whether you inherit money or not and I’m sure your husband would never begrudge that. The problems begin when you start saying you’re going to treat her to something the other children aren’t getting.

ArborealArdour · 29/10/2023 18:22

Fraggeek · 29/10/2023 17:39

Personally I couldn't leave my stepson out. I'd want to do something with my own children but also something as a family. Yes a holiday is doing just that but I mean a similar activity to what I do with my children, for us all that my stepson would feel just as included in.

This year we went on a large family holiday, paid for by my family. My stepson wasn't included. We didn't have the funds to pay the extra this time around. When we spoke about it, we made it clear that as we'll be in a better financial position, we'll all go and he will be with us.

Yes I want that time alone with my children to enjoy things but I would feel awful knowing a child is missing out and the thoughts and feelings they'd have around that.

Read the OP carefully.

DH and OP are in agreement that OP can go somewhere with her own child. So that's fine. The issue isn't the trip, but the X amount OP is giving her child to spend, on the trip.

Why would the SC have any 'thoughts and feelings' about this. Seeing as they won't know about it anyway. How are they missing out here?

Btw they are ALREADY going on a family holiday so your example is totally irrelevant. Furthermore, OP's son is 7, they're tweens. I highly doubt that they'd have strong feelings of missing out on a weekend of primary school kid activities.

Fraggeek · 29/10/2023 17:39

Personally I couldn't leave my stepson out. I'd want to do something with my own children but also something as a family. Yes a holiday is doing just that but I mean a similar activity to what I do with my children, for us all that my stepson would feel just as included in.

This year we went on a large family holiday, paid for by my family. My stepson wasn't included. We didn't have the funds to pay the extra this time around. When we spoke about it, we made it clear that as we'll be in a better financial position, we'll all go and he will be with us.

Yes I want that time alone with my children to enjoy things but I would feel awful knowing a child is missing out and the thoughts and feelings they'd have around that.

funinthesun19 · 29/10/2023 17:39

I don’t understand the stance of “their mum would not give your child something” of course not. Your child has nothing to do with your SC mum?? It makes no sense to compare the two things?

I think this comparison does hold some weight when you think both women are only mums towards their own. OP should be able to go out and buy her child a new coat just as much as the stepchildren’s mum should be able to, without thinking about each other’s child.

It’s the DAD who should think about both. OP should be able to treat her child to something with her own money just as much the stepchildren’s mum will treat them - without thinking about anyone else.

SecondUsername4me · 29/10/2023 17:35

If you are marrying someone who already has children then all of the children should be treated equally

How does this work when the children only live there part of the time? Should the OP and her child just never go and do anything or buy anything or whatever just because the step kids aren't there thay day?

Sherm24 · 29/10/2023 17:30

I have a ‘blended’ family, 23
yrs, youngest child being 18 mths, eldest 3 yrs , when we got together, we also have a child together, 7/8 yrs between the other 2. He treats them all the same, inheritance, salary, treats etc. there is no, one without the other, and for that, my husband will be, a great parent. I don’t know what’s it’s like to be a step parent, so can’t comment on that, I just know about my family, and DH has always treated them all the same ❤️

Santibbz · 29/10/2023 17:12

I don’t understand the stance of “their mum would not give your child something” of course not. Your child has nothing to do with your SC mum?? It makes no sense to compare the two things? Surely the same comparison would be, if the bio-mums husband/boyfriend came into money, would he be expected to give money to his own children if he has any plus the 11 and 13 year old of his wives?
Would your husband be annoyed if his children were left out in that sense too?
I have 3 of my own children plus 1 stepchild. I would never dream of treating them any differently. Imagine how the stepchildren would feel? It’s awful to do that to children.

JMuldoon79 · 29/10/2023 17:04

It’s easy to resolve just treat them to something. I think it’s wrong if you’re married to decide it’s your money and it’s you who decides, in a marriage it would be joint and where you have children from his other relationship it’s not fair to just treat one child. Personally I think there’s more to it and you’re doing it as a form of control.

Someoneonlyyouknow · 29/10/2023 15:57

I think you can definitely do something with/for your child without making a big fuss about not spending equally on the stepchildren. It might be harsh to plan the day out on when they will be at your house unless your DH does something with them

funinthesun19 · 29/10/2023 15:03

“If DH leaves you…”

Well I think some stepmums would really quite welcome the thought. At least they’ll be able to be a mum without silly unreasonable conditions attached.

Passepartoute · 29/10/2023 14:43

Creamteasandbumblebees · 29/10/2023 13:09

It shouldn't make a difference. If you are marrying someone who already has children then all of the children should be treated equally. By doing this she's sending a clear message that she's prioritising her own child over her step children. I don't think that's kind or fair and if it continues it will ultimately cause resentment between OPs own child and her step siblings. I can see why her husband is upset by this.

How can you treat them equally when two of them are not in the house five days a week? Is the third supposed to live a monastic life all that time in case they should get something they enjoy when the others aren't there to enjoy it also?

Even with non-step siblings it isn't at all unusual to take different children to different events - DD and I are very happy to do our own thing whilst her brothers go to football, for instance, and when she was smaller her brothers certainly didn't want to go to places like Peppa Pig world with her. So if OP is taking her child out on her own, her husband can take the older ones out.

Backagain23 · 29/10/2023 13:48

Creamteasandbumblebees · 29/10/2023 13:09

It shouldn't make a difference. If you are marrying someone who already has children then all of the children should be treated equally. By doing this she's sending a clear message that she's prioritising her own child over her step children. I don't think that's kind or fair and if it continues it will ultimately cause resentment between OPs own child and her step siblings. I can see why her husband is upset by this.

Do you know what's not kind or fair and likely to cause resentment?
Making OPs child grow up without knowing their relationship with their own mother is special and unique.
Making OPs child grow up thinking their older siblings are extra special to everyone because their parents split up.
Making OP and/or the DSC carry on some charade of being mother/child.
What do you mean "it's unreasonable to expect a child to place anyone as equal to their own mother"? OP is family after all...
Well, that's awkward...

Creamteasandbumblebees · 29/10/2023 13:09

AnneLovesGilbert · 29/10/2023 12:36

She’d be angry. Because they're all his children. Obviously 🙄

It shouldn't make a difference. If you are marrying someone who already has children then all of the children should be treated equally. By doing this she's sending a clear message that she's prioritising her own child over her step children. I don't think that's kind or fair and if it continues it will ultimately cause resentment between OPs own child and her step siblings. I can see why her husband is upset by this.

SecondUsername4me · 29/10/2023 13:04

Creamteasandbumblebees · 29/10/2023 12:33

I'd be devastated if my husband prioritised our bio daughter like this and left out my eldest daughter. Fortunately he has always treated them exactly the same. I think you are being unreasonable.
How would you feel if your husband splurged lots of money on the children from his first marriage but left your child out?

This is a moot point as all three of the children are his.