Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is being unreasonable me or DH? Shared children and stepchildren issue

183 replies

GarlicOnEverything · 27/10/2023 10:07

I have recently inherited some money, not a ridiculously massive amount but a decent amount.

There are a few things I'd like to do it, inc saving some, but one of the things is wanting to take out our child and get them some nice things / take them on a day out or weekend away with me.

I work full time and don't get as much time as I'd like to go and do fun things with our child (7). So to have a mummy and DC day is something I really want to do and having the opportunity to spoil them a little makes me happy.

DH thinks I'm being unreasonable to give money to DC (was thinking of giving them X amount to spend whilst we are on our day / weekend trip or to buy something they really want) and not give the same to his older DC who are 11 and 13.

Fwiw, I am using some of the money to do some renovations on our house that we all live in and to put toward a family holiday for next year. I think if I want to spend a few hundred pounds on our child then it's my business?

aibu?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GrannyRose15 · 05/12/2023 15:09

The inheritance is your money. It doesn’t belong to DH or DC and certainly not to DSC. Do with it as you please.

NavyKitchen · 31/10/2023 19:22

I'm not sure if it's because I've known dsc since she was 3 and she's now an adult with a family of her own so it's been such a long time, but we just think of ourselves as having 4 children (3 dc together).
That being said, we've always had separate days out/treats for each of the kids to try to give them one on one time.
Our youngest is the only one under 18 now so he probably gets more than the others but it's evened out over the years.
We have mirror wills. Everything to the spouse and then eventually everything 4 ways.
My dc aren't part of dsd's mum's family (although she's very kind to them) so of course, they wouldn't inherit from her side, but dsd is part of my family. She considers my siblings her aunts and uncles and my parents her grandparents.
That's just the way it is and my dc wouldn't feel any hurt by not receiving from dsd's mum's side but dsd would be hurt to not be treated in the equal way she always has been in my family.
I do appreciate that we are lucky to have the dynamic we have and not everyone step family is the same.

AuntMarch · 31/10/2023 16:56

My inital reaction is that YANBU. I don't understand the comparisons with the bio mum and her not treating the OP child though. There is no reason she'd even necessarily have met them!

Do you normally combine all finances/is DH the breadwinner? Because maybe then he sees it as your joint money. And if it were then I could understand his point. (But as he is saying you should gift it then I'm assuming that isn't the case.)

RedPinkPeach · 31/10/2023 09:59

Pallisers · 30/10/2023 21:33

So this mum can never spend time or money on her one daughter without involving her step kids? Never? That is ridiculous. The stepkids have 2 parents - and a step parent who is happy to spend money on their home and their family holiday from her inheritance. That she then can't spend a bit of money on her only child as a one-off day-out, without bringing along her stepkids too is just insane.

It would be different if she was planning a special day with her daughter and her husband. Yeah, leaving out his kids then would be a bit mean. But she is planning a day with just her and her daughter.

OP, don't overthink this. Take your daughter out for the day. Spend the time. If you want to say "granny/grandad/whoever left the money" made this possible do. Do it on a day your step kids aren't with you.

Exactly. I spent time 1-2-1 with each of my children.

Pallisers · 30/10/2023 21:33

Brumbies · 27/10/2023 10:39

You're a family or you're not. To not involve your SC is a big mistake, imho.

So this mum can never spend time or money on her one daughter without involving her step kids? Never? That is ridiculous. The stepkids have 2 parents - and a step parent who is happy to spend money on their home and their family holiday from her inheritance. That she then can't spend a bit of money on her only child as a one-off day-out, without bringing along her stepkids too is just insane.

It would be different if she was planning a special day with her daughter and her husband. Yeah, leaving out his kids then would be a bit mean. But she is planning a day with just her and her daughter.

OP, don't overthink this. Take your daughter out for the day. Spend the time. If you want to say "granny/grandad/whoever left the money" made this possible do. Do it on a day your step kids aren't with you.

MrsZargon · 30/10/2023 16:12

YABU - I believe that when you enter into a relationship with someone who already has kids you are agreeing to enter into a relationship with them too! You state it is a decent amount of money and I’m assuming that the spending for the day out would be in the region of £100 or so, so really would it be that hard to also give that to the other 2?
For those saying that if his ex-partner came into money she wouldn’t give any to OP’s child that is completely flawed logic as she is not in anyway in a relationship with OP or her daughter so it’s completely different! Obviously it also depends on the dynamic in your relationship. If your money is separate and your partner sometime treats his older kids and not the child you have together then that could also be taken into account, but I suspect that is not the case!

AllWeWantToDo · 30/10/2023 14:35

I must be a shit mum, I often do things with one or another of the dc . They range from 28 down to 10 so there's often been things through the years that would be inappropriate or boring for some. Don't all parents try to spend individual time with their dc. Why isn't it acceptable if there's sc involved

Ghyur · 30/10/2023 14:10

This right here is the problem with not having household money and rather your's and mine. A whole heap of division arises when one gets a lump sum and the other wants a say as to how it should be spent.
The household renovations and holiday are not “for the children,” they may use and attend but realistically they are of no direct benefit to them.
Realistically even two or three bio children would never have the same amounts spent on them. Having two of my own I assure you there is no spreadsheet kept to ensure this happens!!
I think you’ve missed a trick here OP, if I were in your position right now I’d be knocking the renovations (and possibly holiday) on the head and use the money to reduce your hours in work and subsidise your wage during that time. You will get to spend more time with your DC which would be far more beneficial than a day out with a budget. Also alleviates any current friction about how and when the money should be spent from DH.

IncomingTraffic · 30/10/2023 13:20

WillowCraft · 30/10/2023 13:06

No, but if that's all it is then why make a fuss about the inheritance? Presumably 7 year old already does things with mum when stepchildren are at their mum's house. The issue is not really the activity, it's the making a point that "my child will benefit from this and yours won't".

What will cause resentment -in both the youngest child and his mother - is this insistence that they only get to behave like a mother and child if the SC are at their mum’s house.

WillowCraft · 30/10/2023 13:06

funinthesun19 · 30/10/2023 11:19

Causing bad feeling within the family is going to be much worse for your own child than anyone else - they will forget the day out in a week or 2 but the resentment caused will last a lot longer. I wouldn't do this to them

I think this is really overly dramatic. I don’t think they will feel any resentment in years to come because their younger sibling went out somewhere fun with his mum one day back in 2023.

No, but if that's all it is then why make a fuss about the inheritance? Presumably 7 year old already does things with mum when stepchildren are at their mum's house. The issue is not really the activity, it's the making a point that "my child will benefit from this and yours won't".

funinthesun19 · 30/10/2023 11:20

Somewhere fun that they might not even like either, given the age gap.

funinthesun19 · 30/10/2023 11:19

Causing bad feeling within the family is going to be much worse for your own child than anyone else - they will forget the day out in a week or 2 but the resentment caused will last a lot longer. I wouldn't do this to them

I think this is really overly dramatic. I don’t think they will feel any resentment in years to come because their younger sibling went out somewhere fun with his mum one day back in 2023.

SeaMonkeysTookMyMoney · 30/10/2023 10:58

Without more information it's really hard to say. I mean if the step kids visit every other weekend and don't spend much time with you or their sibling then it wouldn't seem unfair to me to only spend the money on the house and your DC. But if the step kids live with you, you see them regularly and you and DC have a good relationship with them it does seem unreasonable to expect them to be pushed aside. I think it comes down to whether you see them as family or not. Are they just someone else's kids you have to put up with now and again but have no attachment to, or do you think of them as part of your extended family and consider them older siblings of your DC? If they matter to you, even just a little, it would be appropriate to use a portion of the money on something for them (perhaps a new game, some robux or tickets to something they like?).

ScartlettSole · 30/10/2023 10:20

Tlolljs · 27/10/2023 13:06

I think it depends on how much it is. Sounds like a fair whack and step kids are getting a holiday out of it. Home improvements will benefit them but are not quite the same.
Good suggestions op take your child on this day out and treat them to clothes toys etc but give the older ones a treat too.
Whatever they’re into new video game, football ball boots, horse riding hat. But a treat for them too.

This sounds a really reasonable compromise

ScartlettSole · 30/10/2023 10:17

Coffeerum · 27/10/2023 10:41

@Annasgirl Imagine that their mum inherited money - would she be spending any on your child?

To be fair I hate this comment, it isn't comparable at all. The DH's ex wife isn't step mum to OP's child, they have no relationship however OP lives with these children as a family for a portion of the week.
What would their mum do is just a stupid comment that has no relevance.

I agree. The more comparable would be if OP had a child who wasnt her husbands, how would she feel if he treated "his/their kids" but not hers.

ScartlettSole · 30/10/2023 10:13

Personally i couldnt do it. When me and my husband got together i had a daughter, he had a son. We all lived together and we said "we have 2 children". None of this, this ones mine, that ones his. We now have a baby together and all three are treated the same.

Onethingatatime23 · 30/10/2023 10:04

I think it would be different if you all lived together in the same house and their mother was not around. Just do something with you and DC when the others aren't there, don't involve DH at all.

Even if they were all your kids it would be quite normal to spend one on one time with each of them from time to time.

WillowCraft · 30/10/2023 09:53

GarlicOnEverything · 27/10/2023 15:09

Because I would like to do something special for and with my child.

That's not a good reason. You are only thinking of yourself and not your child. Technically they are all your children. There's nothing to stop you doing something special with your child and giving the stepchildren something too. The older ones won't want to do the activity probably so that's ideal - give them some cash instead.

Causing bad feeling within the family is going to be much worse for your own child than anyone else - they will forget the day out in a week or 2 but the resentment caused will last a lot longer. I wouldn't do this to them .

Backagain23 · 30/10/2023 09:50

WillowCraft · 30/10/2023 09:46

If you've inherited thousands I wonder why you would deliberately leave the stepchildren out. It's like you're trying to make a point as giving them £50 each won't make any difference to you.

However it may make a difference to them, your husband and your child - a negative effect.

I would be looking at it from the point of view of your own child's best interests as well as those of the step children. There is no point driving a wedge between them.

Years into the the future when you and your husband are long gone, your child will still have your stepchildren as their family. That is what you should be thinking about

If my DSDs love for her (half) brothers had to be bought and paid for in advance by me specifically, I'd not want her in their lives anyway.

WillowCraft · 30/10/2023 09:46

If you've inherited thousands I wonder why you would deliberately leave the stepchildren out. It's like you're trying to make a point as giving them £50 each won't make any difference to you.

However it may make a difference to them, your husband and your child - a negative effect.

I would be looking at it from the point of view of your own child's best interests as well as those of the step children. There is no point driving a wedge between them.

Years into the the future when you and your husband are long gone, your child will still have your stepchildren as their family. That is what you should be thinking about

ianthes · 30/10/2023 08:52

IncomingTraffic · 30/10/2023 08:48

They are not equal parents at all. It’s a stepfamily. SMs are only considered ‘equal’ when it’s about her paying for stuff.

If she wanted to attend parents’ night at school or have one of the two school show tickets allocated per family, it will turn out that she is not the SC’s parent and she should get back in her box.

Sorry if that was to me I meant equal parents to the shared child. When OP said it's up to her what she spends on her daughter. I would (being devils advocate) say sometimes it's not only up to her... if dad doesn't want his child to be spoilt in favour of the other two.
As I said, it's not a straightforward situation, blended families rarely are!

IncomingTraffic · 30/10/2023 08:48

They are not equal parents at all. It’s a stepfamily. SMs are only considered ‘equal’ when it’s about her paying for stuff.

If she wanted to attend parents’ night at school or have one of the two school show tickets allocated per family, it will turn out that she is not the SC’s parent and she should get back in her box.

ianthes · 30/10/2023 08:44

Ooh every days a school day, thanks @AnneLovesGilbert 🥰

AnneLovesGilbert · 30/10/2023 08:42

There’s a handy feature where you can read all of OP’s posts @ianthes and it’ll save you asking pointless questions.

ianthes · 30/10/2023 08:33

I think if I want to spend a few hundred pounds on our child then it's my business?

This would also give me pause for thought as your husband.
Either you're equal parents or not, therefore what you spend on your shared child is both of your business and your husband may not want your shared child growing up thinking that they're just 'half siblings' and that it's okay to have different treatment because of that.
I don't think it's as straightforward as you do what you want with your money. Do you usually share household finances?
Honestly that kind of attitude would really make me consider if I had made a wrong decision having a step mum for my children who would think like that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread