Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu inappropriate Halloween costumes

78 replies

Lemonllama · 27/10/2023 09:31

Am I alone in thinking some parents use Halloween dress up days to show how "cool" they are by dressing up their kids as inappropriate characters?

By inappropriate I mean characters off of TV shows and films that they have never seen. Just seen a 7 year old dressed up as a character with a bottle of wine and fag off a TV show that she hopefully has never heard of . I find it odd, won't the children have to explain all day who they are?

How is a 3 year old meant to tell people she is meant to be Mrs hinch or a politician ect . It's just for the parents clout and to post all over Facebook.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MyBlueDiary · 27/10/2023 17:27

SleepingStandingUp · 27/10/2023 15:03

Do you think all kids should be dressed in plain white until their old enough to express a preference? Otherwise babies are always a billboard for their parents tastes. The baby doesn't care if it's clothes come from the White Company or Lidl, is muted shades of green or covered in zebras.

Well, to some extent it’s unavoidable- parent chooses White Company or Lidl for baby clothes and that says something to the world about that baby’s parent. But there’s a big difference between that and thinking “I like the Ramones, therefore I’ll put a Ramones Tshirt on my baby”. Not least because I think people often do this as a sort of ironic joke, like dressing your kid as Mrs Hinch or Liz Truss. I find it really cringeworthy, at best.

MapleSyrupWaffles · 27/10/2023 16:15

phoenixrosehere · 27/10/2023 11:06

Yes, in Canada and the States, you dress up for Halloween however you want which I think is the fun part because people can get creative with it. There are Halloween Costume Contests and it is usually one of the creative, handmade types that were often winners. I remember a classmate winning because she went as a bag of jelly beans in primary. She was pretty much wearing a clear plastic trash bag with different coloured balloons and a cardboard with thin string around her neck that hung around the middle with the brand name of the jellybeans in the front.

There’s only so many “scary” age-appropriate things you can be for Halloween as children.

In Canada (possibly America) one of the reasons for this is that is meant to be a disguise (so that the spirits roaming around on Hallowe'en night don't recognise you) - so anything and everything is fine, doesn't have to be scary or Hallowe'en themed; it's the disguise that is the point.

It seems like here is the oddness - like a superficial version of the whole idea, just taking some bits from it and making it as gory as possible.

In Canada (at least some places, I'm sure not everywhere) you don't ring doorbells - you shout trick or treat, or Hallowe'en apples, and if it's loud enough the door is answered. you might get asked to sing a song or tell a joke (kind of nursery rhyme song or simple joke is fine). Pretty much everyone in the community takes part (again, at least in some areas) and it's not seen as begging, or intimidating, or anything like that - it's much more a fun night, mostly for children. They wear Hallowe'en costumes to school, there are parties at Brownies or other activities, the supermarkets are full of bags of treats that are specifically 'Hallowe'en candy'. You also can (or could, no idea if it's still true) collect money at each house with special Unicef charity boxes that were given out and returned to school, with coin slots in the top, that you wore on a string round your neck.

And the actual trick or treating was only on the 31st.

Dramatic · 27/10/2023 15:58

I did dress my 1yo as Chucky, she would have also had no idea what any other costume was though.

Every year from 2 onwards I've let them pick their own costumes.

BoothsChristmasBook · 27/10/2023 15:56

Just remembered my kid once went as a "dead kitten".

Every couple of minutes he dropped to the floor and "died"

DrinkingMyWaterMindingMyBiz · 27/10/2023 15:48

Blondebrunette1 · 27/10/2023 15:00

@Lemonllama have you posted this "for clout?" mums net badge of honour 🎖️. Whilst I don't entirely disagree with your thoughts on grown up Halloween costumes I know my opinions are for my own family, there's no need for a thread bashing others. Mumsnet need a new forum for the judge Judy's, you can call it "Am I the best mum, because I do/don't.....?"

This 🤣. Or within that “My DC’s would never…”

MrsPepperpotspickles · 27/10/2023 15:43

My child has a dress up day today at nursery. She’s 3. I told her she could choose one of her 2 halloween costumes (cat & witch) or one of her usual dressing up rail costumes. She chose sleeping beauty. Sorted. No hassle and I don’t care if its ‘uncool’ it’s appropriate and she picked it herself!

PrincessHoneysuckle · 27/10/2023 15:43

HomeBird43 · 27/10/2023 12:43

I went to a Halloween party at uni (early 2000s) and some guy was dressed up as Madeleine McCann…

How did u know it was madeline mccann ?

cocksstrideintheevening · 27/10/2023 15:21

DTs have chosen and made their own costumes since they were old enough, we have had a taco and a burrito, dead zombie horse kids, glow stick people, dead zombie cheerleaders (there's a theme there). I much prefer to let them get on with it and they have fun doing it.

They won a make the guy competion on fireworks night a few years ago, it was shit but they had made it themselves. The guy said they won because it was obvious they have made the effort and not the parents.

Gets me off the hook anyway.

DeliahSmilah · 27/10/2023 15:11

@Ponoka7 that's a whole other debate. As a Saints fan, most horrific would be P*rtsmouth followed by Liverpool....

HowAmYa · 27/10/2023 15:06

My 5 year old dictated what she wanted for Halloween and she got it lol. 'I wanna be Wednesday from that hands hands dance' is what I was told and I eventually found a good replica + wig for about 13 quid
Thanks Temu!

I find it very very weird for a kid who's at the age that can talk and watch TV to be dressed on something that they've never seen or liked. Wtf are these parents on dressing kids with fags and bottles from shows the kids wouldn't even heave heard of! Fine for the adult but not for the kid.

SleepingStandingUp · 27/10/2023 15:03

MyBlueDiary · 27/10/2023 14:12

I don't like this either- not because the costumes are necessarily inappropriate (although they might be) but because it seems really pathetic for an adult to commandeer what's supposed to be a fun occasion for children and turn it into an opportunity for a shit joke for their own adult friends ("look, here's Noah dressed as Boris Johnson, hahhaha what am I like?")

There again, I also don't like seeing babies in band Tshirts for bands they've never heard of. A baby is a person not a billboard for their parents' tastes- if they're in a band Tshirt it should be the Wiggles not the sodding Ramones. So I am a bit zero tolerance about this stuff.

Do you think all kids should be dressed in plain white until their old enough to express a preference? Otherwise babies are always a billboard for their parents tastes. The baby doesn't care if it's clothes come from the White Company or Lidl, is muted shades of green or covered in zebras.

Ponoka7 · 27/10/2023 15:02

DeliahSmilah · 27/10/2023 09:40

A child dressed in a shiny tracksuit with a blonde wig, big gold chains and a cigar was spotted on holiday last weekend ( also saw some Liverpool shirts and pumpkins which were also horrific)

What's horrific about Liverpool shirts?

Blondebrunette1 · 27/10/2023 15:00

@Lemonllama have you posted this "for clout?" mums net badge of honour 🎖️. Whilst I don't entirely disagree with your thoughts on grown up Halloween costumes I know my opinions are for my own family, there's no need for a thread bashing others. Mumsnet need a new forum for the judge Judy's, you can call it "Am I the best mum, because I do/don't.....?"

TheIsleOfTheLost · 27/10/2023 14:54

@BoothsChristmasBook I have a welcome to the jungle door mat 😂

And full parental settings on youtube, so I can't listen to half the stuff I want to on youtube, even when the kids aren't in.

This year they have chosen minion and generic red and black with cape costumes. Long past when they would let me choose their costumes.

TheLovleyChebbyMcGee · 27/10/2023 14:50

I love the branston pickle jar!! I take a lot of joy in different halloween costumes, other notable ones I've seen that really tickled me was a cashline machine, a banana, and a sheep made by gluing about 500 cottonwool balls on to a jumper.

BoothsChristmasBook · 27/10/2023 14:28

@TheIsleOfTheLost Welcome to the Jungle on the other hand 😉

Band tees on babies ffs. Exactly the same thing, parents using their kids to express their own adult tastes.

ghostyslovesheets · 27/10/2023 14:23

A couple of years back I had two younger teenagers trick or treating dressed as Tubs and Edward - asking if I had local sweets for local people - I almost gave them the whole lot - they were fabulous

But yes - I agree that some costumes are OTT - mine always wanted to go as zombies, cats or Doctor Who characters - if you want to know how to knock up a TARDIS costume out of a blue pillowcase I'm your woman!

TheIsleOfTheLost · 27/10/2023 14:22

@BoothsChristmasBook of course there is a difference. He has been bopping around to music since he had muscle control. No one gets graphically eaten alive in sweet child o mine.

He also spent several months singing nothing but baby shark, so plenty of child specific music too.

MyBlueDiary · 27/10/2023 14:12

I don't like this either- not because the costumes are necessarily inappropriate (although they might be) but because it seems really pathetic for an adult to commandeer what's supposed to be a fun occasion for children and turn it into an opportunity for a shit joke for their own adult friends ("look, here's Noah dressed as Boris Johnson, hahhaha what am I like?")

There again, I also don't like seeing babies in band Tshirts for bands they've never heard of. A baby is a person not a billboard for their parents' tastes- if they're in a band Tshirt it should be the Wiggles not the sodding Ramones. So I am a bit zero tolerance about this stuff.

RubyBoozeDay · 27/10/2023 14:08

I went to a festival in September where fancy dress was prevalent, and there was a man dressed in a nurse's uniform, dangling a baby doll by the foot, and a name badge saying Lucy. I was disgusted. Jimmy Savile was also there.

As for children's fancy dress, we've had some early tick or treaters, dressed a witches and zombies, nothing inappropriate so far...

Jewelspun · 27/10/2023 14:06

@MindIfISlytherin my ex's daughter was ten in 2005 which was when she had the playboy party! I thought it was awful but as you say there was playboy stuff in all the shops.

SleepingStandingUp · 27/10/2023 14:02

BoothsChristmasBook · 27/10/2023 13:36

"No 6 year old needs a stranger things t shirt. I did put band t shirts on the kids when they were tiny, but consider that worthwhile as ds1 now loves guns n roses."

There's zero difference. You're judging people for doing what you did. Fucking bizarre 🤣

I've just had a look through photos from a Halloween party last night and the kids were dressed as Spider-Man, a vampire, a zombie soldier, a Harry Potter, hermione, a ghost and a sparkly pumpkin dress. Personally I think most people dress their kids appropriately, I've not seen any kids with fags or Jimmy saviles running around

Except there's rarely an age limit on music unless it contains explicit content. There's plenty of Guns N Roses you could pop on Alexa whilst the kids are having a dance to it. I wouldn't pop Stranger Things on whilst the kids are up.

Putting a Guns r Roses t-shirt on is different to me dressing DS in Peter Rabbit because I like him. They're both just parents taste and choice.

SplendidUtterly · 27/10/2023 14:00

I remember being around 8 or so and a friend of my DM and her partner dressed up on halloween as what my child brain thought at the time were "olden day clothes and wig" it wasn't until a few years later i remembered and mentioned it to my DM and she said that they were in fact dressed up as hindley and brady 🙄

mrssanchez · 27/10/2023 13:58

Not costume related but I am really shocked by some of the comments on the various online debates about under 15s not being allowed to watch Five Nights At Freddie's at the cinema. I've seen several parents declaring that their 10 year old (or similar) is obsessed with the Saw films and loves watching them.
Sorry but, wtf?!

KimberleyClark · 27/10/2023 13:41

I remember a year or two ago being at a birthday party at a friend’s house around Halloween. There was a woman there with her son about 11. He was wearing a big pair of fake glasses and the mum said “yeah he’s really into Jeffrey Dahmer at the moment.” I was like wtf.