Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I've inherited a considerable amount of money

237 replies

Back2Black · 26/10/2023 22:20

And decided to divide it between my DCs without their knowledge.
AIBU?

I'm a single parent. 3 are uni / just finished & one at senior school. The plan is to put the money in trust equally between the 4 DC until they each turn 30.

The reasoning is, my mum died when she was younger than I am now & my dad not much older than I am. So I thought my inheritance should skip a generation & go straight to my DCs.

Is this fair?

OP posts:
Holdyournoseandthinkofchocolate · 27/10/2023 09:08

If you and your DCs are entirely UK based then an offshore trust is a silly idea for a number of tax reasons. If you came up with that idea yourself then you need proper advice. If someone else has suggested it to you then look hard at how you are paying them and what they are getting out of it, it is unlikely to be the best solution.

If you are UK domiciled (= roughly of UK origin, actual definition is more complicated) then placing more than £325k in a trust, onshore or offshore, will result in a 20% upfront tax charge of the excess to the £325k.

lechatnoir · 27/10/2023 09:08

when I was in my early 20’s I got a similar size inheritance. My folks basically handed £10k for me to do what I wanted and then told me I had £100k towards a deposit for when I want to buy a house. My Dbro bought a B2L almost immediately but me & Dsis waited few years each until we were ready and it meant we knew we had a decent deposit. The inheritance was actually my parents and they decided to gift the sums to us so there was no question or us missing out on interest of such like as it was for a very specific purpose as & when we were ready. It was the difference between us getting on the housing ladder in the south east on lower incomes or probably still renting in our 40’s (or living in significantly smaller/cheaper property)

BackAgainstWall · 27/10/2023 09:01

30 is an excellent age in my opinion.

I would invest it in a very good property (singular), in a good part of the country where prices will inevitably increase over time.

A trust won’t give them such a good return on the money, and in 10 years or whatever (I don’t know the ages of your DCs), the huge amount now will be very devalued.

Lovemusic82 · 27/10/2023 09:00

I would keep the money in your own account and use it to help the dc when they need it. They might need it before they get to 30? One might get married and need money for a house, they might want to pay of student debt or need private health care? You could invest it and then by the time they need the money there could be a lot more?

LovelyGreenCushions · 27/10/2023 08:59

Why do you need an offshore Trust?

Nowherenew · 27/10/2023 08:58

Tealtoffee · 27/10/2023 08:52

I'd want to determine what they spend it on and if they were going off the rails - I'd want to have the funds to help them - I have a friend whose son is very ill and because it's mental illness the NHS are useless - he needs residential specialist help and that is going to cost £££ - if she had the money she could offer him residential care - if he had the money he'd self medicate and drink himself to death - he's in his early 30s now - he's needed help for quite a few years.

Very good point!

Perhaps it’s worth looking into the will being split 4 ways if you die but you holding on to the money until then and gifting it to them as and when is needed.

EasternStandard · 27/10/2023 08:57

Could you say they have the money for a deposit when they’re ready to buy?

Nowherenew · 27/10/2023 08:56

I’m due to receive £10k in the next couple of years, which is a great amount but obviously not life changing.

I have decided to put most of it into a trust for my DD as like you I am a single parent and she has absolutely no other family apart from me.

I do have life insurance but that’s only if I die obviously but I’d like her to have a bit of money just to help her out because if I die she will literally have no one to help her.

I think you have done absolutely the right thing.

If I got that amount, due to my circumstances I would have taken some out for myself but if you don’t need the money then I can see why you haven’t.

I don’t know what age this money would be most useful though.

It depends on their circumstances.
Some people mature and settle down very early on but some people are still quite immature and would waste it in their late 20s/30s.

I’d probably say around 25/30 and hope that they use it as a deposit for a home etc and not waste it but I guess it will be their money and if they choose to waste it then that’s still up to them.

Iwasafool · 27/10/2023 08:54

Mirabai · 27/10/2023 08:47

I’ve seen people with funds released at 25 fritter it away, so I think 30 is a good age.

But have you considered provision for yourself in retirement so your kids are not burdened with your care? You’d need a pension pot of a million + to yield ~ 30k a year in retirement.

Equally, a good care home is 50k + a year, 70k+ if dementia is included. Think what those sums will be in 30 years. Selling 500k house, for eg, will only fund 5-6 years in a care home at current rates.

So yes, you need financial planning advice.

I think £500k invested well will provide income for care for well over 5 years. You can also buy a care annuity. So yes good financial advice is important. What we've found with an elderly relative is that once you count in their pension, Attendance Allowance, and income from investment it will last for a lot longer than 5 years.

Tealtoffee · 27/10/2023 08:52

I'd want to determine what they spend it on and if they were going off the rails - I'd want to have the funds to help them - I have a friend whose son is very ill and because it's mental illness the NHS are useless - he needs residential specialist help and that is going to cost £££ - if she had the money she could offer him residential care - if he had the money he'd self medicate and drink himself to death - he's in his early 30s now - he's needed help for quite a few years.

Iwasafool · 27/10/2023 08:51

Can there be some flexibility? I mean say one of them marries young, has a baby or two, living in an expensive rented place and you wish they could have the £100k to improve their life and your GCs lives. I have no idea how trusts work but that is the thing that would make me think.

Mirabai · 27/10/2023 08:47

I’ve seen people with funds released at 25 fritter it away, so I think 30 is a good age.

But have you considered provision for yourself in retirement so your kids are not burdened with your care? You’d need a pension pot of a million + to yield ~ 30k a year in retirement.

Equally, a good care home is 50k + a year, 70k+ if dementia is included. Think what those sums will be in 30 years. Selling 500k house, for eg, will only fund 5-6 years in a care home at current rates.

So yes, you need financial planning advice.

Lenor · 27/10/2023 08:44

I’m 25, have 3 dc and own my own home with my husband. I’d actually be pretty pissed I think if I found out that there had been 100k sat in an account waiting for me. In theory it’s lovely and a wonderful surprise, but actually there are lots of big life decisions that will have been made and that the 100k would have made a real impact against. For example, we’ve just moved house and again settled for a bigger, better house that isn’t our forever home because we were just priced out of the bracket for what we really need long term. We have no plans to move again in a few years but knowing we could have just skipped an entire house move and all the costs of moving would have been helpful at the time, and we may have waited.

I also think if there’s ever a time to have a bit of extra financial cushions it’s when DC are tiny. I would have done anything to have longer maternity leaves with my daughters (I’m self employed, so we’re talking a few weeks with each of them). Again, knowing there was 100k just sat waiting for me would make me very resentful the information wasn’t volunteered up sooner when it was really needed.

Lovely idea, but I wouldn’t keep it a secret past adulthood.

plumtreebroke · 27/10/2023 08:41

Why not use some of it to fund their Uni (if it really is a very big sum) then divvy up the rest. Don't leave them up to their necks in debt until they are thirty, and I would say 25 to get the rest.

DisforDarkChocolate · 27/10/2023 08:40

To be honest, while I can see the logic in your reasoning I don't agree with your plan.

Firstly, you should be secure. You may not die young. Secondly, why not designated some of this to simply enjoy. So upgrades to make your nicer to live in, a family holiday or too. You don't have to be extravagant to do these. Thirdly, I think any plans for your children to have money in the future need to be more flexible, 30 could mean several years in grotty house shares growing their overdraft.

I think overall you just need to take more time, it's a big decision.

Blondebutnotlegally · 27/10/2023 08:38

I wouldn't do it until 30 because buying a house is near impossible nowadays. This could really help them. Maybe 25?

My mum did this with us a few years ago. It was invaluable help. She kept it in her bank until we were ready to put a deposit down, there was no question or debate as to what it was for. She even still had mortgage to pay but helping us was more of a priority!

NOTANUM · 27/10/2023 08:32

Great idea!

I’ve asked relatives to consider leaving my share of any estate - which they openly say I’ll get a part of - to my children instead.

As similar ages, I hope we all die within short space of time as old people drinking wine and going on cruises. There’s no point having money come to me for a year or two before moving down the line.

Lavenderflower · 27/10/2023 08:31

I think 30 sounds sensible.

MyBlueDiary · 27/10/2023 08:31

There’s no point in putting £100k per child offshore- it won’t save you anything.

Giving money to your children is great if you can afford it but you are overcomplicating it. Why would you keep it a secret from them? Surely it’s better they know so that they can make life plans accordingly.

In your shoes I’d just tell them you have £100k for each of them which they can have at any time for a deposit or else for any purpose once they’re 25 (or 30). Then get a solicitor to create a straightforward trust on these terms (pp’s point about unwinding a trust after 18 depends on how it’s drafted). Or (even simpler) don’t bother with the trust and just give them each £100k at the relevant point (this is disadvantageous for tax but gives you more control).

EasternStandard · 27/10/2023 08:11

Are you ok for retirement?

As long as you split it equally, which you are

But I’d aim for them using it on housing deposits rather than just spend it on stuff and holidays

Drenchend · 27/10/2023 08:09

And unless you are extremely wealthy some for you also

Doris86 · 27/10/2023 08:09

Is it fair to who? I’m sure your children won’t be complaining if you do this. It’s your money and entirely your choice what to do with it. Why is this even a question for Mumsnet?

Drenchend · 27/10/2023 08:09

Op I would definitely keep some for for yourself.. Even if you wanted to dole that back out to them over the years?

Wouldn't 60 grand be enough for deposits?

Maybe give them 5 grand each now and see how it goes with the rest?

Another 10 grand each at 40 wouid be amazing and...

Think about how amazing it would be to put money into bank for any gc.

I would also put 5 grand each into a sipp fir them... Self invested personal pension into either a global fund eg buying little bits of companies all around the world or us stock markets... Buying little bits of their company eg apple, Google and so on

Ie i wouldn't gift 100 in line go... 60 or even 70... Hold back some so you can gift them decent sums at Xmas perhaps or when they have dc... Give them small few grand each now, some into sipp.. For when they get to 58...little sum waiting mkre if they add to it and some for gc to put into junior isa for gc.

theleafandnotthetree · 27/10/2023 08:09

I think you're crazy personally! I would keep it and use it as and when needed in a basically fair way, ensuring everyone gets roughly the same amount overall but only a proportion of the overall amount. So maybe I would set aside 120k for that but the rest I would use as I saw fit, either to enable me to retire early or work less, to travel, to support causes I'm interested in, to make life easier or more interesting! etc. My parents sold land - so basically unearned income too - when I was around your children's ages and my siblings and I saw, at most 10-15% of it. But they were very useful amounts when they came. What has been the best gift was knowing we don't have to worry about them financially.

Glittertwins · 27/10/2023 08:07

itsalongwaybackfromsorry · 26/10/2023 23:06

I was under the impression you couldn't put it in a trust until they were 30 here ... it's theirs as soon as they hit 16?

You can set it up however it is a right pain in the backside. We looked into it for our DCs and the amount of hoops needed, the financial advisor advised against it in the end.