Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I've inherited a considerable amount of money

237 replies

Back2Black · 26/10/2023 22:20

And decided to divide it between my DCs without their knowledge.
AIBU?

I'm a single parent. 3 are uni / just finished & one at senior school. The plan is to put the money in trust equally between the 4 DC until they each turn 30.

The reasoning is, my mum died when she was younger than I am now & my dad not much older than I am. So I thought my inheritance should skip a generation & go straight to my DCs.

Is this fair?

OP posts:
VWdieselnightmare · 27/10/2023 12:26

For those saying to put it on a pension for the kids - you can't just stick loads of money in pensions, you have to have earnings to match it. You can put £60k pa into your pension, or your annual earnings, whichever is lower. If no earnings the most you can put is £2,880pa.

When I said put it into a pension funds for the children I meant invest in growth funds or similar so that it grows over the next 30 years. To make the most of it — making the maximum use of ISAs and SIPPs, for example — would require working with the children so that they knew about it. That may or may not be such a great idea. Some young people would like the idea that to a small extent their future in retirement was covered. Others would probably be trying to get access to it early. Only the OP will know.

forthwrong · 27/10/2023 12:25

Blondebutnotlegally · 27/10/2023 08:38

I wouldn't do it until 30 because buying a house is near impossible nowadays. This could really help them. Maybe 25?

My mum did this with us a few years ago. It was invaluable help. She kept it in her bank until we were ready to put a deposit down, there was no question or debate as to what it was for. She even still had mortgage to pay but helping us was more of a priority!

^This, in spades. 30 is far too late, and if they don't have common sense by 25 they're not going to have it a 30.
DP and I struggled financially throughout our 20's, finally scrimped and scraped together a big enough deposit for first property at 30 (with no help at all from parents who had inherited large sums and could easily have helped). But house prices doubled in the years we were renting and we are still paying the price financially. Having enough for a deposit in our early to mid 20's would have been life changing (and we would not have pissed it away on a range rover).
My grandparent's advice to members of extended family whose children were getting married / setting up house together in mid 20's was: give them as much as you can afford now, because now is when they need it.

ChampagneLassie · 27/10/2023 12:24

I don’t think there is such a thing as a trust where you can withhold till their 30…if instead you’re meaning a discretionary trust and that you wouldn’t want anything paid out till their 30 that makes sense. I’d recommend getting a STEP accredited solicitor and IFA to create trust and advise on investment of the money.

payriseday · 27/10/2023 12:13

ManyMaybes · 27/10/2023 12:02

Most people massively underestimate the amount of money they need in a private pension to be comfortable in retirement. Some think they are rich because they have a £100k pot at 60! Spoiler - that will pay for an austere retirement.

I don’t know how much you earn but let’s say you wanted a £40k income in retirement, 10ish of that would come from the state pension (only at state retirement age) so you need another 30k.

The usual advice is to plan to draw up to about 4% per year from the fund to maintain the balance of the fund considering inflation, growth etc (but in any given year the fund might go up or down and also depends on your investments). Let’s say you followed that advice then drawing 30k would require a pension pot of £750k (not adjusting for future inflation, so in reality it would need to be higher, to get 30k adjusted for inflation).

Thinking about the above will your pension be sufficient?

Even if it is, I would consider paying off the student loans now as the interest on those is outrageous. But this also depends on how much your children expect to earn - in some but not all cases it might be beneficial paying them off.

You definitely need professional financial advice to consider your personal situation and provide tailored advice, not speculation from the mums that have very little context on your situation.

I think this is brilliant advice. Don't rush into anything and get some professional advice.

ManyMaybes · 27/10/2023 12:02

Most people massively underestimate the amount of money they need in a private pension to be comfortable in retirement. Some think they are rich because they have a £100k pot at 60! Spoiler - that will pay for an austere retirement.

I don’t know how much you earn but let’s say you wanted a £40k income in retirement, 10ish of that would come from the state pension (only at state retirement age) so you need another 30k.

The usual advice is to plan to draw up to about 4% per year from the fund to maintain the balance of the fund considering inflation, growth etc (but in any given year the fund might go up or down and also depends on your investments). Let’s say you followed that advice then drawing 30k would require a pension pot of £750k (not adjusting for future inflation, so in reality it would need to be higher, to get 30k adjusted for inflation).

Thinking about the above will your pension be sufficient?

Even if it is, I would consider paying off the student loans now as the interest on those is outrageous. But this also depends on how much your children expect to earn - in some but not all cases it might be beneficial paying them off.

You definitely need professional financial advice to consider your personal situation and provide tailored advice, not speculation from the mums that have very little context on your situation.

User0000009 · 27/10/2023 11:56

Back2Black · 27/10/2023 00:18

I think it's just enough for each of them to put a deposit on a house.

Yes this is the best thing to do

OopsaDazy · 27/10/2023 11:56

It's not clear @Back2Black how much financial knowledge you have.

For example, trusts are complicated. (We looked into this with our FA.) There are implications around the growth of funds and taxation. There has to be someone to manage the trust in the child's interests, outside of the financial set-up. We were advised that there are better ways to put money aside and that trusts are not worth the considerable admin and costs they incur if for less than £1M.

A lot comes down to how much you trust your children to do the right thing.

Ours have had early inheritances from us and their grandparents, of a similar amount, and they have not touched it other than for house deposits. We stipulated it was either for higher ed (like PhDs) or houses.

You could consider investing the £300K yourself, with advice, and it being there are as a carrot once your DCs settle down and find a house to buy.

Being realistic, unless you die very soon (god forbid) your children could want to buy within the next 5 years when they are late 20s.

Lm1981 · 27/10/2023 11:39

I think that’s a great idea and very generous of you to be putting your children at the forefront of the inheritance.
only thing I’d consider is making sure it’s invested so it’s gaining money - in other words make the 400k work for you until it’s time for the children to get it. 30 is a good age as it gives them time to find their own feet and usually they would have gained some experience.

Trethew · 27/10/2023 11:35

Have not read all 9 pages but not knowing that they have this money might place them in an awkward position, e.g. if applying for benefits, or divorcing. Anywhere they are required to make financial disclosure

Siddalee · 27/10/2023 11:26

Ive not read the full thread, but I have read all the OP's posts.

I'm in a similar situation- I'm about to inherit soem money and intend to pass it all on to my DCs now(ish).

It looks like I'm going to inherit around £120k from my mum's estate. I have two DCs - both in their mid 20s and both unable to get on the property ladder- partly because they would be looking for a mortgage on a single income.

I have a great pension for when I retire, which I intend to spend seeing the world and then ensuring the last part of my life is as comfortable as possible. I dont want to be worried about going into care eating up their inhertiance, so I want them to have what I can give them now.

Having nursed my mum through the last awful months, I don't want my kids to carry the same weight as I have (not that I have any regret or resentment). I've made it clear to the DCs that when the time comes, I'll be using any money available to me to ensure I have the best care I can afford and its likely there wont be an inheritance from me. Giving them this money now, goes some way to assuage the guilt I feel in potentailly not leaving them anything from me! However, we've all agreed that the money is to be used as a deposit.

So, going back to the OP, yes I think its a great idea and putting somethign in place so they recieve the money at a time in their lives that will help them ensure security and stability is a good idea too.

User0000009 · 27/10/2023 11:13

I too had a sizeable inheritance. I used it to make life easier for my children ie to get on the housing ladder.

OopsaDazy · 27/10/2023 11:10

You also need to proper financial advice.

Planning for your own retirement.
Possible care home costs (would you need to sell your home?)
Pension in excess of the state pension.
Private health insurance premiums?

Only after doing this can you afford to pass the money on.

Dolma · 27/10/2023 11:09

OP you need to pay attention to the poster who pointed out that a trust can be dissolved by the beneficiary at any point when they are over 18. It's known as the rule in Saunders v Vautier. It's a waste of time to debate whether you put it in trust until they are 25 or 30, because the trust deed is ultimately overridden by their ability to access it at age 18. You need legal advice on your plans.

OopsaDazy · 27/10/2023 11:08

You aren't really skipping, you're just giving them an early inheritance.

We did this with my MIL's estate. The Will was changed (this was all legal and done shortly after she died- it's an accepted process) and DH gave a third to each child of we kept a third.

They put it towards house deposits.

I don't see why you think it's an issue.

OopsaDazy · 27/10/2023 11:06

I don't understand the skip a generation.

Your children would normally inherit from you, their parent.

How is what you plan 'skipping' something?

IVFNewbie · 27/10/2023 10:58

How much money is it?

MintHoneyTea631 · 27/10/2023 10:50

There is no rush
You could take a year to think what you want to do with the money

If you look on money saving expert website they always recommend

Pay off debts
Have 3 to 6 month emergency savings
Put maximum into ISA
Pay into a pension
Spend some on yourself

It may be more tax efficient to put money into LISA'S for all your children ?

I am also concerned that if you give money to your children that it comes with strings attached- "you must spend it on X, Y,Z" . Should their be strings attached ?

Suggest get some financial advice before making big decisions

DoggerelBank · 27/10/2023 10:46

Passing it on to your kids, great if you can definitely afford it. But think long and hard before setting it all up as a trust. I've been involved in a trust that an older family member set up for my kids' generation. The cost and hassle is considerable. If you're talking about a fund of half a million plus, maybe it makes sense, but for smaller amounts there are a lot of annual overheads (ongoing financial advice and accountancy as well as legal set up costs) that eat into the final amount the kids will get. And don't get me started on how long it takes to administer.

Who else will be trustees? You may think the hassle is worth it, but if you die before your youngest is thirty, other people will have that hassle thrust upon them. My fellow trustees and I have really struggled since the family member died. We have different attitudes to finances and life in general, but are all tied to being responsible for this trust. In a toxic job, you can decide to leave, but it's not so easy with the trust. We have got to the point where relatives we used to be fond of are now people we will avoid at all costs as soon as the trust is wrapped up. You could pay lawyers or accountants to be trustees professionally, I believe, but that then eats even more into the pot.

Also, wouldn't it make sense to help your kids buy a home before they're thirty? If I was you, I'd gift them the money (not sure on the rules of how much you can gift though), invest it, get the kids to sign over responsibility, passwords etc to you, being very vague about how much cash there is, and sort it all out for them until you trust them to use the money to help buy somewhere to live. But outside any formal trust arrangement. Unless you have any particular reasons to think they'll go against your wishes and take the money out and spend it on drugs or fast cars?

Also, if a large amount, is it too late to amend the will so it's an inheritance for them rather than a gift from you? I believe there are advantages to doing that, but I'm not too clear - worth asking the probate lawyer?

Coffeebutter · 27/10/2023 10:44

You can do as you wish with the money, I would certainly make sure I had enough for future myself/pension. You could work out amount would help you and then split the rest.

30 is still quite young for a lump sum depending on how mature they are.

Why trust now ? Is it make tax efficient?
If no rush/tax reason could you not hold onto the money for a bit and work out what to do ?

finally ; the interest rates are so favourable at the moment you would get a nice return even whilst you think about what to do with it.

LakieLady · 27/10/2023 10:42

CagneyAndLazy · 26/10/2023 22:24

Up to you what you do with it, but why 30?

My DSS inherited from one of his GPs when he was 4 or 5. The money was left in trust until he was 30, with a proviso that the trustees could let him have it earlier if they considered he would do something sensible with it. She set the age at 30 as she didn't want him getting a shedload of money at an age where he might be reckless and fritter it away.

He was allowed the money at 21, and put down a 60% deposit on a house. Twelve years on, his mortgage is small by current standards and he has shedloads of equity in the house.

mn29 · 27/10/2023 10:35

Back2Black · 26/10/2023 22:31

Sorry, also 'fair' because it was left to me & I've decided to pass it on to DCs.

I’m sure your benefactor understood that once the money passed to you, it’s yours to do with as you wish. Not sure where ‘fairness’ comes in to this, you seem to be overthinking it.

Mirabai · 27/10/2023 10:34

LovelyGreenCushions · 27/10/2023 10:25

Attendance allowance is £68.10 or £101.75 a week- so more than £4000- but not much more!

Anyone reading this thread and with an elderly parent not claiming- have a look. It is very simple and in my experience the successful claim rate is very high.

Thanks, my bad.

Notanevillandlord · 27/10/2023 10:31

MariaMeringue · 27/10/2023 00:42

When my DH died four years ago, my DC were 12 and 14. I inherited his pension, which was a large sum of money, but I wanted it to go to DS and DD when they are old enough to spend it wisely. They are 16 and 18 and both in Sixth Form now, so it won't be for a while.

I decided to buy a house with the money, which I rent out. When both DC are at the stage of wanting to buy their own properties (they are only 17 months apart in age and I imagine this will be in their mid/late twenties), I will sell it so they can have half the money each. It's worked out well in the meantime, as I have benefited from the rent money from it every month, which has been helpful for school fees while they're still living at home and will go towards their university fees after that. The capital value of the house has increased by £150,000 since I bought it in 2019, so it has been a good investment and I think it was the best thing I could have done with the money to keep it safe for them.

This

I would do exactly the same. If the Op wants she can even divide the rent by 4 and put it in their accounts on a monthly basis, providing she has enough to pay for the upkeep of the house.

TheNoodlesIncident · 27/10/2023 10:30

Unless you are an IFA yourself, I would make an appointment with one and get some really good financial advice from them for your best course of action. I'm not saying you should or shouldn't give your entire inheritance away, it's up to you, but there are many aspects of financial services you won't be aware of and therefore don't take into account. Nobody here knows your personal circumstances but there's so much variance and there will be things that have an impact on what you might do.

I agree with PP that they are better off not knowing about the money until you choose to give them it.

Mirabai · 27/10/2023 10:28

BIossomtoes · 27/10/2023 10:15

If our investments were only yielding 5% we’d be gutted.

It depends on so many factors - do you manage your portfolio yourself or do you have a wealth management firm - they take hefty fees. It also depends on your level of risk, and also on the economy.