Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think no, David Lloyd, this is not “taking all measures to protect..children”

135 replies

HermioneWeasley · 26/10/2023 19:48

AIBU to think allowing adult males to accept spaces where women and girls are undressed is a clear safeguarding risk?

To think no, David Lloyd, this is not “taking all measures to protect..children”
OP posts:
GoGoGo2 · 26/10/2023 21:48

Agree to this

EwwSprouts · 26/10/2023 21:45

Males in the female changing room is a risk and a safeguarding risk.

David Lloyd Clubs advertise 12,500 children taught to play tennis. Much of this is in holiday clubs and comps where parents do not have to stay. Girls want a quick toilet break... should not result in an Eddie Izzard scenario.

Alopeciabop · 26/10/2023 21:45

SpoonGirl17 · 26/10/2023 20:34

Maybe take your transphobia somewhere else if it bothers you that much. If a cis man wants to hurt you or your DD they will. Also you are statistically most at risk from the men who are already in your life.
Trans women are not the enemy. Dangerous men are. Trans women are far far more likely to be attacked than to attack and that is what will happen if we exclude them from safe female spaces. Stop swallowing the disgusting lies being peddled by right wing bigots pretending to care about women and our safety suddenly
Also what exactly is your solution? A genitals check? What about trans men? They might have the “right” genitals but I think their big burley beards and muscles may raise some eyebrows.

There are so many unisex changing spaces out there that are used daily with no issues. Focus on something actually important.

This is RIDICULOUS. The ONLY reason women need safe space is because males have historically and statistically caused them harm.

BUT not all males cause harm. The ones that don’t are expected to (and do) accept that women need these safe spaces.

Simply because they were BORN with particular chromosomes/genitals they politely step aside/avert their eyes/give us these safe spaces.

The point is these men know that a woman can’t TELL whether they mean them harm or not. These gentlemen RESPECT that because they were born male, sadly women have to take extra care around them. Just because THEY know they wouldn’t hurt a fly, doesn’t mean they can just waltz into women’s safe spaces.

Here, the issue is NOT with “transness”. The issue is that they were born male. The issue is that we don’t know WHO’S the bad guy and who isn’t.

identifying as a woman doesn’t take away your maleness. It doesn’t take away your ability to harm. It doesn’t qualify you as “nice” or “safe”.

Since when does the word Trans = harmless. Are ALL trans people fundamentally harmless? No! They’re PEOPLE ffs. Hence, like all of us, some are GOOD, some are BAD. And sadly we don’t have any way of knowing who, so for safety’s sake we have come up with some little ways of trying to protect ourselves - GOOD men respect this and don’t try to foist themselves into our spaces. They don’t stomp their feet and say we’re discriminating based on their sex - even though that’s exactly what’s happening.

viques · 26/10/2023 21:42

Farmageddon · 26/10/2023 21:39

Because males are always prioritised above females, silly - even in women only spaces.

Yes I get that. I was musing.

Farmageddon · 26/10/2023 21:42

Lifeomars · 26/10/2023 21:13

I read somewhere that trans people make up 0.03% of the population, is this accurate? in all my life I have only known 3 trans people, 2 were male to female and the other was female to male. I never had any issues with any of them, in fact the reverse. I also know that one of them was beaten up and constantly harrassed by their neighbours and had to move, due to horrible physical and verbal abuse. That's just my take on the current debate.

That's a bit like me saying that because I have some male friends who I know and adore, that all men are just fine and never a problem to women ever.

RavingStone · 26/10/2023 21:42

I wonder if you've stopped to consider why you are statistically most at risk from the men who are already in your life, SpoonGirl17?

It is simply because abusive males have most easy access to the women they live with / know.

Why did you think it was?

You are suggesting that we give males (including abusive ones) more places with easy access to more women, that's all. Just because safeguarding makes some males feel bad.

We can't tell which males are abusive until too late, apart from recognising red flags such as boundary pushing. Wanting to be in women's spaces despite many women's opposition is a red flag IMO. Not all transwomen do this.

Froodwithatowel · 26/10/2023 21:41

And because it isn't about the embarrassment and harm, that like all the word salad and silly language, is a fig leaf trying to disguise that it's about being in the room with women with clothes off.

Farmageddon · 26/10/2023 21:39

viques · 26/10/2023 21:20

I really don’t understand why the embarrassment and potential harm to women by biological men in a changing room is seen as so much less important than the embarrassment and potential harm to biological men who identify as trans women by other biological men in a changing room.

Because males are always prioritised above females, silly - even in women only spaces.

Froodwithatowel · 26/10/2023 21:38

So male people, however they happen to identify, can get their kit off next to any women and girls they feel inclined to, and women who do not want to be involved in this can stick it. As if the male does assault them, the women and girls can always tell a member of staff. Who let's face it, won't give a toss.

As pretty much all females past a certain age have clocked, a male can make your life very, very unpleasant without ever laying a hand on you. That's before we look at how many rapes with forensic evidence don't make it to court.

And if you don't happen to say yippee and clap for the males involved, you're 'transphobic'.

Yeah. Any male doing this to women is not a nice person, and 'misogynist' is the least of the names I'd be using.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 26/10/2023 21:37

No women anywhere in the world lobbied for men to be present as women remove clothing - in changing rooms, showers, hospital wards or even for women's sport to be handed over to man. None of us.
It was men who decided that certain men should be given access to women undressing etc because it made them feel validated in their new "identity" as women. It's long overdue for all women to stand up and remind these people that women aren't support humans for men. Men need to ensure that male single sex spaces must be safe for all men - no matter what they wear, call themselves or how they identify. This is a men's problem to resolve and it's long overdue for them to step up to the plate.

ladedahde · 26/10/2023 21:35

@Lifeomars that may be your experience but your personal feelings or experience are irrelevant here, the fact is that transwomen are male and therefore should not have the right to use female single sex spaces under any circumstances. Its an outrage that they imagine they can and as you can see from voting results most women do not want males in these spaces for good reason.

EtiennePalmiere · 26/10/2023 21:34

plumtreebroke · 26/10/2023 21:15

I don't think anyone minds a trans person using female facilities if that is where they are comfortable, it's the fact that any man can use female facilities just saying I am trans when they aren't and just want to get into places where women and girls may be vulnerable and not fully clothed.

How do you know the difference? Are you sure there is, in fact, a difference?

AInightingale · 26/10/2023 21:34

YesHeIsMyFirstBaby · 26/10/2023 20:31

But... it seems safer to me to allow trans women into the women's and trans men into the men's.

Otherwise cis men (who are ACTUALLY dangerous to women) can stroll into the women's without question because they may well be a trans man forced to go into the women's!

Please explain this magical gift you have for distinguishing between a poor vulnerable and 'genuine' trans identified male (if there is such a thing, which I seriously doubt) and a leering opportunist?

Freshstart78 · 26/10/2023 21:32

Trans female is a transman, and then they contrast trans women with trans women when I assume they were trying to say they don’t stop trans men using the women’s 🤣

They sound very confused. Bless the writer they probably spent a whole day on that and still non the wiser.

grayhairdontcare · 26/10/2023 21:32

If a trans woman considers themselves female then you think they would have the same feelings as sharing a changing room with someone with a penis when it's a safe space.

Milarky · 26/10/2023 21:31

I don't think anyone minds a trans person using female facilities if that is where they are comfortable,

I don't need any survey to tell me that 100% of women would not want a naked man with his penis on display in an open changing room. Especially with young girls and teenagers naked there too.

Are you completely mad? How can you not understand this???

ladedahde · 26/10/2023 21:30

Ah so you are supposed to wait until a man who "identifies" as a woman has exposed himself or worse to your children or yourself before complaining, ok I got it. Thank god I don't give my money to these enablers anymore.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 26/10/2023 21:30

lanthanum · 26/10/2023 21:23

So if someone presenting as female turns up at David Lloyd, are they supposed to demand proof that they are female and always have been? What proof would be accepted? Are you happy to provide that proof for yourself?

The social conract worked fine until a certain group of men decided they needed access to women when undressing for their own validation purposes. Single sex facilities for men and women were respected. Women knew that any man accessing changing rooms, showers, hospital wards etc were there for the wrong reasons and could protest and they would be removed.

Now some groups have decided to abandon society's basic rules and withdraw women's rights to privacy & safety from men - all without consulting with women. As we see at David Lloyd.

flyingbuttress43 · 26/10/2023 21:29

No man born male can become female - ever.

lanthanum · 26/10/2023 21:23

So if someone presenting as female turns up at David Lloyd, are they supposed to demand proof that they are female and always have been? What proof would be accepted? Are you happy to provide that proof for yourself?

EtiennePalmiere · 26/10/2023 21:23

viques · 26/10/2023 21:20

I really don’t understand why the embarrassment and potential harm to women by biological men in a changing room is seen as so much less important than the embarrassment and potential harm to biological men who identify as trans women by other biological men in a changing room.

That's what we asked Transalphamale on their AMA about a thousand times, without getting an answer

Fionaville · 26/10/2023 21:22

It's not complicated at all. Trans women are not female, so they don't belong in female only spaces. Female spaces should be free from all males. No matter how they identify. It's about safety for females.

agent765 · 26/10/2023 21:21

EvelynKatie · 26/10/2023 21:17

I do mind any biological man in the female changing room, no matter what gender identity they associate with.

So do I.

viques · 26/10/2023 21:20

I really don’t understand why the embarrassment and potential harm to women by biological men in a changing room is seen as so much less important than the embarrassment and potential harm to biological men who identify as trans women by other biological men in a changing room.

VeronicaSawyer89 · 26/10/2023 21:18

plumtreebroke · 26/10/2023 21:15

I don't think anyone minds a trans person using female facilities if that is where they are comfortable, it's the fact that any man can use female facilities just saying I am trans when they aren't and just want to get into places where women and girls may be vulnerable and not fully clothed.

Actually, plenty of people mind transpeople of the opposite sex using our changing rooms! TW are still male!

Swipe left for the next trending thread