Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think no, David Lloyd, this is not “taking all measures to protect..children”

135 replies

HermioneWeasley · 26/10/2023 19:48

AIBU to think allowing adult males to accept spaces where women and girls are undressed is a clear safeguarding risk?

To think no, David Lloyd, this is not “taking all measures to protect..children”
OP posts:
SorryImAMan · 27/10/2023 09:12

That’s the problem. Some of the campaigning is forcing people who look like men into your spaces.

You are all in denial we exist. You say you can always tell. But the only way you can tell for most of us is to see our genitalia.

Just because you are ok with us in women’s changing rooms doesn’t mean all women are.

Theres no damn way I’m going to make women feel uncomfortable.

But if the law us going to make us sex offenders for going into the men’s, some of us will use your spaces. I may take my chances.

And then whenever someone who looks like a man goes to the ladies, they can say ‘I’m a trans man’. It will work.

Froodwithatowel · 27/10/2023 09:10

SorryImAMan · 26/10/2023 22:35

Really it’s not that easy to tell.

I’m a trans man, I’ve been on testosterone 20 years.

I look like a man. I have a beard. Never tried hitting a woman. But I can open jars my wife can’t. I suspect I could assault a woman if wanted to.

Ive been using mens changing rooms since 2003 without getting a second look. I can run in the dark without feeling scared. If I looked female wouldn’t I have been assaulted by now?

if I walked into the women’s I think almond of you would feel uncomfortable.

I will never do that. Because I don’t want to make women feel uncomfortable. I would get changed at home, avoid drinking, give up exercise outside the home.

But non-passing trans people should use discretion.

Also, women have the right to feel safe. Make your own spaces. Not my business.

But don’t force me into your spaces. Can’t you campaign for women’s only and ‘mixed’? Or something.

Edited

Women requiring privacy, dignity, safety and not have to get their kit off in front of random males who want to use their bodies for validation at the very least if not other purposes are not 'forcing' you to do anything. This is one of those disingenuous 'if you don't shut up and deal with a naked penis next to you from someone with long hair, you'll have to deal with me with a moustache and then you'll be sorry' really rather mean and nasty coercion lines. You change wherever you want, I really don't care.

And 'non passing' is ridiculous. Many male people are very, very deluded about this. Just because no one has been pushed to the point of rudeness of saying 'yes, I know' to their face does not mean anyone has been deceived. And wanting to deceive women into putting up with something they would not consent to if they knew is not 'kind' or even basically moral or respectful of others.

Trans people can do what they want with their bodies and their words, good luck to them. Male people regardless of identity can stay out of women's spaces and leave women alone, and try to manage a bit of reciprocity in the respect they constantly demand. Non trans people are not on this earth as bloody NPCs in trans lives.

Itsbritneybitch22 · 27/10/2023 09:06

@OKt They do and not had any children die in their facilities.

Naunet · 27/10/2023 08:54

Also, women have the right to feel safe. Make your own spaces. Not my business

We already did. 🙄

Naunet · 27/10/2023 08:52

YesHeIsMyFirstBaby · 26/10/2023 20:31

But... it seems safer to me to allow trans women into the women's and trans men into the men's.

Otherwise cis men (who are ACTUALLY dangerous to women) can stroll into the women's without question because they may well be a trans man forced to go into the women's!

Safer for who? Men who want to identify as women, maybe although I’ve never heard stories of men beating up transwomen in men’s spaces. What I have heard though is plenty of stories about so called transwomen abusing women and children in women’s spaces. They’re also more likely to be sex offenders than men who are happy being men, according to prison stats.

Male identity crisises shouldn’t be made women’s problem.

EvelynKatie · 27/10/2023 08:23

SorryImAMan · 26/10/2023 22:35

Really it’s not that easy to tell.

I’m a trans man, I’ve been on testosterone 20 years.

I look like a man. I have a beard. Never tried hitting a woman. But I can open jars my wife can’t. I suspect I could assault a woman if wanted to.

Ive been using mens changing rooms since 2003 without getting a second look. I can run in the dark without feeling scared. If I looked female wouldn’t I have been assaulted by now?

if I walked into the women’s I think almond of you would feel uncomfortable.

I will never do that. Because I don’t want to make women feel uncomfortable. I would get changed at home, avoid drinking, give up exercise outside the home.

But non-passing trans people should use discretion.

Also, women have the right to feel safe. Make your own spaces. Not my business.

But don’t force me into your spaces. Can’t you campaign for women’s only and ‘mixed’? Or something.

Edited

Women are campaigning to simply keep their existing spaces. Trans people can campaign to have their own “mixed” or whatever they want spaces.

CliantheLang · 27/10/2023 00:58

Skyisbluegrassisgreen · 26/10/2023 22:43

Are you daft. The problem isn’t genuinely trans people living their lives but the perverts exploiting these rules for their own gain. Not wanting to allow this is not transphobia.

What are "genuinely trans people"? No human has ever changed sex. So, there are no people who are "genuinely trans".

There are only men and women (no matter how they "identify") and men don't belong in women's spaces and sports. HTH

ladedahde · 27/10/2023 00:36

@SorryImAMan As far as I'm concerned its up to males if they want to accept trans men in their spaces. If trans people want a separate space they can use also fine. But women need female only single sex spaces which trans identified males are banned from entering.

Panastasia · 26/10/2023 22:45

lanthanum · 26/10/2023 21:23

So if someone presenting as female turns up at David Lloyd, are they supposed to demand proof that they are female and always have been? What proof would be accepted? Are you happy to provide that proof for yourself?

I don’t need proof. I would know a man at a 100 meters, in a dark alley, with the wind behind him. All this whataboutery, re “genital checks and proof and presenting” is ridiculous.

VeronicaSawyer89 · 26/10/2023 22:44

Elvis1956 · 26/10/2023 21:52

Right I'm a man and I am sure there are people originally made and female who feel they are both in the wrong body.
but you cannot,should not allow anyone to attend female dressing rooms unless they are fully post ops trans. Ditto post o p female to malry.
so David Lloyd at max loses what a max of 10000 potential members...I e pervs who claim to be women but aren't...

Nope, I don't care if a man makes himself an eunuch, he's still a man and shouldn't be in female spaces.

Skyisbluegrassisgreen · 26/10/2023 22:43

Are you daft. The problem isn’t genuinely trans people living their lives but the perverts exploiting these rules for their own gain. Not wanting to allow this is not transphobia.

SinnerBoy · 26/10/2023 22:39

TeaGinandFags · Today 20:55

Sex segregated spaces such as changing rooms and toilets are protected by law. A law David Lloyd are breaking.

Unfortunately, it's a bit more complicated than that. If a club wants to enforce a women only rule, then the law is on there side if a transw enters and tries to insist that they are entitled to be there.

On the other hand, if a club has a policy that transw are allowed to use the female facilities, then the law supports that, too.

Any organisation has to have the will to use a policy, which excludes transw from female spaces; the law needs to be changed, as I'm sure you'll agree!

SorryImAMan · 26/10/2023 22:35

Really it’s not that easy to tell.

I’m a trans man, I’ve been on testosterone 20 years.

I look like a man. I have a beard. Never tried hitting a woman. But I can open jars my wife can’t. I suspect I could assault a woman if wanted to.

Ive been using mens changing rooms since 2003 without getting a second look. I can run in the dark without feeling scared. If I looked female wouldn’t I have been assaulted by now?

if I walked into the women’s I think almond of you would feel uncomfortable.

I will never do that. Because I don’t want to make women feel uncomfortable. I would get changed at home, avoid drinking, give up exercise outside the home.

But non-passing trans people should use discretion.

Also, women have the right to feel safe. Make your own spaces. Not my business.

But don’t force me into your spaces. Can’t you campaign for women’s only and ‘mixed’? Or something.

sanluca · 26/10/2023 22:28

Where is that thread where the transrights activist said that 100 women and girls assaulted per year as a result of transwomen being allowed to use the womens toilets and changing rooms was an acceptable number? Only if it as more than 100 year upon year would they feel the policy might have to be revisited.

Darnley · 26/10/2023 22:25

Rubbish….you are a handmaid to the vicious thuggery of mens rights activists and should be utterly ashamed of yourself. but I know you won’t be. Nowhere near enough intelligence for that.

HermioneWeasley · 26/10/2023 22:25

@Mummy08m ive said upthread that I’m not the correspondent. I saw this in social media today.

OP posts:
Darnley · 26/10/2023 22:22

You’re not really getting this are you ?

sanluca · 26/10/2023 22:22

GreyWednesday · 26/10/2023 21:02

@sanluca I can’t tell whether your last paragraph is made up of rhetorical questions or whether you’re disagreeing with me. If it’s the latter then I think you might have misunderstood me.

Rhetorical, was agreeing with you. Sorry, should have made that clear first.

Mummy08m · 26/10/2023 22:18

Drews · 26/10/2023 20:36

Have you had a more recent update since this one in March?

Good point, well spotted. Op why are you sharing this 7 months later, specifically...?

Inastatus · 26/10/2023 22:17

EvelynKatie · 26/10/2023 21:17

I do mind any biological man in the female changing room, no matter what gender identity they associate with.

@EvelynKatie - 100% agree

Farmageddon · 26/10/2023 22:16

Elvis1956 · 26/10/2023 21:52

Right I'm a man and I am sure there are people originally made and female who feel they are both in the wrong body.
but you cannot,should not allow anyone to attend female dressing rooms unless they are fully post ops trans. Ditto post o p female to malry.
so David Lloyd at max loses what a max of 10000 potential members...I e pervs who claim to be women but aren't...

Sorry, what? Fully OP trans, and how exactly are they going to check that??

Regardless of any surgery (which most TW don't actually have) men should not be in women's spaces full stop.

HermioneWeasley · 26/10/2023 22:16

Just to clarify, I’m not Emma, she has shared this online as part of an ongoing dispute with DL. I moved from Virgin Active (who have the same policy) to Bannatyne’s because of their stance on single sex spaces.

@SpoonGirl17 yelling “transphobia” doesn’t work here my dear. By all means debate us, but you’ll find well informed women with facts and evidence. Humans can’t change sex, trans identified males are no less of a risk to women and girls than other males and women are entitled to single sex spaces under the equality act. We are not human shields - if men’s spaces aren’t safe then by all means campaign for third spaces.

OP posts:
ladedahde · 26/10/2023 22:01

@Elvis1956 as a man your "opinion" on this isn't really needed and any male should not be using female single sex spaces trans identified or not, pre or post op because they are just that female single sex spaces and it is not possible to change sex, that is all there is to it. There are also cases of post op transwomen hanging about female single sex spaces trying to approach young under age teenage girls for nefarious reasons so no, its never ok.

Elvis1956 · 26/10/2023 21:52

Right I'm a man and I am sure there are people originally made and female who feel they are both in the wrong body.
but you cannot,should not allow anyone to attend female dressing rooms unless they are fully post ops trans. Ditto post o p female to malry.
so David Lloyd at max loses what a max of 10000 potential members...I e pervs who claim to be women but aren't...

SidewaysOtter · 26/10/2023 21:48

Of course there’s no issue with transwomen being in women-only spaces. What could possibly go wrong?

To think no, David Lloyd, this is not “taking all measures to protect..children”
Swipe left for the next trending thread