Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think no, David Lloyd, this is not “taking all measures to protect..children”

135 replies

HermioneWeasley · 26/10/2023 19:48

AIBU to think allowing adult males to accept spaces where women and girls are undressed is a clear safeguarding risk?

To think no, David Lloyd, this is not “taking all measures to protect..children”
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Froodwithatowel · 28/10/2023 13:34

DdraigGoch · 28/10/2023 13:03

On the contrary, I believe that they know exactly what they are talking about. The choice of words is a deliberate attempt at muddying the waters and gaslighting the OP into doubting that TWANW.

This.

It is an attempt to compel you into a world where you cannot refuse to pretend.

DdraigGoch · 28/10/2023 13:03

Frenchfancy · 26/10/2023 19:51

What do they mean by trans female? It's like they don't really know what they are talking about.

On the contrary, I believe that they know exactly what they are talking about. The choice of words is a deliberate attempt at muddying the waters and gaslighting the OP into doubting that TWANW.

nothingcomestonothing · 28/10/2023 12:14

Xenia · 28/10/2023 11:18

Very male language - you will care - a direct order. Most women don't want people with a penis in the female changing rooms. If it is been chopped off and someone has taken female hormones AND they have fully under English law changed gender then it is probably okay. If they are still fully equipped with male private parts however I think they might be better off using the disabled toilet

Even then, it's still a no.

Men who have cosmetic surgery/medication/ a bit of paper with a lie on are still men. Sarah Jane Baker being a good example.

They retain male patterns of offending (including using a object if a penis isn't available or functioning). They retain male physical strength and size, they can assault and intimidate women physically just as easily as any other men.

Their presence excludes some women, whose beliefs or needs don't differentiate between men with surgery/meds/bit of paper and men without.

There would be no practical way to enforce that as a rule, especially since you are not a allowed to ask to see a GRC, a GRC isn't proof of anything other than the ability to get the name changed on your gas bill, and politicians want to make them even easier to get. How would anyone woman in a changing room know if the man coming in has surgery/meds/GRC, or is a predator or a chancer? Or all three?

And most importantly, women say no. No men of any kind in women's spaces. Not if they have surgery, not if they change their name, not if they 'pass', not if really want to and will be sad if they're not allowed. No.

Xenia · 28/10/2023 11:18

Very male language - you will care - a direct order. Most women don't want people with a penis in the female changing rooms. If it is been chopped off and someone has taken female hormones AND they have fully under English law changed gender then it is probably okay. If they are still fully equipped with male private parts however I think they might be better off using the disabled toilet

Catsanfan · 28/10/2023 09:27

@SorryImAMan why are you on here threatening women? Be 'man' enough yo explain yourself

Froodwithatowel · 27/10/2023 17:49

if the law forces me into your changing room. Then believe me. You will care!!!"

Love, you're female. I really, really won't. You crack on.

GabriellaMontez · 27/10/2023 15:58

The response is disgusting. Vote with your feet.

YouSetTheTone · 27/10/2023 15:54

@SpoonGirl17 your comment was false. Transwomen are in fact ‘far, far’ more likely to be a perpetrator of sexual assault than be a victim. TW offend in line with their sex, and as 98% of sexual violence is perpetrated by men you can work out how this tracks, given that TW are biologically male.

The statistics of assault or murder of TW is vastly lower than that perpetrated against women. Vastly.

Stop expecting women to be gaslit into allowing men into their single sex spaces and campaign for third spaces for transgender people.

Naunet · 27/10/2023 14:53

SorryImAMan · 27/10/2023 11:54

Im trying to warn you. These rules are going to force trans men into the ladies, they have in the US.

Look. How do you know when you meet passing trans people?

Don’t you just assume they’re cis?

Ive passing doing this for 20 years. I know I pass.

I didn’t always pass, but people treat me differently when they clock me as trans.

They did that for a while. Now they don’t.

My wife knows I pass. People I trust to tell me know I pass.

My wife’s friends who are gender critical are open about it in front of her, and me. Without a hint of awkwardness.

I’ve travelled extensively in Saudi Arabia and the Indian subcontinent without harassment.

I’ve walked through dubious areas in the dark.

Ive even once accidentally gone into the ladies toilet, and the woman in there freaked out.

Most people who pass stay the hell away from a bunch of people with your opinions and aren’t out.

You don’t believe me.

But if the law forces me into your changing room. Then believe me. You will care!!!

🙄 then no one is going to be forcing you into the women’s if you pass so well, are they? You sound like you’re trying to threaten us into compliance by the way, did you mean to?

MrsOvertonsWindow · 27/10/2023 14:34

"Nasty fear mongering, threatening women for daring to have boundaries".

Indeed. It always comes down to threats. Women are not allowed views or discussions without someone coming along and threatening them - with physical violence, intimidation, verbal abuse (bigot & transphobe), being cancelled, disciplined, sacked and threats of sexual and physical violence:
"I'm trying to warn you But if the law forces me into your changing room. Then believe me. You will care!!!"
There's a never ending tsunami of threats made against women simply asking for something we've had since the Victorian times - single sex spaces when we're vulnerable and exposed. I know it's the only way an anti democratic belief can be forced on an unconsenting population - but it's wrong.

Stop threatening & bullying women - on here, online, outside conferences, wherever women meet and try to speak. Just stop.

nothingcomestonothing · 27/10/2023 12:58

SorryImAMan · 27/10/2023 11:54

Im trying to warn you. These rules are going to force trans men into the ladies, they have in the US.

Look. How do you know when you meet passing trans people?

Don’t you just assume they’re cis?

Ive passing doing this for 20 years. I know I pass.

I didn’t always pass, but people treat me differently when they clock me as trans.

They did that for a while. Now they don’t.

My wife knows I pass. People I trust to tell me know I pass.

My wife’s friends who are gender critical are open about it in front of her, and me. Without a hint of awkwardness.

I’ve travelled extensively in Saudi Arabia and the Indian subcontinent without harassment.

I’ve walked through dubious areas in the dark.

Ive even once accidentally gone into the ladies toilet, and the woman in there freaked out.

Most people who pass stay the hell away from a bunch of people with your opinions and aren’t out.

You don’t believe me.

But if the law forces me into your changing room. Then believe me. You will care!!!

I'm trying to warn you
But if the law forces me into your changing room. Then believe me. You will care!!!

Frood had it bang on upthread: This is one of those disingenuous 'if you don't shut up and deal with a naked penis next to you from someone with long hair, you'll have to deal with me with a moustache and then you'll be sorry' really rather mean and nasty coercion lines. You change wherever you want, I really don't care.

Nasty fear mongering, threatening women for daring to have boundaries. Please provide receipts for the times that transmen have been forced in to the ladies, as you claim, in the US or anywhere else.

If you pass so well that people who've known you for years don't know you're trans, how will you be forced into women's spaces exactly? Or are we at the 'there will be genital inspections' portion of the discussion now?

Nanny0gg · 27/10/2023 12:33

SpoonGirl17 · 26/10/2023 20:34

Maybe take your transphobia somewhere else if it bothers you that much. If a cis man wants to hurt you or your DD they will. Also you are statistically most at risk from the men who are already in your life.
Trans women are not the enemy. Dangerous men are. Trans women are far far more likely to be attacked than to attack and that is what will happen if we exclude them from safe female spaces. Stop swallowing the disgusting lies being peddled by right wing bigots pretending to care about women and our safety suddenly
Also what exactly is your solution? A genitals check? What about trans men? They might have the “right” genitals but I think their big burley beards and muscles may raise some eyebrows.

There are so many unisex changing spaces out there that are used daily with no issues. Focus on something actually important.

How do you know which man is dangerous?

You don't, so keep ALL men out of women's spaces.

And to a lot of women, this is VERY important

SorryImAMan · 27/10/2023 11:54

Im trying to warn you. These rules are going to force trans men into the ladies, they have in the US.

Look. How do you know when you meet passing trans people?

Don’t you just assume they’re cis?

Ive passing doing this for 20 years. I know I pass.

I didn’t always pass, but people treat me differently when they clock me as trans.

They did that for a while. Now they don’t.

My wife knows I pass. People I trust to tell me know I pass.

My wife’s friends who are gender critical are open about it in front of her, and me. Without a hint of awkwardness.

I’ve travelled extensively in Saudi Arabia and the Indian subcontinent without harassment.

I’ve walked through dubious areas in the dark.

Ive even once accidentally gone into the ladies toilet, and the woman in there freaked out.

Most people who pass stay the hell away from a bunch of people with your opinions and aren’t out.

You don’t believe me.

But if the law forces me into your changing room. Then believe me. You will care!!!

Fairtobefairohhhhhc · 27/10/2023 10:48

Vote with your feet

nothingcomestonothing · 27/10/2023 10:42

SorryImAMan · 27/10/2023 09:18

Ps. By us. I mean trans men. (Who you call trans identified women).

What’s happened elsewhere is that when trans women are banned from the women’s, then trans men are forced in.

I don’t really care about trans women,
btw.

If I thought you were NPCs I’d just go
to the ladies and shrug and say ‘law says I can’
Because it smells better and I may get to look at naked ladies.
Im not going to do that because I have some sense of empathy.

Because I don’t want women to feel uncomfortable. And because I like my cis-male privilege

Bollocks. Noone is forcing you anywhere. Change in the men's if you want, that's between you and the men. Or the unisex, if there is one.

PS you don't have 'cis-male privilege', you're not a cis (sic) male. Extremely few trans people pass at all, even fewer pass consistently. Humans are very good at accurately sexing each other. People not telling you you don't pass, isn't the same as you passing

To think no, David Lloyd, this is not “taking all measures to protect..children”
Eventingmum · 27/10/2023 10:27

That's shocking. It's going too far now. Women are getting marginalised and we need to stand up for our rights.

HermioneWeasley · 27/10/2023 10:09

@Eventingmum not as far as I’m aware

OP posts:
Eventingmum · 27/10/2023 09:57

The letter is dated the 1st March. Has anything changed since this date?

Naunet · 27/10/2023 09:49

SorryImAMan · 27/10/2023 09:12

That’s the problem. Some of the campaigning is forcing people who look like men into your spaces.

You are all in denial we exist. You say you can always tell. But the only way you can tell for most of us is to see our genitalia.

Just because you are ok with us in women’s changing rooms doesn’t mean all women are.

Theres no damn way I’m going to make women feel uncomfortable.

But if the law us going to make us sex offenders for going into the men’s, some of us will use your spaces. I may take my chances.

And then whenever someone who looks like a man goes to the ladies, they can say ‘I’m a trans man’. It will work.

What the hell are you talking about? I don’t give a shit if you use men’s spaces, you’re not a threat to them, your conversation as to if you should use those spaces should be with men, it’s irrelevant to the conversation of men using women’s spaces.

itsmyp4rty · 27/10/2023 09:34

This is the difference @SorryImAMan between you and transwomen who often unfortunately couldn't care less who they make feel uncomfortable as long as they are getting their affirmation.

'I will never do that. Because I don’t want to make women feel uncomfortable. I would get changed at home, avoid drinking, give up exercise outside the home.'

'Im not going to do that because I have some sense of empathy.'

The other difference of course is that as a biological woman you pose absolutely no threat to the men you change with.

itsmyp4rty · 27/10/2023 09:30

SpoonGirl17 · 26/10/2023 20:34

Maybe take your transphobia somewhere else if it bothers you that much. If a cis man wants to hurt you or your DD they will. Also you are statistically most at risk from the men who are already in your life.
Trans women are not the enemy. Dangerous men are. Trans women are far far more likely to be attacked than to attack and that is what will happen if we exclude them from safe female spaces. Stop swallowing the disgusting lies being peddled by right wing bigots pretending to care about women and our safety suddenly
Also what exactly is your solution? A genitals check? What about trans men? They might have the “right” genitals but I think their big burley beards and muscles may raise some eyebrows.

There are so many unisex changing spaces out there that are used daily with no issues. Focus on something actually important.

Then transwomen need to be using all those unisex changing spaces that are out there.

Inastatus · 27/10/2023 09:28

@HermioneWeasley - thanks for posting about this. I have contacted my local DL and will encourage my friends to do the same. My 19 year old DD is also a member and I am very concerned.

SorryImAMan · 27/10/2023 09:18

Ps. By us. I mean trans men. (Who you call trans identified women).

What’s happened elsewhere is that when trans women are banned from the women’s, then trans men are forced in.

I don’t really care about trans women,
btw.

If I thought you were NPCs I’d just go
to the ladies and shrug and say ‘law says I can’
Because it smells better and I may get to look at naked ladies.
Im not going to do that because I have some sense of empathy.

Because I don’t want women to feel uncomfortable. And because I like my cis-male privilege

TheGoogleMum · 27/10/2023 09:16

This is why we need 3rd spaces, I can see why a trans woman wouldn't want to change in the men's but I can also see why women wouldn't want to change with someone with a male body! I know it isn't what they want though.

Froodwithatowel · 27/10/2023 09:14

Disingenuous bollocks.

No one cares whether female people go into the mens room or not because baldly, you are not a sexual or violent threat. The men might be embarrassed, but what goes on in mens spaces is up to them.

This is about men, of any identity, in a female only space.

Mens needs can be met without harming women. And all this wittering is not about anyone's safety, it's all about leveraging the right of men to be with non consenting women in a state of undress. It's bloody VILE behaviour.