Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DIL left nasty drunk messages on my phone.

330 replies

zarasmyworld · 26/10/2023 16:34

I woke up on Sunday morning to a voicemail from my son's wife saying I was manipulative and a narcissist and my husband was a mug for putting up with me, that I'm a terrible mother and grandma and lots of other upsetting things.
I have been very upset understandably about this and have asked DIL to explain but she says she doesn't remember saying it and didn't mean it.

Ds says as she was drunk and as she doesn't remember to just forget about it.
I haven't even had an apology in nearly a week and Ds doesn't even seem bothered that she's been so unkind.
AIBU to think I'm owed some sort of apology or explanation and ds shouldn't let her speak to me like this?
I shouldn't be expected to just carry on as if it didn't happen should I?
I have told DS how hurt I am but still no apology.

OP posts:
poppettypop · 27/10/2023 20:52

MummyPencil · 27/10/2023 20:19

Sometimes kids maintain very artificial relationship with mum/dad for any reason.

Mu husband’s reason is inheritance

How do you know your son disagrees with his wife??

That's horrible and lacks so much integrity. I would hate to think this of my children!

Kgiggl3s · 27/10/2023 20:48

My MIL is manipulative etc. My husband (her son) and I are always shocked and offended by her but don't bother pulling her up anymore for various reasons, the top reason being we can't be bothered with the drama and dont see her enough to bother. Anyway she has absolutely no idea we feel this way about her - she comes over for dinner, we host, we smile etc but when she leaves we breathe a sigh of relief. She has absolutely no idea we feel this way because we rarely confront her and choose the easy life instead.

Anyway my point being could this be a similar scenario. Do ds and dil tolerate your usual behavior but when drunk it had all come out?? I hope not but it is possible. Either way leaving that message was super nasty.

Widower2014 · 27/10/2023 20:37

No, get a male friend to leave her a message

Vicncrew · 27/10/2023 20:37

I totally agree with this. I would go around to their house when both your son and dil are together and say you want to sort this out. Then you can replay the message that she left and watch their faces and see what comes out if thus. Being face to face is so much better then there's no escaping thus or making pitiful excuses via messages

LaDamaDeElche · 27/10/2023 20:30

I think if someone genuinely didn't remember and were told they had said vile things, they would apologise profusely. Certainly not think denying recalling it would suffice. Completely agree that they should. Sometimes people are just mortified though. Tbh I was more addressing the posters who were saying that OP must have done something, or that the DIL must really mean it. The DIL has behaved terribly by not sorting this out. The fact her son is also sweeping it under the carpet is a bit odd. Maybe they had a massive drunken row and he said some stuff about OP not liking her or whatever and she left the message. Who knows?

ClareBlue · 27/10/2023 20:28

If you think it is on your son to tell her what she can and can not say then maybe she is sick of it. What expectation do you have of your son's actions to stop her saying things.

ChristmasCrumpet · 27/10/2023 20:26

FrippEnos · 27/10/2023 18:25

Maybe there is more to the story than the OP is putting forward.

This could also be the case. But I always take the OP at face value, you can't really advise otherwise.

One of two things has happened here. OP is indeed everything DIL called her out on. And either unaware, or knows perfectly well.

Or, OP is baffled as to where this has come from, and given the comments about how she makes a mug of son/husband it suggests he has been telling his wife nasty things about OP. It also explains his urgency that OP says nothing to DIL.

Someone once told me that a lot of their issues were down to their mother abandoning them, and putting them in care. They gained my empathy, sympathy, support. I met the mother, and had such low opinion. The character in my mind had been formed. Later, I spoke of the time in care, she was horrified at the story. I then spoke about other horrible things I had been informed she had done. All untrue. And neither of us would have been the wiser until I broached the subject.

Perhaps it's because I see such similarities that I'm pretty sure it's the son.

ClareBlue · 27/10/2023 20:25

Maybe be the bit where you say your son shouldn't let her speak to you like this, is a clue.

Grammarnut · 27/10/2023 20:23

NotSuchASmugMarried · 26/10/2023 16:36

Have some fun with it. Leave a message on her phone saying she's an unfaithful slag and a tart and then, when confronted, say you were drunk and can't remember doing it.😂

Well fine, if you never want to speak to your DS again. Otherwise don't do that. If she was drunk and forgets I would let it go with her but think about what she said and ask myself if she had any justification for saying this.

babybeets · 27/10/2023 20:23

Oh, absolutely this.

TellingBone · 27/10/2023 20:21

JaneyGee · 26/10/2023 17:26

Exactly. People reveal what they really think when they're drunk. In fact, they're much more honest than when sober.

I recall reading in Billy Connolly's autobiography that he said that when drunk he had, '...told people I love that I hate them and told people I hate that I love them'.

I have two theories:

1: They were having an argument and your son did it on her phone to bring trouble to her door

2: They were having an argument and she did it to bring trouble to his door

billy1966 · 27/10/2023 20:21

LaDamaDeElche · 27/10/2023 20:10

I actually disagree that she means it. If she remembers nothing she's probably had a blackout. People say and do things completely out of character during a blackout. Things can literally come out of nowhere that people don't mean or think, certainly not consciously.

I think if someone genuinely didn't remember and were told they had said vile things, they would apologise profusely.

Certainly not think denying recalling it would suffice.

Mittleme · 27/10/2023 20:20

ive never been drunk because i dont drink and probably cant tell what influence people are under when they are drunk .
i think you definitely need an apology from her if she says she cant remember saying these things and you forgive but my question is was she drunk enough to be able to select her mother in laws phone number out of all numbers on her phone ?

agonyau · 27/10/2023 20:19

NotSuchASmugMarried · 26/10/2023 16:36

Have some fun with it. Leave a message on her phone saying she's an unfaithful slag and a tart and then, when confronted, say you were drunk and can't remember doing it.😂

I was about to suggest the same! Give her a taste of her own medicine then smile sweetly when, possibly, challenged by her or Ds & claim you “cant remember saying that, must be a reaction to some medication you had to take.. “ 😂

In all seriousness, I’m shocked you haven’t received an apology regardless of whether she was drunk or not, and your DS should be pushing for an apology from her or at very least apologising on her behalf (though it’s not the same). It would be good all round to get to bottom of her outburst though, coz family fallouts have far reaching, long term negative implications. Good luck 🍀

MummyPencil · 27/10/2023 20:19

ChristmasCrumpet · 27/10/2023 15:57

Well apparently the son is a "mug" for putting up with her.

So where do you think this has likely come from.

DIL isn't cross at MIL about their relationship. She's cross about the portrayed relationship between MIL and son.

Sometimes kids maintain very artificial relationship with mum/dad for any reason.

Mu husband’s reason is inheritance

How do you know your son disagrees with his wife??

bemusedmoose · 27/10/2023 20:16

Alcohol loosens the lips - im an extremely honest drunk so have to be careful because all that tongue biting i do eventually will be spewed out. People dont just go on one of these drunken tirades without some background to it. The fact your son doesnt think she should apologise also reflects he is thinking there's truth in what she said.

So either there is some back story to this and she has had enough or she is a complete bitch.

Yes an apology for the drunken outburst would be nice, if she doesnt remember (maybe play the message back to her) or if she does remember. Because even if it's true she was rude.

Trouble is if she is right and you are a narcissist then you wont see fault in what you do or admit you might have upset them to cause this. So talking it through will achieve nothing.

However if she is wrong and you arent then you would want to clear the air and find out why this was said - alcohol doesnt invent historical events, it unleashes them so something has happened somewhere.

I married a narcissist so i know full well how difficult a situation it is. I also had him call me a narcissist because he was trying to cover up the abuse and blacklisted me with everyone we knew to hide it.

So maybe you all need to think about what you want from this going forward do you want to repair the family or cut them out? Can you move on after this or is it a game changer? Because if you want to continue a relationship then you need the truth from them, warts and all and then you need to not hold it over them - clear the air and close the book. If needed make changes. Dont go dragging it up over and over. If you cant do that then you have to sever all ties.

MummyPencil · 27/10/2023 20:16

Yes my husband has very pretentious relationship with his mother and it certainly put unnecessary stress on our marriage.

Sadly we don’t know the FULL story.

LaDamaDeElche · 27/10/2023 20:10

I actually disagree that she means it. If she remembers nothing she's probably had a blackout. People say and do things completely out of character during a blackout. Things can literally come out of nowhere that people don't mean or think, certainly not consciously.

Josell12345 · 27/10/2023 20:09

The same would apply the other way round. I dont think it means people control each other just that he should defend his own parents from an onslaught from his wife.

Londongirlx · 27/10/2023 20:00

I'd be furious that it was said and furious there was no apology

Nopenopenopenopenopenope · 27/10/2023 19:57

That smells like a drinking problem to me.

howdoesyourgardengrowinmay · 27/10/2023 19:56

NotLactoseFree · 26/10/2023 17:30

Also, I just want to add two things:

  1. Narcissist people often live to do the DARVO thing and accuse everyone else of narcissism. So I have to wonder about your DIL here.
  2. exBIL is, I am 95% sure (albeit this is an armchair diagnosis) a covert narcissist. One of the things he has done for years but that his various victims or other members of the family seem to accept is send extraordinarily vile, unpleasant and aggressive messages to people and then expect everyone to just carry on as normal after. Obviously, the main person who gets this is SIL but he's done it to all of us. DH's family all think I'm a bit "precious" because I have said that those messages to me were the last straw and I will have nothing to do with him. SIL seemed quite surprised by my horrified reaction to reading a stream of abuse from him followed by, 12 hours later, a warm, friendly, loving message.

So I would be asking you if you've ever had any concerns about your DS's relationship?

No idea if that's narcissist behaviour but your bil sounds like a Jekyll and Hyde fruit loop. I don't blame you for keeping a distance.

We have someone like that, he's very weird and not normal. I keep a civil distance and pointedly ignore his bizarre outbursts. I wouldn't choose to have anything to do with him, but he's there so I just politely blank him 🙂 he hates that cos he loves getting a reaction.

Buffs · 27/10/2023 19:55

What will an apology/explanation get you? Is there a backstory?

Fusterclucked · 27/10/2023 19:44

I just panic checked my outgoing calls to make sure this post isn’t about me!

billy1966 · 27/10/2023 19:42

Crafthead · 27/10/2023 19:28

They're laughing because it's inappropriate. That's why it's funny.

Absolutely this.

Levity!

Of course it wasn't meant seriously.