Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brother at Wedding Dress shop

87 replies

LeclercBeans · 26/10/2023 15:54

Note: Names have been changed for their privacy.

I am going wedding dress shopping with my little cousin (Maddie, 21F) as she and her fiancee (Tom) have been together since age 15/16. Maddie wants to bring her 2 brothers - Charles (32M) and Max (35M) wedding dress shopping as well as her grandmother and me. The only problem is grandma says no to the brothers and she's paying!

Backstory, they are full siblings and their mother basically 'gave them up' when Maddie was 6 months as her husband (their father/my brother) died a month before her birth (RTC) and she started drinking/drugs etc and couldn't care for them as so overwhelmed with 2 boys, a new born and grieving.

As the oldest was only 14ish they moved in with their grandparents (their mums mum, not mine) majority of the time and they lived on and off with me/my parents.

The three of them are very close. Maddie moved in with Max full time in 2011 when she was 9 and Max was 23 as he had a very good job and had a house etc. and they where so close. Charles also moved in in 2010 during the holidays for uni and stayed until he was around 24. Maddie still lives there when she's not at uni.

I'm just saying this so you can see how close they are! So Maddie wants her 2 brothers (and me and her grandmother) to come to the wedding dress shop with her, but her grandma said men don't normally come and it should be just us 3 females.

Maddie is devastated as she wants her brothers to help pick out the dress. I feel I can't really say anything as I'm not related to her grandma (other side of family) and her grandma is contributing quite a large sum to the wedding. Their grandma is very temperamental and stuck in her ways and she has threatened multiple times to not contribute anything to the wedding unless Maddie does this/that etc. Only problem is grandma pushed the location on them and its v expensive and they've put a deposit down so would loose lots of money they can't afford! (Again I know how privileged she is to have someone contributing a big sum!)

Is it normal for men/fathers to come dress shopping (it will just be us in the shop - no other families)? Should I push it more with grandma to let them come? Or tell Maddie to drop it? I just feel with her wedding, she should choose!
I don't know what to do as I don't want to annoy anyone!

OP posts:
Autiebibliophile · 27/10/2023 03:54

I'd go with you and brothers to choose the dress. Then return at a later date to'chose' the dress with grandma

Thepossibility · 27/10/2023 02:25

I went dress shopping with my Nan, mum and bridesmaids. It was awful and stressful with all the negative opinions. Nan was the worst. Everyone liking different things and hating others opinions with a passion. Very disheartening.

I ended up randomly going to see a dress I saw in a magazine with my brothers. They were so complimentary and lovely, it was a much nicer experience. I bought the dress with no regrets.
Although on my wedding day Nan said the dresses she chose for me were nicer Hmm

The gran is a fucking bitch, using what should be a lovely day as a power trip. Why should she get her way?

2jacqi · 27/10/2023 01:48

so really Max brought her up from the age of 9? of course he should be there if she wants him there. granny needs to get a life and stop dictating to maddie just how her wedding is going to be!

Catsmere · 27/10/2023 01:43

My first thought is whether there will be other women there choosing dresses. They wouldn't be likely to want men in the shop.

Gymnopedie · 27/10/2023 00:21

Also it's only dress shopping, I cannot imagine those boys want to be there in any way shape or form!

Can't you whatsapp pictures to the brothers so they can contribute without having to hang around through interminable changes of clothes?

Maybe they really want to be there? (a) because they love Maddie and (b) because they want to protect Maddie from her grandmother.

custardcream3 · 26/10/2023 22:43

Zebedee55 Because they are men who are equally involved and invested in their daughters. My husband and I just went to our daughters second fitting. He's her dad, he's bought her clothes from when she was born, he's bathed her, read bedtime stories, fed her, had days out, done homework, taken the call when her boyfriend finished with her, you get the point. We are equal parents, he didn't give an opinion on each dress other than to say she looked beautiful in each one because he knew his opinion on the dress was irrelevant but he's still a parent and was very welcome!

BrimfulOfMash · 26/10/2023 19:00

Who cares what is ‘usual’ or what anyone else does?

She wants her brothers.

Who fulfilled many of the roles of a mother in the absence of grandmother’s daughter!!!

Whoever is most likely to make the grandmother see sense should talk to her.

If she won’t budge I think your niece could write her a letter saying how very important it is to her, so with huge thanks for setting up the shop visit, she would like to make her own arrangement and invite who she likes. Including grandmother if she would like to come.

meganorks · 26/10/2023 18:52

I'm overly invested in 'say yes to the dress' and the 'no foxes in the hen house' is usually about the fiance. While it is more usual just to have female friends and family, there are quite often dads/brothers/gay best friends etc.

She should be able to do what she wants for her wedding. It sounds like grandma is enjoying the power play and is going to make the wedding what she wants. Probably best to cut her losses now

Ladyaelic · 26/10/2023 18:47

Let me guess, granny didn't get the wedding of HER dreams so she's determined granddaughter IS going to get the wedding granny would have liked... And granny also thinks love can be bought. Personally I'd be telling her where to stick her filthy lucre though I'm not sure I'd have been able to at 21...

Doormatnomore · 26/10/2023 18:43

I lost my dad young, bur older than Maddie and still had my mum. But those stage of life things still have a gaping hole. Maybe wedding dress shopping isn’t important or special to everyone but maybe maddie just wants her brothers as involved as possible because neither her mum or dad will be there.

my dh and brother in law (other side) would love hours in a dress shop and presumably Maddie knows her brothers!

id be telling granny to shove it and either they come or she’ll buy a dress off the internet and tell everyone. If granny is so worried about “appearances” that’ll focus the mind.

PabloandGustheGreySquirrels · 26/10/2023 18:40

The Grandma is sexist but....she's paying! Also it's only dress shopping, I cannot imagine those boys want to be there in any way shape or form! I wouldn't want my brother with me, that would creep me out.
Boundaries!!! Healthy boundaries

nzborn · 26/10/2023 18:36

I think it's lovely she wants her brother's there

elliejjtiny · 26/10/2023 18:19

Love the image of the f1 drivers going wedding dress shopping! Maddie should have who she wants there, I had my brother with me. Also 21 is a perfectly normal age to get married. I was 22 but wanted to get married at 20. Dh and I have been together 22 years and married 19.

Is she planning on doing more than one trip? I went to loads of different dress shops before I found my dress and took different people each time.

Iwant2beJessicaFletcher · 26/10/2023 18:01

It's up to Maddie who she wants and I can see why she wants her brothers there. If it was me, I would go with my brothers secretly, choose my dress with them and then re-visit with you and her grandmother & pretend that it was the first time she had been. Im sure if she explained to the dress shop they would go along with it.

That way she gets what she wants (which is not unreasonable) and the completely unreasonable grandmother thinks she's 'won' and still contributes to the wedding.

If Maddie was a lot older and settled down, had a good job etc, I would just say to stuff the grandmothers money but right now she wont be able to afford this and I think after her difficult start in life she deserves to have the wedding experience she wants.

Good luck

PrinnyPree · 26/10/2023 17:52

TempName247 · 26/10/2023 16:48

Go in secret with Maddie and her brothers without Gran, then go again with Gran so she can pay for the dress. To be honest though I think 21 is too young to be getting married 😬.

This is what I was going to suggest, let her have the illusion of control.

However if she wants to get married at 21 that's up to her, she's not a teenager.

Lizzieregina · 26/10/2023 17:48

Goodornot · 26/10/2023 17:12

5 people to shop for a wedding dress? That's too many. Imagine if every bride brought 4 people with her.

Its the norm here in the US! DD recently married, only wanted 3, but an entourage would be the norm. We were the smallest group in the shop!

BrideToBe2313123 · 26/10/2023 17:43

Toddlerteaplease · 26/10/2023 17:42

Will the shop allow that many spectators?

That too!
When I checked them out them out quite a few had maximum of 2 other people.

Toddlerteaplease · 26/10/2023 17:42

Will the shop allow that many spectators?

BrideToBe2313123 · 26/10/2023 17:41

Do any of you realise how long wedding dress shopping will take? Of course, it depends on how fussy the involved parties are, but still.
You don't just go to 'one shop', try on a few dresses and get out ASAP.

As much as they love Maddie I highly doubt that the brothers want to spend hours in a shop.

This isn't a 'big moment'. there will be multiple trips, she needs time and space to work out what she likes without the opinion of an entourage.

grandma is being U, but so are the rest of you for bigging this trip up. She might leave at the end with no wedding dress at all!

Far better for her and one other person to try loads on, then bring whoever for the final few.

The reason it takes a long time is because most women aren't used to such formal dresses.. the way it sits, feel etc you can't tell until you've tried the dresses on.

crosstalk · 26/10/2023 17:39

Two trips. And not just to one shop. Maddie also still needs to work out what to say if Granny doesn't like what she and the lads have picked out. I really don't see why men can't go shopping for The Dress with the bride. Presumably they have taste so she won't be going masses of cleavage, thigh high splits. But I'm also of the opinion that Granny shouldn't be paying if she's going to pull strings this way and waiting till M and T can afford their own wedding .. perhaps with help from the close brothers ... might give them a fighting chance of doing what they want.

LeclercBeans · 26/10/2023 17:35

Love your guys' idea of going twice. Think I will suggest it and clue in the staff like someone said so everyones on board!

I think the fact that her gran looked after her when she was little at times makes her gran think she 'owes her something' !

Never was a fan of the lady but you guys have just confirmed it for me haha

OP posts:
abouttobecomeagrandparent · 26/10/2023 17:35

Let Maddie go with her brothers first and narrow it down to a couple of dresses and then let her go again with Gran.

AliceOlive · 26/10/2023 17:21

Two trips - first with the brothers and later with Gran.

KyeeMaClune · 26/10/2023 17:19

Well Dh came dress shopping along with my Mum. I chose a dress I absolutely loved he made a comment on not liking a certain aspect of it so imagine that response when I saw him at the altar. That was almost 25 years ago. I chose a dress we both liked.

If granny won't budge then I would encourage her to shop without granny and bring whoever she wants and then do a fake dress shop with granny "finding" the dress.

Bristolnewcomer · 26/10/2023 17:16

I would get Maddie to tell her gran that if her dad were alive she'd be taking him - as he isn't she'd like her brothers to be there. It might not be traditional but it's an emotional time and she really wants them to come in her father's place.

If Gran doesn't say yes then she really isn't very nice! (I suspect that she just doesn't understand WHY Maddie wants them there)

Swipe left for the next trending thread