Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To cut off friend of nearly 30 years?

184 replies

Seakayaker100 · 26/10/2023 13:31

Name changed as very outing.
I have a very good friend, been with me through lots of life's milestones, always there when I've needed her. Now I feel like the worst friend as I can't be there for her right now. Her ex has been arrested and remanded out of the blue, and turns out he has been caught in an undercover online sting and arrested when arriving at a house to carry out child sex abuse that had been planned online with an undercover police officer. She's in pieces and is verging on suicidal, but wants to stand by him. Has visited him on remand, is listening to his excuses and even justifying that there wasn't a victim so not that bad. I've said no, I can't support her in this, and that despite not being convicted yet, I want no part in anything or anyone involved with him. When they were dating, she brought him to my house and to watch my son in a school event. She seems confused why that is upsetting me. I feel guilty to desert her when she's suicidal, but I can't play any part in this. (She has other MH services involved).
Please tell me I'm not being unreasonable, or if you think I am, explain why? His shitty choices have ruined a great friendship, but I'm more upset about how poor her boundaries are with this. This is no doubt due to her mental health, but I can't see a way to support her that doesn't involve listening to her making excuses and down playing what he's done.

OP posts:
Haffiana · 26/10/2023 15:46

Why is she standing by and visiting an ex anyway?

ManateeFair · 26/10/2023 15:46

VWdieselnightmare · 26/10/2023 15:31

How close are you? Just wondering if, over 30 years, you've only met the husband a handful of times.

You're making this all about you and not about her, OP. Which is okay if you're happy with that but not it you really are such good friends that you've supported each other through previous difficult experiences. This has to be about as difficult as it gets and a 'friend' who insists 'I'm right, you're wrong' at a time when you're suicidal doesn't strike me as much of a friend.

IIWY I'd give it some time to let her process things more completely. She's in shock and desperately trying to find a way to make everything feel better and normal. I'd see her on her own, probably in cafes or wherever, and I'd say that I was struggling with the idea of being friends with a woman who was excusing her husband's sexual abuse. But I wouldn't behave just like all the other righteously indignant judgy folk all anxious to point fingers. I'd like to think I was better than that.

I absolutely hate it when I see people looking for ways to blame women for things men do.

Read the OP's other comments in the thread.

The man is not her friend's husband or even her boyfriend. He is an ex - they didn't even live together even when they were a couple. He's literally just a bloke she dated for a while. They have no ties to one another.

This isn't a situation where a woman's life has been turned upside-down by an accusation against the husband or partner she shares her whole life with. It's a situation where a man someone used to date was caught in the act of planning and trying to attend the rape of a child, and his ex-girlfriend has inexplicably decided that this is the time to rekindle her previous relationship with him. Very different.

BalletBob · 26/10/2023 15:45

Wheredidyougonow · 26/10/2023 14:48

Oh boo. Please don't excuse her. She's standing by a paedo- what is there to be confused or wringing her hands about. She's actually entertaining the idea that he is a victim??

So if the police told you today that one of your dearest loved ones had been arrested for sex offenses against children, you would just instantly be able to compute that information? Your brain would just immediately accept that this person you love - possibly have loved for decades - is in not the person you have known all this time, but is in fact a monster of the worst kind? And you didn't spot it.

I think with a bit of emotional intelligence it's not really difficult to see why women sometimes find it exceptionally difficult and traumatic to accept the reality in these situations and why there may be a period of denial or minimisation, hopefully before they are able to accept what has happened and deal with it appropriately. I don't think that vilifying women who are still reeling from the discovery that their husband/son/partner etc is a pedophile is at all helpful. It's just misogyny, basically. Blaming women for men's crimes. I mean, there are people on here saying that these women are "on the same level" as the men who actually rape children.

Whathappened123 · 26/10/2023 15:43

I would give her time to come to terms with it. You don't need to condone what he did by supporting her. Having been in a similar situation (though he didn't arrange to meet, just communication, which was bad enough), but we were still married, she is probably still in shock. And also, these things aren't as black and white as people like to think. There is a lovely community of parents/partners/children of offenders who support each other, and I hope she's been given their information. It's an incredibly lonely and confusing time.

NotLactoseFree · 26/10/2023 15:42

I think I' actually have more sympathy if he was her current partner. But he is an ex, and one assumes therefore she's full aware he's not perfect. It's hard to understand why she is sticking by him then. And certainly suggests a very disordered relationship.

@LookingForPurpose what you and your family are going through sounds truly awful and I am so sorry you have had to face it. It does sound like you have not really had the support you need and that while your son's behaviour was clearly not acceptable, he has been scapegoated. I hope that you all find a way through this in due course. Unmumsnetty hugs and even some xxx

Memyselfandtheothers · 26/10/2023 15:41

I’ve said YABU but hear me out. I’m talking here as someone who was sexually abused as a child and the impact of this has completely blown my life apart.

At this stage, she will be in shock and denial. This is huge for her. The man she loved and was married to is a monster and her whole marriage was lie. This is a lot for someone to digest and her brain will be trying in all sorts of ways to deal with this, including denial, trying to minimise it. I don’t think I could completely process being married to such a monsterous man in a short space of time. She will need time and support to come to terms with it. I hope the MH services she’s engaging with are able to support her long term with this. This is traumatic for her and is on top of other MH issues. I would guess that at this point, she does not have capacity to process the significance of what her husband has done and the impact he could have had on a child’s life…or may has already had, depending on what comes out of the investigations.

However, you are absolutely right not to go along with her minimising it and making excuses. She needs firmness and consistency and the message to be reinforced that what he has done is serious and that she cannot stand by what he has done. I understand if you don’t feel you can do this. And it isn’t your responsibility. But if you could support her while firmly standing your ground and maintaining your own boundaries and well being, then having your support could help her with this. It’s a difficult line. You definitely don’t have to support her but is there a way you could be in the background while she tries to work some of this stuff out. It may just take her a while to see the situation for what it really is.

if she never changes her view then I don’t know where you go…and what is the time frame in such a thing…I don’t know.

but my guess is she doesn’t condone what he’s done…it’s just way too horrific for her to process.

Unicorntastic · 26/10/2023 15:39

YANBU OP, is he really an ex? You could never fully trust her again if she is in anyway involved with him, that’s the only way to protect your children.

ManateeFair · 26/10/2023 15:37

Also, remember the victims of Nick, Edward Heath, Cliff Richards some senior military officers and politicians. For 12 months their friends left them saying and thinking exactly as you are. They were innocent.

Are you mad? FFS, none of those people were caught by undercover police officers making arrangements with other paedophiles to meet up at a house to abuse children. None of them were even arrested, as far I'm aware, let alone charged with anything. Edward Heath died in 2005, long before anyone named him, and was therefore not left by his friends. In fact, I'm pretty sure none of those people were left by their friends, because their situation was one of the police simply looking into an accusation and finding zero evidence, not one of being caught in the act of plotting to rape a child, charged and remanded. It is NOT REMOTELY THE SAME.

Frankly, you sound as bad as the OP's bloody friend. Get a grip.

Heronwatcher · 26/10/2023 15:33

YANBU but I think in your position I might make it clear that I would try to support her, but not him if that’s possible? So try to keep the friendship going to an extent but make it clear that you can’t get involved in her decisions to remain with him, you can just help her with her own mental health (like recommending therapy etc). I say this because I think there’s a reasonable chance that after the initial shock she may well change her mind and it would be helpful to have the support to leave, rather than being completely isolated at that point.

Flyhigher · 26/10/2023 15:32

If she's suicidal she needs to look after herself first. Paedo ex's need to be banished.

ThereIbledit · 26/10/2023 15:31

Unpopular opinion but I think it takes great strength of character to see that rarely in life are things totally black and white, and to attempt to stay in touch with her, navigating this. Not everybody would be up for, or up to, that. But for a 30 year old friendship if you are up to and up for trying, I would. As others have said, it's very common for people to go through denial as they try to make a huge mental adjustment from the person they thought they knew to the person who they prove themselves to be.

It's okay if you don't feel up to this. It's okay if you do, but want to put some boundaries in place around what you will and won't discuss or sympathise with.

VWdieselnightmare · 26/10/2023 15:31

How close are you? Just wondering if, over 30 years, you've only met the husband a handful of times.

You're making this all about you and not about her, OP. Which is okay if you're happy with that but not it you really are such good friends that you've supported each other through previous difficult experiences. This has to be about as difficult as it gets and a 'friend' who insists 'I'm right, you're wrong' at a time when you're suicidal doesn't strike me as much of a friend.

IIWY I'd give it some time to let her process things more completely. She's in shock and desperately trying to find a way to make everything feel better and normal. I'd see her on her own, probably in cafes or wherever, and I'd say that I was struggling with the idea of being friends with a woman who was excusing her husband's sexual abuse. But I wouldn't behave just like all the other righteously indignant judgy folk all anxious to point fingers. I'd like to think I was better than that.

I absolutely hate it when I see people looking for ways to blame women for things men do.

ManateeFair · 26/10/2023 15:29

The people saying 'Nobody wants to believe that their partner is a paedophile' and 'There hasn't been a trial yet' are missing the point, I think.

The woman in this case isn't actually saying that she believes the man is innocent. She isn't denying that he went to a house after arranging to rape a child. She's making excuses for him and saying that, as it turned out there was no child there for him to rape, he hasn't done any harm. That's very different from believing that, eg, it was a case of mistaken identity or that it was all some kind of misunderstanding. Instead, she's acknowledging that he did have conversations online about his desire to abuse children, and also that he went to a house having made arrangements to do so - but she's 'making excuses' for him and saying he hasn't really done anything wrong because the arrangements turned out to be a trap.

Also, note that OP describes the man as her friend's EX, not her partner. She's making excuses for the horrific criminal behaviour of a man she isn't even together with.

OP, I'd walk away from her. She sounds like a fucking nightmare.

CaroleSinger · 26/10/2023 15:28

Why's she so wrapped up in an ex anyway?

Flyhigher · 26/10/2023 15:26

You can justifiably cut her off. You can say that you will think of her but this is indefensible. Going into a paedo act is just not acceptable. You can message her support obliquely but you simply can't discuss this anymore.

On another note this must surely be a large paedo ring, the police wouldn't bother with just one person surely. They are too busy.

OhDoSitDownAndShutUp · 26/10/2023 15:26

I couldn't be friends with someone who -

defends a nonce
makes excuses for a nonce
stands by a nonce

GoodOldEmmaNess · 26/10/2023 15:25

Depending on how recently your friend received this bombshell, it may just be that her feelings haven't yet caught up with her new reality. She hasn't yet had time to process what she now knows about her DH, so many of her attitudes towards him are still caught in the pre-revelation pattern.

For that reason it does seem harsh to cut her off, rather than remaining as a source of support for her at what must be a horrendous time.

I don't feel judgey towards you at all for this decision - god knows whether or not I would be able to provide suppport for a friend in the same circumstances. And I'm sure no one else would judge you either. But it does seem like the best course of action would be to set boundaries about what you are and are not prepared to listen to, and to remain with her to provide support in matters that will not be controversial between you, such as practical help, cheerful distractions and being a compassionate listener within the boundaries you have set.

gelatogina · 26/10/2023 15:25

Wow @LookingForPurpose what a sad sad time for your family. Sending you best wishes for your future.

AcrossthePond55 · 26/10/2023 15:24

Seakayaker100 · 26/10/2023 15:02

@LookingForPurpose thank you for sharing your experience - it sounds horrendous. I can see that with a family member, you have a greater obligation to find the truth and work out if continued contact is possible. I'm struggling with this being her ex, and there really being no need to maintain any relationship at all. They weren't married and never lived together, there is no long lasting ties to each other. And yet she is effectively choosing him over me, as I have said I can't support her if she sticks with him. It's so messed up 😔

Please don't think of it as choosing him over you. I think it's more choosing him over herself. Perhaps she feels 'how could I ever have been involved with/loved someone like that?' and is trying to convince herself that he isn't 'like that' in order to keep herself 'sane', for lack of a better word. Denial is very common in situations like this, be it child sex abuse, murder, or even addiction. We don't want to believe, so we choose not to believe. But in these cases the truth eventually forces itself on us.

Make your feelings clear to her, tell her you love her but cannot support her in this. Then, if you can, try to sort of 'hover round the edges' of her life and hope she comes to her senses.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 26/10/2023 15:23

I'm struggling with this being her ex, and there really being no need to maintain any relationship at all. They weren't married and never lived together, there is no long lasting ties to each other

I'm struggling with that too, so wonder if there's any possibility he isn't actually an ex, and that knowing or suspecting what's gone on she's lied about seeing him so people don't think badly of her?

It would certainly explain some of her MH struggles, but then it would affect how I'd handle this too if it was true

TeaGinandFags · 26/10/2023 15:23

Redglitter · 26/10/2023 13:58

Exactly this.

This would be a total deal breaker fir ne especially as she's making excuses for him. He was caught this time but I'd be wondering if he'd met anyone before & not been caught. What are the odds of him chatting to an undercover police officer the very first time he engages with a child online

This

I couldn't give an airborne sexual encounter about whether it was his first time or his millionth. He was still involved to his back teeth. What else do you need to know?

I would be kind to friend bc every woman has had stand by your man blasted into her ears since birth. The friend needs to appreciate exactly how much evidence is required to find yourself in court and how hard these men work to appear like the perfect guy.

MinnieL · 26/10/2023 15:22

The forum I mentioned is called Stop It Now

willWillSmithsmith · 26/10/2023 15:20

It’s the fact she’s standing by him that would do it for me. If she was shocked and disgusted and wanted nothing to do with him then I’d have supported her but she’s basically condoning and excusing his behaviour. I couldn’t stay friends with someone like that no matter how long I’d known her. She is an appalling judge of character and not worthy of your friendship especially considering your son was inadvertently in the company of such scum she still chooses to associate with.

LookingForPurpose · 26/10/2023 15:17

@WeightWhat

I was out of the country on a weekend away with my DH celebrating our first trip Alone when my house was raided. My 3 children age 15-21 were home when the police came through the door. Thankfully my youngest was with other family. I got a call from the police, asked them to hold so I could throw my guts up from sheer horror and panic and then had to wait 12 hours until I could fly home. So it was an incredibly tough time.

I spoke to my sons right away. My eldest admitted it to me right away he has ASD and oddly is very honest, said it was hentaii which is like anime porn? Don't Google it. Tentacles, animal human hybrids etc. anyway, even though it's cartoons it's illegal as the characters often have school uniforms and or are animals or hybrids. So he made a statement saying yes it was him. Then Covid hit and it was delayed 30 months to sentencing. The police found even more of the hentaii images and videos that he had forgotten about. It was only AFTER sentencing it came out in his therapy that he had been groomed online and he had a pornography addiction and that had also caused the horrific (and often suicidal) transgender issues he has been going through from age 13-18.

The grooming and addiction the police were not the slightest bit interested in, even though my son offered the details of every person in what was and still is, an active online paedophile ring sharing the very same images that he was prosecuted for. They had a conviction and that's ask they wanted. They refused to even look into the petite that had added him to these hidden groups are 13-14 as they are resident all over the world and they wouldn't have an icicle in hells chance of getting any arrests etc.

So then I found it easier in some ways, to reconcile my revulsion and my personal gender critical beliefs . He says he's never been attracted to children, he just liked hentaii. And none of his behaviour has ever suggested an interest of ANY kind in any children of any age. The fact that I was a victim of child hood sexual abuse myself made it harder. Some days, even now, I am so angry that I can't even look at him. He's torn my family apart. Im his carer but he can't remain at home so he had to go and live in a flat a few miles away. His world is very very small. But he's complying 100% with probation, engaging with therapy etc and has since got a diagnosis of ADHD and is now medicated. But he's chronically unhappy and says if this is all his life will ever be then he doesn't want to be here for it. 23 yo and his entire life is over as far as he is concerned. It kill's me and on my darkest days I even found myself thinking the same. It's incredibly hard. But he's my son. What else can I do?

I think the ops friends will come to her senses. But it will take a while. She's likely to see sense Especially when she realises any children she has to this man will be taken away as he won't be allowed near them. If she had children with somebody else then they would rightly report any contact with him and the same would happen if she can't protect them. Or when he's found guilty and it goes the papers and People know they are /were together. Her life won't be worth living.

MinnieL · 26/10/2023 15:15

When this all came out were they together at the time or already broken up?

There’s an anonymous forum which is for people who need support in situations like these. People who’s children/husbands/family members are abusers and need to talk to people in similar situations. I can’t remember the name but I’d direct her there for support.

Of course you don’t want to drop a really good friend who’s suicidal but at the same time I don’t see how you can support someone who’s supporting this man. It’s a tricky one. I don’t envy you at all