Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To cut off friend of nearly 30 years?

184 replies

Seakayaker100 · 26/10/2023 13:31

Name changed as very outing.
I have a very good friend, been with me through lots of life's milestones, always there when I've needed her. Now I feel like the worst friend as I can't be there for her right now. Her ex has been arrested and remanded out of the blue, and turns out he has been caught in an undercover online sting and arrested when arriving at a house to carry out child sex abuse that had been planned online with an undercover police officer. She's in pieces and is verging on suicidal, but wants to stand by him. Has visited him on remand, is listening to his excuses and even justifying that there wasn't a victim so not that bad. I've said no, I can't support her in this, and that despite not being convicted yet, I want no part in anything or anyone involved with him. When they were dating, she brought him to my house and to watch my son in a school event. She seems confused why that is upsetting me. I feel guilty to desert her when she's suicidal, but I can't play any part in this. (She has other MH services involved).
Please tell me I'm not being unreasonable, or if you think I am, explain why? His shitty choices have ruined a great friendship, but I'm more upset about how poor her boundaries are with this. This is no doubt due to her mental health, but I can't see a way to support her that doesn't involve listening to her making excuses and down playing what he's done.

OP posts:
Maddy70 · 26/10/2023 16:08

It sounds like she is in shock and having to deal with this awful situation.

She's in denial

Continue to be there for her but be very clear you do not support her having any contact with him

she needs relevant support from professionals

Sittingonabench · 26/10/2023 16:07

I do t think YABU but at the same time I think giving her a bit of grace while she comes to terms would be the best way forward. I don’t really think this is about him but about her. If everything they say is true, not only has she fallen for every lie but she has loved the man and worse facilitated his potential abuse against vulnerable people she cares for. I can’t imagine the guilt and fear associated with that. So she is trying to find ways around it. To support her I would consistently and repeatedly state that she has done nothing wrong. Whenever she makes an excuse for him it would be no but you did nothing wrong.like I say I don’t think YABU but I do think this is the time she needs you most.

VWdieselnightmare · 26/10/2023 16:05

ManateeFair · 26/10/2023 15:46

Read the OP's other comments in the thread.

The man is not her friend's husband or even her boyfriend. He is an ex - they didn't even live together even when they were a couple. He's literally just a bloke she dated for a while. They have no ties to one another.

This isn't a situation where a woman's life has been turned upside-down by an accusation against the husband or partner she shares her whole life with. It's a situation where a man someone used to date was caught in the act of planning and trying to attend the rape of a child, and his ex-girlfriend has inexplicably decided that this is the time to rekindle her previous relationship with him. Very different.

Ah, okay — I started responding when the OP had posted just the one post and then the phone rang and I came back to things later. I'd assumed from the original post that the ex was someone who the friend had been involved with for years until relatively recently.

I hate drip feeds.

This now sounds like the typical messy situation people get themselves in when everyone involved is having a strong emotional reaction. Difficult to understand the friend's reaction. Easier to understand the OP's righteous 'it's him or me' response, though I'd repeat that I don't think someone who's a real friend would threaten to stomp out on a point of principle when their dear friend is expressing suicidal thoughts.

verdantverdure · 26/10/2023 16:03

horseyhorsey17 · 26/10/2023 16:00

You can't be friends with her.

The scales may fall from her eyes soon though, he will have been gaslighting and grooming her for this very eventuality.

Yes he probably will have been.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 26/10/2023 16:03

Unless he has children with this man he's you EX, he's not part of your life any more

Allegedly

Like yourself I feel there's probably more to this story, and as said upthread I do have to wonder just how much of an "ex" he is

verdantverdure · 26/10/2023 16:01

I don't usually have "red lines" as such but I think making excuses for a child abuser might be one.

Every objective observer knows that the only reason he didn't abuse a child when he turned up to abuse a child is because no child was there.

You could try and hang on until he's convicted @Seakayaker100?

If she's still making excuses for him then, then... Glitterball

Assuming he gets convicted.

I know women do defend men who do unforgivable things.

At my friend's rape trial the rapist's mother and girlfriend shouted "slag" at her outside court. He got off and then we found out it wasn't his first rodeo. I expect he'll get off the next time too.

horseyhorsey17 · 26/10/2023 16:00

You can't be friends with her.

The scales may fall from her eyes soon though, he will have been gaslighting and grooming her for this very eventuality.

Chocaholic4672 · 26/10/2023 15:59

I understand how you are feeling however I think it would be a shitty thing to dump a friend who is clearly traumatised. She probably has no idea how to feel and is on auto pilot. It's early days and she is still processing it all.
I am sure she will have more judgement and hostility from many people, don't be one of them.

PoachedEggSandwich · 26/10/2023 15:59

She knows where I stand and seems to have got the message today that I don't want anymore than to check she is alright.
Well there you go then. Walk away. She's clearly not alright and maybe having got your message, she won't bother you any further

MinnieL · 26/10/2023 15:59

Another thing I’d add is if you tell your friend about the Stop It Now website, try not to look at it yourself. It’s an open forum like MN and you can click on any post to have a read. So many people on there stand by their partners and it’s quite depressing to read.

She may want to speak with other people about the situation instead of trying to get support from yourself. Good luck

beatrix1234 · 26/10/2023 15:59

@EmpressSoleil I feel like there is more to this story. I would be upset/angry if I heard an ex was arrested for something like this but it wouldn't make me suicidal.

Exactly, unless he has children with this man he's you EX, he's not part of your life any more. It's shocking, upsetting etc.... but why is she feeling suicidal? I believe there's more to this story that she's not telling.

adriftinadenofvipers · 26/10/2023 15:57

I don't understand why she is supporting an ex???

Would she not be sick to the core to think she had sex with a man like this?!

EmpressSoleil · 26/10/2023 15:56

The thing is, if everyone drops her she's just going to be pushed towards him more and will have no one in her life to challenge the rubbish he's feeding her.

I feel like there is more to this story. I would be upset/angry if I heard an ex was arrested for something like this but it wouldn't make me suicidal.

I don't think she's in her right mind at all right now. If you want to cut the friendship dead, that's entirely your prerogative. You don't need to support her in supporting him but I'm not sure I'd totally abandon such a long standing friend.

beatrix1234 · 26/10/2023 15:55

Why is you friend supporting an EX and going to visit him to jail? Why is she defending a pedophile? You need to cut loses with this person. She's completely delusional.

Lastchancechica · 26/10/2023 15:55

Seakayaker100 · 26/10/2023 15:54

He's been on remand for four weeks and bail was denied at a separate hearing. I'm thinking the evidence is very strong and he doesn't seem to be denying it but more that he made an error in judgement/wouldn't have actually done anything.
I am continuing to message my friend to check in on her, but I'm not asking or discussing anything about him. She knows where I stand and seems to have got the message today that I don't want anymore than to check she is alright.

Bail is rarely denied. The courts must have significant concerns that he will reoffend/is a risk.

Iknowthis1 · 26/10/2023 15:55

I think you could make it clear that you can't be a part of this without cutting off the friendship completely.

She hasn't been accused of anything and she sounds very vulnerable. If all her friends desert her she will have no one but him. She will never come through this if he is her only source of information or comfort.

dapsnotplimsolls · 26/10/2023 15:54

How long ago did they split up? Has she been hoping that they would get back together? That might explain why she's defending him.

jannier · 26/10/2023 15:54

She has mh issues I'd also be wondering if he's been coercive

Seakayaker100 · 26/10/2023 15:54

He's been on remand for four weeks and bail was denied at a separate hearing. I'm thinking the evidence is very strong and he doesn't seem to be denying it but more that he made an error in judgement/wouldn't have actually done anything.
I am continuing to message my friend to check in on her, but I'm not asking or discussing anything about him. She knows where I stand and seems to have got the message today that I don't want anymore than to check she is alright.

OP posts:
ExtraOnions · 26/10/2023 15:53

Classic Kubler-Ross territory … shock & denial being the first two stages, which is where I guess your friend is.
It’s a cycle she needs to go through

PoachedEggSandwich · 26/10/2023 15:52

If this is your stance, what do you want from this post? Loads of people telling you that you're right?

Only you know if you're capable of giving her time, or if you can't abide by any of it.

Me personally, I don't think I could walk away from my friend of 30 years, who I presumably loved, especially whilst they're suicidal. But then I've experienced suicide and maybe that shapes me a bit.

Your friend has nothing to do with her ex partners behaviour. This is a shock to you, imagine what its like to be her right now. By standing by her temporarily you're not condoning him, but you would be giving her the benefit of the doubt to gather her self on this matter. If this is still her stance in a few weeks, then I'd walk away, but right now, if this was was your partner, would you literally drop him as if he never existed? Or would you be confused, wondering why, feeling guilty and not know what was up and what was down? Sometimes its hard to say confidently what you'd do until you were in the situation.

PrinnyPree · 26/10/2023 15:50

I would just tell her you will be there for her but she has to make a choice between him and you. He is a paedophile. If SHE chooses him, she has ended the 30 year friendship, not you.

I would also worry (and be suspicious) about her minimising what he's done tbf and why she is so keen to keep in touch and support him if he's an ex and they aren't married, that's a little red flag quite frankly.

Elfidela1980 · 26/10/2023 15:50

It’s still early and she can’t bring herself to see the truth. Doesn’t mean she won’t. From what you’ve said you know she probably only feels this way because she’s not in a good place mentally and while you don’t judge her for that, why would you, you can’t sit and listen to his excuses coming out of her mouth.

Pretending otherwise wouldn’t be friendship, sometimes friendship is doing exactly what you’re doing now, being honest even at the expense of the relationship. It would be wrong to pretend to her as well, because she’s in danger herself. What will her life be if she stands by this man?

What happened before she knew wasn’t of her making, and she’s not to blame. But there is no excuse she can offer for him, and no mitigation either, that will change your view of him. So I’d possibly tell her that. Unless you think it might be more than she can stand. If so, take a big step away and wait and see what time does. Agree with the PPs who’ve mentioned they’ve defended their own abusers. It’s not so easy to have clarity when you’re in the situation.

Hemax1 · 26/10/2023 15:48

Hugely tough situation to be in.
please give her time. Her whole world has exploded and it takes a huge amount of time to process everything and try to understand what’s going on. Believe me I’ve been in a situation similar to her. She’ll desperately want to believe that it’s not right, that she should have known if it was happening, her belief in people has been rocked to the core too.

You may need to withdraw from her for a while if you find you are hitting a brick wall with her, but the hurt, the truth and the realisation will come in time for her. If she reaches out to you then, would you be prepared to extend an olive branch?

For me talking things through with my friends was a huge part of processing what went was going on and I’m very grateful to them for getting me through that time. But understandably it’s hard to hear that she believes his innocence and excuses whilst you know he wouldn’t be on remand without evidence.

Remember she’s not the guilty party in this and she’ll be trying to navigate the situation without having any reference points of how to do so.

Lastchancechica · 26/10/2023 15:48

I have friends as old as this.

I would end the friendship this is not negotiable op. A red line.

Tell her why, that you will always care but can’t see or support her any longer. Maybe this action will help show her what a terrible mistake she is making. People will find out and tar her with the same brush.