Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you work in a university have you noticed a recent change in student behaviour?

333 replies

0987ghj · 26/10/2023 11:26

I graduated from university in 2019, and have now returned to study a different course. I've noticed a big difference in student behaviour and I wondered if it's something that university staff have also noticed or if it's just my course.

I'm hoping that this thread doesn't seem like I'm trying to slate current university students/gen Z. A few of the examples I've seen are from mature students, so I don't think it's generational/an age thing.

There's a lot of talking now during lectures, people just talking loudly whilst the lecturer is talking (not even whispering). It's pretty brazen and full on conversations, not just a quick question or comment, and really distracting. People are often late quite a lot, there's routinely a few students who are 40+ minutes late to a 2-hour lecture. I know there are some reasons people may be late such as childcare issues, or traffic or illnesses like IBS that make it hard to leave the house in the mornings so that might just be why, but it's a lot more lateness than I ever saw in my degree before. There would be the occasional person 5-10 minutes late, but not 40+ minutes.

People also start packing up and starting to leave before the lecturer has even finished talking. Our lectures always finish slightly early to allow time to walk to other lectures so there's not really any need for it. I don't remember this happening before, unless it was because the lecture had ran over and even then people would quietly/subtly pack up.

OP posts:
MangosteenSoda · 27/10/2023 18:25

RampantIvy · 27/10/2023 15:37

There wasn't any spoon feeding at DD's university. It isn't a top 10 or one that would pass muster with the snobby mumsnetters on the HE boards even though it is in the top 20 for her course, but the students were expected to do their own research.

In her first year DD told me that at one lecture just before some December exams a student asked the lecturer what topics would be covered in the exams. The lecturer replied "this isn't school. You are expected to know and revise all the topics we have covered so far. We don't tell you what is going to be included in exams."

DD asked for a PEC when she was struck down with covid during her third year dissertation and it was refused. Even her dissertation tutor was astounded that it was refused.

Tbh, I think the lecturer’s response re exam content was ok because that’s the fact of it and the student should have known that. Perhaps it could have been phrased more nicely, but I sometimes find directness is the best option to avoid confusion and to set expectations.

I am surprised your DD didn’t get an extension for illness though.

MangosteenSoda · 27/10/2023 18:16

I teach on a course with an intake of between 350-380 first years. I think this year’s cohort seem to more in line with the 2020 cohort who were only very latterly affected by Covid in their 6th form years.

21 and 22 had fewer interpersonal skills and there was also an issue with grade inflation. This seems to have worked itself out a bit more this year and I’ve been really pleasantly surprised by the competence and engagement of the new starters. We have had to remind the cohort as a whole to stfu in lectures though.

I love working with this age bracket. They are on such a journey. Yes, it can be VERY frustrating at times and I agree with the heavy volume of students needing support plans being incredibly high right now. I just love it when you see them starting to grow. The first thing a particular student said to me last year was, ‘I don’t know what I’m fucking doing here innit’. I suggested we try to unpack that somewhat 😁 This year, that student is a peer mentor and I absolutely love seeing them walk around our building with their head high, looking confident and happy.

The other cohort I mainly work with is Postgrad taught students. They are mostly international and this is actually my specialty. They come with a different set of challenges but also come with a lot of knowledge, bravery and experience we need to unlock.

The single thing that bugs me about this cohort is a lack of obvious engagement and participation in certain activities that require active engagement and participation. We have numerous engagement models to support our learners and students can pick the model that suits them best… but participation is a must. I really do find it frustrating when students opt for an online option that is meant to be participatory and then sit there with cameras and mics off. It’s really unfair on the students who have attended that sort of session with the expectation of participating.

CosimoPiovasco · 27/10/2023 18:10

TortolaParadise · 27/10/2023 18:08

@CosimoPiovasco I would love to know. I guess academic attainment comes from a different part of the brain that emotional intelligence and problem solving comes from!

Absolutely.
Its not a mark of common sense

TortolaParadise · 27/10/2023 18:08

@CosimoPiovasco I would love to know. I guess academic attainment comes from a different part of the brain that emotional intelligence and problem solving comes from!

CosimoPiovasco · 27/10/2023 17:39

TortolaParadise · 27/10/2023 16:12

OMG, I work with these people - disrespectful, no criticism allowed, hysterical, anxious, sensitive to all perceived slights and yet is huffy and rudeness personified!!!!

This is exactly the sort of stuff my friend who is a tutor at uni says.
One of the top unis requiring all As and Astars.
How on earth did they get those grades

TortolaParadise · 27/10/2023 16:12

All2Well · 27/10/2023 08:03

In the past 6 years, I've taught at two different university. With every year that's passed, but especially since the pandemic, I've seen students become less and less emotionally mature and, frankly, completely unable to cope with the adult world.

At my current university, more than half of my students have support plans from Wellbeing that says that due to mental health reasons tutors need to allow them to be flexible with attendance and deadlines. More than half. Bear in mind that most assessments are practical, can't be carried out alone and take place in a dedicated lab with additional technicians' support which all has to be booked an academic year in advance for timetabling.

I'm neurodiverse with often crippling anxiety and depression but I NEVER used any of that as an excuse or expected other people to pander to me. This is next level entitlement. One student even involves a friend and fellow student as part of their accomodations for fibromyalgia ("must be allowed to leave the lab or lecture at any time and take Emma to care for her. If student becomes distressed, Emma must implement support plan. Student must be allowed to not attend lectures at short notice and have Emma stay at home to
care for them.") 9/10 I find the student in the cafe opposite the lecture theatre laughing and joking with their boyfriend and a miserable looking Emma who now has lots of work to catch up on.

The same students every week wander in 45 minutes late (but yes, coffee in hand) with a different excuse every week. It's a practical course, so when they're late they're not just missing out on learning a technique or method and demonstrating a competency, they're often messing things up for the rest of the group who rely on one another for practice and demonstration. Then there's the walking out of the room and walking back in at random intervals (because, anxiety) by several different students every week. And passing round phones and giggling at something random on TikTok or Snapchat rudely.

There's a really odd expectation now that we are substitute parents and need to meet their emotional needs, sort out squabbles and personal minor (petty!) conflicts and never give any form of criticism at all. Even suggestions about approaches to time management, study skills etc are taken personally and staff have to be unreasonably careful not to say anything that might be taken as personal criticism.

One personal tutee posted a series of tweets about me saying that her now ex favourite tutor clearly thinks she's insane and a complete nut job because she told her she needed therapy. She'd been unable to take part in lectures, labs and seminars for six weeks because whenever she'd make the slightest mistake she'd scream a slew of abuse at herself, hit things, and cry hysterically and had taken to just showing up at the door of the lecture theatre and crying hysterically and saying "I can't do it. I can't sit in there knowing I'm the shittest student week after week." despite being on track for a first. After six weeks of all of this (and getting pulled out of teaching several times to support her), I'd gently told her I'd made a referral to Student Wellbeing to see if she might be eligible for some additional support such as counselling.

They openly bitch about and mock my colleagues to me, as if they expect me to join in. We're held up to impossible standards yet disrespected. By adults who have an inability to get out of bed and make it on time to a 12pm lecture (because it's too early) and who sulk constantly if pretty much anything is asked of them.

On my first day at my most recent university, the systems were down and no one could print off a list of student's names. In my first seminar that day I passed a sheet of paper round the 20 students and asked them to write their name, and pronouns down for me (because God forbid you misgender one of them) and you'd have thought I'd asked them to climb Everest naked and blindfolded, "wait what? Why? What am I writing again? Do you need middle names? Can I put my nickname down instead? What if you don't have pronouns? What if they change a lot? Can't you just learn my name now? Wait, why have I been given a piece of paper? What do I do with it next? Who is it for? Do you want my mobile number and halls and my parents details in case there is an emergency too? I can't do it I don't have a pen, I didn't bring one and my student loan ran out and I can't afford one until pay day. Can someone else do it for me? Can you not do it for me?"

I honestly feel more like a children's TV presenter or play room leader than a lecturer. Crazily enough I've found if I basically act like Ms Rachel then they are all happy and I come out on top of all the course evaluations ("we hate all the other lecturers, they're weird and boring and they smell but we like you, you're the BEST and make learning FUN!", genuine feedback there.)

I am genuinely considering going back to primary teaching. They're better behaved and get more learning done.

OMG, I work with these people - disrespectful, no criticism allowed, hysterical, anxious, sensitive to all perceived slights and yet is huffy and rudeness personified!!!!

RampantIvy · 27/10/2023 15:37

There wasn't any spoon feeding at DD's university. It isn't a top 10 or one that would pass muster with the snobby mumsnetters on the HE boards even though it is in the top 20 for her course, but the students were expected to do their own research.

In her first year DD told me that at one lecture just before some December exams a student asked the lecturer what topics would be covered in the exams. The lecturer replied "this isn't school. You are expected to know and revise all the topics we have covered so far. We don't tell you what is going to be included in exams."

DD asked for a PEC when she was struck down with covid during her third year dissertation and it was refused. Even her dissertation tutor was astounded that it was refused.

FarEast · 27/10/2023 15:26

US Universities ran regular student satisfaction surveys and responded to the results (though this seemed to drive sone grade inflation compared with grading here). It's interesting that our student loan system hasn't had the same effect and that 'market forces' don't seem to be driving a more demanding and motivated student culture.

It has driven changes, just that they aren't necessarily for the better. The NSS (national satisfaction survey) is a blunt instrument, which asks questions that seem to expect negative answers, and with very little expectation that students actively engage with their work. For example, it doesn't ask "How satisfied are you with your preparation and participation?"

The stats experts at my place say that it wouldn't past a 1st year assignment in setting up a satisfaction questionnaire ...

The spoon-feeding is often about things that de-skill students. For example, in my humanities field, students expect to be told almost individually, exactly what they need to be doing, instead of consulting the documentation we provide - in required detail - on our virtual learning environments. They no longer go to the library to search for sources - they expect to have a reading list with links to the digitised material, at a keystroke, and even in their final year, they don't know how to search for sources independently. And this is not because we haven't shown them. Repeatedly.

RampantIvy · 27/10/2023 15:16

I do think a lot of the problems stem from the aspirational aim of getting 50% of school/college leavers to go to Uni. Quite simply 50% aren't capable of a Uni education at that age, and 50% of jobs don't need a degree. Unis have had to expand massively to cope with the influx and their resources are stretched to the limit.

I agree. I think far too many young people go to university when other options would be more suitable for them.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 27/10/2023 14:42

Gymnopedie · 27/10/2023 13:11

Make attendance required. Have it disclosed on transcripts that are provided to future employers.
Fail them if they don't attend. Take registers.
Don't give extensions without documented extenuating circumstances eg a bereavement or hospitalisation.
Make deductions to the grades of the students talking in lectures.
Only make recorded lectures avaliable in special circumstances.

Yes of course. And tell them to stop talking or you'll ask them to leave, don't allow students in who are nearly an hour late for a two hour lecture, don't explain to the students what they should already know but don't because they haven't done the reading (taking time away from those who have), etc...

Good luck with getting management to support you when you do, when their focus is on retention and achievement because their funding is dependent on those things. (The crieria for funding is a whole other issue.)

Interestingly, the school of medicine at my university do fail students whose attendance is lower than 80%. It works. They all attend.

Theoretically, the same rule applies to all students in the university but it is not implemented.

Once we were back on campus, I only made recordings available in special circumstances and now no longer make them available. My head of discipline did ask me to confirm I was providing recordings as we were required to do so. I asked him to point out where that was documented (it was documented as desirable, not required) and I heard nothing else. I get excellent attendance in comparison to those who provide recordings.

I have no problem giving extensions for reasonable reasons.

I don't explain to those who have not done the reading and I have been known to ask them to leave if the session is a flipped class. I do tell them they can come and join us once they've done the reading.

I do not tolerate talking in my lectures so they don't (caveat - I don't have very big classes).

It helps that I am reasonably close to retirement, get good student feedback and am in Ireland, rather than the UK where things appear to have gone to pot in terms of staff conditions for academics.

Autumnvibes23 · 27/10/2023 14:27

CosimoPiovasco · 27/10/2023 13:23

All three of mine were the same.
Missing freshers would have put them at a severe disadvantage.
Different units were explained so they could make the choice prior to the start of the course.

For all three, different unis and different courses, there were lectures on the basics during freshers week. Like yours the science courses did intros in lab safety, explaining the machines etc.

Its not all just party party

On my nursing degree the course started about a month before Freshers. So all the introductory stuff was compulsory. However, some people did go away during reading weeks, which I can understand because you don't get many holidays during a nursing degree, but they did miss out on the opportunity for extra practice in the nursing lab etc.

Gymnopedie · 27/10/2023 14:24

Blimey!
Are some really that delusional?!

Yes. But they don't care.

CosimoPiovasco · 27/10/2023 14:21

Autumnvibes23 · 27/10/2023 14:14

While that is the case at your university it just isn't the same elsewhere. My DS isn't at Uni but a College and when he applied for the course we were told it would be 90% f2f. But it isn't. It's half remote and half in college.

my sons uni only started a mix of online / face to face lectures in academic year starting sept 2021
He still had some online into 22/23
All lab work though was from sept2021.

Superscientist · 27/10/2023 14:19

My UG was 2006-2010 and my postgraduate 2011-2017 and noticed a big decline in students attitudes between my UG and the end of my postgraduate. The students just wanted to be told the answers and weren't interested in studying. My partner is an academic now he has noticed a decline in student attitudes since he started having his own students in 2015 and now it's with junior researchers too. The difference for us was clear between those that paid £3k a year to £9k a year. Students seemed to switch from being students to being consumers and generally their attitudes stank. "I'm paying to be hear" sort of thing completely ignoring that our dept was £7k a year deficit per student due to the costs not covering the cost of a science degree

CosimoPiovasco · 27/10/2023 14:16

Bouledeneige · 27/10/2023 14:12

To be fair when I went to university in the 80s I regarded it as an extension of growing up, independence, partying and having fun and putting off getting a proper job. I did all of those things but worked when I needed to and got a good degree that enabled me to study abroad to get a masters afterwards. I also worked in my holidays to pay for the only holidays I would get as I no longer went away with my parents (who even went to the Carribbean to stay with my sister who lived there without taking me). I never afforded to visit her. At that time of course i didn't have a loan as a much smaller minority went to university.

A difference I noticed though when studying in the US for my masters was that because they paid for their degrees the US students were much more motivated to ensure they got their money's worth. They mostly were highly motivated to study, and challenged the 'service' they received if they thought they weren't getting their money's worth. They often had jobs and hobbies like sports which they were equally motivated about. They seemed more concerned about their future employment prospects (perhaps because they have less of a welfare state safety net to fall back on?).

US Universities ran regular student satisfaction surveys and responded to the results (though this seemed to drive sone grade inflation compared with grading here). It's interesting that our student loan system hasn't had the same effect and that 'market forces' don't seem to be driving a more demanding and motivated student culture.

But I'd hesitate to criticise young people now. I was pretty silly and university was a growing up experience.

I studied at an American Uni and my experience was very very different.
They rarely turned up, we’re very entitled and the standard was very low.
They were allowed to repeat units constantly until they got the grade they wanted.
In the 80s we weren’t allowed to do that.

Autumnvibes23 · 27/10/2023 14:14

All2Well · 27/10/2023 10:20

Whilst I appreciate that every university is different, I'm fed up of seeing posts about online lectures.

For myself (and actually my colleagues and friends who taught across a number of universities in my part of the country);

All learning went online from March 2020 until the end of the Academic year. Which for my course was the end of April 2020. That's the only time all learning was delivered online. Just over two months.

From September 2020, we did socially distanced hybrid learning at my old place of work, at my current place of work they did entirely face to face (except for when two huge outbreaks caused the course to shut down temporarily). At my old workplace, all seminars and small groups were in person and tutor led with windows open, 2m distance, masks except most students declared
themselves exempt and extra hygiene methods, most individual tutorials were online and most of the huge lecturers were online although at first we had to split the year group into bubbles, repeat the lectures several times and deep clean and air the room in between but this was unsustainable. The university insisted we did 70% of teaching face to face as we were a practical course. As soon as the government advice changed from "work from home" to "work from home if you can" we were in, in person,
even though we were in a Tier 3 area. It was a nightmare to carry out as staff kept catching covid from the students (who'd often attend knowing they had covid or symptoms of covid) or contact tracing would essentially shut down the course for a while. But we were not teaching "entirely online for years" as people often make out.

This is now the 3rd full Academic year that learning has been completely back to normal, ie 100% face to face.

Ironically, attendance was far better when it was hybrid or online, possibly because we were all in lockdown and there was nothing better to do.

While that is the case at your university it just isn't the same elsewhere. My DS isn't at Uni but a College and when he applied for the course we were told it would be 90% f2f. But it isn't. It's half remote and half in college.

CosimoPiovasco · 27/10/2023 14:12

Gymnopedie · 27/10/2023 14:09

Sometimes parents' money. But it's about the threshold you mentioned. They believe that EITHER they won't earn enough to have to pay it back OR have no intention of getting the sort of job that would mean they would pay it back OR believe it will be a very small amount OR just ignore it.

Edited

Blimey!
Are some really that delusional?!

Bouledeneige · 27/10/2023 14:12

To be fair when I went to university in the 80s I regarded it as an extension of growing up, independence, partying and having fun and putting off getting a proper job. I did all of those things but worked when I needed to and got a good degree that enabled me to study abroad to get a masters afterwards. I also worked in my holidays to pay for the only holidays I would get as I no longer went away with my parents (who even went to the Carribbean to stay with my sister who lived there without taking me). I never afforded to visit her. At that time of course i didn't have a loan as a much smaller minority went to university.

A difference I noticed though when studying in the US for my masters was that because they paid for their degrees the US students were much more motivated to ensure they got their money's worth. They mostly were highly motivated to study, and challenged the 'service' they received if they thought they weren't getting their money's worth. They often had jobs and hobbies like sports which they were equally motivated about. They seemed more concerned about their future employment prospects (perhaps because they have less of a welfare state safety net to fall back on?).

US Universities ran regular student satisfaction surveys and responded to the results (though this seemed to drive sone grade inflation compared with grading here). It's interesting that our student loan system hasn't had the same effect and that 'market forces' don't seem to be driving a more demanding and motivated student culture.

But I'd hesitate to criticise young people now. I was pretty silly and university was a growing up experience.

Gymnopedie · 27/10/2023 14:09

CosimoPiovasco · 27/10/2023 13:52

Assume you’re talking about money given to them by their parents.
Money from student finance is taken out at source from the April after you finish your course once you are earning over a certain threshold. Students never see it in their ‘pay packet’. It’s taken just like tax and NI.

Of course some will move abroad and some are 60yrs plus so won’t necessarily pay a penny back,

Sometimes parents' money. But it's about the threshold you mentioned. They believe that EITHER they won't earn enough to have to pay it back OR have no intention of getting the sort of job that would mean they would pay it back OR believe it will be a very small amount OR just ignore it.

CosimoPiovasco · 27/10/2023 13:52

Gymnopedie · 27/10/2023 13:40

Why go to Uni and pay all that money if you aren't willing/ able to get the most out of it?

Because some (quite a lot of) students - and it explains a lot of the behaviour and attitude seen on this thread - DO see it as a way of putting off having to work and having three or four more years of partying and drinking and yes, drugs. And those students usually don't care about the fees that 'they' are paying because that's another attitude that they have, that they will never pay it back.

Assume you’re talking about money given to them by their parents.
Money from student finance is taken out at source from the April after you finish your course once you are earning over a certain threshold. Students never see it in their ‘pay packet’. It’s taken just like tax and NI.

Of course some will move abroad and some are 60yrs plus so won’t necessarily pay a penny back,

Gymnopedie · 27/10/2023 13:40

Why go to Uni and pay all that money if you aren't willing/ able to get the most out of it?

Because some (quite a lot of) students - and it explains a lot of the behaviour and attitude seen on this thread - DO see it as a way of putting off having to work and having three or four more years of partying and drinking and yes, drugs. And those students usually don't care about the fees that 'they' are paying because that's another attitude that they have, that they will never pay it back.

user1497207191 · 27/10/2023 13:39

I do think a lot of the problems stem from the aspirational aim of getting 50% of school/college leavers to go to Uni. Quite simply 50% aren't capable of a Uni education at that age, and 50% of jobs don't need a degree. Unis have had to expand massively to cope with the influx and their resources are stretched to the limit.

Of course, it's good to be aspirational, but not at the expense of the other options, i.e. workplace learning, apprenticeships, trades, and of course, the virtual removal of further education for adults which makes it harder for older people to career change.

The crux is probably far too many people going to Uni who don't need to and aren't really suitable for it.

AreYouShittingMe · 27/10/2023 13:29

SlowDog · 27/10/2023 08:41

"The sense of entitlement started when the fees increased, and general cost of being a student went through the roof. Suddenly, instead of working together, students became customers- disrespectful, arrogant, entitled customers."

It's not a sense of entitlement though is it? If you're paying through the nose, you are entitled to get something good for your money. If I had been paying this much when I went to university I wouldn't have so easily accepted it when things were not right and teaching was not of good quality.

But that's the frustration. Students are paying for a service, and rather than engaging in the service and making the most out of it, they are late, disruptive and at times appear unable to cope with the course requirements. Of course they should be getting a good service, but degree level education involves being active in the process. You can take a horse to water but you can't make it drink. But when the horse is paying for the water and refusing to drink it does seem baffling to me. I've an undergraduate and two postgraduate degrees. All involved some sort of sacrifice (financial/ personal etc). But I have benefitted career wise from my education. Why go to Uni and pay all that money if you aren't willing/ able to get the most out of it?

CosimoPiovasco · 27/10/2023 13:23

RampantIvy · 27/10/2023 13:18

On the WIWIKAU Facebook page a lot of parents have asked how necessary it is to attend freshers week, usually because they have booked a family holiday or there is a family wedding to attend. Many replies are to the effect that all they do is party all the time, which IME simply isn't true.

In my daughter's case they had introductory lectures where they covered things like referencing, plagiarism, attendance, expected behaviours, academic expectations, deadlines etc. Also in DD's case it was to get all the lab equipment and protective wear she needed and to familiarise the students with where everything was.

I wonder if a lot of these badly behaved students skipped these introductory lectures?

All three of mine were the same.
Missing freshers would have put them at a severe disadvantage.
Different units were explained so they could make the choice prior to the start of the course.

For all three, different unis and different courses, there were lectures on the basics during freshers week. Like yours the science courses did intros in lab safety, explaining the machines etc.

Its not all just party party

FarEast · 27/10/2023 13:20

Good luck with getting management to support you when you do, when their focus is on retention and achievement because their funding is dependent on those things. (The crieria for funding is a whole other issue.)

And the raking over the coals you'll get (and your whole Department) of students moan about being disciplined etc in the NSS.