Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you work in a university have you noticed a recent change in student behaviour?

333 replies

0987ghj · 26/10/2023 11:26

I graduated from university in 2019, and have now returned to study a different course. I've noticed a big difference in student behaviour and I wondered if it's something that university staff have also noticed or if it's just my course.

I'm hoping that this thread doesn't seem like I'm trying to slate current university students/gen Z. A few of the examples I've seen are from mature students, so I don't think it's generational/an age thing.

There's a lot of talking now during lectures, people just talking loudly whilst the lecturer is talking (not even whispering). It's pretty brazen and full on conversations, not just a quick question or comment, and really distracting. People are often late quite a lot, there's routinely a few students who are 40+ minutes late to a 2-hour lecture. I know there are some reasons people may be late such as childcare issues, or traffic or illnesses like IBS that make it hard to leave the house in the mornings so that might just be why, but it's a lot more lateness than I ever saw in my degree before. There would be the occasional person 5-10 minutes late, but not 40+ minutes.

People also start packing up and starting to leave before the lecturer has even finished talking. Our lectures always finish slightly early to allow time to walk to other lectures so there's not really any need for it. I don't remember this happening before, unless it was because the lecture had ran over and even then people would quietly/subtly pack up.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Kittykatastrophe · 04/11/2023 23:48

Ooh @Autumnvibes23 Are we too posh to wash ??? 😏😉.

I joined the NHS in 1994 as an auxiliary nurse on a 120 bedded acute elderly block . It was hard graft which I loved . I certainly wasn’t academic then . 2 years later I started my nurse training purely because I had NVQ level 3 and I had an insight into actual nursing . These days I’m an advanced practitioner with a masters etc , how? I really do not know because I’m not brainy by any means but I have common sense and I’m not afraid of hard graft . The practical skills I had attained during my time as an auxiliary helped me during my training as I was unfazed by death, nudity and bodily fluids which incidentally caused a lot my intake to leave the course I after the first ward placement . Yes there is a lot more to nursing nowadays , some good some not so good . Actually caring about other humans , wanting to make a difference is nowhere near as apparent among the majority of the student nurse population that I interact with which saddens me greatly . A lot of excellent colleagues have not gone on to do their nurse training because of the academic aspect and the attitude towards them from people who profess to be “very academic” who are probably in a post where they don’t wear a uniform and walk round with a clipboard all day 🙄

PumpkinPie2016 · 02/11/2023 19:54

I'm not a lecturer but when I went to uni 2005-2009, no one behaved in that way on my course (I read Physics) 😳

Talking over someone/texting etc is just plain bad manners. I'm surprised the lecturer doesn't ask them to leave!

I have just completed an MA part time, online and alongside a family and full time job. Most of the course was in the same position and it is far from easy. However, the number who would never complete the discussion post activities/left assignments to the very last minute and then were pleading for help on the forum at the 11th hour or wanting extensions was unreal.
Obviously, occasionally things happen but it was the same people over and over.

ColleenDonaghy · 02/11/2023 19:44

OchonAgusOchonOh · 02/11/2023 19:27

The reality is that drive to succeed, hard work, good behaviour etc is correlated with high entry requirements. The requirements may not be strictly academic (e.g. Art portfolio) but still require hard work and effort. Courses with low entry requirements, regardless of the university, have the opposite.

Exactly.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 02/11/2023 19:27

PhotoDad · 02/11/2023 19:08

Absolutely! It's just that some other PP have been making the connection "drive to succeed" = "high grades" and I was giving a gentle reminder that it ain't necessarily so.

The reality is that drive to succeed, hard work, good behaviour etc is correlated with high entry requirements. The requirements may not be strictly academic (e.g. Art portfolio) but still require hard work and effort. Courses with low entry requirements, regardless of the university, have the opposite.

ColleenDonaghy · 02/11/2023 19:22

PhotoDad · 02/11/2023 19:08

Absolutely! It's just that some other PP have been making the connection "drive to succeed" = "high grades" and I was giving a gentle reminder that it ain't necessarily so.

Actually across a whole undergraduate cohort I suspect it is. Again we're not talking about individuals here, we're talking majority of cases.

IME more specialised courses tend to have more motivated students as well, because those students have been driven to apply for that course by a real interest in the subject. Whereas more generalist courses tend to have more people who applied because they had to apply for something and this seemed the least worst option.

PhotoDad · 02/11/2023 19:08

OchonAgusOchonOh · 02/11/2023 17:28

The comment that was referred to as snobbery said courses that were harder to get in to, not ones that required better academic results. Drama/music/art, generally require a level is skill to be demonstrated either via interview or portfolio. You cannot demonstrate that level of skill without having put work into it and they are therefore generally hard to get in to for anyone who hasn't the talent and put the work in.

Absolutely! It's just that some other PP have been making the connection "drive to succeed" = "high grades" and I was giving a gentle reminder that it ain't necessarily so.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 02/11/2023 18:34

ludocris · 02/11/2023 18:29

It referred to 'bums on seats' universities with lower admissions requirements which we all know means academic grades the vast majority of the time.

I think the reason I find it snobbish is because it over simplifies the situation, and doesn't take into account other reasons for the attainment gap, including socioeconomic conditions and factors such as caring responsibilities, students who come from broken homes etc.. There are a great many reasons affecting academic performance, not just how well behaved you are in classes.

Yes, there are many reasons. However, as a lecturer, I can tell you that in my experience there is a correlation between academic achievement required for entry and behaviour in class.

There are obviously individual differences within classes but a cohort that have had to achieve well for entry tends to result in a better work ethic and more attention and engagement in class.

ludocris · 02/11/2023 18:29

It referred to 'bums on seats' universities with lower admissions requirements which we all know means academic grades the vast majority of the time.

I think the reason I find it snobbish is because it over simplifies the situation, and doesn't take into account other reasons for the attainment gap, including socioeconomic conditions and factors such as caring responsibilities, students who come from broken homes etc.. There are a great many reasons affecting academic performance, not just how well behaved you are in classes.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 02/11/2023 17:28

ludocris · 02/11/2023 16:30

But those students have presumably worked very hard at music/acting/art to get in to those courses and are simply continuing with that in the same way those on more academic courses who achieved well are continuing.

Exactly @OchonAgusOchonOh. So students who get lower academic grades aren't necessarily going to be worse behaved than those with high grades....

The comment that was referred to as snobbery said courses that were harder to get in to, not ones that required better academic results. Drama/music/art, generally require a level is skill to be demonstrated either via interview or portfolio. You cannot demonstrate that level of skill without having put work into it and they are therefore generally hard to get in to for anyone who hasn't the talent and put the work in.

ludocris · 02/11/2023 16:30

But those students have presumably worked very hard at music/acting/art to get in to those courses and are simply continuing with that in the same way those on more academic courses who achieved well are continuing.

Exactly @OchonAgusOchonOh. So students who get lower academic grades aren't necessarily going to be worse behaved than those with high grades....

ColleenDonaghy · 02/11/2023 14:19

Blinkityblonk · 02/11/2023 14:05

I do think though, that quiet and no rudeness should be the standard for all classes, not dependent on the lecturer to enforce that, it's hard on newer lecturers. Again, the tone should be set at the top and any that don't do that should be visiting the Head of Education, just as poor/rude/unprepared lecturers should also be reported.

Yes we had some younger, less experienced lecturers being challenged on their marks last year - very inappropriately, referencing mental health and suicide etc. Our senior staff are extremely supportive and helped them deal appropriately.

Blinkityblonk · 02/11/2023 14:05

I do think though, that quiet and no rudeness should be the standard for all classes, not dependent on the lecturer to enforce that, it's hard on newer lecturers. Again, the tone should be set at the top and any that don't do that should be visiting the Head of Education, just as poor/rude/unprepared lecturers should also be reported.

Blinkityblonk · 02/11/2023 13:59

In their defence- my students this year are lovely! RG uni. All very enthusiastic, I say all, probably two-thirds are anyway and if the others don't attend, that's on them and will reflect in their marks.

I don't tolerate talking in my lectures, if two people start whispering or chatting, I do the Hard Paddington stare and wait for them to finish. I only have to do this once or twice a term and everyone realises this isn't a lecture for chatting! If they are on Insta instead of listening to me, but quiet and not interfering with other's concentration, that's on them.

I also don't have problems with lateness, it's absolutely 5 min max and always with an apology.

I think students see how other students behave and so I set out my stall very early. I'm a very committed lecturer and give a lot to them in terms of my time and energy and in return I expect politeness, courtesy to other students and some engagement.

I feel this group has been so short-changed by Covid, a lot of them are keen to learn. I have had issues in the past with lots of emails about silly things, or the odd difficult student, but nothing unmanageable. I would not get disciplined unless I did something truly terrible though like was racist, so I do feel my head of education has my back.

I could not cope with the classroom problems of secondary for one second, but I don't generally have them, for which I am truly grateful.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 02/11/2023 13:52

I haven’t been at uni in a decade, but the difference between early 00s (UG) and 2010s (PG) was astounding. I was used to not even having powerpoint presentations in UG lectures - you made your own notes, nothing was provided to you for reference after. Students tended to group together with friends and compare their notes to build a bigger and better resource for exam prep.

I was 10 mins late once as an UG (slept in) and the shame as I walked in was something I can still feel when I recall it now.

By contrast, at PG level everything was provided - presentations and lecturer notes all online, everything recorded for later listening, lecturers would hold online study groups on portals, all sorts. So much chatting in lectures, lateness, ambivalence, students not caring. I was really taken aback by it.

I can’t imagine what it’s like now - must be horrendous. The quality of graduates coming through into the profession is definitely very poor - not in their academic skills per se but the soft skills. Their SPAG is shocking, they don’t seem to know how to write emails, and they’re abrupt and rude to other people.

ChocolateCakeOverspill · 02/11/2023 09:21

The thing about being late, at our university if people have recommendations for reasonable adjustments this might mean that there is a statement in there saying people can arrive late and leave early and the lecturers shouldn’t draw attention to it. Firstly it’s practically impossible in a cohort of hundreds to know who has a learning contract and what it says and secondly if you comment to some students and not to others it would be clear who has a disability which is a breach of confidentiality. So you just have to let everyone get away with it, it sets out a culture of just coming and going as you want. In fact a friend did pull up some students for wandering in 45 minutes into an hour and a half session and they complained and she had to apologise.

ColleenDonaghy · 02/11/2023 09:20

OchonAgusOchonOh · 02/11/2023 09:10

But those students have presumably worked very hard at music/acting/art to get in to those courses and are simply continuing with that in the same way those on more academic courses who achieved well are continuing.

Yeah they're probably the most passionate and engaged students around!

OchonAgusOchonOh · 02/11/2023 09:10

PhotoDad · 02/11/2023 09:05

Agreed with the general sentiment, but with the addition that A-level grades aren't always the best or only measure. Plenty of very talented and driven kids on music/acting/arts courses with low academic grades!

But those students have presumably worked very hard at music/acting/art to get in to those courses and are simply continuing with that in the same way those on more academic courses who achieved well are continuing.

PhotoDad · 02/11/2023 09:05

Agreed with the general sentiment, but with the addition that A-level grades aren't always the best or only measure. Plenty of very talented and driven kids on music/acting/arts courses with low academic grades!

ColleenDonaghy · 02/11/2023 08:52

In our school we have cohorts with entry requirements ranging from the highest to the lowest in the (RG) university. There is definitely a correlation between entry requirement and engagement, and between (unsurprisingly) uni marks and engagement.

Obviously at an individual level some students with low marks will be fantastically dedicated, and some with high marks will be awful, but it is definitely easier to teach a high achieving group.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 02/11/2023 08:49

ludocris · 02/11/2023 08:44

Nope. Suggesting that students who don't achieve the highest grades/don't have the privilege of going to Oxbridge are worst behaved than those who do is snobbish.

It's not at all snobbish. In Ireland students get into courses based on a points system. One of the courses I teach on has fluctuated a bit over the years. When points are high, students are more diligent and attentive and thus better behaved.

It makes sense. If they've worked hard in school and achieved well, they are likely to continue doing so. And yes, I know not all students who work hard achieve high grades but nobody achieves very high grades without work. It just comes easier to some than others.

ludocris · 02/11/2023 08:44

FarEast · 02/11/2023 08:07

So achieving academically is snobbish? I've heard it all now.

Nope. Suggesting that students who don't achieve the highest grades/don't have the privilege of going to Oxbridge are worst behaved than those who do is snobbish.

FarEast · 02/11/2023 08:07

So achieving academically is snobbish? I've heard it all now.

ludocris · 02/11/2023 07:59

CurlyhairedAssassin · 29/10/2023 00:29

Does it depend on how hard it is to get into the uni concerned, I wonder? My son's a second year at Cambridge. His course is full on, he works ultra hard or he won't keep up. If you're 5 mins late to a lecture you're not allowed in. The disruption would be too much to the other students. They all worked hard for their place and know it's a privilege to be there and are all academic anyway. They wouldn't jeopardise it by not handing work in or not turning up to labs or supervisions.

The unis whose admission requirements are lower and which need bums on seats to survive - are they going to attract the most hard-working and dedicated students?

This comes across as a little snobbish I'm afraid. The playing field isn't equal.

Annemaria · 30/10/2023 15:11

Of course students now are the “customers” and they are allowed to make dubious criticisms, sometimes vengeful, of their lecturers which would not have pertained in the past. I think it is disgraceful that lecturers have to be nervous of student feedback. The judgements of immature students should be dismissed.

BigBrightStarz · 30/10/2023 05:34

I completely agree. I've been out of education for a while. However, I started my university degree in 2022/2023. I'm completely taken aback by the amount of students, both young and elder generation, who just seem like they're not bothered at all.

It's the same as your experience, walking in/out of class loudly, packing away items whilst the lecturer is speaking, having full blown discussions, laughing and talking over the lecturer, despite being asked to be quiet a number of times. Some people even falling asleep during class and not even hiding it. It's completely blown me away 😕

Swipe left for the next trending thread