Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or Are Humblebrags on the Rise Here?

63 replies

Dguu6u · 26/10/2023 08:09

I've been around these parts for a while, and lately, I can't help but notice something that's been bugging me. Maybe it's just me, or perhaps there's a trend going on here, and I'd love to know if you've picked up on it too.

It seems like there's been a surge in threads where people are airing their money concerns, cost of living issues, and the struggle to make it all work – all while sneaking in these subtle humblebrags about their rather cushy situations. You know, the ones where they casually drop their £100K salaries, or talk about their 5-bedroom house with the 'small rooms', or are able to afford expensive houses, fancy cars, and luxuries, all while saying they expect to have more money left over at the end of the month.

I totally get that financial situations differ from person to person. But it's a bit tough to relate when so many of us are grappling with rising costs, bills piling up, and just trying to make ends meet.

So, I gotta ask: is it just me, or are you seeing more of this too? Is it because I'm noticing it more due to all the current struggles we're facing, or are these type of posts really on the rise here?

Am I being unreasonable in feeling this way? What's your take? 🤔🤷‍♀️🙏

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Caththegreat · 02/02/2024 04:41

Yep

Zebedee55 · 26/10/2023 17:47

lightinthebox · 26/10/2023 08:50

These are the posts that scream fake to me.

Earning a high salary (so surely some degree of higher education and intelligence) but unable to apply common sense and basic budgeting?

Honestly, I take MN with a large pinch of salt. All these people in high earning jobs have time to post on MN all day? Sure 🙄

A lot of social media is fantasy land. Anyone can say they earn whatever, and live in whatever, work at whatever, but it doesn't always make it true.😉

CreationNat1on · 26/10/2023 17:33

I don't think the "humble brag is any worse than the" false poor mouth", just fucking own it.

ShirleyPhallus · 26/10/2023 17:26

lightinthebox · 26/10/2023 16:40

On MN everyone’s husband has a high salary and you can’t discuss his hobby because it’s ‘outing’.

MN is a forum of pure fantasy and delusion.

I find it really sad when women brag about the achievements of their husband.

ALWAYS on threads of “if you earn 6 figures how did you do it?” Posters come on to talk about their husband. Not the question is it

MolyHacaroni · 26/10/2023 17:14

I don't know about that but the kind I have an issue with [and it's been happening for ages] is where someone comes into a thread, like some of the cost of living ones, and says that they're lucky they aren't struggling but they feel for those on the thread and outside world who're sharing that they're struggling.

I think it's highly insensitive, beyond humble bragging and just cruel. No one would know if they scrolled past. if they really wanted to say something, they could've simply just added their "condolence" without saying anything else about themselves because it is completely irrelevant and unnecessary, but nope. It seems they can't help but share how well they're doing while patting the heads of those on the thread who're not doing well.

It probably makes them feel better about their lives but I find it disturbing and I rarely post on those threads for this reason. I think it's best to let people grieve/struggle in peace without inserting "my better life" into their conversation.

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 26/10/2023 17:02

lightinthebox · 26/10/2023 16:40

On MN everyone’s husband has a high salary and you can’t discuss his hobby because it’s ‘outing’.

MN is a forum of pure fantasy and delusion.

Yes, and I'd bet my monthly salary that in 99% of cases the hobby is football, cycling, or golf!

Those well known niche, outing activities.

roundtable · 26/10/2023 16:58

Mn has always had the braggy posters. I don't think they are fawned over like they used to a decade plus ago though thankfully. Some of them were exposed as total fantasists.

I find the funny in those posts though. I suspect most of them aren't real. The ones bragging about their child exceptionally gifted or talented or tall/modelesque dc do make me eyeroll a tad sometimes.

Not the one off ones were a parent is thrilled about an accomplishment their child/ren has achieved through hard work and dedication. I completely get that and that should be celebrated.

However, there's a difference between being proud of your child/ren rather than living vicariously through them/using them as a method to make the parent seem so very amazing.

lightinthebox · 26/10/2023 16:40

On MN everyone’s husband has a high salary and you can’t discuss his hobby because it’s ‘outing’.

MN is a forum of pure fantasy and delusion.

Floogal · 26/10/2023 16:29

At least ast the humblebragging isn't as bad on MN as it is on the Student room. Example: "Am I good enough for Exeter University with A,A,a*?"

Mumsnet seems to be full of "ugh, everyone fancies me". Or just dropping in above average IQs, gifted and talented kids as well as the high salaries into conversation.

CroccyWoccy · 26/10/2023 15:37

I guess there’s some threads where people lack self-awareness but most people have concerns which seem trivial to someone else in a worse position. It doesn’t mean that they don’t want advice or to talk the issue through with other people.

”How do I treat my in growing toe nail?”
”You should be grateful you even have two feet!”

Where does it end? None of us can have a whinge if we’re not terminally ill or living in war zone?

Wednesdaysotherchild · 26/10/2023 15:31

You’re probably just more sensitive to it because of your own experiences.

notlucreziaborgia · 26/10/2023 15:23

EatYourVegetables · 26/10/2023 14:15

YANBU, but I don’t think it’s humblebrags. I think it’s people who are honestly so self centred that they think they have it hard.

Eg:

  1. I heard there is a COL crisis, and this year skiing will cost us a little more than last year. Write a thread about the squeezed middle and how we’re not getting any government help while others are!

  2. I heard there are MN threads about overcrowding and people trying to figure out how to best use their space. I want in on the discussion! Our fifth bedroom is quite small, and we don’t have enough rooms for a guest room AND two home offices. Start a thread complaining how we’re overcrowded!

  3. I heard thousands of people died in Israel. I wonder if it’s safe for me to go to London, in light of this?

The irony.

As if thinking every thread has to centre you/your preferred group to be performative on behalf of isn’t self centred.

If someone’s thread isn’t relatable to you, who cares? It doesn’t have to be. You don’t have to approve, or even engage at all.

EatYourVegetables · 26/10/2023 14:15

YANBU, but I don’t think it’s humblebrags. I think it’s people who are honestly so self centred that they think they have it hard.

Eg:

  1. I heard there is a COL crisis, and this year skiing will cost us a little more than last year. Write a thread about the squeezed middle and how we’re not getting any government help while others are!

  2. I heard there are MN threads about overcrowding and people trying to figure out how to best use their space. I want in on the discussion! Our fifth bedroom is quite small, and we don’t have enough rooms for a guest room AND two home offices. Start a thread complaining how we’re overcrowded!

  3. I heard thousands of people died in Israel. I wonder if it’s safe for me to go to London, in light of this?

yeekls · 26/10/2023 14:11

I saw one the other day... "we earn £340k and can't afford to send our only child to private achool"

There was a post yesterday where she said they earned £200,000 but didn't feel well off, they just saw those as earning less as being poor...the frightening thing is I believe they were being entirely genuine...

ManyMaybes · 26/10/2023 13:56

I think sometimes people like the opportunity to discuss things like this with other people.

They may not know many other people in the same financial situation as them so can’t talk about that part of their life in the real world, but it is still something they want to talk about.

All2Well · 26/10/2023 13:55

I saw one the other day... "we earn £340k and can't afford to send our only child to private achool" 🤔

Rogue1001MNer · 26/10/2023 13:49

Like a couple of other posters, I assume a lot on mn is creative fiction

notlucreziaborgia · 26/10/2023 13:29

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 26/10/2023 12:51

This isn't "struggling" though. It's bad money management, plain and simple. They have options available to them that would reduce their outgoings (e.g. not to take out the expense car lease) and they choose not to exercise those options.

"Struggling" is where people have limited or no options to reduce their outgoings, and are still unable to make ends meet.

Having no money left at the end of the month through choice is not the same as being in that position through necessity. It's amazing how many people don't seem to recognise the difference. You see it all the time on here ("Oh, but we are squeezed and really struggling, because private school fees are so high, and we have an enormous mortgage on our detached house")

Edited

A lot of people are in a situation where things they can not longer easily afford things that at one point they could, despite making the same or even more money. Aka struggling to meet their usual costs. No one said there aren’t people that have it worse, that does tend to go without saying (or must a lower earner in the UK have to mention lower earners in third world countries, lest they be accused on not recognising their privilege?). The point is that people are fully entitled to post about their own situations without making a performance of centering X group. Those in or sympathetic with X group are free to ignore the threads they don’t like, and/or make their own.

Of course people are going to be pissed off and frustrated with being in the aforementioned situation of struggling to pay for their normal lifestyle. Despite some being in a better position than others to readjust and cut costs, it’s still a position that they’re not going to enjoy being in. That other people have it worse doesn’t change this. That other people have it worse doesn’t mean they have to shut up and never speak on their own issues.

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 26/10/2023 12:51

tiggergoesbounce · 26/10/2023 10:22

The thing is, being a high earner does not mean you have a comfortable house. It can be that they have the big house, thats in negative equity, all cars on tick or company cars so they dont own them and the bills on their big houses swallow their salaries. So they can't release any cash and they live to their limit, so they do struggle. They are just as likely to struggle as anyone else.

Ive know people at both ends and the person who earns less has more free cash as they are better with money.

And yes of course, some come on to brag, thats ok. Just see it for what it is and move on, there has always been the braggers on here, its nothing new.

This isn't "struggling" though. It's bad money management, plain and simple. They have options available to them that would reduce their outgoings (e.g. not to take out the expense car lease) and they choose not to exercise those options.

"Struggling" is where people have limited or no options to reduce their outgoings, and are still unable to make ends meet.

Having no money left at the end of the month through choice is not the same as being in that position through necessity. It's amazing how many people don't seem to recognise the difference. You see it all the time on here ("Oh, but we are squeezed and really struggling, because private school fees are so high, and we have an enormous mortgage on our detached house")

notlucreziaborgia · 26/10/2023 10:55

Angryappendix · 26/10/2023 10:48

@ShirleyPhallus @notlucreziaborgia
I said SOME in my original post.

Some rich people are happy some aren’t, some poorer people are happy, some aren’t.

I am in the middle, I would be gutted if I couldn’t go abroad for my holidays or buy the clothes I want or eat the food I like BUT I’d also be gutted it I worked 9-7 never saw my child but had a huge house and car and was squeezed even though I earned alot. I appreciate not all rich people are in this circumstance but some are.

You said that those that think they’re happy are kidding themselves, having been tricked by society. This based on your own individual ideas as to what would make you happy. Why the assumption that people are tricking themselves, rather than finding their happiness in different things to you?

’The rich are secretly miserable when compared with those with less’ is a tired trope based less on actual reality and more so on wishful thinking.

Angryappendix · 26/10/2023 10:50

I also appreciate some people are really affected by the cost of living, whether they were well off before or poor.

It’s been a difficult time for everyone. Peace and love x

Angryappendix · 26/10/2023 10:48

@ShirleyPhallus @notlucreziaborgia
I said SOME in my original post.

Some rich people are happy some aren’t, some poorer people are happy, some aren’t.

I am in the middle, I would be gutted if I couldn’t go abroad for my holidays or buy the clothes I want or eat the food I like BUT I’d also be gutted it I worked 9-7 never saw my child but had a huge house and car and was squeezed even though I earned alot. I appreciate not all rich people are in this circumstance but some are.

Nevermind31 · 26/10/2023 10:32

Some might come to brag, but others might just like discussing their issues?
yrs, people with more money have more choices, but it really isn’t as easy as selling your 5 bed detached in the south east and moving your kids to the North.
jobs, family, friends, school, support network…

tiggergoesbounce · 26/10/2023 10:22

The thing is, being a high earner does not mean you have a comfortable house. It can be that they have the big house, thats in negative equity, all cars on tick or company cars so they dont own them and the bills on their big houses swallow their salaries. So they can't release any cash and they live to their limit, so they do struggle. They are just as likely to struggle as anyone else.

Ive know people at both ends and the person who earns less has more free cash as they are better with money.

And yes of course, some come on to brag, thats ok. Just see it for what it is and move on, there has always been the braggers on here, its nothing new.

Unicorn2022 · 26/10/2023 10:18

There are always the exceptions but I find that the high earners who have been brought up in wealthy families and been given all the financial support and opportunities are those least likely to have any idea about budgeting. They probably do feel hard done when they realise their £100k salary doesn't afford them the same lifestyle they had growing up.

My boss earns several million and has two kids at university in the UK. He pays for their fees and accommodation and gives them an allowance of £2500 a month each and a car. They are planning to become lawyers, probably helped by their dad's contacts. If they ever had to fend for themselves on a trainee solicitor salary of £52k they would have a very nasty shock indeed.