Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that any one who designs a town, building, theme park or attraction should have to spend the day navigating it in a wheelchair?

133 replies

Flufferblub · 26/10/2023 07:31

Needed a wheelchair on some days since my early 30s, and the experience has been eye opening. Some spaces seem well designed such as airports, but others it feels like disabled people are a complete after thought. Even in new places that have just been built in the past few years. You can understand in historic towns and places, but if some where has been designed and built in the 21st century, you'd think that they'd put a button to open the disabled toilet door.

The people who design and run these places need to spend a day getting around in a wheelchair. Design it with wheelchairs in mind first, and everyone else will be alright. Who doesn't like a ramp and automatic doors any way?

OP posts:
magicmole · 26/10/2023 10:33

Lemonyfuckit · 26/10/2023 08:44

I agree OP. My DF was a lecturer in design, and he used to run a module where he made the students spend time in a wheelchair and wearing a blindfold navigating buildings / transport etc so they could experience the challenges of getting about day to day with a disability, and hopefully design better to meet everyone's needs.

An ex of mine had to do similar exercises when a student. They found how hard it was to navigate their own campus with a disability let alone making their way around the city. That was 20+ years ago so it's likely that some of the people on the course have gone out into the workplace and been involved in creating brand new buildings which are still inaccessible.

I can imagine lots of reasons why things might be excluded/forgotten during the design and build process like an architect with a "vision" prioritising style over function or the groupthink of committees. And of course money. But I wish more of them would apply what people like your DF taught them.

Beamur · 26/10/2023 10:24

I have been sent on a training course to give me a small idea of this. It was illuminating - I hope I did bring what I learned to work. (Public sector).
As a Guide Leader a few years ago we did several weeks of activities all around disability awareness, we had a talk and visit from Guide dogs and lots of other things. For a while one of our Guides was in a wheelchair and finding things to do as a group which included her was much less easy away from where we met (which was fully accessible).

IncomingTraffic · 26/10/2023 10:20

And as @ButWhatAboutTheBees explains, sometimes the lip is more accessible for one group of users but less accessible for another.

Ensuring accessibility for everyone can provide impossible. Especially with budgetary constraints. If we set the bar so high that no one can ever afford to build or rennovate anything, only those with no choice to do so will even bother. That helps no one.

sashh · 26/10/2023 10:18

PabloandGustheGreySquirrels · 26/10/2023 08:18

It's not that they don't 'need' to be, it's often that they are either listed buildings and cannot be altered as it would compromise the structural integrity of the building. Or that due to how the building was constructed, there's no physical way of altering it without knocking half of the building down, due to the much sturdier materials used to construct the building, such as stone etc.

There is a hotel near me that claims it can't put a lift or accessible entrance in because they are, "a listed building" which is rubbish, and they built an extension of new bedrooms that are on the ground floor with a fire exit from the corridor on the ground floor.

So they actually have a door from the corridor to the outside on the ground floor but you can only use it to get out of the building.

IncomingTraffic · 26/10/2023 10:17

Lemonyfuckit · 26/10/2023 09:02

Fairly obvious to not have unnecessary height differences......if you are designing something to be accessible. Which really, all public spaces / building / transport should be. I would say have a duty to be, surely it's a mark of a civilised society that public life is accessible and possible to navigate for all.

Which may well add costs of course and there will be complexities. But one of the challenges of good design is to meet all the requirements within the allocated budget.

I think my point is that they might not turn out to be unnecessary. And it may not be obvious to people moving through the building why it’s necessary.

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 26/10/2023 09:31

Ramps aren't suitable for all accessible needs, steps can be easier to navigate if you're unsteady on your feet.

Those bumps at the opening of doors which are uncomfortable for wheelchair users can be there for white stick users so they can feel where the opening is.

Adjusting things down for those under 5 ft can make it inaccessible for those who are taller (or in big, motorised wheelchairs as these tend to be higher)

There's no doubt some things need to be made more accessible like making sure the accessible toilet is actually big enough to get a wheelchair in but some accessible features clash with each other

PissOffKen · 26/10/2023 09:21

Yes, absolutely, and they should have to navigate it blindfold with a white cane as well. There are more disabilities than those that require the use of a wheelchair. The entire world forgets us blind people exist, it’s like they’re blind and can’t see us, it winds me up. I’m all for disability awareness and making adjustments for wheelchair users and other disabilities, absolutely it should be a priority, it would just be nice if we were considered as well, and not ignored, forgotten about, excluded and way off the bottom of the list.

in the town where I commute to to work, they have clearly done the minimum tick list of adjustments, tactile paving, rotating cones on the bottom of light control boxes etc. Unfortunately the tactiles tend to be badly situated on corners and almost impossible for blind people to use without walking themselves out into the middle of a busy junction. There’sl only one rotating cone at each crossing, despite there being two light control boxes,, all pretty poorly situated, one on each side of the poorly situated tactile paving, and the cones all seem to have been placed for the use of a left-handed white cane user. The crossings are dangerous and impractical and I don’t feel safe using them at all. There are a couple that are completely unusable they’re so dangerous, I’d end up dead in a week. It makes me so angry, those things are supposed to be there to help visually impaired people but they’ve done it with absolutely no care or thought and made the whole place much more difficult and dangerous.

sadly I suspect we’ll all have to whistle, because developers and companies are far more interested in cost and aesthetics than they are in actually accommodating people with disabilities. Twas ever thus and it will no doubt remain so.

Iheartmysmart · 26/10/2023 09:18

I remember going to view a new build house a few years ago and a huge deal was made about how the houses had extra wide doorways to allow for wheelchair access. But nearly every single house style had step access to even get in it! And they were really narrow and often at an angle so you couldn’t even install a ramp.

FallingAutumnLeaf · 26/10/2023 09:08

YANBU to say that buildings should be designed appropriately for all users.

However, YABU to think everyone prefers a ramp to steps - I would actively avoid a ramp given a choice.

I have also struggled when a voice intercom was placed at wheelchair height, as I struggled to bend low enough to make myself heard.

Yes, wheelchair access is essential, but the needs of everyone need to be considered - and that may well involve duel systems to cater for everyone.

megletthesecond · 26/10/2023 09:07

Yanbu. I was on crutches for part of the summer and that was an eye opener. I am now obsessed with good stair design. Deep steps, holdable (?), not too slippy or chunky hand rail etc.

Sirzy · 26/10/2023 09:05

New larger public buildings should also have to have a changing places toilet installed in them too. Disabled toilet facilties are shocking for most but even worse for those who need hoisting/tables etc.

Spendonsend · 26/10/2023 09:03

I really think more should be done around disability and street design. I have a blind friend and its mad how many bloody hanging baskets or street signs are at bump your head height. My town has a vision charity that will walk round with the town council when they put new things up but thats only recent.

Lemonyfuckit · 26/10/2023 09:02

IncomingTraffic · 26/10/2023 08:56

it actually seems fairly obvious to not have unnecessary height differences

part of the problem is that accessibility is not the only design constraint in play. There may be other issues that are in no way obvious.

And budgetary constraints … that is very often the biggest barrier. It’s not always immediately obvious why eliminating a height difference might be considerably more expensive.

Fairly obvious to not have unnecessary height differences......if you are designing something to be accessible. Which really, all public spaces / building / transport should be. I would say have a duty to be, surely it's a mark of a civilised society that public life is accessible and possible to navigate for all.

Which may well add costs of course and there will be complexities. But one of the challenges of good design is to meet all the requirements within the allocated budget.

itsmeafterall · 26/10/2023 09:02

I remember being in a newly refurbed outpatient department once, waiting for my (as usual, very late) appointment. In comes the trust CEO and entourage going a PR exercise to show how accessible the new building was. He'd decided (or his PR people no doubt) to do this from an actual wheelchair, although he didn't need one.

There was much fanfare, photos and Hoo-haa. One of the on duty nurses then suggested that he try the disabled toilet that was a door directly off the main waiting area. It turned out that got a wheelchair in there that you couldn't actually close the door 😂😂😂😂. Cue much embarrassment and "erm, please note that down for remedial action" to his beleaguered assistant, and much chuckling behind hands from his staff and 'helpful' suggestions from the smirking staff that maybe it wasn't a problem for him to have a wee with the entire waiting room watching? Appalling design though clearly done by someone with no insight or ability or understanding.

I did then have a bit of fun when the CEO cheerily asked me "well young lady. What do you think of our lovely new building?" Me: "I'd prefer it if didn't have to wait for overrunning appointments for 2-3 hours every time I visit (which was very regularly). He then blamed the consultants for packing their lists too much and that they were incompetent in their scheduling. I answered the case of the overworked drs and asked him to consider , maybe employing more doctors instead of slagging them off? He was mid- blathering some pathetic answer when I finally got called in. Apologising to the consultant for making him wait for me, I explained why, and also what his CEO had just said to me publicly about his incompetence. "Would you mind waiting a few minutes whilst I go and talk to him ?" Asked the lovely consultant. Me: "no problem, full your boots mate". Consultant came back a few minutes later and thanked me for the heads up. I'd love to have been a fly on the wall for that conversation 😬

That CEO, such an imperious wanker. No wonder services for disabled people were so shit. Some PR afterthought for what is a core demographic for hospitals.

I do agree re accessibility though. I despair when new buildings have a beautiful staircases at the front and a titchy scruffy side entrance for people on wheels. Like you're the second rate visitor.

And buttons always high up out of reach.

I'm not a wheelchair user but even I can spot the obvious issues. It's not rocket science to think about it and design spaces that work for everyone. Infuriating.

redskyanight · 26/10/2023 09:00

Yes! I'd add that they should also include people who use mobility aids -they also need accessible buildings but their needs are not always the same as wheelchair users.

I've just spent a few days going to university open days with DD (who uses a mobility aid). I appreciate that a lot of the buildings are old, and accessibility was worked out afterwards, but it was shocking how difficult it was in some places. And that some places had zero signage and you were somehow meant to work out that getting to the only lift involved going in the side door and through a maze of corridors.

Sirzy · 26/10/2023 08:58

Ideally people with a wide variety of disabilities would be involved in the process. You can obviously never make anywhere fit everyone’s needs but by having a range of people in the discussion you can make it as accessible as possible.

too many places just do a box ticking exercise for disabled facilties rather than thinking what is actually needed.

ticketstickets · 26/10/2023 08:58

LovelaceBiggWither · 26/10/2023 08:04

The fact is that accessible buildings help everyone, they don't suddenly inconvenience other users.

yes, most people will be parents with a baby in a buggy at some point.

As a parent of small babies, bus travel was only accessible to me when they intorduced the wheelchair accessible busses.

IncomingTraffic · 26/10/2023 08:56

it actually seems fairly obvious to not have unnecessary height differences

part of the problem is that accessibility is not the only design constraint in play. There may be other issues that are in no way obvious.

And budgetary constraints … that is very often the biggest barrier. It’s not always immediately obvious why eliminating a height difference might be considerably more expensive.

Rosecoffeecup · 26/10/2023 08:51

Porridgeislife · 26/10/2023 08:04

Our very new office building would be impossible for a wheelchair user and I’ve thought this often! I genuinely don’t know what the architect was thinking.

The only way onto each secured floor is to swipe your card approx 2.5m away from the door handle, which gives you about 3 seconds to open it before it locks again - it’s sufficiently quick that I miss it fairly often. The glass door is large, heavy and only opens one way.

Exactly the same in my office. Then once you're into a secure floor, half the meeting rooms and offices have heavy, manual sliding doors which need a real tug to open

IncomingTraffic · 26/10/2023 08:50

I think, conceptually, this is one of the drawbacks of a purely social model of disability. There’s some sort of utopian aspiration/hope embedded in it that, if only we could get the design of social and material environments right, no one will be excluded (or disabled by any impairment they may have).

It’s not that this is entirely wrong or anything. But pragmatically it’s not going to work out that way. And some kinds of impairment are going to be experienced as disability in all circumstances.

(I also hate the term impairment, but it’s used in disability studies for a reason).

Inclusive design is so important. But there are always complexities and trade offs. One person’s accessible is another’s totally inaccessible. And it’s not always obvious where these complexities will arise.

Lemonyfuckit · 26/10/2023 08:49

LovelaceBiggWither · 26/10/2023 08:04

The fact is that accessible buildings help everyone, they don't suddenly inconvenience other users.

100% this.

Lemonyfuckit · 26/10/2023 08:48

lamalamalamasquirrel · 26/10/2023 07:55

I personally feel they should consider employing people specifically for this on their team. It's too important to leave it to one person to do it as a side project.

Yes, it should be central to how buildings / public spaces / transport is designed in the first place. It also strikes me (without wanting to sound flippant) as not being terribly difficult to do, PROVIDED people give it some thought in the first place - ie it actually seems fairly obvious to not have unnecessary height differences, where there are height differences to include a ramp, to put buttons to open things at wheelchair height, to make doorways and openings wide enough, to put handrails in certain places etc etc.

Lemonyfuckit · 26/10/2023 08:44

I agree OP. My DF was a lecturer in design, and he used to run a module where he made the students spend time in a wheelchair and wearing a blindfold navigating buildings / transport etc so they could experience the challenges of getting about day to day with a disability, and hopefully design better to meet everyone's needs.

IncomingTraffic · 26/10/2023 08:43

As for buildings access, the amount of places...including hospitals that have bumps on the floor in doorways is nuts. Have you ever tried to get a wheelchair over one of those without causing the wheelchair user more pain? Impossible!

This is potentially one of those areas where there are incompatible needs and purposes (not in all cases - it often is just crap design!).

but there can be reasons why a lip at a threshold might be more accessible to some point but less accessible to others. It’s often quite complex to meet all needs (and other requirements that aren’t obvious).

LittleLegsKeepGoing · 26/10/2023 08:32

My mother's local town has had a huge redevelopment to the section that leads to the shopmobility (you know, where the disabled parking is) bit. So a redevelopment designed and signed off in the last 10 years.

For some insane reason the entire walkway leading to/from the shopmobility and the shopping area is canted - the only part of it that's actually horizontal is criss crossed with dipped drainage channels or the flower beds.

It's a nightmare trying to safely push a wheelchair through that section and not tip my mother into the flower beds. I can't even imagine how much more difficult it would be for someone to navigate it themselves. I'd also expect people who have visual impairment to struggle on the section.

As for buildings access, the amount of places...including hospitals that have bumps on the floor in doorways is nuts. Have you ever tried to get a wheelchair over one of those without causing the wheelchair user more pain? Impossible!

This is the 21st century, we are constantly being told we need to be inclusive but day to day councils, hospitals, government officials, businesses don't actually try to be inclusive beyond waving a stupid sodding flag now and again.

Swipe left for the next trending thread