Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that any one who designs a town, building, theme park or attraction should have to spend the day navigating it in a wheelchair?

133 replies

Flufferblub · 26/10/2023 07:31

Needed a wheelchair on some days since my early 30s, and the experience has been eye opening. Some spaces seem well designed such as airports, but others it feels like disabled people are a complete after thought. Even in new places that have just been built in the past few years. You can understand in historic towns and places, but if some where has been designed and built in the 21st century, you'd think that they'd put a button to open the disabled toilet door.

The people who design and run these places need to spend a day getting around in a wheelchair. Design it with wheelchairs in mind first, and everyone else will be alright. Who doesn't like a ramp and automatic doors any way?

OP posts:
SerendipityJane · 26/10/2023 12:55

Yes, have all the seminars you like about reasonable adjustments and rest breaks

Held in inaccessible buildings, naturally.

There was a massive sigh of relied when Teams/Zoom became normalised, as it meant no need to spend money on adjustments.

Once again - prove me wrong.

Doormatnomore · 26/10/2023 12:52

i always bring this up when there’s underemployed disabled people or more often helping getting the disabled into work. Yes, have all the seminars you like about reasonable adjustments and rest breaks but you actually need a line of the job advert that says whether you can actually access the building. Cause all the shops, offices, hospitals and cafes mentioned on this thread are off limits. My last office was all singing all dancing and cost eye watering sums. Lift access to all floors, great except once in the lift most chairs couldn’t turn around so you had to hope someone was there to yell which floor it was - such a stupid mistake. Anyway then covid happened and it me 1 person could use a lift at a time so a queue of thousands.

SerendipityJane · 26/10/2023 12:51

lamalamalamasquirrel · 26/10/2023 07:55

I personally feel they should consider employing people specifically for this on their team. It's too important to leave it to one person to do it as a side project.

They do.

Just as a friend who uses a wheelchair discovered, not people who have disabilities.

Disbelievers are free to find examples that contradict me, of course.

Bookworm20 · 26/10/2023 12:25

Yes 100% agree with this. I don't know why it isn't done.

I am not a wheelchair user but I had to use one for a couple of months a few years back following an operation.

And my god, what an eye opener. I was actually embarrassed i'd basically sailed through my life thus far blissfully unaware how challenging it was. I honestly hadn't realised just how difficult every single bloody thing was for wheelchair users. Even some fairly new buildings which I just assumed would be fine, were not! How, in this day and age, they cannot get it right I have no idea.

BodegaSushi · 26/10/2023 12:24

Ithinkitstimeforbed · 26/10/2023 11:03

I am ashamed I only realised how inaccessible how many places were until I started pushing a pram- prams which are maybe more manoeuvrable and easier for other people to assist with. I’m often in places thinking how on earth is a wheelchair user meant to navigate this! I am near 3 tube stations and not one with step free access! Or when people park on the road and you can’t fit through, or those bloody lime bikes taking up the whole pavement! I know making somewhere accessible for everyone is impossible but absolutely agree and am surprised anyone could have voted Yabu!

Or bin day, where the pavement is littered with bins all day despite collection in the morning

Ratfinkstinkypink · 26/10/2023 12:10

I have a child who is 3, registered blind, is fully dependent on others for all of his needs, the world is a pretty inaccessible place for children like him. Even at our local hospital the Changing Places bathroom was full of equipment meaning the bed and hoist were not accessible.

gotomomo · 26/10/2023 12:06

Yanbu - after all flat entry and wide doors benefit another larger demographic, parents not to mention the elderly! I had a double buggy for two years, it was an eye opener! (My older dd has asd so it was used longer than normal thus heavier children? Yes as others have said we need to recognise all disabilities but push button doors and slopes are enabling for all!

BodegaSushi · 26/10/2023 11:59

Also can I add that disabled people shouldn't have to jump through hoops either to access things where the rest of the public don't.

Eg: recently went to a London museum after it was closed for well over a year for a refurb. Before leaving I accompanied my disabled client to the toilets. Took the lifts down and walked to the end, only to find that the locked door couldn't be opened with a radar key, but with another one that you had to get from staff.

So we had to walk back and wander looking for a member of staff, found one who had to go and find another member of staff to bring said key. And to top it all off, we ended up being locked in and had to pound on the door and wait to be let out.

It's so dehumanising.

Flufferblub · 26/10/2023 11:51

Yes there should be both 👍

OP posts:
ColleenDonaghy · 26/10/2023 11:49

Flufferblub · 26/10/2023 11:36

I completely agree that all disabilities need to be accommodated of course. I was just speaking from my perspective as a wheelchair user. But who's going to be fucked off by a ramp and automatic doors? Or better yet, a smooth level with automatic doors.

Ramps are harder than steps for people with prosthetic legs I believe, and possibly some visual impairments (hard to gauge the steepness of the ramp).

So there should be both.

TigerRag · 26/10/2023 11:48

They're developing part of town. Some eejit has put bollards in the middle of one of the paths which you won't be able to get through with a pram / wheelchair / mobility scooter.

elephantandorchid · 26/10/2023 11:47

@SerendipityJane I wonder if we live near to the same hospital? I was taking a relative to hospital recently and as he is in a wheelchair had to time the run through the revolving door so we didn't get stuck in it. Absolutely crazy. Pushing the wheelchair and making a mental note of where the dropped kerbs are has made me much more sympathetic to wheelchair users (and angry about people who park on pavements so there isn't enough room to get past).

Burnoutwhat · 26/10/2023 11:46

Absolutely. But I think one of the problem is almost all towns and lots of buildings, particularly public ones like schools and hospitals aren't designed from scratch. They are added to slowly with lots of bad choices to be addressed and undone.

BodegaSushi · 26/10/2023 11:42

Or Holland Park where they spent months refurbing the toilets only to reopen them having removed the baby change from the disabled toilets and having them only in the main toilets where, you guessed it, you need to climb steep stairs.

I guess disabled people can't have or care for children 🥲

BodegaSushi · 26/10/2023 11:38

My favourite is Shadwell station, where the lifts take you to a mezzanine just above the platform, then you're on your own to make it down the stairs 🙃

Flufferblub · 26/10/2023 11:36

I completely agree that all disabilities need to be accommodated of course. I was just speaking from my perspective as a wheelchair user. But who's going to be fucked off by a ramp and automatic doors? Or better yet, a smooth level with automatic doors.

OP posts:
Catsmere · 26/10/2023 11:28

BarbaraofSeville · 26/10/2023 08:01

I agree.

A minor point in the grand scheme of things, but I was always a bit Hmm that the mirror in the accessible toilet in my office building could only be used while standing up.

It did double as the ladies toilet for that area (male dominated building so few women used it but still showed that no-one had thought about it).

Reminds me of the wheelchair accessible loo in my local shopping centre (which only opened in 2017). Whoever the genius was that designed it put the toilet paper dispenser (one of those huge circular things that hold several rolls) so far back that you have to twist on the toilet seat and reach backwards to get at it, and stuck the soap dispenser in the corner, hemmed in by the basin and the hand dryer, so nobody sitting in a wheelchair - even a small one - can reach it.

greenacrylicpaint · 26/10/2023 11:17

and edi seem to have only one topic as priority atm which is very frustrating

greenacrylicpaint · 26/10/2023 11:13

yabu

it's about standards and enforcement. that's what you need to concentrate on.

but I agree that standards are not as good as they could be and enforcement is not a priority it seems.

randomchap · 26/10/2023 11:06

It's not just the design of the buildings that needs looking at. It's also the way people treat the facilities. There's been loads of times I've had to complain that the accessible toilet is unusable as it's being used for storage. Or has things outside that means the door can't open wide enough

TVaddict23 · 26/10/2023 11:05

I agree. I was thinking about this yesterday in work. As you come out of the lift on my floor you need to walk through 2 sets of double doors. The first set has a touch button for wheelchair users but the second set doesn't?! Makes no sense.

TenderDandelions · 26/10/2023 11:04

There's so much talk of trying to get disabled people back in to work, then they build buildings that are supposedly accessible but aren't very well designed. There is definitely an opportunity here! Actually disabled disability assessors to work with architects?!

YANBU OP. I remember when I was at school we did a project on accessibility and I had to go in to our local town and assess various shops. I have a disabled sibling that uses a wheelchair so I was only too familiar with some of the issues.

The whole "well we've got a ramp" doesn't really work when a) the ramp is so steep you needs the muscles of The Rock to wheel yourself up; or b) when you get to the top of the ramp there's a dodgy high threshold across the doorway, or a door just wide enough to skin your knuckles.

Ithinkitstimeforbed · 26/10/2023 11:03

I am ashamed I only realised how inaccessible how many places were until I started pushing a pram- prams which are maybe more manoeuvrable and easier for other people to assist with. I’m often in places thinking how on earth is a wheelchair user meant to navigate this! I am near 3 tube stations and not one with step free access! Or when people park on the road and you can’t fit through, or those bloody lime bikes taking up the whole pavement! I know making somewhere accessible for everyone is impossible but absolutely agree and am surprised anyone could have voted Yabu!

HunterHearstHelmsley · 26/10/2023 10:57

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 26/10/2023 09:31

Ramps aren't suitable for all accessible needs, steps can be easier to navigate if you're unsteady on your feet.

Those bumps at the opening of doors which are uncomfortable for wheelchair users can be there for white stick users so they can feel where the opening is.

Adjusting things down for those under 5 ft can make it inaccessible for those who are taller (or in big, motorised wheelchairs as these tend to be higher)

There's no doubt some things need to be made more accessible like making sure the accessible toilet is actually big enough to get a wheelchair in but some accessible features clash with each other

I regularly have to use crutches and I find ramps worse than steps. I can deal with steps! I'm unsteady on ramps and have fallen.

I agree with a previous poster that tactile paving can be a pain but the reason for it being there is important.

It's hard to try and meet everyone's needs. I don't think there's an easy answer.

JustKeepSlimming · 26/10/2023 10:44

Im always shocked by new buildings with poor accessibility. I used to work in an office which was built in about 2000. There was literally no access except for stairs. We simply couldn't have had anyone in a wheelchair working there (or visiting, but we didn't really have visitors).

The top floor was reached by a spiral staircase, so anyone with sight loss would probably have struggled too.

I always wondered how it was ever approved.