Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that any one who designs a town, building, theme park or attraction should have to spend the day navigating it in a wheelchair?

133 replies

Flufferblub · 26/10/2023 07:31

Needed a wheelchair on some days since my early 30s, and the experience has been eye opening. Some spaces seem well designed such as airports, but others it feels like disabled people are a complete after thought. Even in new places that have just been built in the past few years. You can understand in historic towns and places, but if some where has been designed and built in the 21st century, you'd think that they'd put a button to open the disabled toilet door.

The people who design and run these places need to spend a day getting around in a wheelchair. Design it with wheelchairs in mind first, and everyone else will be alright. Who doesn't like a ramp and automatic doors any way?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WiddlinDiddlin · 27/10/2023 16:53

Jelllytot - I think SerendipityJane was being sarcastic there.. not actually stating they think wheelchair users are a nuisance!

Hospitals are one of the least accessible places going - waiting rooms are set out for chairs, people who walk. Wheelchair users will often have to wait in the corridor and I have been forgotten on a number of occasions, my name being called ou in teh room or on a screen I can't see and no one has remembered im in the corridor waiting!

There is little room around beds for wheelchairs meaning your chair (if you've managed to bring it in with you, and you can't if you're ambulanced in you will need someone to fetch it for you!) will be put out of your reach.

Disabled accessible toilets are often broken, repurposed, not up to standard etc.

Parking is a fucking nightmare, lifts too small or slow and rammed with people ( a friend often attends a v large hospital over multiple floors in a northern city, she can miss appointments waiting on lifts as they're so busy and so slow) who seem to think the wheelchair user should defer to foot traffic always.

It's very difficult to report accessibility issues to anyone (who to? where?) and even if you do, bugger all gets done and businesses/architects/planners KNOW this. As long as a vague nod towards accessibility is done, the rest can be fudged - so yay they put in an accessible toilet iwth a wheelchair logo on the door.

The fact it is rammed full of huge bins and baby change tables, isn't big enough to get a power chair in and turn it around to exit (try reversing out, omg!) is all by the by 'they've done their best'.

My worst accessiblity story was a burger place in Birmingham. Its split over two levels as its on a hill, so two entrances, stairs between them.

There is seating on both levels - i went in the top, told no, go down the hill to the bottom we're not serving on this floor right now.

Go down the bottom and the ramp/stairs combo is not guard railed, i have to turn with a steep drop in front of me and to my side (behind me when ive turned) to go through double doors... Only the staff don't have the key for the second half of the door! So I can't get in. So can they open up the upper floor? No. Sorry.

Then they asked if I could leave the wheelchair outside?!

What, leave 2.5K of custom chair just... sat on a busy street? Even if I could have walked to a table, no fucking way!

Then we had to make it all the way back up the steep hill to get back to the train (which is why we went in the top door in the first place, far too steep a hill for a manual chair user!) Fortunately a big chap offered to help give me a shove or id still be there now I think!

Zero fucks given by them whatsoever. I did complain in writing, I was promised a voucher. It never arrived.

Jelllytot · 27/10/2023 16:48

SerendipityJane · 27/10/2023 16:47

I know. It's much funnier seeing wheelchair user left at a bus stop because they can't get into a bus with the pram bays full.

I completely disagree with what you're saying.

SerendipityJane · 27/10/2023 16:47

Jelllytot · 27/10/2023 16:30

Wtf?

Sorry if I've misinterpreted what you've said but I really don't think that's funny

I know. It's much funnier seeing wheelchair user left at a bus stop because they can't get into a bus with the pram bays full.

jannier · 27/10/2023 16:43

My sister is in hospital at the moment she can't get into the disabled toilet and for hygiene reasons been told she can't have a commode by her bed. Downstairs in the very large hospital there are two disabled toilets both with baby change and it takes a good 10 minutes to walk between them....one doesn't have a working drop down frame, neither is big enough for a disabled scooter and one is always being used by people from the A&E department. There are 4 sets of normal toilets

Jelllytot · 27/10/2023 16:30

SerendipityJane · 27/10/2023 15:47

You only need to be on MN for a few days to realise how much of a nuisance wheelchair users are. Especially when they take up the pram spaces on buses.

Wtf?

Sorry if I've misinterpreted what you've said but I really don't think that's funny

Woollyjumpersandtomatosoupweather · 27/10/2023 16:26

Wheelchair user Dfriend had a 7 day hospital stay recently which was gross. No mobile hoists or willing staff to help her get into the 1 working accessible shower room, and the nearest wheelchair accessible loo was absolutely filthy, and the loo roll holder attached on the other side of the room from the toilet. You needed 6 foot arms to reach the loo roll! She complained to PALS but heard nothing back.

Whomever designs hospitals, which surely must receive a lot of wheelchair users, let alone new buildings, should employ a wheelchair user to check that basic washing and toileting facities are suitable for everyone.

SerendipityJane · 27/10/2023 16:21

longtompot · 27/10/2023 16:05

I just remembered my dds mentioned that cash machines and self service tills aren't set up very well for wheelchair users. You can't get close enough to them to hide when you are putting in pins

Gosh ! You mean disabled people have money ?

We'll soon put a stop to that. No money = no problems accessing a cashpoint.

Lonejohny · 27/10/2023 16:11

Totally agree

longtompot · 27/10/2023 16:05

I just remembered my dds mentioned that cash machines and self service tills aren't set up very well for wheelchair users. You can't get close enough to them to hide when you are putting in pins

OceanicBoundlessness · 27/10/2023 16:01

Also agree about baby changing tables being only in disabled toilets and the new version of this.. I complained about two negative experiences in a mixed sex toilet in a bar and was directed toward the disabled toilet. Why should I have to inconvenience a disabled person to avoid the potential of having to watch a drunken man peeing and worse.

OceanicBoundlessness · 27/10/2023 15:57

Electric vehicle charging.
Accessibility hasn't been considered until very recently and I think.a working standard is still in process of being produced.
Problems are booths or spaces that aren't wide enough to maneuver a wheelchair around, charging points up on kerbs and large bumps to put the front wheels against that can't be navigated in a chair. That's without considering how heavy the charging cables are.

TigerRag · 27/10/2023 15:51

Sirzy · 27/10/2023 14:56

This time of year becomes particularly fun when shops want to use every inch of space for Christmas displays without thinking of accessibility. I would think the extra displays would be an issue for those who are visually impaired.

there is a card shop (part of a chain) locally that I won’t go in any of their branches because they are so difficult to navigate

It was difficult during covid where companies put seating outside blocking most of the pavement.

SerendipityJane · 27/10/2023 15:47

Jelllytot · 27/10/2023 15:39

YANBU at all.
I know this isn't the same but since DC was born earlier this year, it is not easy at all navigating London with a pushchair and using things like the tube. And it made me think about it from a wheelchair user's perspective. I am really surprised that "the greatest city in the world" does not better cater for wheelchair users. It's really poor.

You only need to be on MN for a few days to realise how much of a nuisance wheelchair users are. Especially when they take up the pram spaces on buses.

Jelllytot · 27/10/2023 15:39

YANBU at all.
I know this isn't the same but since DC was born earlier this year, it is not easy at all navigating London with a pushchair and using things like the tube. And it made me think about it from a wheelchair user's perspective. I am really surprised that "the greatest city in the world" does not better cater for wheelchair users. It's really poor.

SerendipityJane · 27/10/2023 15:39

And this is a nice neighborhood

Presumably they want to keep it that way ...

LivingDeadGirlUK · 27/10/2023 15:37

Sirzy · 27/10/2023 14:56

This time of year becomes particularly fun when shops want to use every inch of space for Christmas displays without thinking of accessibility. I would think the extra displays would be an issue for those who are visually impaired.

there is a card shop (part of a chain) locally that I won’t go in any of their branches because they are so difficult to navigate

Yes I think my mum thinks I'm a snob for not shopping in Primark, Quality Save etc but in reality I just can't relax with so much stuff around and then all the people rummaging through like a jumble sale. It's also incredibly hard to actually find what you need when a store is set up like that and you are visually impaired!

Kokeshi123 · 27/10/2023 15:11

The pavements around my parent's place are so, so hard for any kind of wheeled vehicle - abrupt edges with no slope leading you down to the ground. And this is a nice neighborhood! I think the problem is that nobody (except me, apparently) actually walks in that area. The whole neighborhood is now largely baby boomers with hardly any young families, and I wonder what will happen in the future as people start to get older and need mobility scooters etc.

Sirzy · 27/10/2023 14:56

This time of year becomes particularly fun when shops want to use every inch of space for Christmas displays without thinking of accessibility. I would think the extra displays would be an issue for those who are visually impaired.

there is a card shop (part of a chain) locally that I won’t go in any of their branches because they are so difficult to navigate

SerendipityJane · 27/10/2023 14:53

Also notice the modern trend of cobbled uneven paving to wanky places up. Totally impassable in a wheelchair. But then again, that was the idea, wasn't it ? Who wants disabled folk around making people feel uncomfortable ?

DuesToTheDirt · 27/10/2023 14:26

It's certainly an eye-opener pushing someone round in a wheelchair, and due to the weight and the centre of gravity it's nothing like a pushchair. Even a tiny kerb is difficult to negotiate, and as for shop doors... often I need three hands to open the door(s), keep them open, then get in with the wheelchair, though usually the staff see me struggling and come to help.

DuesToTheDirt · 27/10/2023 14:21

HunterHearstHelmsley · 26/10/2023 19:40

The bin men should be returning the bins to the edge of the property, where they collect them from. It would be unreasonable to expect someone to return from work to put the bin away.

I honestly don't know how wheelchair users manage in my area. Some of the pavements are not wide enough for a wheelchair user to get past a bin, whereever you put the bins. I suppose the only solution would be to have them on each path to each house (few driveways here), rather than on the pavement, both before and after collection.

LuciaPillson · 27/10/2023 14:08

I occasionally use a transport chair but much more often a walker with wheels. So I'd say I'm considerably more mobile and able than someone who uses a wheelchair, but still weak, tired, ill and mostly can't go anywhere the walker can't go. Recent experiences:

After bin men have been, walk a few feet along the pavement, stop, move someone's wheelie bin, walk a few feet, stop, move someone's wheelie bin... the bins even empty can be quite heavy and I find it tiring, but at least I can do it! Not everyone can. People's landscaping companies leaving big bags of garden rubbish etc on the pavement, and those I can't move.

Went into a shop in a mall which was on various levels. There was street access to one level of the shop which was a bit like a landing, with no till, and stairs up and down to the other levels. Around the corner was a little platform lift with a sign to push a button to summon staff who never answered it. I had something I wanted to buy but there was no way of doing it so I left it.

Shops: narrow aisles, things blocking aisles, steps up to shop, steps down to shop, heavy doors and so on. Heavy doors even in hospitals, sometimes there are some automatic doors and some not and nobody seems to think it's an issue.

Lifts in hospitals where all the able bodied people make a dash for the lift and by the time I get there with my walker the door closes in my face. I know all the lifts in the hospital I'm in the most, and try to use the least busy ones because of this.

And so on, and my needs are trivial compared with people who use wheelchairs.

SerendipityJane · 27/10/2023 11:01

We’re find facilities are a bit better where we live now, but the main thing we have noticed is that accessible facilities aren’t full of clutter, they’re clean and not used by lazy people who don’t actually require them.

You can learn a lot waiting for a lift with a wheelchair user. When I'm out with a friend and there's a crowd , I'll wait with them for the lift, make sure they are in, then cheerily shout "I'll take the stairs". And usually get there before the life.

The recent fad for needing lifts to get from a car park to a supermarket shop floor hasn't really panned out well*. You can't get a wheelchair and a load of trolleys in there at the same time. And you can't get a wheelchair on the travellator.

Probably better you don't think about what if there was a fire. My friend did use a phrase "Crispy C***" once. (Which did sound like a new range, rather that what the fire services would find at the top.)

Simonjt · 27/10/2023 07:14

randomchap · 26/10/2023 11:06

It's not just the design of the buildings that needs looking at. It's also the way people treat the facilities. There's been loads of times I've had to complain that the accessible toilet is unusable as it's being used for storage. Or has things outside that means the door can't open wide enough

We’ve found this a lot, my husband needs to use the accessible toilet when out, he was once presenting at another company and the accessible loo not only have one of those huge electric floor cleaners in, there were old tables, chairs and just random bits thrown everywhere. He took some photos and then left, his choice was to just leave and find a toilet elsewhere, or wet himself.

We’re find facilities are a bit better where we live now, but the main thing we have noticed is that accessible facilities aren’t full of clutter, they’re clean and not used by lazy people who don’t actually require them.

lamalamalamasquirrel · 26/10/2023 19:57

WiddlinDiddlin · 26/10/2023 19:50

This wheelchair user ain't offended - I think its possibly better to have some truly disabled people doing this, but actually none disabled people might highlight issues better as they won't be used to it, won't have found all the work arounds etc.

Fair point! I was thinking more a person not used to a wheelchair would be more likely to "cheat" and say something was fine.