Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think student funding is in crisis and yet another area this government just can’t be bothered to fix.

204 replies

Fr00tL00ps · 26/10/2023 07:01

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-67206767

To get access to full loans your family needs to earn under £25k. In this climate many families above can’t afford to top up and fund now sky high rental fees and utilities as they’re paying for rises in their own. There is now a two tier uni experience with the children of those under £25k and richer families able to top up able to attend uni full time and eat.

Why is it ok for for young people to live in poverty just because they’re students ? Also why is parental income taken into account for an 18 year old at uni living away from home but not for an 18 year old living at home receiving Universal Credit?

Julia Żelazo pictured outside her university accommodation building

Student maintenance loans almost entirely used up by rent, report warns

The average cost of university accommodation in England is almost level with the average maintenance loan.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-67206767

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Boomboom22 · 26/10/2023 20:29

Another good point that the parents who need to know the most that they are expected to chip in are the ones who probably charge their kids rent to live at home, and not in a normal saving it all to give back way. They often discourage their kids from uni due to not understanding that many pay back nothing at all or a pittance compared to the loans. Still lots pay it off by 40 so surely enough comes in? You also have people who make a deal, my friend owed about 8k left and settled at 5k so did save interest etc. They were on about 100k at the time.

Boomboom22 · 26/10/2023 20:26

Very very good point about uc. Really they should make that 25 too, seeing as mw is 23 and education is to 25 due to the assumption of parents paying. Def parents income should be taken into account for uc, but are you sure under 25s living at home are allowed to claim? I don't think they should be unless mw and uni is also changed.

Zanatdy · 26/10/2023 20:23

Students can and should be expected to work too. Even if their course / Uni doesn’t allow it, the holidays are long. My DS worked full time all summer and earned 5k. Not only helpful for the coming year but also got his valuable experience to talk about in job interviews. He doesn’t work term time as he plays sports evenings and weekends hence working full time in summer. He can head back to the same job next summer too

Zanatdy · 26/10/2023 20:14

I don’t agree with the system at all but it’s done as many students never repay and it’s tax payers money. I think it’s a really bad system, and what is crazy is mum could move a new boyfriend in just before kid goes off to uni, he earns a good salary (say mum only earned 15k) and suddenly he’s responsible for paying for his girlfriends kids education! Meanwhile child’s father would be living nearby, earning 200k a year and is expected to pay zero. It’s a bonkers system is really is. Cost of living crisis, many families are expected to find more and more money.

What’s worse is many parents have no idea student loans are means tested. Otherwise perhaps they’d start a college fund at birth like many in the US do

maddening · 26/10/2023 20:07

nancy75 · 26/10/2023 08:00

I could understand if this money was given as a grant, but as it’s a loan I don’t get the need for means testing at all

This - not even just not a grant - a loan which you are likely to pay over £20k in interest on.

boys3 · 26/10/2023 19:57

At the end of the day you get a degree make it to good use and you earn on average 10k a year more over your working life it can increase your earning potential by 350k by in vesting 40k to get degree

that average is largely meaningless though. The IFS published a detailed study only a few years ago (would be interesting if they did an update).

Going to university is a very good investment for most students. Over their working lives, men will be £130,000 better off on average by going to university after taxes, student loan repayments and foregone earnings are taken into account. For women, this figure is £100,000. (These and other numbers are in “discounted present value” terms, which means counting earnings later in life less than those earned earlier on. Without discounting, returns look much bigger.)

However, these average returns mask large differences across individuals. So while about 80% of students are likely to gain financially from attending university, we estimate that one in five students – or about 70,000 every year - would actually have been better off financially had they not gone to university.

At the other end of the spectrum, the 10% of graduates with the highest returns will on average gain around half a million pounds in discounted present value terms. Much of this variation is explained by the subject studied at university: students of medicine and law, for example, achieve very high returns on average, while few of those studying creative arts will gain financially from their degrees at all.

That's just about hard cash. As the authors note: This study only looks at financial returns. Other personal and social benefits may be as or more important

https://ifs.org.uk/publications/impact-undergraduate-degrees-lifetime-earnings

The impact of undergraduate degrees on lifetime earnings | Institute for Fiscal Studies

We control for students’ prior attainment and family background to estimate the causal effect of going to university on earnings and employment.

https://ifs.org.uk/publications/impact-undergraduate-degrees-lifetime-earnings

EqualityWhatequality · 26/10/2023 19:52

Why would they? Their kids will be ok. They don’t want to address inequality so the more plebs don’t go to university the more they can retain their power and wealth. Vote for psychopaths, get psychopathic policy.

Blackbyrd · 26/10/2023 19:47

Don't forget that students always used to be able to sign on for unemployment benefit and get Housing Benefit during the summer holidays which was a substantial income boost. Under Universal Credit, the few catagories of students that can even apply are receiving a pittance comparatively

What would help would be proper careers advice in secondary schools and colleges, with all possible avenues into employment explored. Some degrees offer very poor value for money, however talk of "Mickey Mouse" degrees is often misguided when you look at the breakdown of the UK economy and what sectors actually contribute the most

I am not seeing many jobs suitable for students being advertised, merely odd ZHC and one-off positions. It's not as easy as people seem to think to mix studying with working. Also, given the state of university finances, why didn't they invest in student accommodation and themselves benefit from rents paid? That way they could have helped the poorest students directly with reduced rents. Seems utterly short-sighted on their part

MrsMurphyIWish · 26/10/2023 19:20

rwalker · 26/10/2023 18:43

At the end of the day you get a degree make it to good use and you earn on average 10k a year more over your working life it can increase your earning potential by 350k by in vesting 40k to get degree
so no it shouldn’t be free
but there should be better finance options
it’s Chaos at the moment too many examples to list from people keep earnings below 29k so never pay it back to a woman getting a new partner and this partner’s income slashes the loan the kids nothing to do with new partner

it was on Jeremy vine today tbh the woman who was complaining that after she paid her rent did have enough money for the student experience as in socialising and going to student balls didn’t get my sympathy I don’t see why taxpayers should subsidise socialising

350k post grad? You’re having a laugh! I can only comment on teacher degrees but nope.

MrsMurphyIWish · 26/10/2023 19:09

CeciliaMars · 26/10/2023 10:44

For the people saying that working part-time jobs is the norm when doing a degree, I agree that's fine for most degrees, but what about teaching, nursing, midwifery, medicine etc, where the hours of the course and often the shift work means that they don't have time for part-time jobs? What then?

Late to this. But I’m a teacher. On my practices I taught all day and went straight to work to my bar job. I’ve worked since I was 14. However, this is what I needed to survive as I grew up in poverty.

Fortunately, I had no Uni fees, a full load, a bursary - a Labour gov in 1997-2000 (my uni years) got me where I am today. No way could I have gone to Uni without that.

DH and I have saved for our DC’s education (child benefit into ISA’s) but I doubt they’ll have the Uni experience we did. We want our kids to have part time work for the world of work experience. They do need to earn (not for parties but to cover their courses). I do not want them to work to eat one meal a week like the student in the article.

rwalker · 26/10/2023 18:43

At the end of the day you get a degree make it to good use and you earn on average 10k a year more over your working life it can increase your earning potential by 350k by in vesting 40k to get degree
so no it shouldn’t be free
but there should be better finance options
it’s Chaos at the moment too many examples to list from people keep earnings below 29k so never pay it back to a woman getting a new partner and this partner’s income slashes the loan the kids nothing to do with new partner

it was on Jeremy vine today tbh the woman who was complaining that after she paid her rent did have enough money for the student experience as in socialising and going to student balls didn’t get my sympathy I don’t see why taxpayers should subsidise socialising

Desecratedcoconut · 26/10/2023 18:26

Almondmum · 26/10/2023 18:22

Everybody gets the maximum amount of maintenance loan regardless of parental income. Part of that loan becomes a grant depending on parental income. So those on low incomes end up owing less.

That's not right. The maximum loan is linked to parental income. There's no grant.

Sorry, that'll teach me for not reading properly. That sounds heaps better for students.

Almondmum · 26/10/2023 18:22

Everybody gets the maximum amount of maintenance loan regardless of parental income. Part of that loan becomes a grant depending on parental income. So those on low incomes end up owing less.

Barbadossunset · 26/10/2023 18:21

I wonder if things will change if universities start struggling.to fill places because people stop going.

I don’t think things will change - universities will just increase their numbers of international students.

cheerypip · 26/10/2023 18:18

Almondmum · 26/10/2023 07:12

It's crazy. We don't get everything right in Wales but we do at least have a better handle on student finance.

I wonder if things will change if universities start struggling.to fill places because people stop going?

How does it work in Wales?

HedgerowHysteria · 26/10/2023 17:47

@Icelolly999 there is no cancellation of doctors' debt if they move abroad. They move because junior doctor pay rates are so much lower than they can get abroad and because their UK working conditions are awful. A carrot of debt cancellation if they stay in the NHS for a fixed period would be so much more of an incentive than any stick approach. They are taking enough of a bashing at the moment.

The would-be medic DC who are really facing financial barriers are the ones whose parents are just over the full loan threshold in terms of income but with insufficient money to subsidise them. These DC are not in a position to do any part time work to make up the shortfall and it makes it impossible for them.

Icelolly999 · 26/10/2023 17:18

I agree the system is ridiculous.

I would make a full loan eligible to all, with stricter parameters to pay back and no cancellation for moving abroad which is probably why we lose so many drs and other health professionals.

To be honest though, because we are having to subsidise both our dc’s as we only get the minimum loan, it will be better for them in the long run because they will have less to pay back. Some of the kids with low income parents will have so much to pay back it puts them at a disadvantage which seems unfair.

HedgerowHysteria · 26/10/2023 16:23

@Ylvamoon but not for DC studying to become doctors. The fallout of this mess is a big financial barrier to DC from less privileged backgrounds studying medicine. Not a good thing for society as a whole.

Ylvamoon · 26/10/2023 16:16

... there is also a up to 5k bursary from the NHS for those choosing to study a health care profession. Not just nursing, but also physiotherapy, radiology, midwifery, ...

boys3 · 26/10/2023 16:02

Blankscreen · 26/10/2023 14:59

My dss is having 2 gap years to save up funds to take to uni.

I went in 1997-2000.
I think the biggest change between now and then has been to the rents that students have to pay.

Whereas when I went student housing was cheap it has been commercialised and there are now companies specialising in 'luxury' student accomodation. The rents are crazy.

DSS wants to go to Bristol but the rent is far higher than the loan he is entitled to take.

Surely there should have been planning conditions imposed that student housing was to be rented out at below market rate.

I actually despair at this country.

Surely @Blankscreen the biggest change as compared with when you went is the number of UK DCs now going to university, plus the increase in international student numbers. Add to that years under governments of both colours of new housing supply in general falling hugely short in every single year of what is needed. It not a great surprise where we find ourselves. Simple supply and demand, not great anywhere and even worse in certain student towns and cities.

and possibly worse when student halls in many of the relatively newer Uni are not Uni owned either. And that before we get to living out, as most 2nd years and beyond, will need to.

CanvaQueen · 26/10/2023 15:53

One thing that is bizarre is that a resident parent’s live-in partner’s income is included for student loan calculations as ‘household income,’ but a non-resident parent’s live-in partner’s income isn’t included for child maintenance calculations.

Why should an unrelated adult have to pay another adult’s living costs?

Badgerstmary · 26/10/2023 15:08

Also at Exeter uni, those students whose parents earn less than 25k will receive an Access to Exeter bursary for £2100/£1260 per year depending on how much they earn. The 25-30k section only began last year.

Badgerstmary · 26/10/2023 15:00

My dd is at Exeter uni & she has just been told she will be receiving an Access to Exeter bursary of £800. This is to help students whose parents earn less than approximately 30k. This is such a relief, but it seems wrong that the sliding scale for parental income starts so low.

Blankscreen · 26/10/2023 14:59

My dss is having 2 gap years to save up funds to take to uni.

I went in 1997-2000.
I think the biggest change between now and then has been to the rents that students have to pay.

Whereas when I went student housing was cheap it has been commercialised and there are now companies specialising in 'luxury' student accomodation. The rents are crazy.

DSS wants to go to Bristol but the rent is far higher than the loan he is entitled to take.

Surely there should have been planning conditions imposed that student housing was to be rented out at below market rate.

I actually despair at this country.

Luckydip1 · 26/10/2023 14:56

I don't think people realise how dire government finances are, worst of all is the government is paying £100 billion a year just in interest on its loans now rates have gone up. Fixing education, NHS, crime, social care properly would cost £100s of billions.

Swipe left for the next trending thread