Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that people without safeguarding training shouldn't be giving advice about safeguarding on MN?

66 replies

calmandcaffeinated · 25/10/2023 22:35

As the title says. I've read so many posts regarding a safeguarding concern on MN, and the amount of people commenting to do nothing or to mind your own business is sickening.

It's clear to me that none of these people have had safeguarding training, and in no way should comment as it puts children at risk. I'm not sure what the answer is, but given how heavily policed MN is anyway I think more moderation is needed.

Perhaps IABU, as we should have balanced views on things and it's free speech, so please let me know if I am. I just want to know the general consensus on this matter.

OP posts:
AnneElliott · 26/10/2023 09:38

I agrée with you. Although I also think people shouldn't post (as fact) on any subject when it's clear they don't k ow what they're talking about. Lots of people chat complete shit with such confidence it's pretty mind blowing.

SoShallINever · 26/10/2023 09:34

I completely agree OP.
I reported a case a few years ago about a sexually active 12 year old girl. The poster, the girls mum was asking for contraceptive advice for her. The fact is at 12 the girl can't give valid consent to sex and is therefore bring abused.
I honestly think that in such cases MN should report to the Police, they have our email addresses, it could be followed up. If they truly cared about children they could do so but it's an "anonymous forum" apparently, so they don't.

My day job involves safeguarding regularly, my advice on here is, if in doubt contact your local SS/MASH (multi agency safeguarding hub) and let them decide if it needs to be taken further.
There are consequences for those who suspect abuse but do nothing. Something that I think MN should remain mindful of.

paintingvenice · 26/10/2023 09:22

HeddaGarbled · 26/10/2023 09:15

I’ve been subjected to safeguarding ‘training’ on a regular basis because of my job but it’s always seemed to me to just be common sense: if you have concerns, report them to the designated safeguarding lead person. That’s it really.

I think one of the key things about safeguarding training that people aren’t aware of and is often missed is the responsibility of the person to report concerns (even if the subject doesn’t want it reported).

For me it’s a key consideration if I were to share anything-nothing is confidential; but also that responsibility to share actually takes away a lot of that side of mumsnet where people say to mind your own business.

paintingvenice · 26/10/2023 09:19

What annoys me is mumsnet removing some of the more crazy but harmless threads that are pretty funny because they might be trolls, the ones every gets involved with and are quite entertaining really, but leaving posts with dangerous and harmful advice.

HeddaGarbled · 26/10/2023 09:15

I’ve been subjected to safeguarding ‘training’ on a regular basis because of my job but it’s always seemed to me to just be common sense: if you have concerns, report them to the designated safeguarding lead person. That’s it really.

Locutus2000 · 26/10/2023 09:06

sprigatito · 25/10/2023 22:49

I think the line is pretty much "personal attacks, hate speech and libel"

It's a discussion forum. Everyone gets to jabber away on any topic. Including talking utter bollocks. The problem isn't people talking bollocks, it's people thinking a bunch of online potluck strangers can offer reliable legal/medical/professional advice instead of talking to the relevant bodies IRL

"I think the line is pretty much "personal attacks, hate speech and libel""

Still trying to work out how the fuck that Britney thread is acceptable then.

BurbageBrook · 26/10/2023 08:20

109 percent agree. These posts put children at risk and I think MNHQ should edit or remove them and replace with safeguarding guidance.

QueenOfTheLabyrinth · 26/10/2023 03:38

It would be disingenuous to pretend that safeguarding training is ONLY about keeping the vulnerable safe, it’s not. Sure the company / organisation may present it as such but a huge part is about covering one’s own (and the company / organisation’s) back against legal / financial implications & fulfilling insurance obligations. This means safeguarding training & protocols don't allow much room (if any) for common sense & personal judgement; this is a restraint Joe & Jane Bloggs don’t have though as they can exercise common sense & personal judgement.

lemmein · 26/10/2023 03:08

I think these things tend to right themselves. If someone posts a load of ill- informed nonsense they are usually dealt with quite quickly by other posters.

I seen a post a few days ago implying the man the OP was concerned about couldn't be a paedophile because he was attracted to her, an adult woman. They were put right within a few posts! I think it's worth keeping these posts and their responses up.

I do hate those threads though when an op is concerned about an health issue and dithering of whether to go to A&E or not. Every.single.time some dick will reply (often several!) telling them if they can post on MN they don't need A&E....winds me right up 🙈 Again though, their 'advice' is usually corrected quite quickly by following posters.

GrannyRose15 · 26/10/2023 02:48

If people post on MN then presumably they want to know what Mumsnetters think. Advice is just that. No-one has to follow it.

Jellycatspyjamas · 26/10/2023 02:30

My fear is that by having people outwardly going against safeguarding guidance it puts OPs off from reporting, and this is my main concern.

Part of the difficulty is that safeguarding is complex, there’s very rarely one single appropriate response or approach to take so even amongst trained professionals you’re going to get different opinions.

The other thing for me is that some of the posts from people who claim to have safeguarding training/knowledge give ridiculous advice - often on the basis of a days mandatory training every year to keep their certification or whatever.

Better all the posts go into the mix and people can use their common sense and judgement than have an assumption of knowledge and expertise because Betty did an e-learning module.

KittenKins · 26/10/2023 00:27

WanderingAroundintheLark · 25/10/2023 22:49

I wonder if mumsnet should have a safeguarding mod. But then where do yo draw the line as mumsnet can identify posters. Still think it would be good or would it stop d v victims posting

There are forums that have disclaimers such as the following;

"If we become concerned about you or anyone else while using one of our services, we will act in line with our safeguarding policy and procedures. This may involve sharing this information with relevant authorities to ensure we comply with our policies and legal obligations."

It does put people off posting, although I'm sure it also helps many others.

GoodOldEmmaNess · 25/10/2023 23:16

People say wrong stuff on here about a whole load of vital issues. It's fine, since no one in their right mind would base important decisions on forum posts made by random anonymous people on the internet. People post about serious matters in order to talk them through with peers, not to get expert advice

ACGTHelix · 25/10/2023 23:08

the other issue is when some posters are correct others dont want to admit to it at times too.

MolyHacaroni · 25/10/2023 23:07

I believe in common sense.

Posters are advised to seek further advice and take posts here as suggestions, whether they're coming from someone who claims to be an expert or knowledgeable or a randomer.

Treat everyone's post equally - with a pinch of salt and a bit ot common sense - and seek real life advice after posting here.

As for the posts, MN can't just take down a post that 'seems reasonable' [I don't know if it does or not] on the say-so of someone who claims to have attending a training. [Not saying that you haven't, just that MN can't prove it and the posts may not have been taken down because there are no obvious signs that they're wrong or dangerous besides you saying so].

ACGTHelix · 25/10/2023 23:06

calmandcaffeinated · 25/10/2023 22:44

I understand about it being an open forum, and anyone can say anything ofc. But given how much MN is policed I don't understand why certain responses aren't taken down. Where is the line?

aparently you can say you believe in x,y,z but some posts get deleted even if its accurate information as to the reasons thats the wisdom of Hq

underneaththeash · 25/10/2023 22:59

You can't. It's the same on the health boards. I had someone arguing with me that someone's symptoms indicated that they had iritis (which is a serious eye condition). Mum had health anxiety and the symptoms didn't match - it was dry eye - as I'd said.

calmandcaffeinated · 25/10/2023 22:54

Thanks for the view points. I like the PP about a safeguarding moderator but it's probably too much to ask.

I am happy to accept IABU in my expectations here on the whole. I would be in support of more being done where a safeguarding issue is raised (perhaps a phone number or website link could be sent to OP on what to do).

OP posts:
UsingChangeofName · 25/10/2023 22:52

I too think this is impossible to 'police'.

As others have said, anyone can claim knowledge / experience / qualification in anything - but it isn't a Gvmnt website, it is a discussion forum, and an international one at that, meaning different cultures and expectations for all sorts of reasons.

It might not be a bad idea for there to be more warnings (reminders?) that anyone can state what they like on the internet, and that nobody is able to check they are who, or what they say they are (as there are warnings on some threads).

calmandcaffeinated · 25/10/2023 22:51

My fear is that by having people outwardly going against safeguarding guidance it puts OPs off from reporting, and this is my main concern.

I don't think it can be policed in terms of who is posting, but it's fairly clear some of what people say is utter rubbish.

What I don't understand is the line for which things are removed or not. Perhaps that is what my issue is with. I was reading a thread about OP being barred from a uni thread for disagreeing with posters which seemed to be of no danger to anyone, and then read a thread about concerns about children being hit and posters were allowed to give dangerous advice.

OP posts:
saveforthat · 25/10/2023 22:50

YABU. On MN people with no legal training give legal advice. People with no medical training give medical advice etc. Your post should read" people shouldn't ask for professional advice on a random internet forum".

INeedAnotherName · 25/10/2023 22:49

How do they prove they've had training though?

sprigatito · 25/10/2023 22:49

calmandcaffeinated · 25/10/2023 22:44

I understand about it being an open forum, and anyone can say anything ofc. But given how much MN is policed I don't understand why certain responses aren't taken down. Where is the line?

I think the line is pretty much "personal attacks, hate speech and libel"

It's a discussion forum. Everyone gets to jabber away on any topic. Including talking utter bollocks. The problem isn't people talking bollocks, it's people thinking a bunch of online potluck strangers can offer reliable legal/medical/professional advice instead of talking to the relevant bodies IRL

WanderingAroundintheLark · 25/10/2023 22:49

I wonder if mumsnet should have a safeguarding mod. But then where do yo draw the line as mumsnet can identify posters. Still think it would be good or would it stop d v victims posting

StarDolphins · 25/10/2023 22:47

I disagree. It’s a discussion forum where many responses will be ‘wrong’ - where do you draw the line, no one can reply if they’re not qualified would mean a LOT of empty posts. There’s also no way to police it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread