Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that people without safeguarding training shouldn't be giving advice about safeguarding on MN?

66 replies

calmandcaffeinated · 25/10/2023 22:35

As the title says. I've read so many posts regarding a safeguarding concern on MN, and the amount of people commenting to do nothing or to mind your own business is sickening.

It's clear to me that none of these people have had safeguarding training, and in no way should comment as it puts children at risk. I'm not sure what the answer is, but given how heavily policed MN is anyway I think more moderation is needed.

Perhaps IABU, as we should have balanced views on things and it's free speech, so please let me know if I am. I just want to know the general consensus on this matter.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Binkie98 · 27/10/2023 14:02

SoShallINever · 26/10/2023 09:34

I completely agree OP.
I reported a case a few years ago about a sexually active 12 year old girl. The poster, the girls mum was asking for contraceptive advice for her. The fact is at 12 the girl can't give valid consent to sex and is therefore bring abused.
I honestly think that in such cases MN should report to the Police, they have our email addresses, it could be followed up. If they truly cared about children they could do so but it's an "anonymous forum" apparently, so they don't.

My day job involves safeguarding regularly, my advice on here is, if in doubt contact your local SS/MASH (multi agency safeguarding hub) and let them decide if it needs to be taken further.
There are consequences for those who suspect abuse but do nothing. Something that I think MN should remain mindful of.

How is anyone to know whether there is any truth in the post?
The police are thinly stretched, and won't have the resources to try to find out if a Mumsnet post is true or not.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 27/10/2023 13:55

calmandcaffeinated · 25/10/2023 22:43

Thanks, I put minimal responses, except to report whatever it is to the relevant persons.

I feel more needs to be done. I've reported responses that go directly against safeguarding regulations, and they are still left for days. I think it's seen as a valid opinion, but when that goes against all safeguarding legislation surely it should be taken down.

I don't know what the answer is.

It should.

Woush · 26/10/2023 21:38

There are layers of "safeguarding training. As a DSL, I might inwardly roll my eyes at suggestions (on Mumsnet) to report to school. Right thing to do, but I may read it and know DSL will do nothing of worth with the info. Equally, MASH social workers likely roll there eyes knowing that more than half the MASH referrals (in my LA) from DSDSLresult in no action.

There is filtering of urgency at every level:

  • Those with no safeguarding training (say a school yard mum) reports to someone with safeguarding training (say a teacher)
  • The teacher filters on if this is enough to need reporting to DSL. Many teachees don't need to go to DSL with these "safeguarding" reports ftom parents, usually when they aren't actually safeguarding.
  • The DSL then filters the safeguarding reports that are made to them, to decide if further referrals are needed, say to a MASH social worker. Many reports just sit in file or have in-school outcomes.
  • MASH social workers then deem if an assessment is needed, large proportions of MASH referrals close with no action, even though a DSL has viewed a referral necessary.
  • Assessment social workers then do the assessment and take advice from Social Care Managers if social care involvement is needed longer term and create a plan. Lots of assessments result in no further action.

The above is oversimplified for the lay person. My point is that it would be hard to draw a line. The line on when safeguarding action is necessary and urgent changes depending on your role.

Flamingogirl08 · 26/10/2023 21:27

I disagree actually. Safe guarding training is designed to protect an organisation as much as a vulnerable person so said training is not always applicable to a situation away from that organisation.

Also as somebody who has had safeguarding training I'm not convinced that it makes somebody more qualified than the average person with common sense. Some of it is nonsense.

ToastMarmalade · 26/10/2023 21:03

I agree but in a different way. I think many topics on mumsnet are fairly common eg safeguarding children, domestic abuse, health complaints etc and I wonder whether it would be helpful to have a ‘fact check’ in the main forums linking to the main helpful credible sources eg mumsnet, childline etc with a short summary.

There is a use for views, support and opinions but sometimes it seems that if enough people pile on with one view, it can seem like ‘the factual view’ but it’s not.

gamerchick · 26/10/2023 20:50

MN isn't moderated. I don't know why people keep saying more moderation is needed.

Report posts.

WillowCraft · 26/10/2023 20:48

The value of this site is the range of opinions from different types of people. Every post ends up with loads of replies and it generally is a balance of viewpoints. I think most people realise that it's not professional, regulated advice. To be fair relying on a single professional, however well trained, isn't always a great idea either, for nuanced situations.

It's insulting people's intelligence to say that they are going to accept a single response telling them not to report when other responses are saying the opposite. Most people are just posting here to test their own thoughts on an issue before taking the next step. If they weren't planning to do anything they probably wouldn't bother posting. Even if you are definitely going to report something, getting a range of opinions on here can be a helpful guide to how others might perceive your actions.

Oblomov23 · 26/10/2023 20:40

Presumably you are talking about certain threads op. Which ones? What was said? Most stuff I see doesn't go against safeguarding training. Most of which is common sense anyway.

BrownTableMat · 26/10/2023 20:27

YABU. In my line of work most people are required to do “safeguarding training”. But this varies from an hour’s online course in the absolute common sense basics, to three half days in more depth. I’ve done the highest level available but this absolutely does NOT make me an expert in safeguarding and I am acutely aware that I must report any and all safeguarding concerns to someone who is.

I am therefore not qualified to offer advice on safeguarding on this forum just because I’ve had “safeguarding training” and would not do so. And someone else in my type of work who’s done an hour online and a multiple choice quiz, certainly isn’t. You know what they say about a little knowledge.

ColleenDonaghy · 26/10/2023 20:17

NeverDropYourMooncup · 26/10/2023 20:07

Your desire to regulate those opinions smacks of authoritarian overreach

I disagree - because I believe the OP is referring to all the 'Ooh, no, mind your own business, don't interfere, there's no point, nobody will do anything, I had a 49 year old boyfriend when I was 14 and I knew exactly what I was doing, they'll just snatch the child up for adoption if you say anything, you fancy her husband, don't you/you're the ex wife/new stepmother/sibling with their nose out of joint aren't you' types of posts.

The fundamental of safeguarding is report it. If it's nothing, it's nothing. And if it isn't nothing, then you've done something to help protect a vulnerable person.

Yeah but this isn't a forum for safeguarding experts. No one should be regarding what anyone posts on here as perfect advice, whatever they claim their background to be. This is equivalent to asking your friends' opinions over coffee, not a meeting with a solicitor/accountant/teacher.

If an OP takes bad advice, that's on the OP, not the poster who gave the advice.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 26/10/2023 20:07

Your desire to regulate those opinions smacks of authoritarian overreach

I disagree - because I believe the OP is referring to all the 'Ooh, no, mind your own business, don't interfere, there's no point, nobody will do anything, I had a 49 year old boyfriend when I was 14 and I knew exactly what I was doing, they'll just snatch the child up for adoption if you say anything, you fancy her husband, don't you/you're the ex wife/new stepmother/sibling with their nose out of joint aren't you' types of posts.

The fundamental of safeguarding is report it. If it's nothing, it's nothing. And if it isn't nothing, then you've done something to help protect a vulnerable person.

Shoulderpads · 26/10/2023 19:52

Completely agree. I must prefer and trust the woo threads.

gotomomo · 26/10/2023 19:45

I'm a safeguarding officer, 95% is actually common sense and whilst there is an element of specialist knowledge, it's sometimes still subjective - commenting on a post is also so dependent on information shared. Any advice here should always be considered opinion not fact!

JSMill · 26/10/2023 19:45

calmandcaffeinated · 25/10/2023 22:35

As the title says. I've read so many posts regarding a safeguarding concern on MN, and the amount of people commenting to do nothing or to mind your own business is sickening.

It's clear to me that none of these people have had safeguarding training, and in no way should comment as it puts children at risk. I'm not sure what the answer is, but given how heavily policed MN is anyway I think more moderation is needed.

Perhaps IABU, as we should have balanced views on things and it's free speech, so please let me know if I am. I just want to know the general consensus on this matter.

You're so right! There a lot of people on MM commenting on things they know nothing about.

TulipCat · 26/10/2023 19:32

Meh, it's an internet chat forum, people give their opinions. If you want to correct someone, do so, but in general the message should be "Don't expect a free internet forum to have expert advice on it"

theduchessofspork · 26/10/2023 19:25

YABU. People are expressing opinions.

MN is v clear that nothing on here should be taken as a professional opinion.

This is a general interest forum, if people want professional advice then they need to go get that.

CranfordScones · 26/10/2023 19:20

If people need advice on safeguarding then perhaps they shouldn't ask random strangers on the internet.

Your desire to regulate those opinions smacks of authoritarian overreach. Are you going to regulate conversations on safeguarding that take place in pubs and at bus stops? The opinions offered on MN have no more official status than those.

Some opinions may not conform to safeguarding orthodoxy - that doesn't mean they're 'rubbish'. Women only got the vote because people confronted orthodoxy. YABU.

SlothBabyTruth · 26/10/2023 15:58

Nobody should really give 'official' advice on MN and it shouldn't be taken as such.

No-one knows who is posting or if their tale is true. And no-one knows if the people responding are real or have any experience or training either.

I generally cringe when someone posts and says "Dr/nurse/safeguarding lead here" become they could be someone lying who isn't a Dr or nurse or safeguarding lead or could be one who just isn't up to date in training or has personal bias.

On the whole, people need to move away from the idea that MN is a primary source of appropriate and/or accurate advice. It isn't and never has been. You can get some good advice but you can't state it's a good place to get it.

icechocs · 26/10/2023 15:49

I'm not convinced that "training " means anything much these days to be honest.
I 'm not going to automatically presume that someone knows best just because of a random course they attended.

CarPour · 26/10/2023 11:57

Whilst I agree you shouldn't comment if you don't know what your talking about its important to remember that MN is a forum, anyone can comment and anyone can lie. Something as serious as safeguarding MN is probably not the best place to take advise and a lot of posts need to be taken with a pinch of salt.

I also think it's impossible to police. Maybe a safeguarding Mod or the same sort of generic post as is given when domestic violence is being mentioned.

gurgham · 26/10/2023 11:52

I'd never use the term safeguarding as when it is used, it strikes me as a defined term. But if I thought someone seemed at risk one way or another I'd suggest they seem help/make a report - that's basic common sense isn't it?

WandaWonder · 26/10/2023 10:19

People need to take responsibility for not solely relying and information they get of the internet

You can only exercise people's brains for them so much, one thing society has a increasing problem with is lack of personal responsibility

YourDiscoNeedsYou · 26/10/2023 09:58

I think the training aspect is a bit of a red herring. I don’t think you’re necessarily saying that some posters claim to be safeguarding experts when they aren’t, OP? More about general damaging advice being given to safeguarding concerns.

This post makes me remember a particular thread quite a while ago, where someone was asking advice on an adult with some red flag behaviour around children. There was so much ‘advice’ saying along the lines of “leave the poor guy alone, you’ve got no proof, he’s probably been DBS checked, the school probably already know, jeez how come men can’t just get on with their job without these sort of accusations, you’ve got no proof”. While there were some people on the thread giving informed safeguarding advice, most of it was dangerous and completely against current legislation and advice.

MN don’t need to check every members credentials, but it would be relatively easy to pop on a thread with a generic message in line with government guidance. Like “”here’s a link to nspcc advice for if you have concerns”. They do this warning whenever the thread might prompt members to send money to someone.

ColleenDonaghy · 26/10/2023 09:54

It's a chat forum, no one should be coming here for formal advice, whether it's safeguarding, legal or medical (or anything else). Anyone can say they're anything they want and no one will have proof.

What it is useful for is gathering a range of opinions from people with a range of backgrounds.

Shinyandnew1 · 26/10/2023 09:40

I agree, but I’m not sure how you could police it. People will always offer irrelevant/pointless/unhelpful advice. it’s rather like the divorce threads where people will be told they’ll get spousal maintenance because their mate got huge amounts of it despite this being a long marriage/decades ago and the OP’s husband earns £30k and they’ve only been married 3 years.

Safeguarding is clearly more serious though. I think it would probably be useful to have a ‘report as this concerns child safeguarding’ and then MN could rely and tell then to contact x.

Swipe left for the next trending thread