Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does anyone have a child who has no hobbies / talent AIBU to be concerned.

130 replies

Blueyisnowfamily · 25/10/2023 21:15

My daughter 10 pretty much struggles with everything -
she has got health issues - they are medical not SEN.
she is not academic in the slightest - really struggles with writing etc
has just started learning to read okay but up to a year ago could not.
maths she is better at but is still behind with division and times table.
she is dreadful at sport ( bless her )
she is not very good at art but tbh she doesn’t apply her self.
she is not musical or shown any interest in music.
there is nothing she is passionate about. I never worried before as she was so young but now at age 10 I wonder if if this is usual ?

OP posts:
leccybill · 26/10/2023 10:16

I'm a secondary teacher. We have 2 pupils who are non-verbal, working at KS1 levels, cannot access the typical curriculum without much reduction in every subject, don't come to assemblies or the canteen because of their sensory issues - and yet they are both not eligible for a SEN specialist school. So for your daughter's school to be suggesting non-mainstream for her, suggests much more concern than perhaps you've understood.

Do you think she is ASD? Dyspraxic?

ThinkingAgainAndAgain · 26/10/2023 10:00

A great deal of what you’ve said sounds like dyspraxia, which my DS1 has.
Some of what you’ve said sounds like hyper mobility (can’t sit up straight, lolls) which my Ds2 has.
A lot of what you’ve said sounds like ASD, which both of mine have.

Are you in a position to have a private Ed psych and OT report? They will be different assessments, but different professionals. I think we paid around £800 for the dyspraxia assessment, which was done at home, and included the report and recommendations. This is now attached to D’s’ ECHP. The Ed psych assessment was more.

Boomboom22 · 26/10/2023 09:59

You need to go above the head of the community paediatrician who sounds awful. Clearly there must be some quite serious sen if as you say the medical condition can't explain it.
What you describe is very very behind as you know. There is no way a child who cannot access the primary curriculum fully can be expected to succeed at year 7, and you've described academic issues in every area. Eg you say quite good at maths then say struggles with times tables. In year 5 they are doing fractions, percentages, some algebra, measures of central tendency etc.
Your title is misleading, its not so much she doesnt have a hobby as she is very behind in school. It does sound like a specialist school would be better unless some sort of drastic change and progress can be made which would be an awful lot of pressure on her.
It seems the time has come to get another opinion and really be clear how far behind she is to the point her school think she won't cope, make sure they know she can't access regular school like a classroom most of the time or an assembly. Secondary will be much much noisier especially non selective.

SeasonalDependency · 26/10/2023 09:56

I used to worry similar about my son when he was 10 and nearing the end of primary school. However, he is nearly 13 now and has a huge love for football and mountain biking. He plays football for a local under 13s football team and despite starting at least 4 years after everyone else on the team with no prior experience, he's a great player. We used to think he wasn't sporty at all.

Some children take a bit longer to come out of themselves. My son was very late being able to tie shoe laces, his physical dexterity at primary age did concern is for a little while (he's still horrendously clumsy!)

Montegufoni2017 · 26/10/2023 09:48

I think you should just ensure she is introduced to everything but you can’t force it and not should you need to. I have only just discovered a couple of hobbies in my 30’s. Some of my friends have no hobbies and nothing they’re overly passionate about and they’re all happy normal individuals with relationships, jobs, friends etc
some friends have talent and passion for their job but struggle in other aspects of life.

she might not ever find a hobby and that’s ok. Or she might later on be passionate about something but not excel in it and that’s ok. Or she might find a hobby and be incredible and start winning comps and medals and that’s ok too.
don’t overthink it, as long as she’s happy

Failingatlife22 · 26/10/2023 09:45

What you are describing sounds like DCD or Dyspraxia, my daughter who is 8 has just been diagnosed. Your description could be her but there is help and she is improving. She can’t hold a pencil well, kick a ball, can’t cope with loud class rooms or assembly. There is help, occupational therapy has helped my daughter so much. I hope you get the help and support you need

ChimneyPot · 26/10/2023 08:55

Is there a process for appealing the Community Paeds decision? Or can you pay privately for an assessment?
Is there a support group of charity that can help you advocate for your daughter?

mynameisnotmichaelcaine · 26/10/2023 08:43

She sounds absolutely dreadful OP. I'm sorry you're having to deal with this.

letspopthekettleon · 26/10/2023 08:29

TheGreatHat · 25/10/2023 21:28

Would it help to re frame the way you think about her? Personally I think the idea of every one having a talent that they just have to find is a load of rubbish! You've described what she isn't, but what is she?
What does she enjoy? How does she spend her time? Is she caring? Empathetic? Funny? What are her interests? Is she sociable? Imaginative?

Academics and the arts are not the beginning and end of talent, success or happiness

This in spades

Blueyisnowfamily · 26/10/2023 08:11

@mynameisnotmichaelcaine she says it’s all medical trauma.
now she does have quite severe medical needs however the person who actually did her refferal for ASD was her specialist consultant and he says she is basically talking crap as he has Multiple patients with her condition and none of which he has felt the need to refer and it doesn’t effect cognitive abilities.’

OP posts:
oannao · 26/10/2023 08:06

Hi

mynameisnotmichaelcaine · 26/10/2023 08:03

I literally cannot comprehend how a community paediatrician can claim that it's absolutely ok for a child with no SEN to be unable to write or take part in PE at ten years old. It doesn't make any sense.

Have you started looking at local secondary schools? It's worth a look now to see what is out there that will meet her needs.

As for hobbies, DS and I do a lot of visits to local art galleries and museums. He enjoys these trips out, and has picked up a fair amount of knowledge along the way. He has an inset day on Friday and we're planning a day out to see the Museum of the Moon, which is currently close by, and a lunch out.

Blueyisnowfamily · 26/10/2023 07:45

@mynameisnotmichaelcaine she has a very extensive ehcp
sounds ridiculous I know
she did get ehcp on medical grounds BUT gradually over the years the EHCP has become more about her other needs than medical
we have
OT / Physio / speech and language.
on the waiting list for CAHMS.
the community paed will not even entertain the idea that something else is going on.
she is in year 5.

OP posts:
mynameisnotmichaelcaine · 26/10/2023 07:34

OP, my son was rejected for an ASD assessment at that age, even though it was clearly obvious that something was up. School and I continued to fight and he got one at 15.

You need to work with school on this. If both of you push, it will eventually happen. How are they currently funding her 1:1?

She won't be able to go to a specialist school without an EHCP, so it needs sorting now. Is she Year 5 or Year 6?

bozzabollix · 26/10/2023 07:24

You need an educational psychologist and then a occupational therapist if the outcome is dyspraxia. I have a child with dyspraxia and the OT was nothing short of miraculous with the treatment. Made such a difference. She sounds severely dyspraxic to me.

Having a label to explain everything made a huge difference to my son. It improved his self esteem no end and he’s getting on pretty well now.

TeenDivided · 26/10/2023 07:20

Does she have an EHCP? if not it sounds as if her needs are easily enough to warrant one. You can apply yourself if needed the SEN board is very helpful.

My DD struggled with everything at school, but always showed a great interest in animals, so we focused there and she went on to do animal care at college.

Keep looking and trying different things, something will hopefully take her fancy.

But please consider getting an EHCP too.

Laurama91 · 26/10/2023 07:17

Shes probably just not found anything she's interested in. My dad and brother are academically not so smart. But my dad is brilliant at his job, he's a builder. He can't do all aspects. Make anything out of bricks. My brother is the same. My gran once described a bird to him and he told her what type it was.

horseymum · 26/10/2023 07:14

She sounds lovely, you must be proud of the progress she has made. I would second other suggestions of horse riding. Improving gross motor skills will help with fine motor. A Riding for the disabled group where they have a physio available would be ideal. Riding will improve posture, proprioception, cure, confidence, communication and give her an activity she can enjoy and you a community of support. Growing plants can be very satisfying, my DD loves growing on new plants from cuttings to give to people.
As for not being able to join in PE, it sounds like the teacher needs more training in inclusion as all children should be able to take part if they adapt the lessons.
Craft wise, would she enjoy clay modelling or decoupage? Was going to suggest crochet as much easier than knitting but might be tricky just now if pencil control not comfortable.
Keep pushing for an assessment as well, they don't suggest not going to mainstream lightly and you need to get the right support around her.

TempersFuggit · 26/10/2023 07:04

theprincessthepea · 26/10/2023 05:39

Instead of hobbies - make a list of her strengths. Maybe encourage them.

simple things like talking, being observant, loving animals, curiosity about a subject - can be hidden gifts that lead to something later on down the line.

completely agree.

liveforsummer · 26/10/2023 07:02

Dc with no SEN do not have 1:1 support unless they need it for the medical condition. Do any of the things you list relate to that condition (such as the not sitting up straight)? From the list there, if unrelated to her medical issues it seems she has more than one thing going on. Such as asd along with dyspraxia which fwiw very commonly goes side by side. It's frustrating you're falling at then first hurdle. This can happen with girls are they don't always tick the right boxes in the check box assessment but a lot of the things you describe ARE pretty text book

Jibo · 26/10/2023 07:00

There must be things she likes though? What does she do to fill time at home?

SharonEllis · 26/10/2023 06:56

Neither of my children showed interest in anything much at that age & I was really worried. They have gradually both found things they are really into since - you have to give children time. Try and make sure she's not on screens all the time & give her a variety of experiences - she'll develop a passion for something else entirely and surprise you!

nibblessquibbles · 26/10/2023 06:43

Blueyisnowfamily · 26/10/2023 06:40

@nibblessquibbles the school believe she has SEN
they have pushed and pushed for an ASD assessment but here there is 2 stages
we never get to the actual ADOS assessments as the first appointment with the community paed always comes out as she doesn’t need one.
she has an OT - which highlights Multiple areas
speech and language - despite 6 years of therapy she still is delayed in speech ( mainly speech errors seen in 4 year olds ) but she does understand all words etc and is now mainly pronunciation issues and anxiety.

Ah sorry understand the situation now. Can you get a second opinion on the community paed? This seems really at odds with what you and school are describing.

Blueyisnowfamily · 26/10/2023 06:40

@nibblessquibbles the school believe she has SEN
they have pushed and pushed for an ASD assessment but here there is 2 stages
we never get to the actual ADOS assessments as the first appointment with the community paed always comes out as she doesn’t need one.
she has an OT - which highlights Multiple areas
speech and language - despite 6 years of therapy she still is delayed in speech ( mainly speech errors seen in 4 year olds ) but she does understand all words etc and is now mainly pronunciation issues and anxiety.

OP posts:
LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood · 26/10/2023 06:23

Are you sure she is not dyslexic? Or has other educational needs? It’s not always obvious.

That aside, I’d not worry she has no “talent”. But I would keep trying to find something that ignites an interest in her. I’d try to develop a hobby or 2 just for fun and some things to start giving her practical life skills and improve her confidence.

What about a trip to Hobbycraft or similar to see if anything tajes her fancy?
Scrapbooking.
Origami.
Modelling with clay.
Chess
Gardening if you have a garden or allotment
Or indoor plants, create a terrarium or cactus garden
Get her into nature, go on walks armed with an app or a book to identify plants and birds and trees. This could be combined with photography.
Martial arts is a great confidence builder and many children who are not sporty at school thrive doing it out of school.
Help her develop cooking and baking skills.
And/or DIY.
If her maths is relatively strong, try coding.

As others have said keep talking to her about all sorts of things to develop her social skills and her general knowledge.