Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Electric vehicle parking spaces

153 replies

CanIExtend · 25/10/2023 20:37

Is it reasonable to park a non EV in an EV parking space?

the ones near me have quite a lot of extra space around them as they were previously disabled and parent and child parking. And are much more convenient than where the disabled and parent/child spaces have been relocated to.

are these spaces protected as per disability spaces? Or are they viewed as more of a courtesy as per parent/child spaces?

YABU - EV spaces should be for EV’s only
YANBU - EV spaces are a courtesy like P&C spaces and it’s just unfortunate if an EV is unable to use the space.

OP posts:
321user123 · 27/10/2023 15:41

LiquoriceAllsort2 · 26/10/2023 00:58

I have done this a couple of times, I have an extension cable for the charger and I have parked in front plugged in and blocked the offending car in and did my shopping.

… what happened when you got back? 🫣

321user123 · 27/10/2023 15:39

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 26/10/2023 03:36

All of these systems are monitored - they know the minute you're at 100% charge. At work I get 15 minutes after I get to 100% to move my car, or I start getting a per-minute fine that's automatically removed since it's linked to my credit card. I usually move it at closer to 90% so I don't get stuck in a meeting.

Ah, thanks - interesting. I didn't know that (well, I don't own an EV and thus never use those spaces, so wouldn't have any reason to know).

So what happens in the scenario that I mentioned, when you need to both charge your EV AND you need to park somewhere where the spaces quickly fill up all day? Do you resign yourself to having to pay a huge fine for leaving your car there long after it is charged, so that you can enjoy the day doing what you actually came there for (and being hated by other EV owners with flat batteries in the meantime); or do you have to cut short your day and drive straight home immediately after charging?

Is there any way to 'nobble' the settings for your car, so that it only trickle-charges extremely slowly - if unwanted fast-charging is going to effectively wreck your day and force you to go home far too early, once you no longer 'need' your space as much as somebody else might?

Is this potentially like a high-tech version of 'is man made for the Sabbath or is the Sabbath made for man?' - with 'EV' here taking the place of 'the Sabbath'?

I'm already personally strongly deterred by EVs and their many apparent disadvantages - and knowing that you could risk a hefty fine if you don't strictly fulfil both of the required purposes in occupying an EV space (in contrast to the one straightforward purpose that you pay for with an ICE vehicle using a normal space: parking only) is hardly helping to sway me.

I suppose all of these issues are going to be eventually obsolete by the time we're all forced to have EVs and all but a handful of ICE vehicles have finally been chased out of town - once the remaining ICEs have all worn out and/or the price of petrol and diesel is comparable to that of cinema pick 'n' mix - as presumably every single space will be either for an EV to park, an EV to charge or both, so no driver would be at any advantage or disadvantage in using any one dual-purpose space; unless the charging facility was out of order, I guess.

Edited

Realistically, this is simply a perception issue.
Those who don’t own an EV see them as parking spaces.

These are chargers which have allocated space because your car cannot be suspended in space while charging so needs to occupy a physical space.

So the only criteria is charge your EV and move when you’re done as you do at a gas station.

321user123 · 27/10/2023 15:15

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 25/10/2023 21:44

what if there was an electric car parked there but it wasn't being charged?

I've wondered this. Obviously, the answer is that you move your car once it's charged; but we go on holiday to a lovely seaside place where the car park (including three spaces for charging EVs) fills up really quickly, and people almost always park there for the whole day. The beach part of the town is in a valley, so there's absolutely nowhere else to park that isn't up a long, extremely steep hill.

If an EV owner pays to park for the whole day and then pays to charge their car, are they justified in not coming back from the beach and finding nowhere to move it to once it's charged, so presumably having to drive home?

I suppose, if you leave the charging cable attached, nobody would know that you weren't charging it - unless they've been watching your car all day; obviously, with a petrol/diesel pump, if there's nobody standing there, it's not being filled!

Not EV owners ourselves, but it's a bit of a quandary, surely?

I can almost 100% guarantee that those chargers are 7Kw chargers , which in reality often only do 1-3Kw.
For the majority of today’s EVs to fully charge the car on that speed it would take anywhere from 8-11+hours.
So the likelihood is that those cars are, in fact, charging the whole day.

Secondly, you can in fact tell if a car is charging or not by looking at the charger or at the port of the car either one or both will have lights.
POD point chargers have a blue light when idle, green when charging and red when not charging or if there’s an error while charging.
Blue/red flashing the charger may be broken.

Kokeshi123 · 27/10/2023 14:57

Hopefully yes, as my experience is that roads are better maintained in countries where you have to pay for major roads (I'm talking about things like expressway tolls, since as far as I know no country as yet has started true road pricing...although I think Singapore is currently quite close).

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 27/10/2023 11:32

Well, in that case, we’re in agreement. Road-pricing is what we need. It’s transparent and fair, manages demand, makes externalities visible, and ensures that road maintenance gets paid for.

It would be nice if they can finally work something out so that the roads can be maintained - they haven't managed to find any way for the last few decades.

I know you always get somebody saying that there's no such thing as road tax - which is true - but afaia, all of the VED receipts just go straight into the general fund and aren't earmarked for mending roads at all, as most people would hope/expect; but maybe the government of the day will have a big change of heart once we're all paying per mile - especially as EVs tend to be heavier on average?

user1477391263 · 27/10/2023 00:00

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 26/10/2023 18:00

Yes, how truly shocking and terrifying that governments actually need to raise tax revenue in order to pay for stuff.

Absolutely fine when they do it fairly, honestly and transparently.

Well, in that case, we’re in agreement. Road-pricing is what we need. It’s transparent and fair, manages demand, makes externalities visible, and ensures that road maintenance gets paid for.

Maleficentient · 26/10/2023 20:03

The EV chargers connect to various apps so people with EVs can find a place to charge. If you park a regular car in that spot the charger will still show as empty and with navigate the person who needs to charge there. Whoever paid for the charger is a business. Parking in that spot is crap thing to do for everyone. Most places will ticket you and rightly so.

potatoheads · 26/10/2023 18:43

@CanIExtend This is where I’m coming from. I’m just trying to understand why people can get so outraged at someone using/abusing an EV space yet simultaneously get outraged at someone expecting a PC space to be used appropriately
Because as many people have explained THEY ARE CHARGING STATIONS not parking spaces. They generate money for the CP owners. Do you park in a stranger's driveway because it's close to the shops? Do you park in a petrol station and trot off to the shop? Then why think you can park in a charging bay?

potatoheads · 26/10/2023 18:41

AsWrittenBy · 25/10/2023 21:00

I suppose that if only ev can park in the ev spaces, they won't mind not parking in the non ev spaces?

Yes I know.... I'm being facetious but if spaces are being removed, or prioritised, then how is it fair for us who cannot afford to buy an ev?

They are charging stations. They generate income for the CP. They aren't parking spaces. Do you park in petrol stations or people's driveways and trot off to do your shopping? Why would you expect to park in an EV charging station?

thorneyislanddoris · 26/10/2023 18:15

YABVVVU

And SELFISH

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 26/10/2023 18:00

Yes, how truly shocking and terrifying that governments actually need to raise tax revenue in order to pay for stuff.

Absolutely fine when they do it fairly, honestly and transparently.

Bramshott · 26/10/2023 17:22

I suspect OP knows the difference very well but just wants to start a bunfight...

Mumaway · 26/10/2023 16:41

Yes usually. Our car park says that you must be charging to park there. Tesla branded chargers start charging you for blocking 5 mins after charging complete

Blueuggboots · 26/10/2023 16:23

It's very frustrating as an electric vehicle owner to find a space to charge being taken up by a car not charging...someone could be desperate for the charge...

user1477391263 · 26/10/2023 14:43

Yes, how truly shocking and terrifying that governments actually need to raise tax revenue in order to pay for stuff. 🙄

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 26/10/2023 14:23

So yes I think the massive difference in running costs will drop but I suspect it won't become more expensive than ICE just more equivalent.

Sorry, I didn't phrase that very well at all. I was meaning once (virtually) all ICE vehicles are gone and EVs are all that remain.

I do agree with you that EVs will end up costing (at least) as much as petrol and diesel cars do now; it's just that (imho) they've been promoted with a twin-pronged approach of environmental benefits and big financial savings.

I don't know if either one of these factors has had more of a bearing in people buying them than the other? If people have been largely swayed to switch by the much reduced running costs (after the initial outlay), I suspect they will end up quite disappointed.

It wouldn't surprise me if we eventually see a specific tax increase based on electricity used to charge EVs - even at home - to take into account the fact that generating the electricity for them still causes a load of pollution, which they may just 'discover' in the same way that they 'discovered' that diesel cars are a lot more polluting, just as soon as they'd told everybody to go and buy one.

Once EVs are all we have, they may even just add it on as standard, so that even non-car-owning households have to pay it too - a bit like everybody currently has to pay for the BBC, even if they only ever watch commercial telly (granted, it is possible to avoid it legally by watching no live TV at all).

However much governments try to make out that 'sin taxes' are there because they want to discourage you from doing/buying something, they frequently budget and plan based on people doing just that - and worry if enough of them stop.

WeMustGetOffTheMountain · 26/10/2023 13:33

I don't drive an EV and I wouldn't dream of parking in one of the charging bays. I think it's very entitled and arrogant to park in one of the charging bays if you don't need to park a vehicle. That would be the equivalent of turning up to a petrol station to find some twat had left their EV parked next to the pump because there was no parking space in the car park. Rude and entitled.

TeenLifeMum · 26/10/2023 13:23

ICE blocking? That’ll get you a ticket. Why do people always think rules don’t apply to them?

user1477391263 · 26/10/2023 13:13

Road pricing will be brought in eventually due to the need to fill in the fiscal black hole left by falling fuel tax and vehicle excise duty, and also due to the need to control the amount of driving that people do. It’ll be horribly unpopular (at least at first…eventually people will get used to it) which is why politicians keep kicking it into the long grass, but it will need to come in at some point.

Biker47 · 26/10/2023 13:05

You'd have to be a special kind of cunt to park in an EV bay in either an ICE vehicle, or an EV that you don't charge.

AdobeWanKenobi · 26/10/2023 11:02

BobblePin · 26/10/2023 00:11

Out car looks like an EV but isn't so ill happily park in those spaces. Thank you very much !

You've managed to remove the exhaust? If not, then it doesn't, no matter how much you think it does. 😂

LameBorzoi · 26/10/2023 10:56

@Ohdearanotheryear No, but I started carrying the marker after coming across cars parked in charging spots when there were clearly other spots available. There used to be a contingent who seemed to think it was funny to do that.

Also, I can't necessarily tell by looking at the car if someone has a disability. Yeah, they may not have the badge, but they might have borrowed someone else's car or something. I can tell by looking if a car is an EV being charged.

wonkylegs · 26/10/2023 10:50

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 26/10/2023 03:47

Slightly off-topic, but I wonder how long it will be - with the fee for charging, the price for the parking (maybe at a premium, if people don't have the spare range to risk trying to find elsewhere) and the pay-per-mile tax that's coming soon - when EVs actually financially cost more to run than petrol or diesel vehicles currently do, irrespective of any environmental benefits in shifting the pollution out of town and to power stations to run them.

Again, this will probably only be a (albeit protracted) temporary problem - until nobody owns their own car anymore and you just call a driverless car on an app to take you where you need to go and then it goes away and sorts itself out so that it's ready for the next person.

They'll still find another way to get tax for it out of us actual humans, though...

I suspect they may become more equal with ICE cars rather than more expensive.
As both with need to pay to park, 'fuel' more equivalent cost, and 'tax' more equivalent
The thing is atm for most current EV owners the expense of charging when out and about is balanced by cheaper charging at home which is what most people do the most - this is probably for many still going to stay cheaper than petrol and diesel costs even with increased demand due to the efficiencies of the newer system and that it can be used with smart charging to balance the grid and also tap into home renewables.

So yes I think the massive difference in running costs will drop but I suspect it won't become more expensive than ICE just more equivalent.

FixTheBone · 26/10/2023 10:37

BobblePin · 26/10/2023 00:11

Out car looks like an EV but isn't so ill happily park in those spaces. Thank you very much !

I've seen people do that. Thankfully my charge cable is long enough that I can park across the front of the bay and still plug in.

Saddlesore · 26/10/2023 10:27

BobblePin · 26/10/2023 00:11

Out car looks like an EV but isn't so ill happily park in those spaces. Thank you very much !

You think your car looks like an EV!!! Why? Have you covered over the front radiator? Or removed the exhaust pipe? You might think it looks like an EV, but I bet no one else does.