Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder when children get manners

110 replies

PestilencialCrisis · 25/10/2023 18:30

Just that really. At what age should children be able to remember to say please, thank you, sorry, pardon etc? Or remember to offer to share things or to automatically ask permission before doing something/taking something without being constantly prompted by adults asking "what do you say?" or "share nicely and offer one to x"

Any helpful tips on getting kids to remember these things themselves?

OP posts:
Londiniumrocks · 25/10/2023 22:29

You have your version of family standards/politeness too, so I don’t care how scruffy our kids look so long as they’re clean, but they do eat sitting a the table, no devices, use a knife and fork properly etc
BFF kids are immaculately turned out at all times but piss about at restaurant tables, are in their phones, run about etc and it doesn’t bother them at all…

retinolalcohol · 25/10/2023 22:27

I remember that if I was taking something from my dad as a kid, and I didn't say please could I have it or thank you for getting it, he would just keep it in his hand. If I ever forgot in public or around others, it would always be 'retinol, what do we say?'

You just have to keep insisting from very early. It's very obvious when I meet an adult whose parents didn't do this Grin rudeness/lack of manners is ingrained over years

VikingLady · 25/10/2023 22:26

Modelling behaviour doesn't work for my kids, btw. Mirroring doesn't work for a lot of autistic kids. They need it explaining instead.

VikingLady · 25/10/2023 22:25

Mine both have ASD/ADHD with a side of pathological demand avoidance, but I've been shit hot on public manners from the start. And I explain repeatedly to them how exactly it makes their lives better: manners = people think you're a nice person = they like you = they make more allowances for you/your meltdowns plus they sometimes give you things.

DD is selectively mute, so we worked out she can smile and nod, or meow (don't ask, she's been a flaming cat for years now).

They're 12 and 8, and I still have to prompt them on occasion. But no one seems to have a problem with that.

Londiniumrocks · 25/10/2023 22:25

When you teach them! Our kids could say a version of ta and please at 2, they were in the first dozen words or so they learned… then you just keep reinforcing -
say please, thank you, you’re welcome, stand back from train doors, let elderly people go first, stand aside for anyone who can’t walk as well as you…

they soon pick up that goos
manners in kids go a looonnnggg way with adults!

DragonflyLady · 25/10/2023 22:22

We just modelled good manners, sometimes quite exaggerated when they were small, and sometimes thanked on behalf of them which prompted them to say thank you. Never actually prompted them to say please and thank you though. Can’t recall how old they were when they automatically said please and thank you.

SantaBarbaraMonica · 25/10/2023 22:22

Mine all have pretty good manners. People often comment on it after play dates. We occasionally have to remind them but DH and I are always polite, even to each other. When he makes me a tea I say thanks babe. If I offer him something he says yes please. I had that hammered into me as a child so it’s been easy to expect it from the kids. I think modelling it is the most important thing.

Mariposista · 25/10/2023 22:20

Ahwig · 25/10/2023 18:46

I started with the word Ta, which my mother hated hearing him say but my son could say that by 2 ish, then as his speech progressed he was able to say thank you properly.
My mother was a stickler for good manners and it was drummed into me as soon as I was able to talk but it backfired once because when I was about 3 -4, we were in a cafe, mum dad and I and suddenly I piped up in a very clear voice, " mummy that man on the next table didn't say please may I leave the table" Apparently my parents wanted the ground to open up but they couldn't tell me off as that was what they had taught me. The man's wife though , as my mum was mumbling sorry, said " you are quite right my dear he didn't and I'm going to tell him off now" 😀

This is absolutely brilliant!
Kids are so funny. Manners are a massive thing in my family and when my son was on his first Reception playdate I was taking him and I was reminding him of 'what do we need to say to Charlie's mummy? And he says 'please and thank you'. And what do we say when it's time to go home? ?thank you for having me'. Good lad. So I drop him off and as I am turning to go, I hear my boy saying 'Hello Charlie's mummy. Please Thank you and thank you for having me'. Then he ran inside to play hahaha

Autumndays22 · 25/10/2023 22:13

Just wanted to comment on this to say some children get anxious around less familiar adults and may not be being rude

wouldthatbeworse · 25/10/2023 22:13

Wow there’s a lot of smug parenting on here.

Hankunamatata · 25/10/2023 22:11

I saw a lovely post on face book about a teacher talking a little bit about manners. I showed my own older kids as it just explains it perfectly (they are nd and manners don't come naturally)
https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=pfbid02h2HTyVYSVekbsAn3SqhpvnBXTqWHFNwku68UgsoA2b62oe1Wkv33rNJpv5QZdMD4l&id=569545120

Log in or sign up to view

See posts, photos and more on Facebook.

https://m.facebook.com/story.php?id=569545120&story_fbid=pfbid02h2HTyVYSVekbsAn3SqhpvnBXTqWHFNwku68UgsoA2b62oe1Wkv33rNJpv5QZdMD4l

spidermonkeys · 25/10/2023 22:07

My children have lots of faults, so I'm absolutely not playing the perfect parent here.

BUT... please and thank you we're automatic by the time they were all 2ish. Every parents evening I have been to the first thing commented on has always been what lovely manners they have and how polite they are.

IMO, it's modelling the behaviour. Always say please and thank you etc to your children and they very quickly learn to copy too. Every time your little ones draw you a picture, give you a rock, etc say thank you. They catch on very quickly.

SunSparkle · 25/10/2023 22:06

I think modelling is more important than promoting. If our children consistently hear us say please thank you and you’re welcome, it becomes second nature to them. Consistency pays off. And also helps role model healthy relationships and interactions.

for example in our house, you always say thank you for your meal. And if part of it is not to your taste, we have a ‘no thank you’ plate to put bits you don’t like. But we do not tolerate ‘yucky’ ‘ewww’ ‘disgusting’ as it’s disrespectful to whoever cooked your meals. You simply just have to say ‘no thank you’.

rbmilliner · 25/10/2023 21:59

Started from day 1 really, always made sure that please, thank you, sorry and acknowledge when spoken to. It was seriously cute as a toddler and was really good at it.

I'd say about 60% at 6 and depends on who's she's with and in what setting. I do think that so few of her peers seem to say please and thank you she thinks she doesn't have to.

Having said that she can turn it on when she wants and is needed though

MissingMoominMamma · 25/10/2023 21:58

I don’t insist on ‘sorry’ at school, but I do encourage the perpetrator to check on the victim to see whether they are ok. Be it verbal, physical or just behaviour that has upset someone else. They quite often end up saying sorry by themselves once the repair has been done.

Sorry just as a word is pointless.

nopenotforme · 25/10/2023 21:52

Teach them to say 'please may I have' etc, stops all that 'what's the magic word?' stuff :)

yellowlane · 25/10/2023 20:22

My dc had manners from age 2. She's still very polite at 12. Always says please, thank you, thanks us for making dinner or doing other things for her.

Weeteeny · 25/10/2023 19:59

I think just start early, reinforce with repitition and always show by example too, and it will become second nature.

My two teenage boys (19 and 16) have lovely manners, my lovely mum helped drill manners into all her grand children
I remember picking them up from their granny's when they were small and asked how their day had been, to be told by DS2 who was around 5.at the time they had been "learning manners from Granny" which made us all laugh and granny look a bit sheepish.

To this day they still put their cutlery together after each meal, offer to help tidy up and say please may I leave the table. Granny ensured they knew it was rude to leave before everyone had finished, dont start until everyone was served etc. No elbows on table and also thank you for making dinner etc after every meal. Table manners were so important to her and each time they say please may I leave the table we all smile and it makes me think of my lovely mum.

Perseverance is key

gotomomo · 25/10/2023 19:56

When do you teach them - straight away
When do they start remembering done of the time - straight away
When do they always remember - never!

In other words you will need to remind but that will reduce over time. You need to be consistent though

imnotthatkindofmum · 25/10/2023 19:56

My kids use manners with everyone except me. They've all been good when out and about since small. I think they watch my modelled behaviour and act accordingly but at home we're still probably not as polite so they follow suit

SleepingStandingUp · 25/10/2023 19:53

RogerTaylorsdrumstool · 25/10/2023 19:45

Agree..

My 2 year old grandson is being taught please and thank you

Well those aren't the same thing. StBrides is saying by 2 hers would say please, thank you, sorry, pardon etc. unprompted. I think it's quite unusual for them to have that level of manners without prompting at 2.

I think like your grandson, most are still learning it at this age.

Op, at nearly 4, they'll remember about 50% to say thank you when we get off the bus, go to the shop etc but will say when reminded "what do we say?". DS, 8, needs reminding occasionally.
The 3 you share really well unless they don't want to

Ilikeyourdecor · 25/10/2023 19:52

My 2.5 yr old almost always says please and thank you and sorry. Rarely says excuse me and does interrupt though.

DH and I are very polite and if dc doesn't say please or thank you I stop what I'm doing and raise my eyebrow at them, and they remember.

I should work more on the interrupting now I've read this thread!

Anamausername · 25/10/2023 19:50

Starting to be consistent in my 2 year old. My 5 year old occasionally forgets her manners but we ignore the comment and she asks again properly.

Not in a really formal way - just speak how you’d like to be spoken to. She’s started saying ‘thanks for dinner mum / dad’ off her own back, so I think she now has inherent awareness of others.

CopernicusCalled · 25/10/2023 19:48

My experience is that at 2/3 they are adorable and enthusiastically say 'yes peese mummy!' and 'fankoo' and all sorts of heart melting toddler talk that makes you think they are going to be the most polite and well spoken child in human history.

At about 4/5 it begins to slide and you gently remind them.

My eldest is nearly 8 and some of the absolute cheek, backchat and lack of manners from him is hair raising.

I'm assuming/hoping it all falls back into place and they'll be polite as adults. They are polite to others when out of the house so I think that's a sign they know the score, they just choose to push it a bit with me.

Girasoli · 25/10/2023 19:48

DS2 (3) is very polite and usually says please and thank you unprompted, he will also sometimes tidy up after himself unprompted (thank you nursery!)

DS1 (7) needs to be reminded more to say please/thank you but apologises without prompting if he accidentally hurts someone/makes a big mess. He is still a very messy eater though.