Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder when children get manners

110 replies

PestilencialCrisis · 25/10/2023 18:30

Just that really. At what age should children be able to remember to say please, thank you, sorry, pardon etc? Or remember to offer to share things or to automatically ask permission before doing something/taking something without being constantly prompted by adults asking "what do you say?" or "share nicely and offer one to x"

Any helpful tips on getting kids to remember these things themselves?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
aSofaNearYou · 26/10/2023 22:36

My nearly 5 year old forgets some times, but has recently started saying please and then saying "I said please the first time" afterwards, so our many reminders seem to be sinking in.

Alalalalalongalalalalalonglonglilong · 26/10/2023 22:05

I work with children age 3 to 5, the youngest ones when they begin never ever have manners. I've noticed this quite consistently. Even when they have extremely polite parents. Either they are a little young to model adults or they need to be taught, I don't know. We are very strict on this and by mid term they all say please and thank you etc when pouring a drink for example. If they don't say it we hesitate and ask them if they have forgotten something. We always say thank you to them and are careful to model too. We tell them if someone is playing in a way you don't like you say 'no thank you' not yell or hit, which is much more instinctive at that age. What I also find interesting is that many of them, even the articulate chatty ones, dont use words at lunch time and do things like hold out a cup and make baby noises indicating they want a drink. We pretend we don't understand and suddenly they are capable of asking.

Whiskerson · 26/10/2023 21:58

PestilencialCrisis · 25/10/2023 18:46

Thank you 🙏 this makes me feel a bit better. I agree that manners are so important, but I'm constantly prompting all the time and feel embarrassed that they don't automatically say please/thank you to friends, family, shopkeepers, waiting staff etc.

I asked them today "what would you do if someone gave you a chocolate bar?" and they both replied quickly "say thank you" so they do KNOW it, they just don't DO it!

Hearing the parent prompting is so much better than nothing, though.

Anyone who's ever had any dealings with kids knows that they don't always remember their Ps and Q's. But what's annoying is when the parents do nothing to remind them. It's so much better to hear a "Now, what do you say to the lady?" even if the child still says nothing, then at least you can exchange wry smiles with the other adult! It shows you're making an effort to teach your child manners, and that's the main thing. We all know it takes time.

suntannedsnowballs · 26/10/2023 21:53

My 2yo has been saying thank you since she was about 14m old

I don't negotiate on manners

Brainfogmcfogface · 26/10/2023 21:51

Mine always have. As babies I always used please and thank you when speaking to them and it’s been apart of their vocabulary’s since they started talking. It’s a non negotiable, and something I won’t budge on, it’s important. My youngest has speech issues and until recently could only say a few words, please and thank you were part of her limited vocabulary. In fact I always get comments on how polite my children are, not even a humble brag, full on boast from me, I’m very proud of how nice my kids are and how well they behave (with others, of course at home they have their moments) I’m doing this alone whilst being very poor, no support at all and caring for elderly infirm parents, so hearing positive feedback about them is such a relief!

RoseGoldEagle · 26/10/2023 21:30

My 7 year old is very polite, and my 3 year old seems to have grasped that adults seem pleased when she says please or thank you so she’s pretty good. My 4 nearly 5 year old hardly ever remembers, I just remind him and he’ll get there. They’re all different.

PestilencialCrisis · 26/10/2023 21:26

Justbefore · 26/10/2023 10:25

In general children copy how they’re spoken to. If you constantly say things to your toddler like “Darling, please can you pass me the salt… Thank you so much” you’re going to end up with a much politer child than if you say “Dc! Ffs can’t you see mummy needs the salt?!”

There’s no age, it’s part of teaching language. If they forget to say thank you, I never did the “What do you say?! What do you say?!” Because that isn’t how civilised people talk to each other. Instead I’d say something like “Love, I know you didn’t mean to, but when you forgot to say thank you, it made me feel unappreciated and that kind of hurt my feelings and made me feel like not bothering to help the next time you ask. I’d love it if next time you could try harder to remember to say thank you. Thank you.”

My child had incredibly polite manners (childminders said they’d never encountered such a well behaved child) until he started school and then obvs started copying the nasty way teachers talk to children and peers do to each other. But you can combat that with discussions about it.

Thank you, will try that (the second paragraph that is - I'm already pretty good at not screaming FFS at them 😁)

OP posts:
HarrysStyle · 26/10/2023 14:11

I agree with @Justbefore with everything apart from the nonsense about teachers speaking negatively towards children, I don't know what she's on about here at all. Confused

Justbefore · 26/10/2023 10:25

In general children copy how they’re spoken to. If you constantly say things to your toddler like “Darling, please can you pass me the salt… Thank you so much” you’re going to end up with a much politer child than if you say “Dc! Ffs can’t you see mummy needs the salt?!”

There’s no age, it’s part of teaching language. If they forget to say thank you, I never did the “What do you say?! What do you say?!” Because that isn’t how civilised people talk to each other. Instead I’d say something like “Love, I know you didn’t mean to, but when you forgot to say thank you, it made me feel unappreciated and that kind of hurt my feelings and made me feel like not bothering to help the next time you ask. I’d love it if next time you could try harder to remember to say thank you. Thank you.”

My child had incredibly polite manners (childminders said they’d never encountered such a well behaved child) until he started school and then obvs started copying the nasty way teachers talk to children and peers do to each other. But you can combat that with discussions about it.

LittleBearPad · 26/10/2023 09:07

Autumndays22 · 25/10/2023 22:13

Just wanted to comment on this to say some children get anxious around less familiar adults and may not be being rude

If they can ask for an icecream/drink or accept one that is offered they can say please and thank you. (SEN aside)

LittleBearPad · 26/10/2023 09:05

PestilencialCrisis · 26/10/2023 02:52

100%!

Mainly from parents of preschoolers.

It all goes to pot at school and you’re back to reminding them. Just keep going modelling and reminding nagging them and it will stick eventually.

Elvis1956 · 26/10/2023 08:45

I'm 55 and still sometimes forget! My parents were very keen on manners and being polite. But I was a shy child so and often struggled to even say thank you to an adult.
But I am positive that most parents get it right and that most kids are polite. I'm a people watcher and I am surprised how good a lot of kids are in that way. I'm a working class person and my cousin's kids and I have a lot of cousins, have had it drilled into them to say please and thank you.

PerspiringElizabeth · 26/10/2023 07:41

Parakeetamol · 25/10/2023 18:33

I think manners are possibly the most important thing ever. I have always been strict with wanting please and thank yous. Do they do it? No, at 9 and 4 they NEVER say it unless prompted. I find it infuriating and constantly explain how rude it is, refuse to give them anything until they've asked politely. But no, it just won't go in.

Same 😄😄 well my oldest, 8 years, constantly needs reminding. He HAS been taught since a baby. Everyone says he’s polite (teachers, waiters etc) and he does ask nicely, but THANK YOU is a real battle!! I think when something he wants is given to him eg pudding, he just wants it ASAP and forgets to say thank you 😄😤

AllotmentTime · 26/10/2023 07:39

What do you do when modelling/prompting good manners isn't working?

Keep persevering and they will get it. As they get older they will start doing more things you can thank them for, and that will be your modelling. And then when you do get a genuine spontaneous thank you for making their favourite dinner or whatever, hopefully your beaming smile reinforces to them how much it means ☺️

Also in my experience there will be a sudden switch where you will go "What do you say?" And realise that actually they were Just About to say thank you and you interrupted them 🤣

Shutthedoormargaret · 26/10/2023 07:12

I think you have to be very strict from the moment they're able to communicate and then remind them in every interaction if they forget. Obviously with a small child it's mostly modelling saying please and thank you etc and reminding them to say it (or try to!).

Mine are 9 and 12 now and are good with manners most of the time (especially with people outside our family) but still need reminding sometimes, especially if they're distracted with something else.

Tone / choice of words is also important when they're older. I sometimes have to ask my kids to say something again more politely because shoving a please on the end doesn't stop something sounding rude.

Starrystarryfight · 26/10/2023 07:05

I do think that if you’re thinking about it and asking here you are probably likely to be keeping it a high priority in your every day life and modelling/reminding already.

My kids can be pains in the arse at home but their manners when out or with other people are impeccable because it was always my ‘thing’ (probably at the expense of other important things tbh)

MaryShelley1818 · 26/10/2023 06:57

DS5 always has beautiful manners, is complimented on it in school regularly.
DD2 I would say 90% of the time but still needs a few reminders.
We've literally drummed it into them from Day one so now it's just second nature to them both.

Usernamesarenoteasy · 26/10/2023 06:30

It's a long slog teaching them. However my kids are now mid teens, and I'm oh so proud of them every single time they say please and thank you. In shops, restaurants, when strangers hold doors open....
It does sink in eventually!

LoreleiG · 26/10/2023 06:17

I think you just have to keep on reminding them and doing it yourself. This is what my parents did and I am now the world’s most polite adult so I live in hope for my own kids.

It’s tedious though isn’t it? It’s also tedious how many perfect parents there always are on these threads!

Thepossibility · 26/10/2023 06:02

As soon as they were learning to talk

ChristinaNotChristine · 26/10/2023 05:55

When they learn to speak and ask for things. All my kids have wonderful manners. They did when they were toddlers and they still do now, even if it's just the teenager thanking the little brother for handing over the tv remote. A please and thank you is always said.

RenegadeMasterx · 26/10/2023 05:13

First thing I taught my two. Everytime I handed them something even from 6 months old I'd say 'ta' or 'thank you mummy' and my children have said please and thank you from the moment they could talk properly. It's so important to instil manners in your children

PestilencialCrisis · 26/10/2023 03:01

hoobanoobie · 26/10/2023 02:06

This. I loved that my DD was always complimented on her manners from aged 3. You teach them, they learn. It's an important part of growing and it's a parents job to instil manners from an early age. First building block towards becoming a civilised human. Why is this a question?

It's a question because this is a parenting forum and this is something I am struggling with as a parent and so I'm asking for advice.

I am doing everything I can think of to instill good manners because I value good manners and I want my children to be polite and I want advice on how I can help them have good manners.

What do you do when modelling/prompting good manners isn't working?

OP posts:
PestilencialCrisis · 26/10/2023 02:52

wouldthatbeworse · 25/10/2023 22:13

Wow there’s a lot of smug parenting on here.

100%!

OP posts:
PestilencialCrisis · 26/10/2023 02:26

This is something I worry about. I am a single parent, so the children don't see anyone else thanking me for making dinner, pouring drinks, tidying up etc. Although I model manners at home, I do worry that they don't see anyone else thanking me for the day-to-day stuff, so aren't exposed enough to pleases and thank yous.

(Before anyone jumps on, I'm sure there are lots of polite children with single mothers, I am just saying this is something I personally am worrying about as my children are not saying please/thank you automatically and despite my modelling they do need constant reminders).

OP posts: