Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you do if you pay for your children's education

87 replies

Satonmytuffet · 25/10/2023 15:15

DH thinks we can afford to send our children to private school starting from pre-prep all the way until university. I disagree. Neither of us went to private schools but DH went to Oxford many years ago now and feels that private school is the best way to go. I would agree if I thought we could afford it but I don't think we can. DH is a solicitor. I am at a crossroads in my career and I am looking to move into something where it would ultimately give me a 6 figure salary but I just feel like people who do send their kids to private schools are much much more well off than we are. Our combined household income is £175k and we live in London.

We currently have one DC but we hope to have another 2 children, or at least 1 more if things don't go to plan. That would ultimately mean yearly fees of £90k at the most.

If all your children are privately educated what sort of jobs do you do? Does generational wealth come into play?

OP posts:
BlowingInTheWind82 · 25/10/2023 22:56

Factor in music lessons (£25 per instrument per week), trips (varies across year groups).

The PTA will do great second hand sales on uniform.

Smartiepants79 · 25/10/2023 22:54

We have a combined income of about £130,000.
Both DC are now at private school. From age 9 onwards. I wouldn’t bother with private before then myself. Use the money for a bit of tutoring if required when needed.
Their fees are not even close to what you’re suggesting though. We pay around £29,000 per year for both! Not in London. We’re very happy with our choice and both kids thriving.

BlowingInTheWind82 · 25/10/2023 22:54

We did State til 8, I would suggest that’s your best time to make the move. If you do 11+ then make sure you’re pushing your DC on the sports side, that’s where the State school kids struggle against those having been in prep.

theduchessofspork · 25/10/2023 22:51

You may well be able to afford it but it’s fairly nuts to go private till 8 unless you are swimming in it, and most people hold off till 11 (tutoring from 9 for 11+)

Rather than adopt polarised positions, crunch the actual numbers according to your outgoings as well as your income, and allowing for realistic rises in fees and mortgage.

BlowingInTheWind82 · 25/10/2023 22:48

Hello @Satonmytuffet no need, this is it - you can do it per child and put in fee rises etc I found it very useful in working out how much it’ll cost us per child (and you can put in point of entry too).

https://www.candidmoney.com/calculators/school-fees-affordability-calculator

Candid Money: School Fees Affordability Calculator

Calculate whether sending your child to private school will leave you under a mountain of debt

https://www.candidmoney.com/calculators/school-fees-affordability-calculator

Satonmytuffet · 25/10/2023 22:48

Thank you everyone. I found your replies really useful and insightful (and mildly demoralising hehe!) I feel like I am really letting the side down with my salary. I'm in academia without a PhD and my earning potential is tragic. I'm looking into literally anything private sector that will pay £££ and with a bonus. However I had hopes of being a bit more present as a mum but I just feel like all the money pressure is on DH and also not sustainable.

For those asking our mortgage is £1500 but DH and I need to do a proper sit and analyse our pensions, savings etc. DH is a real bury-head-in-sand type of guy but is excellent at saving pennies and I am not great with money (but hellbent on improving)

OP posts:
Satonmytuffet · 25/10/2023 22:40

BlowingInTheWind82 · 25/10/2023 18:33

We have a net income of £134k and send two. One to Prep and one to Seniors. Our fees are about £30k a year for both.
we have a tiny mortgage £700pm! we will be upsizing in the next 24 months. School fees have gone up 6% one year then 8% the following year! I will post you a very useful spreadsheet. We have savings and occasional Grandparent gifts probably about £2-£3k a year that we use for their extra-curricular out of school.

DH is a Junior Partner. I run my own sales business.

Yes please, that would be super helpful. Should I private message you my email address?

OP posts:
SphincterSaysWhat · 25/10/2023 21:41

Ps 3 kids 🙄🙄🙄

SphincterSaysWhat · 25/10/2023 21:40

Equity partner (solicitor) and global sales manager for an American company.

BlowingInTheWind82 · 25/10/2023 21:22

I should say I put about £40k a year into my pension through my company and DH prob pays about £25k into his.

HomeatRoseCottage · 25/10/2023 20:51

Fees for private school are around £13k per year where we live. We’re going to do it for secondary but not primary (in catchment for a good primary and I would like my son to make local friends).

Our household income is about £120k, grandparents are going to help with fees. It’s years in the future for us so we might not need GP help by then, but the offer is there if we do.

My husband and I were both privately educated and though we would like to live in a socialist utopia where everyone had equal access to superb, free education in good facilities, that isn’t real life and we would like our child to have the same opportunities we did. We benefited a lot from the educations we received, and it’s a sad fact that if you can pay for the privilege it sets your children in good stead.

scottishmam75 · 25/10/2023 20:49

I earn £150k, Dh £155k plus £25k bonus and we have rental income post tax £12k so £340k approx. Mortgage is £520/£1.2m house costs £2.6k a month. Overpay £1.5k a month

We couldnt afford private without reducing pensions (£2k pcm each) or mortgage overpayment (£1.5k).

We're 40 but realistic most people in IT/ Risk ops lesdership managed out 55ish

Uni is £27k fees, if u pay fees, rental and some living costs thats £70k per child.

Our priority is mortgage, pension, uni

Do u want to be hard up at retirement or not able to afford uni? Sounds like your priority should be career and pension. Not this perhaps

Fifteenth · 25/10/2023 20:41

I earn much less than you do but I saved for a decade before they were born, and continuously ever since.

lekomees · 25/10/2023 20:38

We have one dc in prep and another due to start in a couple of years. Planning to send both private from 4-18. Joint income is £490k, DH works in tech and I run a business. We're in London and our housing costs are high (house in zone 2). No family help. We have some significant investments (raised through savings, not gifted).

I think some state primaries in London are excellent and if I wasn't averse to living further out then I'd seriously consider buying in the catchment of one of the top primaries (by which I mean well within the furthest distance offered) and ideally also in catchment of a top secondary (ideally comp so it only depends on distance, and co-ed if you have different seats or dc aren't all born yet). There are only a few places in London that are in the sweet spot of both though, and those locations didn't appeal to us. But with a bigger family and lower family income it would make more sense than going private.

Pennyslotmachine · 25/10/2023 18:45

We have 1 child in private education. Fees are currently £18k per year then I’d say we spend another £1k on extra curricular, trips, music lessons etc. Our combined income is around £150k and we have no inheritance/help from family. We’re not in London though (I’m from London but we were completely priced out) and now live in a commutable city where we bought a decent house for £500k so our mortgage is nothing like London prices. We’re in the precarious situation of paying the fees from our income (i.e. we don’t have a back up fund) but for us it’s totally worth it.

Busyhedgehog · 25/10/2023 18:38

DH and I are both teachers. DS attends my school. His fee discount will increase as he goes through school but our fees aren't comparable to those in London in thr first place. Our combined income is much lower than yours. We live out in the country, though, so it's fine.
If DS gets through the entrance requirements for our senior school, he'll stay at his independent school throughout. If he doesn't, he'll most likely go to our local grammar school or one of the other independent schools around. We'll see. His current school is the best fit for our family at the moment.

BlowingInTheWind82 · 25/10/2023 18:34

I should say DH could get about £15k net bonus and I prior to taking my salary/dividend make sure I put a lot into my pension.

BlowingInTheWind82 · 25/10/2023 18:33

We have a net income of £134k and send two. One to Prep and one to Seniors. Our fees are about £30k a year for both.
we have a tiny mortgage £700pm! we will be upsizing in the next 24 months. School fees have gone up 6% one year then 8% the following year! I will post you a very useful spreadsheet. We have savings and occasional Grandparent gifts probably about £2-£3k a year that we use for their extra-curricular out of school.

DH is a Junior Partner. I run my own sales business.

Saschka · 25/10/2023 18:30

You can probably afford it if you stick at 1. You cannot possibly afford it if you have 3 children, unless you have significant family money behind you.

I’m a hospital consultant, we have a similar household income to you, also in London. Private schools locally are £25k per year. For three children, you’d be spending £75k per year on fees. We are not hard up in any way, but we do not have £6k per month spare to spend on school fees! We send DS to state (and he is doing well, no complaints).

I do have colleagues with multiple primary-aged children in private school, but the common denominator is that they are not paying the fees themselves, the grandparents are.

casuarinatree · 25/10/2023 18:30

We are in London and have a joint income of around £120 - 150k depending on bonuses/ freelance income.

We have 3DC at a combination of state and private depending on what was right at each stage for each child.

There is no way we could afford to send even one child private with a London mortgage unless we made massive sacrifices to our lifestyle (and we are hardly extravagent). We are very fortunate that GPs cover fees for us and we pay all extras. Ultimately - that will probably be my entire inheritance though.

Mumsanetta · 25/10/2023 18:25

On your current salary I would say you can afford to put one in private education as long as you have a small mortgage.

We have a joint income of £185k and can only afford to send one but that’s because we have a tiny mortgage (around £1.5k pm). DD5 is in reception and all in the school fees are £2k a month.

I’m the solicitor and I’m on £150k.

VanCleefArpels · 25/10/2023 18:18

Satonmytuffet · 25/10/2023 16:33

Are you partners? DH was in private practice but went in house in September. Salary is significantly lower but bonus potential of 100+% - we don't know yet what that will look like as he's only just started and I'm pessimistic.

Save those bonuses!! As others have said secondary is where paying for school makes the difference so you have time

ThereItIs1 · 25/10/2023 17:50

We have 1 DC and currently trying for another. DC is at a private prep, and the hope is that their sibling will join. HOWEVER I'm a teacher at the same school, so get a hefty fee discount, my husband works in insurance, our combined income is just over £110k, both in our early thirties. Our plan is to privately educate our children into secondary, but that is reliant on myself managing to maintain said hefty discount, it wouldn't be viable for us to send both children to private school without it.

ChienneDesFromages · 25/10/2023 17:50

To pay 90k of fees, you’ll need about 180k of salary. I guess only you can decide whether you can live on your salary and DH can put all of his (and a bit more) to school fees, and still give your kids and yourselves the life you want.

We are solicitor and psychologist. Joint income (mostly DH’s drawings) was 520k last year. We’ve only had 2 years of all 3 at private school, it’s generally only been one or two, because we’ve also used grammar schools/ local primaries. When he was a junior partner (on 150 or so) DFIL helped with fees.

I know there’s no way we’d have afforded the fees (even for 2) on 175k. At least, not as well as affording the other things we value (travel, cultural stuff, pets, a nice house etc.) But your lifestyle, housing costs and family situation might be different.

DOmeafavor · 25/10/2023 17:40

If I were you I’d buy in an area with good state schools and therefore have the money to support the DC with extra curricular activities. Best of both worlds.

Swipe left for the next trending thread