Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you do if you pay for your children's education

87 replies

Satonmytuffet · 25/10/2023 15:15

DH thinks we can afford to send our children to private school starting from pre-prep all the way until university. I disagree. Neither of us went to private schools but DH went to Oxford many years ago now and feels that private school is the best way to go. I would agree if I thought we could afford it but I don't think we can. DH is a solicitor. I am at a crossroads in my career and I am looking to move into something where it would ultimately give me a 6 figure salary but I just feel like people who do send their kids to private schools are much much more well off than we are. Our combined household income is £175k and we live in London.

We currently have one DC but we hope to have another 2 children, or at least 1 more if things don't go to plan. That would ultimately mean yearly fees of £90k at the most.

If all your children are privately educated what sort of jobs do you do? Does generational wealth come into play?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
tennesseewhiskey1 · 27/02/2024 14:15

Finance and PR. No generational wealth.

Hobitmum · 05/12/2023 02:17

We both work in IT and are self employed, averaging £8000 per month after tax. We have two kids in private education.

We do make sacrifices to make it work by living in a small 2 bedroom flat, only 1 holiday abroad every 2 years, don’t eat out much and have a babysitter for a date night once every 2 - 3 months. We don’t have any financial help and we have a fairly small mortgage for London (£2000 pm).

I think it’s a case of priorities if you’re on a middle income like us - family home + regular holidays + school fees in London (where we are) needs much more income or other wealth / help. We went for small flat, less travel and school fees as we both valued that more.

scottishmam75 · 26/10/2023 11:39

Interesting debate!

I had 3 kids in 4yrs so would always be a triple hit for about 15y from Yr7- end of uni, so that's a big factor

I went to state schl snd so did DH and all my uni friends. Everyone ambitious and personable is in finance, law, medicine.

My 3 kids are all hardworking and sociable. The older 2 attend career events now as young teens and my son wants quant work experience as soon as he can.

The local state comp here has many v biright kids eg top set for maths is based on SAT score 113-120, where 110 os Greater Depth and 2 sets at this level (of 8).

Kids i know going private (£25k fees) are mostly only children, immigrant kids of builders etc sold a dream, mostly grandparent funded. One girl we know, funded by warehouse business parenfs, was below mid level for maths & english at school. One boy only child got a football sponsorhip but is not bright at all.

Also contextual scoring means private is seen more harshly.

I dont know, didnt seem a good investment of £800k, prefer to pay them through uni and have btl they can live in, instead. And pay for 4-5h turoring a week each child.

Good luck whatever u decide- but use pension calculator first :)

fizzandchips · 26/10/2023 10:47

Usually yes, unless they are in a combined business with a separate prep and senior school which come under the same foundation. Independent School fees will rise if Labour win the next GE.
It depends on your priorities. Many couples both thrive in their careers and independent school can offer the wrap around care they require to facilitate this - often meaning their children eat three meals a day at school. Be careful you don’t allow the tail to wag the dog so to speak, if you are happy in your academic career with long holidays you won’t need to pay for holiday clubs and so your lower income will balance out. Many children will thrive in state school with committed parents who are around and available at the end of the school day and can then pay for holidays, tutors (if necessary) and after school clubs. And as others have mentioned attending state school is shown to increase the chance of being accepted in to Oxbridge.

Heatherbell1978 · 26/10/2023 10:04

Penguinsmum · 26/10/2023 09:51

@heather....out of £300k after tax NI pension etc we are left with about half of that. Yes still a lot but we have a big mortgage and we want to save quite a lot to make sure we always have money for fees even if our circumstances change for the worse. Maybe we are overly cautious.

Yes I guess that's my point about lifestyle. You have a large mortgage which presumably means a large house etc. No judgement, but on the lifestyle we lead, we'd see that as a huge amount and would have no qualms about private school fees.
Someone else on this thread said they would struggle but that's after paying £8k a month for mortgage and pension contributions. Again linked to a fairly extravagant lifestyle compared with most people.

Penguinsmum · 26/10/2023 09:51

@heather....out of £300k after tax NI pension etc we are left with about half of that. Yes still a lot but we have a big mortgage and we want to save quite a lot to make sure we always have money for fees even if our circumstances change for the worse. Maybe we are overly cautious.

mondaytosunday · 26/10/2023 09:24

We sent our kids private after my eldest didn't get in to the nearest four state schools due to oversubscription. The one offered was in measures and far away. We could afford to send him to private so we did (husband was a London lawyer). Daughter followed.
It costs, in London, about £20k a year each child for fees, plus uniform etc on top. My daughter left Sixth form last year and her fees were just over £26k, and they go up about 5% or more a year.
I went to a (very good) state school, my husband private. We both have post graduate degrees.
The value is arguable. If my son had got in to one of those nearby state schools we would have happily kept him there at least for primary education - all were rated 'excellent' by Ofsted. He was not an academic child and left to go to a vocational college at 16 (just as covid hit - disaster). But I think he gained a lot from the school in other ways.
My daughter is academic and gained A stars x 3 at A level. Would she have achieved that at a state school? Maybe. But again she has gained a lot that is not necessarily quantifiable. Where we moved to for the majority of their schooling there were no good state options snd I simply would not have moved if that had been my only choice.
Many of my friends children who went to state school have achieved as well as my friends kids who went to private school. Several of the private kids I know went to Oxbridge/Durham/Imperial/Kings whereas none of the state kids did - they went to Manchester/Sheffield/BU/Bristol/Brookes (as did several of the private kids I know and all fine institutions of course), this has not been indicative of how they have succeeded post graduation, though they are still young yet. Important to note: three kids I know who didn't go to university at all are doing well now in their 30s.
Of my circle, when my husband was alive, we were the wealthiest on paper. Most other families with private school kids either had just one child, family help with fees, in one case a full scholarship, or made just enough to prioritise it over other things. These were outside of London though - if they had lived in London I don't think they could have swung it bar one or two of them.
I'm not sure many of these kids, if any, will be able to send their own kids to private school - none have picked particularly high earning careers.

AmberFields · 26/10/2023 09:14

Peoples circumstances that I know well that were privately educated.

Full scholarships, hospital consultants, senior civil servant in Whitehall, CEO of a global company, worked at the school for fee reduction.

@Stylestuck makes a valid point whilst not favoured quite as people may assume widening participation means formulas such as deprived postcodes are taken in to consideration. I worked in academia for years as does DH who is a head of dept now. Both of us had the poison chalice of admissions in our respective departments for a number of years.

Trust in your own child, you will know them better than anyone here. MIL and FIL offered money to pay a significant proportion of school fees for DS. We turned them down and DS went to the local comp which was close by, DH had a 1.5 to 2 hour commute to his very prestigious school and had zero local friends and it was rubbish for him. DS got all A at A level, no fees, no commute, lots of local friends and he is now doing a paid degree apprenticeship so will have zero debt. He didn’t need the extra help that private schools offer, small classes, filtering children because of an entrance exam being the main two. A private school education does not always mean success. DS GF went to a dreadful comp, I mean really bad, she just got a first and walked straight in to a great job three weeks after finishing uni.

Success overall can start with grades and who you know but there is the innate unchangeable personality that we all have.

MintJulia · 26/10/2023 09:00

£60kish. Single mum. Work in IT.

DS went to state primary, then independent from 11. He won a scholarship that pays 50% fees and was determined to go - he likes maths - so I cover the rest. Plus the local state school was in chaos. The trust has since been wound up.

No generational anything - no dgps. It's a stretch for me but he's happy & doing well.

Heatherbell1978 · 26/10/2023 08:33

FirstFallopians · 25/10/2023 23:37

Thank you for replying!

So if self-funders are a minority and so many are relying on a finite funding source (grandparents, a trust etc), does that not mean that it’s the next generation that are fucked fee-wise? Since the money has all been spent.

I see the value in the private system but surely fees as they are in the English system just aren’t sustainable when decreasing numbers of families can afford it?

I've thought about this too - we're in the minority who will pay through income although have fairly well off GPs on my side who would hopefully 'rescue' us if needs be.

I think lots of things will change in the future to be honest. So as an example, a few years ago we wouldn't even consider it citing that we'd much prefer nice exotic holidays etc. Now the holidays seem like a red herring given that we'd actually prefer not to travel to certain locations due to various risk including climate change so actually is it a big deal if we holiday closer to home as that's potentially where things are heading. Not for us anyway.

So there are lots of evolving factors which might push people to prioritise school fees over other things.

ChienneDesFromages · 26/10/2023 08:32

I do think it can be easy to develop a ‘private school above all else’ attitude to schools. Some parents, perhaps because if they’re own bad experiences, because they’ve not experienced alternatives or even because of some status obsession, will not even countenance state schools. Often making significant sacrifices in terms of their own lifestyles and their children’s other opportunities.

It is worth remembering that there are very many excellent state schools out there, often located cheek by jowl with mediocre private schools that people are making significant sacrifices to access. Our three children have attended a total of eight schools between them and, for me, the three best have been the carefully chosen state schools, which have met their needs perfectly, whether that be SEN (two years in a specialist speech and language unit), or a very high achieving grammar school, perfectly.

While a private education is a ‘nice to have’ I would think very carefully about compromising your family’s opportunities for a wide range of extracurricular activities, travel around the world, having parents work, a bit less, or simply being able to live in a more comfortable house to enable 13 years of private school attendance.

blabla2023 · 26/10/2023 07:51

Similar income, 2 kids, just outside London. it works!

Allice · 26/10/2023 07:47

Work at the school, 50% discount, not great salary but most holidays off, I do term time plus 2 weeks.
My son at a different school paying full fee, my husband is a chartered accountant and covers his fees.

Totalwasteofpaper · 26/10/2023 07:45

FirstFallopians · 25/10/2023 23:37

Thank you for replying!

So if self-funders are a minority and so many are relying on a finite funding source (grandparents, a trust etc), does that not mean that it’s the next generation that are fucked fee-wise? Since the money has all been spent.

I see the value in the private system but surely fees as they are in the English system just aren’t sustainable when decreasing numbers of families can afford it?

It's a really good question... I don't know.
My parents were pretty much how you describe yourself and your DH - just normal and stretched to pay fees.

If I think about people I know anecdotally.

Trust funders I know all have a few generations at least (there are millions compounding in interest)
Our neighbours have 2 DC who had an inheritance from the GPs which paid out almost £1m to each child. They both bought houses outright so 30 and mortgage free in London! Neither of DC or partners work in highly paid industrys - 30-50k max) The parents live in a 1.5m house and live quite well so are paying for the private prep school for the 2 X GC. So potentially the money can be recycled once via GPs house for Great GC then after that is gone?

I think it is already close to unattainable for people without asserts/family resources. We earn WELL (like top 2% or something and have pretty much decided against it.

MsSquiz · 26/10/2023 07:40

Dd1 has just started nursery in private school, and all being well, will stay there until 18. With her sister following her in 2 years. The fees in nursery are £10k for the year, and they increase approx £1k a term to reception, years 1-6 and years 7-13.

I am a SAHM & DH has family money, previously as shares in the family company. When they sold the company, they have chosen to make a family investment company as well as private investments. And we live off the return.

We don't live a flashy lifestyle, budget well within our means to ensure that the girls will also benefit from the family money post school.

MiniBossFromAus · 26/10/2023 07:36

We privately educated our 3. From Y5, Y4 & Y7 respectively.

They finish in Y12 in Aus. A total of 23 years of fees at an average of $30k per year.

So $690,000.00 over a 14 year period - c.49000 a year.

We are broke beyond measure. Literally haven't got 2 cents to rub together. We earn well but this is a huge and consistent amount of money to hand out each month.

A few things to consider - once you do it for one it becomes harder not to do it for all of your children.

Knowing what I know now, I would probably still choose the same path. I would have started all three in Y7 though.

potatoheads · 26/10/2023 07:36

There are private school fees and private school fees. £60k a year vs £18k a year for senior school. At junior level it's cheaper. If you send your dc to pre prep at a cheaper end it's doable. By the time you have 2-3 what will you be earning?

£60k boarding for 2-3 kids? Not a chance unless you are in the very highest earner group. That's 7 figures

ThereItIs1 · 26/10/2023 07:31

Satonmytuffet · 26/10/2023 05:38

Maybe a silly question but discounted fees only in the school you are teaching in, right?

Yes, but many prep schools have tie ins with other schools. I teach at a prep school in Scotland where I get 80% fee discount, but we have a few large senior private schools near us who offer us the same discount at their school. I honestly don't know how long this 'perk' will last, so it's my intention to try and get a job in a 5-18 private school to ensure my child's education.

Stylestuck · 26/10/2023 07:25

Our income is about £150k living in suburbs. We currently send both to private primary at a cost of around 26k a year. When you add in all of our other costs, it’s tight. We don’t have much left over for fun things. We are intending to move to the state system for secondary, we are in a grammar school area and are hoping our eldest will get in there.

For what it’s worth your husband’s assumption that private school is the best route to Oxbridge is false - it is widely reported now that red brick universities are favouring non private school applicants.

Heatherbell1978 · 26/10/2023 07:12

Penguinsmum · 26/10/2023 05:37

We are in Surrey. Household income around £290k / £300 k only one child. Fees around £18-20k per year. Wouldn't be able to do it comfortably if we had 2 DC I don't think

This is where these private school threads become a bit ridiculous. After fees you'd still be left with £200k a year salary? Or maybe slightly less with tax? And that's not enough to live? Lifestyle is a HUGE factor in these discussions. We can afford private school for 2 DC on a joint salary about half of the one quoted here. But we have one car, a 'normal' house, one holiday in France a year etc...

Krystall · 26/10/2023 06:01

Satonmytuffet · 26/10/2023 05:38

Maybe a silly question but discounted fees only in the school you are teaching in, right?

I work in a private school in the finance department. Yes the discounts are only for staff (all staff not just teachers) at our school, we are not connected to other private schools so we do not give discounts to people working in other schools. 😊

MariaVT65 · 26/10/2023 06:01

BlowingInTheWind82 · 25/10/2023 22:54

We did State til 8, I would suggest that’s your best time to make the move. If you do 11+ then make sure you’re pushing your DC on the sports side, that’s where the State school kids struggle against those having been in prep.

This isn’t my experience. My brother and I went to 3 different private schools between us and they didn’t give a shit about how good anyone was at sport. My school didn’t have its own sports ground and was really supportive of SEN. I doubt i’ll ever be able to afford private school but I would hope my son would be fine with his academic skills and not be held back just because he has hypermobility.

OP, this was obv years ago my but my dad owned is own import business and paid for our fees. My mum was a teacher.

I’m guessing things are a lot more expensive in London but something i’ve noticed is that the current private school fees for the school I went to are are pretty much the same as the nursery fees I pay for my son, in year 7 and 8. However, as others have said, the fees then go up each year (plus inflation), so I’d be priced out, and definitely wouldn’t be able to afford more than 1 child.

nibblessquibbles · 26/10/2023 05:50

Satonmytuffet · 26/10/2023 05:46

We will need to sit and fine comb our finances.

Wrt investment plans do you mean saving in a high interest account/investing in stocks and shares?

Stocks and shares mostly. My financial advisor helped find something that gave reasonable stable returns rather than something high risk as I really couldn't afford to lose the initial capital and take big risks. The good thing is if you start early enough then even putting a small amount aside every month will reap returns over the long term but you need to be thinking at least 5+ years and ideally longer. At least that has worked out for me.

Satonmytuffet · 26/10/2023 05:46

nibblessquibbles · 26/10/2023 05:43

Can you afford to start saving now? As PPs have said it really depends on your mortgage and other outgoings. I pay for my DS through share bonuses that I received in my old job and a good few years ago set up an investment plan to cover the last few years of school. That's now going to pay a bit towards uni as DS has part scholarship at current school. The earlier you set up the investment plan the better the returns as it's a long term thing.
Also depends on location as London privates are expensive!

We will need to sit and fine comb our finances.

Wrt investment plans do you mean saving in a high interest account/investing in stocks and shares?

OP posts:
nibblessquibbles · 26/10/2023 05:43

Can you afford to start saving now? As PPs have said it really depends on your mortgage and other outgoings. I pay for my DS through share bonuses that I received in my old job and a good few years ago set up an investment plan to cover the last few years of school. That's now going to pay a bit towards uni as DS has part scholarship at current school. The earlier you set up the investment plan the better the returns as it's a long term thing.
Also depends on location as London privates are expensive!