Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

parents living the high life

413 replies

nearlyemptynes · 25/10/2023 12:15

Now I know we make our choices in life and we live with them. I have 3 children and have supported the eldest through uni and would do the same for the other two if that's what they want. I see this as our responsibility as parents. I have friends who have not supported their kids, haven't encouraged open days etc then when they kids don't go they have wonderful foreign holidays etc after saying they couldn't afford to send their kids to uni. AIBU to think they have their priorities wrong?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
OldLadyChinaCup · 27/10/2023 00:32

@MumApril1990, @Danielle9891
Unfortunately, the government now disagrees and thinks it very much is the responsibility of the parents.
Accommodation costs vary widely between 6k and 10k but if your household income is 25k or above then your YP is on the sliding scale of what they can get. If, like us, you both earn just over 33k then your YP gets the minimum amount which is around £4600. As you can see that doesn’t even cover rent let alone any sort of living expenses such as food and travel. And with thousands of kids in the same boat all competing for any jobs that come up, it’s really up to parents to either help pay the shortfall on their rent and allow them to eat or they don’t go.

I needed a loan when I went but that was enough to cover rent and food and a little socialising. I then worked during the holidays. It’s a whole different ball game financially these days.

SAHMTO · 27/10/2023 00:11

Firstly what if their child doesn’t want to go to uni?

secondly do you understand how many people actually have degrees these days and don’t use them? They come out of uni with £££’s debt and don’t go into their degree line of work either through lack of opportunities or over saturation of the candidate market. A bog standard degree really isn’t much to write home about anymore these days unless it’s something which specifically requires a degree such as medicine/law.

DoughBallss · 26/10/2023 23:44

Unless my children decide on careers that require uni I absolutely will not be encouraging them to go. What a huge amount of money and time so many people I know have spent on wasted courses because they felt like going to uni was the right thing to do.

TigerQueenie · 26/10/2023 23:36

Treesinmygarden · 26/10/2023 19:05

You can't have been working fulltime and studying fulltime though! You must have been studying parttime? You can't do both at the same time!

Oh and yet there I was doing it. Twice. And here I am doing it again right now.

Many thousands of people work full time and study full time. I even manage to go to the gym, go out with friends, volunteer, fit in some caring responsibilities and spend time with my partner.

TheCompactPussycat · 26/10/2023 23:30

OldLadyChinaCup · 26/10/2023 22:49

@TheCompactPussycat,
Well it is a significant amount. My DD gets minimum loan as apparently 2 parents each earning less than 35k are considered high earners by the government for this purpose. We are not; obviously! The shortfall between her loan and her accommodation is 3.5k. So that’s 3.5k just to pay for where she lives and it’s neither London nor an expensive city or even an expensive accommodation option. Then there’s food and, well, just day to day living. She’s desperately trying to get a job but no luck yet and she’s competing against hundreds of others for every vacancy.

So, maybe not quite tens of thousands each year but certainly a significant amount of around 5k. Her brother is due to go in 2yrs. We are genuinely not sure what to do as we simply can’t afford to help both. Our daughter is talking about transferring back home but our local university is ranked nowhere near the one she’s at and she worked so bloody hard to get there. My husband and I are talking about second jobs but who wants their teacher or nurse to turn up to work having barely got off shift from their extra job? 😔

Oh, I agree. It's not an entirely insignificant amount but posters suggesting it is tens of thousands are unhelpful.

It sounds as though your family income is perhaps around the same as ours. DS also only qualifies for the minimum living costs loan and next year we will have 2 at uni. DS hasn't tried to find a job at uni. Instead he comes home and works full-time in the holidays.

Danielle9891 · 26/10/2023 23:25

The kids can pay for themselves to go to uni through finance. I did. I never got any help from my parents. If I'm honest I'd be embarrassed asking them for help as I had a job as well.

threatmatrix · 26/10/2023 23:23

I totally agree with you and can’t believe some of the comments on here. Even if they don’t do well you can always be assured that you did your best for them. My partner has a good job with good money but if his parents had shown an interest in him he’d have been an architect.

MumApril1990 · 26/10/2023 23:18

Everyone I know including myself got student loans to go through uni, it wasn’t considered the parents responsibility.

GUARDIAN1 · 26/10/2023 23:11

But it's not your business is it OP?

You do you and let others get on with doing themselves.

OldLadyChinaCup · 26/10/2023 22:49

@TheCompactPussycat,
Well it is a significant amount. My DD gets minimum loan as apparently 2 parents each earning less than 35k are considered high earners by the government for this purpose. We are not; obviously! The shortfall between her loan and her accommodation is 3.5k. So that’s 3.5k just to pay for where she lives and it’s neither London nor an expensive city or even an expensive accommodation option. Then there’s food and, well, just day to day living. She’s desperately trying to get a job but no luck yet and she’s competing against hundreds of others for every vacancy.

So, maybe not quite tens of thousands each year but certainly a significant amount of around 5k. Her brother is due to go in 2yrs. We are genuinely not sure what to do as we simply can’t afford to help both. Our daughter is talking about transferring back home but our local university is ranked nowhere near the one she’s at and she worked so bloody hard to get there. My husband and I are talking about second jobs but who wants their teacher or nurse to turn up to work having barely got off shift from their extra job? 😔

PyongyangKipperbang · 26/10/2023 22:32

Depends what you mean by "supported".

Not sending any money at all due to spending it all on holidays etc, isnt ok. But insisting that they use loans for fees and any maintenance loans they are eligible for is fine, it is strongly discouraged to pay uni fees upfront by financial experts.

Lots of low income families cant financially help their kids in uni, I cant. I am on a v low income for various reasons, not least being a carer for my parents. She they manage on their loans and their jobs. They chose their uni's with the cost of living very much in mind. So no SE uni's, definitely nothing in London, Edinburgh etc, that sort of thing. One has graduated, another due to this year and one has just started.

If their kids are doing nothing, thats as much on the kids as the parents. Sounds like the parents know that they have a coaster on their hands and see no point sending good money after bad.

Whoisthee · 26/10/2023 22:21

I have a friend like this. Her parents sold their house last year for £500,000 yet she and her partner are on the breadline, living in a tiny house. They had a baby and she could only have six months Mat leave as she couldn’t afford to have longer off. They made their own garden furniture out of pallets. My mum died last year and she really impressed on me not to end up in their situation. I’m not saying give your children a fortune but a £1000 or so would help.

coffeeaddict77 · 26/10/2023 21:55

BIossomtoes · 26/10/2023 21:04

They didn't go because they didn't do well enough in their A levels and the places went to those that did better.

They’d be getting places now, wouldn’t they? That’s what having better opportunities means.

One section of society (reasonably off but not that academic) may have better opportunities although that is debatable given they might have had a good career without a degree in the 80s. The more academic experience fewer opportunities though as they would have got into universities in the 80s without tuition fees or maintenance loans, unlike today.

TheCompactPussycat · 26/10/2023 21:53

ComtesseDeSpair · 25/10/2023 12:39

There’s a significant difference between affording a holiday and affording “supporting” children through university to the tune of tens thousands of pounds - which is what any meaningful financial support is going to look like over three years. I wouldn’t judge a parent for being unwilling to commit to the latter, nor for encouraging their DC to consider other options - particularly if DC is not hugely academic and ultimately sees university as an “experience.”

Oh, come off it!

It does NOT cost tens of thousands of pounds to support a child through university. I know, as I am doing it. Financially supporting a child through university simply means topping up their minimum maintenance loan to an amount that means they can live. If they qualify for more than the minimum loan, then it will cost parents even less.

Samlewis96 · 26/10/2023 21:50

coffeeaddict77 · 25/10/2023 15:33

They need to do a lot more than just say they are estranged and use a different address. You also have to wait until 25 to be considered a mature student for loan assessment so rather more than a couple of years.

https://www.ucas.com/finance/additional-funding/financial-support-students-not-supported-their-parents-estranged

What if you are a parent before 25? Or married? Surely u must count as independent by then

Samlewis96 · 26/10/2023 21:39

CharlotteBog · 25/10/2023 14:01

Most 6th formers need some parent input in order to attend open days.
Most are not yet financially independent enough to afford to take themselves off to multiple open days, and very many would need support with transport to and from (e.g. collecting from the bus or train station when they arrive back at 10pm).
I think it would be quite hard for a 17 or 18 year student to attend open days without their parents support. This is very different to interference and pushiness.

My son managed. Just drove himself there. Mind you he only went to 2 open days. Provably got me to cough up petrol though lol. And i had paid for driving lesson etc and car was a gift But interference in his decisions wouldn't have been accepted. He's been brought up to be independent and worked as well. Think a tad more independent than the schoolkids. Last year ( his 1st year) he mentioned how immature a lot of the people who had come straight from school were. He didn't do A levels but a BTEC ( equivalent to 3 A levels) at a college so learned to study and manage time a bit better than tesmachers spoon feeding 6 formers

whoamitojudge · 26/10/2023 21:11

BIWI · 25/10/2023 12:19

It's actually none of your business how other people choose to parent, though, is it?

Virtue signalling and moral superiority are not good looks.

Exactly this

MigGirl · 26/10/2023 21:08

@Samlewis96
"You know you don't need parents permission to go to uni don't you? As you will be 18 and a legal adult"

You don't need your parents permission to go to university no. But unless you have lived independently (not in the same property) from them for a reasonable period of time then for grants and loans you are still classed as a dependent and they take your parents income into account. Which can make it a lot hard for young people too then access funds to go to university.

BIossomtoes · 26/10/2023 21:04

They didn't go because they didn't do well enough in their A levels and the places went to those that did better.

They’d be getting places now, wouldn’t they? That’s what having better opportunities means.

coffeeaddict77 · 26/10/2023 21:00

BIossomtoes · 26/10/2023 18:56

It’s still an opportunity older generations didn’t have that younger ones do. Many people did want to go and couldn’t because there simply weren’t enough places.

They didn't go because they didn't do well enough in their A levels and the places went to those that did better. That is still the case although competition is obviously not as high academically for some universities and courses. While you could argue that the less academic have more opportunity to go to university now than then it is the other way around for the less well off, particularly if the parents don't make the contribution they are expected to.

Samlewis96 · 26/10/2023 20:53

MigGirl · 25/10/2023 12:22

Yes university isn't the be all and end all, but I would judge, especially if the kids wanted to go and they said no.

I do question some parents priorities sometimes. My sister has been a bit like this DN really needed extra support at school, I said why don't you pay for a tutor(our parents did for us) Her response was they couldn't afford that, yet they run a caravan and go to America on holiday every year. You know some things are just a bit more important then a fancy holiday.

Edited

You know you don't need parents permission to go to uni don't you? As you will be 18 and a legal adult

coffeeaddict77 · 26/10/2023 20:51

Treesinmygarden · 26/10/2023 19:11

Travel - remember how costly it used to be? Internet - masses of information at their fingertips. We had to go to a library. Mobile phones - can be in contact with anyone at any time. We had to queue to use a payphone.

Far, far more university places. Better job market. Greater opportunities for placement years, all over the world. Remote learning more possible. Fewer exams, more coursework.

Edited

I travelled a lot in the 80s and don't remember it being more expensive than today, not least because the cost of food etc was a lot cheaper in some countries than the UK in comparison today. There are more university places so I suppose that means you don't have to be as academic to get in but other factors such as finance make it more difficult for many students (DH and many of my friends got full grants and obviously no fees). Also you didn't need a degree for a lot of good careers anyway unlike today.

Some might like more coursework and less exams but many don't. I prefer exams. It's not an opportunity anyway and neither are mobile phones or the internet.

Thepeopleversuswork · 26/10/2023 20:44

I don't think it's really just a question of going to university vs not going to university though is it? University is essential for some careers, a waste of time for some and for most it's a help but not something to undertake lightly. Everyone has to decide on a case by case basis if the outcome is worth the investment.

It's more the general sense that you as a parent have an investment in your child's future and that you are committed to that, financially and emotionally, as far as you can afford to be.

Your commitment as a parent is to support your child as far as you can afford to do so to set them on the best possible footing for whatever they want to do in life, as long as they have sufficient aptitude. That doesn't mean mortgaging yourself up to the hilt if you can't afford it to put them through university. It does mean supporting them, encouraging them, backing them up, helping them look for affordable alternatives, helping them research things and giving them the moral support they need.

And, critically, not trying to discourage them from doing things because it's "not for the likes of us". I've seen this sort of bullshit class bias applied in both directions: MC parents pushing kids who don't want to go into university because they would be embarrassed on the dinner party circuit if their kids didn't get degrees, and WC parents because they are afraid of their children raising their own aspirations and potentially moving into a different sphere. Both of these types of parents are failing their kids and I judge both types hard.

Narwhalsh · 26/10/2023 20:25

Their priorities and their priorities and your priorities are your priorities.

University degree does not equal a job because they are ten a penny and so many crap degrees out there.

Miyagi99 · 26/10/2023 20:21

nearlyemptynes · 25/10/2023 16:01

It was Cambridge and you are not allowed to work but to be honest the workload is so intense you wouldn't be able to. And for those interested he went to the local state school.

You are allowed to work. They expect around 40hrs in the working week on studying but you are definitely allowed a weekend job and to work holidays.