Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

parents living the high life

413 replies

nearlyemptynes · 25/10/2023 12:15

Now I know we make our choices in life and we live with them. I have 3 children and have supported the eldest through uni and would do the same for the other two if that's what they want. I see this as our responsibility as parents. I have friends who have not supported their kids, haven't encouraged open days etc then when they kids don't go they have wonderful foreign holidays etc after saying they couldn't afford to send their kids to uni. AIBU to think they have their priorities wrong?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Neriah · 25/10/2023 14:18

nearlyemptynes · 25/10/2023 12:15

Now I know we make our choices in life and we live with them. I have 3 children and have supported the eldest through uni and would do the same for the other two if that's what they want. I see this as our responsibility as parents. I have friends who have not supported their kids, haven't encouraged open days etc then when they kids don't go they have wonderful foreign holidays etc after saying they couldn't afford to send their kids to uni. AIBU to think they have their priorities wrong?

I do wish somebody would define the word "friend", because on MN it seems to vary on a spectrum that includes "people I judge", "people I despise", and "people everyone should despise".

Oddly, I always thought that a friend was sombody one liked.

Pezdeoro41 · 25/10/2023 14:18

CosimoPiovasco · 25/10/2023 13:30

That’s not how University is financed.
Every student gets a student loan for the fees…..
Every student gets the minimum maintenance student loan….
Neither of these are based on parents earnings.

It is only the maximum maintenance loan that is based on parents earnings. If you earn too much students don’t get it and parents need to top up,

I understand how uni is financed! Some people might not be willing to take the debt though. And if they are and get the full amount, then the parents aren’t stopping them from going. I did say it depends on the circumstances.

lifeturnsonadime · 25/10/2023 14:17

Heelenahandbasket · 25/10/2023 14:14

I got a grant too and worked too. My grant (like yours and like all grants) was means tested based on my parents income. Because my parents had an obligation to support me if they had the money. As it happens they didn’t have the money and I got a full grant and loan.

so yes, students have always relied on parental support

Ok I thought you were saying that historically everyone expected and had parental support but you're not saying that.

So it's the same now, except I think that the loans have not kept up with cost of living rises.

Treesinmygarden · 25/10/2023 14:17

Antst · 25/10/2023 13:27

Yes, I really am about this topic. I have seen so many kids' lives torpedoed by older relatives and Daily Mail types who have insisted that further education/training isn't necessary. It's never based on facts. It's always about the older relatives' own insecurities.

It would be nice if it were still possible to leave school and have a comfortable life without having to gain further qualifications/skills, but we don't and it's not fair to kids to limit their options by pretending we do. The older generations live in a completely different world. Even those WITH good qualifications in fields like Engineering struggle to afford housing and childcare these days. Those without qualifications need to hope their parents will house them.

That is just so much crap.

Back in the 70s/80s when I was growing up, my parents were very education focused. My aunts/uncles/family friends were too. Both my parents were very intelligent but never got the chance to further their education. My dad left school at 14 to work on the family farm. It was always assumed that we would go to uni, and 3 out of 4 of us did. The one who didn't had health issues.

Most of my cousins also are graduates, on both sides of the family. I would not have missed out on my uni experience for the world. That was pre-Blair, when something like the top 5% of 18 year olds went to uni.

Two of my three children are graduates, and the third is in uni.

However, I see a huge value in vocational training, particularly now that graduates are ten a penny. I had a tiler working here recently, same age as my eldest, who has a degree and PGCE. I am willing to bet (certainly from what I paid him!) he is earning a huge amount more than my DC, and has more autonomy over his work. This guy left school at 16 and went straight onto building sites.

I also think degree apprenticeships are a great way to go, because you're earning and learning at the same time, not accumulating a mountain of debt.

I am at a loss to see why this OP garnered so many snarky responses. I can only assume that these are down to some inadequacies/personal hangups on the part of the posters.

I would never treat myself to "wonderful foreign holidays" while depriving my child of the opportunity to go to university! I think that's disgusting actually. I do still think though that there are ways and means for a young person determined to go to uni, and that a lack of parental support isn't necessarily a deterrent. All of mine have contributed to their own education by working part-time. They've been supported in various ways, from living FOC at home, to having their everyday living expenses supplemented, and one spent a year on unpaid internships in London - that cost big-time!!

I guess we were in the fortunate position of being able to do that and take holidays abroad, including paying for all three offspring to go with us.

@nearlyemptynes I don't think your comment is unreasonable. I am getting to a point in my life where I would like to put myself first more often, having been a mum for 26 years, but it wouldn't ever be at the expense of my kids. I don't think any decent parent would.

Differentstarts · 25/10/2023 14:14

Op your not doing your kids any favours by funding their uni lifestyle. They need a job and work experience like most other uni students it teaches lifeskills and looks good on a cv.

Heelenahandbasket · 25/10/2023 14:14

lifeturnsonadime · 25/10/2023 14:05

That's funny because I got a grant and topped up with several part time jobs.

Not ideal but it was what I had to do.

I got a grant too and worked too. My grant (like yours and like all grants) was means tested based on my parents income. Because my parents had an obligation to support me if they had the money. As it happens they didn’t have the money and I got a full grant and loan.

so yes, students have always relied on parental support

lifeturnsonadime · 25/10/2023 14:12

CosimoPiovasco · 25/10/2023 14:08

@lifeturnsonadime im the same.
Didnt get a penny or even emotional support.
Dont think my parents had the first idea what Uni was all about.
They had to leave school at 14

I think for many first generation undergraduates this is the case.

I also applied for a hardship fund from my uni at one point after my Dad died and I incurred additional expenses.

I think many don't realise, most of my friends were funded and some came into (and spent) inheritances whilst at uni.

I cleaned toilets, worked behind bars, did part time tele-sales and retail roles to fund my law degree!

AngelsWithSilverWings · 25/10/2023 14:11

@TigerQueenie absolutely agree with you there. We told our DS who is taking A levels next June to let us know which open days he wanted to go to and we would book accommodation and take him to them. He dragged his feet and even though we kept checking in with him he didn't seem interested. He has now finally told us that he wants to do an apprenticeship instead and has applied and is going through the process of skills and competency tests and digital interviews now.

My DH works in the field that DS wants to work in and having spoken to lots of younger people in his line of work it seems the trend is towards apprenticeships now because of the cost of uni. My friend's daughter has just finished her apprenticeship in the same field and is now qualified and earning a good salary with no student debt.

There is a part of me that is sad he won't get the full uni experience ( DH and I didn't go to Uni so part of it was us wanting him to experience what we couldn't ) but I believe he has made the correct decision for him.

Obviously DH and I will be quite happy not to have the financial burden of three years supporting him through uni but we were prepared to do it if that's what he wanted.

Maddy70 · 25/10/2023 14:09

Sounds like they have supported their children in their own way as have you

CosimoPiovasco · 25/10/2023 14:08

lifeturnsonadime · 25/10/2023 14:05

That's funny because I got a grant and topped up with several part time jobs.

Not ideal but it was what I had to do.

@lifeturnsonadime im the same.
Didnt get a penny or even emotional support.
Dont think my parents had the first idea what Uni was all about.
They had to leave school at 14

user1497207191 · 25/10/2023 14:08

CharlotteBog · 25/10/2023 14:01

Most 6th formers need some parent input in order to attend open days.
Most are not yet financially independent enough to afford to take themselves off to multiple open days, and very many would need support with transport to and from (e.g. collecting from the bus or train station when they arrive back at 10pm).
I think it would be quite hard for a 17 or 18 year student to attend open days without their parents support. This is very different to interference and pushiness.

Yes, I agree. There are loads of Unis that aren't in city centres and that are nowhere near railway stations, so the journey becomes very complicated and involves different modes of public transport which, in the absence of any integrated system means trains/buses that don't connect etc. Given how crap and unreliable public transport is these days, it's not really a viable option for lots of students, especially if they're relying on the "last" train home at the end of the day, which far too often doesn't run, potentially leaving the student stranded overnight!

At the very least, I think "lifts" from parents, at least part of the way, are pretty much the norm these days.

CosimoPiovasco · 25/10/2023 14:07

TigerQueenie · 25/10/2023 13:53

I'd expect an 18yr old to be going to open days and making decisions about their education and career without the interference or pushing from their parents.
So I'd assume that those who don't go to the open days don't want to go to uni. And that's fine.

In my day…..blimey I said it!😳
Yes we all went off to open days on our own with our heavy portfolios for interviews, our train fare from our own earnings from Saturday jobs and all looking smart.

Times have changed.
These days some parents are more encouraging. More aware.

lifeturnsonadime · 25/10/2023 14:05

Heelenahandbasket · 25/10/2023 14:03

Students have always relied on parental support (other than mature students).

I do think there is a bit of a point here though- why are we happy to fund living costs for those not working on uc, yet students are entitled to nothing at all. Seems grossly unfair to me.

That's funny because I got a grant and topped up with several part time jobs.

Not ideal but it was what I had to do.

Doteycat · 25/10/2023 14:05

TigerQueenie · 25/10/2023 13:53

I'd expect an 18yr old to be going to open days and making decisions about their education and career without the interference or pushing from their parents.
So I'd assume that those who don't go to the open days don't want to go to uni. And that's fine.

Gosh I dont think its fine at all.
DD in her final year was a mess. A total mess. Left to her own devices she would have stayed in bed.
Are you saying i should have let her? What kind of shitty parenting is that?
Instead I talked to her, encouraged her, showed her opportunities, told her she wouldnt have to worry, we would be with her through it all, if she would just try. She wanted it, but she was a mess and couldnt see that she was able for it.
Shes in UNI now, spent the summer in the States, and is figuring out what Masters she wants and what European country she will work in next summer.
Or I could have left her in bed, cos shes 18?
Baffling attitude. Just baffling.

CharlotteBog · 25/10/2023 14:03

All of the boomers I know are very wealthy

You either don't know many people or you have a very selective group of acquaintances!

Blinkityblonk · 25/10/2023 14:03

@CosimoPiovasco I totally believe it, because rents have spiralled out of all control for the whole sector, and so students are suffering a lot from rent rises. So, you can't even get a roof over your head for what the government gives you...

user1497207191 · 25/10/2023 14:03

LemonLight · 25/10/2023 14:01

A nice holiday is cheaper than paying to go to university though 😂

Again, I don't think anyone is talking about the full £50k cost of Uni. They're talking about the "top up" difference between the maintenance loan and actual living costs. That difference, for most, is very similar, if not at lot less, than a holiday!

Heelenahandbasket · 25/10/2023 14:03

lifeturnsonadime · 25/10/2023 13:54

I think OP is angry with the wrong people.

Students should not have to rely on parental top-ups.

This is how universities become elitist again.

It is obviously nice to help our adult children but it should not be the expectation.

Students have always relied on parental support (other than mature students).

I do think there is a bit of a point here though- why are we happy to fund living costs for those not working on uc, yet students are entitled to nothing at all. Seems grossly unfair to me.

OldLadyChinaCup · 25/10/2023 14:02

@Redbrickrebel
My daughter is on minimum loan of around 4k a year. She opted for the second cheapest accommodation which is 8k a year. So, before she even starts to ‘live’ she has a 4K deficit. The cheapest accommodation was £700 less but much further out so required buses at an extra cost making the difference far less. It’s very difficult for first years to get jobs, certainly at first. It’s Oct and she’s already applied for 10 and 2 have agreed to keep her on file. We don’t live in an urban area so there was no real chance of her getting a viable job in 6th form to help her save. She’s our eldest and one of her brothers has a disability and we simply cannot give her much at all as we live in an area of high housing costs so have a huge mortgage and other expensive but not luxury outgoings. We help when we can but she is living on virtually nothing and I know she’s upset that all her friends and flatmates go out and she simply can’t ever as she can barely afford to feed herself. So sadly, she’s not getting that same experience as many others. There are no bursaries available to kids on minimum loans either. The threshold for minimum loan is very low when it’s two salaries and doesn’t account for any outgoings or number of mouths to feed.
So, respectfully, please don’t suggest that it’s not a problem in this country when it really, really is. If we lived in Scotland or Wales she’d be fine but unfortunately we live in England.

CharlotteBog · 25/10/2023 14:01

TigerQueenie · 25/10/2023 13:53

I'd expect an 18yr old to be going to open days and making decisions about their education and career without the interference or pushing from their parents.
So I'd assume that those who don't go to the open days don't want to go to uni. And that's fine.

Most 6th formers need some parent input in order to attend open days.
Most are not yet financially independent enough to afford to take themselves off to multiple open days, and very many would need support with transport to and from (e.g. collecting from the bus or train station when they arrive back at 10pm).
I think it would be quite hard for a 17 or 18 year student to attend open days without their parents support. This is very different to interference and pushiness.

user1497207191 · 25/10/2023 14:01

TigerQueenie · 25/10/2023 13:53

I'd expect an 18yr old to be going to open days and making decisions about their education and career without the interference or pushing from their parents.
So I'd assume that those who don't go to the open days don't want to go to uni. And that's fine.

So you'd happily stand back and let your child make bad decisions and potentially wreck their life because you "expect" them to make their own choices etc?

I wouldn't! I'd make sure I'd guide them to explore all options, make sure they were fully informed about different routes, and then, and only then, would I stand aside and let them make the wrong choice - and I'd make sure they knew without doubt my opinion that it wasn't the right choice! It's called making informed decisions. No one can make an informed decision if they don't know all the facts!

I'd never make a decision for our child, and never force him into a decision, but I'd make sure he was properly informed of ALL options, pros and cons, to enable him to make an informed decision. If he buggers up his life, that's HIS problem, but he's not doing it on my watch due to ignorance or "can't be bothered" to research things properly!

Antst · 25/10/2023 14:01

ilovesooty · 25/10/2023 13:49

That last sentence is a sweeping generalisation.

So what? Conclusions that are based on observation (after observation after observation) are valid.

LemonLight · 25/10/2023 14:01

A nice holiday is cheaper than paying to go to university though 😂

CosimoPiovasco · 25/10/2023 14:01

Blinkityblonk · 25/10/2023 13:46

In many places now, the minimum loan only pays for accommodation, nothing else. I think you pretty much have a duty to fork out for food and basics like travel on top, and that's what the state says, and it pays for those unable to do that, but everyone else should be reaching in their wallets.

Getting a job on top of that is sensible for students, but it shouldn't be to buy food or basic stuff like a water bill IMO. They don't have the earning power and it's harder than you think to get a good flexible student job in a university town flooded with other students.

In most places I’m afraid the minimum loan doesn’t cover rent.
Aberystwyth yes others no.

I have one at Exeter lowest rent was over £6000, but he didn’t get that as they are allocated by the Uni. So his rent is approx £7000.
Other one is in Bristol the rents there were higher.
This is halls cost.
Exeter ds now looking for next year. Rent 48 wks, ( most landlords insist on this ) not including any bills for a house share with 4 in total is £6720 per person. The cheapest he can find. As I said bills not included.
Way way above the minimum loan

CalistoNoSolo · 25/10/2023 14:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

All of the boomers I know are very wealthy, but also very generous with time and money, to their children and to the communities they live in. So your sweeping insulting generalisation is utter bollocks.

Swipe left for the next trending thread