Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Told DH he can't opt out of being a Dad

956 replies

ftm03 · 25/10/2023 09:14

DH runs his own company, the past few weeks parenting our 5 month old has been on me as he's working a lot to get a project done but I am exhausted.

DD has had a cold and cough so sleep has been limited. I'll add that I do 100% of the housework and laundry, dog walking and appointments etc.

DD goes to bed at 6, I've tried to stretch it to 7 but she refuses daytime naps and ends up screaming where she's overtired.

Last night, DH went to bed at 10 and I stayed up to watch something until 11, I know I should sleep when baby sleeps but it's my only alone time from 6:30am, when everyone is in bed.

I went to bed at 11, changed DD's nappy but she'd wet through so I had to wipe her down properly and put her in clean pjs and sleeping bag. 15 minutes later she had done a poo so I changed her again. It took another 45 minutes to settle her. At 4am she was really fussing, I woke DH and asked him to please do her a bottle and check her nappy as I was so tired.

He was annoyed and said he's tired and can't keep up as he'll start making mistakes at work.

This morning as he was leaving I said this comment wasn't fair, 99% of the parenting and housework etc is on me and I'm really tired and he can't opt out of being a Dad because it's 4am and he's tired, he's left for work in a mood with me.

What do we do here? I'm genuinely knackered. AIBU for waking him to do one bottle/nappy?!

OP posts:
Catsmere · 28/10/2023 08:27

Backagain23 · 28/10/2023 06:57

Yes!
I was up at 4.15 with baby DS the the other night, back to bed 4.40 ish, still awake at 6.15 when the knock on the door came from big DS and that was the day started.
DH just rolled over and went back to sleep! Then said he was tired in the morning as his sleep was still "disturbed" 😱

Fuuuuuuck …

Didsomeonesaydogs · 28/10/2023 07:46

He’s perfectly happy with this arrangement where he gets hours of leisure time to kick back or pursue his hobbies while his wife has none. He’s doing almost nothing. He can see the inequality, (he’s not stupid, he can see his wife is still on kid duty when he comes home of an evening) yet he waits for her to break down from exhaustion before offering a few crumbs of relief that he’s even using another woman to fulfil. Talk about entitlement.

This isn’t a partnership, this is a man buying his leisure time with his wife’s emotional and physical labour. It never fails to amaze me how most men will limit their effort to 1% above than the absolute bare minimum it takes for the relationship to not break down rather than give more help to their partner than they absolutely need to.

Household inequity like this makes life better and easier for men. It allows them to earn more at work, to have more leisure time, and to enjoy having children without all the work and stress.

Time is the one thing we can’t get more of. He’s stealing her precious life with his reluctance to give up a little of his time to play his part in raising the child he also made.

@Fruitandclottedcream you are a legend!

Backagain23 · 28/10/2023 06:57

Catsmere · 28/10/2023 00:47

And if being able to drop off again immediately is a man thing, that's all the more reason they should do the night feeds!

Yes!
I was up at 4.15 with baby DS the the other night, back to bed 4.40 ish, still awake at 6.15 when the knock on the door came from big DS and that was the day started.
DH just rolled over and went back to sleep! Then said he was tired in the morning as his sleep was still "disturbed" 😱

Ukrainebaby23 · 28/10/2023 06:30

My DH does 10 til 2am wakes, I do after that, usually 4amish.
If we're both working he will stretch it til 2.30 if he can. We both get up at 6am workdays.

If I'm off and he's working I try to cover from midnight but sometimes I don't hear lo.

Regards nappies, I rate Aldi as being the most absorbant with least leaks, but if you get lots of leaks, sizing up can work.

Fruitandclottedcream · 28/10/2023 03:28

Hi OP,

I'm sorry you're going through this. Sleep deprivation is horrible. Speaking from my own personal experience you need to set some hard boundaries.

My child is much older, but I'm a SAHM and a full time carer. My child wakes lots, so I often run on 3-4 hours sleep a night while my husband sleeps blissfully because he needs to be awake for work.

We agreed weekends were 50/50, but he wouldn't ever pull his weight, regardless of how much I needed his help. I told him therapy or I leave. He took therapy. I also got into therapy to help me strengthen my boundaries.
Other than the usual marital vows, I have now set three firm boundaries in my marriage.

  1. Any time he gets "free" from family responsibilities is matched. If he gets a weekend socialising with his friends, I get a weekend with mine etc.
  1. Household responsibilities are split 50/50 after 5.30pm on weekdays and for the whole weekend. My job may be within the home, but I am still working. Without me my husband wouldn't have his life admin sorted, he wouldn't be able to sleep through the night, have clean clothes, a clean house, food on the table, free after school childcare etc.
  1. If my husband doesn't want to do his share then I will outsource at his cost.
The only time the I've had to outsource was when I first set these boundaries a few months ago. I herniated a disc and was out of action for 5 weeks. Husband didn't do any laundry in this time because he "hates doing it" because I'm better at it. He had to pay £70 of his money to get everything service washed when we eventually ran out of clothes. It did not come out of joint finances because he wouldn't have needed to outsource if he'd done his part.

My husband really REALLY resented me for the first couple of months of my new boundaries. But with therapy, he unpacked those feelings and changed his mindset to recognise that just because I don't get paid doesn't mean I'm not working as hard as him.

He now pulls his weight and I don't feel like I'm dying of exhaustion. Our relationship with each other has improved massively. I'm able to be fully present and have the energy to be a better wife and mother.

I would honestly start by telling your husband that you've decided that if he can't make himself available on weekends, then he is paying for a cleaner to take something off your load. And that if he can't put a load of washing in, then he can pay for a laundry service. And if he resents you then so be it. Remind him that you'd resent him less if he actually supported you and the child you both created.

crumblingschools · 28/10/2023 01:37

DH would sometimes sleep through DS crying at night, but if he was on ‘duty’ so I could have a longer sleep, he would always wake up and somehow I would sleep through knowing someone else would look after him.

I have read on here where couples have more than one child, done give dad the toddler to look after at night and mum the baby and the respective parent will wake up when the DC they have responsibility for cries

PyongyangKipperbang · 28/10/2023 01:26

Catsmere · 28/10/2023 00:47

And if being able to drop off again immediately is a man thing, that's all the more reason they should do the night feeds!

Couldnt agree more!

There is a lot I could say about my ex husband but when he realised that he could wake up, feed DD and go back to sleep again all within half an hour, but me doing the night feeds meant that he was doing all the daytime stuff cos I was useless due to exhaustion, he did every night feed for months!

Catsmere · 28/10/2023 01:06

Catsmere · 28/10/2023 00:47

And if being able to drop off again immediately is a man thing, that's all the more reason they should do the night feeds!

I'm suddenly reminded of this scene from Richard Scarry's Busy, Busy World, which was published in 1968 ... funny how a cartoon dog was a better father and husband than these so-called "dear partners" now, even if he's supposedly doing it to keep the town peaceful!

Told DH he can't opt out of being a Dad
Catsmere · 28/10/2023 00:47

PyongyangKipperbang · 28/10/2023 00:25

Is it a man/woman thing?

Every single man I have shared living space with, father, husbands, sons, BIL, friends etc have all been able to sleep at the drop of a hat. But I dont know a single woman who can do that.

Probably evolutionary reasons, but it doesnt make it any less irritating when a man who can sleep on a washing line is saying "Just sleep when the baby sleeps" Oh ok then genius......

And if being able to drop off again immediately is a man thing, that's all the more reason they should do the night feeds!

BMrs · 28/10/2023 00:34

My ADH has a super stressful job working very long hours but he always helped me with night feeds. Might have been only one night feed but I did get support. I don't think YABU to ask for help

PyongyangKipperbang · 28/10/2023 00:25

Is it a man/woman thing?

Every single man I have shared living space with, father, husbands, sons, BIL, friends etc have all been able to sleep at the drop of a hat. But I dont know a single woman who can do that.

Probably evolutionary reasons, but it doesnt make it any less irritating when a man who can sleep on a washing line is saying "Just sleep when the baby sleeps" Oh ok then genius......

sandyhappypeople · 28/10/2023 00:03

Jellycats4life · 27/10/2023 23:40

@sandyhappypeople Your post was great (especially about mums having to go to bed at 8pm so they’ll be raring to serve again the next day) but especially this:

I've never understood the sleeping when the baby sleeps mantra personally.

Do people never really think about the practicalities? I remember being on my knees with exhaustion, trying to do this. Baby napped, I fell into some sort of dead sleep and was - all too soon - rudely awaken by the baby. I was angry. I was still exhausted. I needed to sleep for a bit longer, but I couldn’t. I felt a thousand times worse for being disturbed from a deep sleep than if I’d just tried to stay awake.

Exactly this, it just isn't practical for a lot of people, I think my problem with it too is that I just can't sleep on demand, and if I KNOW I've got to get to sleep (for being up early the next day for example) I just can't do it! It's a weird frustrating cycle.

I'm incredulous that DH lies down on the bed and literally goes straight off to sleep within 30 seconds, then wakes up 6 hours later fresh as a daisy.. git.

Jellycats4life · 27/10/2023 23:40

@sandyhappypeople Your post was great (especially about mums having to go to bed at 8pm so they’ll be raring to serve again the next day) but especially this:

I've never understood the sleeping when the baby sleeps mantra personally.

Do people never really think about the practicalities? I remember being on my knees with exhaustion, trying to do this. Baby napped, I fell into some sort of dead sleep and was - all too soon - rudely awaken by the baby. I was angry. I was still exhausted. I needed to sleep for a bit longer, but I couldn’t. I felt a thousand times worse for being disturbed from a deep sleep than if I’d just tried to stay awake.

Catsmere · 27/10/2023 23:27

sandyhappypeople · 27/10/2023 23:05

I'm surprised SO many people are saying this.. it seems a really outdated view that when parents are home together the mother should still do EVERYTHING for the baby, and should toddle themselves off to bed at 8pm so they're rested and ready to serve whenever they are needed. Fuck having any actual time to yourself to feel like a human again, while your DH sits downstairs watchin the telly all night like a bachelor.

The last thing I wanted to do when the baby went to bed was go to sleep myself, I needed that time to wind down and use that opportunity to do every little thing that was 10 times harder with a baby attached to you.

I've never understood the sleeping when the baby sleeps mantra personally.

And can't you just imagine how it'd go if OP tried to do that - DH would be sulking because she wasn't there to entertain and feed him when he deigned to return from football. She has two cranky infants to deal with, only one of whose behaviour is appropriate.

Catsmere · 27/10/2023 23:20

@SAHMTO yes, this man just looks worse and worse with every update.

sandyhappypeople · 27/10/2023 23:05

Middleagedspreadisreal · 27/10/2023 19:35

Don't go to bed at 11.00. Go the same time as baby. It's not forever

I'm surprised SO many people are saying this.. it seems a really outdated view that when parents are home together the mother should still do EVERYTHING for the baby, and should toddle themselves off to bed at 8pm so they're rested and ready to serve whenever they are needed. Fuck having any actual time to yourself to feel like a human again, while your DH sits downstairs watchin the telly all night like a bachelor.

The last thing I wanted to do when the baby went to bed was go to sleep myself, I needed that time to wind down and use that opportunity to do every little thing that was 10 times harder with a baby attached to you.

I've never understood the sleeping when the baby sleeps mantra personally.

SAHMTO · 27/10/2023 23:02

@Catsmere yes as you will see above I agreed I was wrong to completely compare situations with OP. I didn’t read any update about him finishing work at 5 and her still putting in finances to the household. I was trying to give a supporting insight as someone who willingly does everything home and child related as my own partner often works 7am-10:30pm running our businesses. I found it hard and absoloutley exhausting in the first year as a new mum and would have appreciated someone to speak to who had a similar set up or scenario at home. Obviously it’s not comparable if OP’s husband had the luxury of finishing work at a normal kind of time.

Reb2014 · 27/10/2023 22:49

I have a 7 month old and a 6 year old. Generally speaking I do the majority of the night wake ups because I’m a SAHM and my husband has quite an intense job. However, there are some nights when I am just exhausted and need his help and it is totally ok to ask for that help. I try not to wake him up before 4, and we agreed really early on that I’d do anything before 5, other than those nights were I just can’t cope any more. Especially nights when one of our kids is poorly, he has to also be a little bit uncomfortable, I’m not superwoman and I can’t do it it all. It doesn’t mean I’m a bad mum, or that I don’t love my kids. If anything, it makes me a better mum because I have the energy to look after them properly!
good luck, and I hope it gets better soon! The first year is really rough, even if it’s also amazing x

Catsmere · 27/10/2023 22:45

SAHMTO · 27/10/2023 13:06

@Comedycook okay well everyone is entitled to their opinion and I’m very aware I was going to get some criticism for having old school ideas like that. In my opinion (as I said originally) if husband is putting business owner hours into running a business (in my scenario we’re often talking 80 hours a week) and ensuring that as a family we are provided for and given a nice life then it’s my personal opinion it’s not unfair to expect mum to do majority of household & childcare responsibilities. Equally if OP usually just gets on with it and doesn’t ask for help unless particularly struggling or exhausted then yes DH is unfair for refusing to help his struggling wife.

She’s not doing the majority. She’s doing all of it. She’s also doing admin for his business. He’s leaving work (or getting home) at five and doing nothing - no feeds, not bathing his daughter, not even putting on a wash, and he waltzes off to his weekend “commitments” ie hobby. His idea of help when confronted with the truth is to palm it off onto his mother.

Dogrough · 27/10/2023 22:03

FSTraining · 26/10/2023 21:43

If she's on mat leave, she's staying at home. A lot of one sided posting going on here from people who clearly have no idea what it's like doing a professional job. I actually think the OP had a point but a lot of her cheerleaders don't have a clue.

Don’t talk rubbish. My wife managed to finish a degree (getting a 1st) and has continued to work full time in a stressful professional job (one of those ones were people always say ‘God I couldn’t do that”) as well as now doing a masters. She is the sole provider because I’m disabled and can’t work- she is also therefore my carer and our children are also disabled so need a lot of extra support.

she has ALWAYS been at least a 50/50 parent with me- whether it’s changing nappies or buying Christmas presents or going to parents evening.

Dogrough · 27/10/2023 21:53

Iudncuewbccgrcb · 25/10/2023 09:27

The problem with this is though is that when OP goes back to work and the child is still waking up through the night (one of mine didn't sleep through until they were 4!) then OP will still end up doing all of the wake ups as well as working because her DH 'doesn't know how to settle her' or will claim 'she only wants you'

As a minimum he should be doing more wake ups at weekends to give you a chance at sleep.

no conversation held by two tired parents at 4am has ever gone well though - needs a proper chat tonight.

This. Also the op is up at 6:30 with the baby- she isn’t having a lie in and a jolly old time chilling out all day ffs. What if she makes mistakes? Falls asleep at the wheel? On the sofa with the baby? Forgets to strap it in the car seat properly?!

How is it that he can sleep all night and have 2 hobbies whereas op just has to be on call for a baby 24 hours a day?!

It’s bullshit.

crumblingschools · 27/10/2023 21:32

@Middleagedspreadisreal could the dad go to bed at the same time as the baby?

toobusymummy · 27/10/2023 21:18

You've already had loads of advice and replies but didn't want to read and run as I totally feel the visceral despair coming through from your post - clearly you've tried to 'keep calm and carry on' for long enough and you're hanging on by the fingertips - you are amazing, and obviously a fab mum but even the most dedicated mum's need some help!! Well done for broaching it with hubby, I think its just your timing that's off a little, this convo needs to be had in the calm light of day when you can both think clearly - the man loves you right? so he hopefully doesn't want to see you break under the strain and there are compromises he can make so you need to figure out together what these are and get them working for you - just a thought but do you have any relatives that could give you both a night off, I know as a new Mum the idea might be horrifying but I can guarantee baby will be absolutely fine for 1 night and then at least you can both get a good, full nights sleep. Big hugs though! xx

76evie · 27/10/2023 21:16

Don’t feel bad. I disagree with other posters. Yes as you are on maternity or if you was a stay at home Mum, I think you should be doing the get up in the nights in the majority. I do however think if you occasionally ask for help on one night, I don’t see why hubby can’t do it as a one off. I don’t think you was unreasonable to ask. As for an hour to yourself, can’t your hubby look after the baby on an evening whilst you go and chill for an hour, even if that just means watching tv upstairs? Everyone needs some me time and he seems to get plenty with football coaching and playing.

Hadenough2021 · 27/10/2023 21:01

Fuck me gently half the comments on here are utter bullshit. If you need help and you are brave enough to say you need help right now, he should be helping. Who gives a fuck who earns what? He’ll be doing a fuck tonne more if you crumble completely because he didn’t help.