Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

PT 2 of Who the F**K still thinks voting Tory is a good idea?

738 replies

Zonder · 25/10/2023 09:07

Would be such a shame not to continue the discussion.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
47
DuncinToffee · 25/10/2023 16:13

@DivingForLove

I think you have highlighted a very important issue here that is often overlooked, women and children continue to be worst affected by poverty.

I work in social care and austerity has had a devastating effect on women - so much support that changed our lives for the better has disappeared. To throw the poor under the bus because Sunak made some sound bite comment about a woman being a woman at the party conference is terrifying.

Knowing what a woman is doesn't heat your house or puts food on the table

SiobhanSharpe · 25/10/2023 16:13

verdantverdure · 25/10/2023 15:54

Is Labour the only alternative to the Tories in your constituency @SiobhanSharpe?

I'm a bit GC myself, but there is no one to vote for on that issue so the best I can do is vote for the candidate who has the best chance of beating my Tory MP in order to contribute to getting the Tories out

Because, despite their recent very effective slogan, their record on protecting women, girls, and children in general is appalling.

Ending Brexit is a huge issue for me. I don't believe our economy can recover until we rejoin the single market and customs union.

But ending Brexit isn't on offer. Again I have no one to vote for on this issue. So the best I can do is vote for the candidate who has the best chance of beating my Tory MP in order to do my bit to help get the Tories out.

I don't think k we can in all one hence do any protest votes or ballot spoiling or staying away from the ballot box this time.

If we can see the decline of this country and we don't like it, we are somewhat morally obliged to take the only effective action we can to get the stories out aren't we?

Surely we agree on that since you are ex-Labour?

Nope, it's actually a Labour stronghold (small university city, big on cycling 😉) and the LibDems and Greens are also strong.
I wouldn't consider voting for either of those two in a blue moon.
Local Labour MP seems like a decent old cove, but probably toes the party line.
For myself, I am politically homeless for the first time in my life.

Xis · 25/10/2023 16:11

I understand why people are running away from the Conservatives, I just don’t understand why they are running towards Kier Starmer and the current Labour Party. Which Labour policies do you think will significantly improve your life? Kier Starmer is so staid and conservative (ha!) that I’m not expecting any exciting new policies from him any time soon.

verdantverdure · 25/10/2023 16:10

Well your excellent post (copied below) will hopefully help anybody who wants to be acquainted with the facts @TooBigForMyBoots

  • No they don't. The whole trans shitshow happened on their watch after PM May announced plans for Self ID in 2017.

In 2021 Minister Penny Mordaunt stood at the Despatch Box and said that TMAM and TWAW. This was in response to HoL's recommendations to changes in the Maternity Bill.

In 2022, Con MP Jamie Wallis came out as trans. Con MP, Crispin Blunt reported a woman to her employer for retweeting JKR, which led to a very distressing time for her. The Tory party appointed Jamie Wallis to the Women's and Equality Com. And PM Sunak gave the top job in Education to Gillian Keegan. A woman who couldn't define the word Girl.

Now, in 2023, the Dept of Ed has told schools they will not provide the promised and much needed advice to school regarding pupils presenting as trans. Just last weekend Miriam Cates had to do a mad scramble after it was reported that PM Sunak planned to include the trans inclusive Conversion Therapy Bill in the King's Speech.

Some Tories know what a woman is.
Some Tories believe TWAW and TMAM.
One Tory believes he is becoming a woman.
None of them care about women.*

verdantverdure · 25/10/2023 16:07

Passepartoute · 25/10/2023 16:06

My staunch Tory, Brexit-voting brother and sister in law are so disgusted with everything that has happened over the last eight years that they are going to vote Lib Dem at the next election, purely because it's the best chance of getting the Tory out in their constituency. Looking at the link upthread, there is a pretty high chance of the Lib Dems winning in that area.

Woohoo!

Passepartoute · 25/10/2023 16:06

My staunch Tory, Brexit-voting brother and sister in law are so disgusted with everything that has happened over the last eight years that they are going to vote Lib Dem at the next election, purely because it's the best chance of getting the Tory out in their constituency. Looking at the link upthread, there is a pretty high chance of the Lib Dems winning in that area.

DivingForLove · 25/10/2023 16:05

@Daddybegood i totally agree but they need to be in power to achieve anything at all. I’m sure they don’t agree with half the stuff they’re saying but the debate has become so toxic and they can’t afford to lose the election. Get in, start making small changes and then start the conversation about how we move forward? So much to do, the Tories have done so much damage 😢. I wish we could be bolder but I fear another decade of Tory rule more 😢

verdantverdure · 25/10/2023 16:02

AngryBird6122 · 25/10/2023 15:44

I usually vote Conservative

I won't be doing so this time around as it is time for a change. But, I don't know who I will vote for at the moment.

The problem I have with the others is they are too far left in some areas that are important to me (trans/womens rights and immigration)

I think very few of us agree with everything and everyone in any particular party.

Personally I probably disagree on something with everyone I know and love.

But we also have a lot in common.

It's the same with political parties. Rather than ruling them out, could you look for common ground and rule one in?

My opinion is that if you are unhappy with the state of the country.

  1. Don't vote for the party that brought us to this low point
  1. Do vote for whoever can win in your constituency in order to actively prevent the Tories getting in again.
  1. Look for the positives and agreement and common ground rather than imposing red lines that apply to almost every party we've got.
Daddybegood · 25/10/2023 16:00

Labour member here & ofcourse after everything thats happened over the last 13 years (but particularly since brexit, & the BJ/ Truss sh!tshows), could never even contemplate voting Tory.
but if the Tories are clearly so dreadful (& in hock to the far right & BNP) why is current Labour tax policy identical, why is the spending commitment to the NHS, social care & education identical and why is a hard brexit, out of the SM & CU, a NO to freedom of movement (costing the economy £40billion pa), & both rowing back on their green agenda suddenly all OK if you stick a red rosette on it?

Sure, I get it, Keir is much more trustworthy & has much more integrity (err..obvs) & the Tories are corrupt, lying, incompetent and in some cases truly nasty (e.g the Rwanda policy)..
we just want to get rid of them..right? And they need replacing....agreed
...but even on immigration there is now barely a fag wrapper between the Tories & Labour.
Surely there must be a Liberal left wing set of policies that would be better off that this Tory nightmare or a Labour party intent on copying everything they stand for beyond scapegoating kids (let's call them "rich kids" for spite) getting VAT added to their key stage maths & English, games, religious studies, pastoral care, HHH etc that will not in reality raise a penny & that will be unacceptable for a closer relationship with the EU, let alone our commitment to the ECHR

DivingForLove · 25/10/2023 16:00

@Passepartoute missed your post but couldn’t have put it better. They know what a woman is and that her place is bare foot and pregnant at the kitchen sink 🙄

DivingForLove · 25/10/2023 15:58

@TooBigForMyBoots thank you! I despair at the “I’m voting Tory because they know what a woman is” brigade. Firstly, no they don’t. Secondly it doesn’t mean they’re the party to vote for as a feminist 😩🤯.

I work in social care and austerity has had a devastating effect on women - so much support that changed our lives for the better has disappeared. To throw the poor under the bus because Sunak made some sound bite comment about a woman being a woman at the party conference is terrifying.

I firmly believe that Labour are moving in the right direction on the toxic trans debate and while I don’t agree with the way Starmer has gone about it, the TRA lobby has become so vitriolic I get why he thought he needed to go the way he did initially.

Passepartoute · 25/10/2023 15:55

YesshesaidyesiwillYes · 25/10/2023 09:46

Conservatives are currently the only party that know what a woman is. Greens and LibDems are entirely captured by trans ideology. I don’t think a man can ever be a woman. I believe we have to find a better solution than women ceding sporting podiums, places on an all female shortlists etc.

I may well hold my nose and vote Conservative. Trans ideology is authoritarian nonsense.

That would no doubt be why the Conservatives have done nothing over the last 13 years about changing the relevant legislation in favour of women's rights. To say nothing of the fact that, for example, they've been refusing to put into effect legislation to protect women accessing abortion clinics, and that they want to take away basic human rights. They've made it perfectly clear that, if they were elected again, they will be looking seriously at reducing maternity and equality rights, reducing the abortion time limits, and reducing women's rights on divorce. To say nothing of reducing disability and retirement benefits, and provision for children and young people with SEN and disabilities.

Do you really want your vote to help in bringing all that about?

verdantverdure · 25/10/2023 15:54

Is Labour the only alternative to the Tories in your constituency @SiobhanSharpe?

I'm a bit GC myself, but there is no one to vote for on that issue so the best I can do is vote for the candidate who has the best chance of beating my Tory MP in order to contribute to getting the Tories out

Because, despite their recent very effective slogan, their record on protecting women, girls, and children in general is appalling.

Ending Brexit is a huge issue for me. I don't believe our economy can recover until we rejoin the single market and customs union.

But ending Brexit isn't on offer. Again I have no one to vote for on this issue. So the best I can do is vote for the candidate who has the best chance of beating my Tory MP in order to do my bit to help get the Tories out.

I don't think k we can in all one hence do any protest votes or ballot spoiling or staying away from the ballot box this time.

If we can see the decline of this country and we don't like it, we are somewhat morally obliged to take the only effective action we can to get the stories out aren't we?

Surely we agree on that since you are ex-Labour?

genesis92 · 25/10/2023 15:50

When Labour get in, it really will be a nice change to be on the other side of the political sitting target. Finally all of Labour's decisions can be scrutinised and ridiculed for at least the next 5 years.

Bring it on, I will be glad of the relief 😆

SiobhanSharpe · 25/10/2023 15:45

I found this on another thread and it sums up how I feel about the Labour leadership and a possible Labpur government.
"....(Keir Starmer) thinks that some men are women just because they say so. He's a liar. If he lies about that simple fact I don't think he can be trusted to run the country.
All that he has to do is draw back on this and come up with some policies that will reassure me and other women that he won't throw women under the bus to appease the purportedly small proportion of men who say they are women and their supporters. But he won't.
It would also be good if he would make it clear that body modification is not appropriate for children and won't buy some men the right to access women's spaces. But he won't. "
Thanks to @lifeturnsonadime

TooBigForMyBoots · 25/10/2023 15:45

verdantverdure · 25/10/2023 15:00

I'm never sure if the people who say things like that are more easily manipulated than most, or not acquainted with the facts, or just looking for a peg to hang the way they plan to vote anyway onto.

I think not acquainted with the facts, because if they were, they wouldn't touch the Tories with a bargepole. CCHQ invented the "at least the Tories know..." slogan and it seems to have stuck. Anyone who takes a wee look will see its just another Tory lie in an ocean of lies.

They have done so much damage to women.Angry

AngryBird6122 · 25/10/2023 15:44

I usually vote Conservative

I won't be doing so this time around as it is time for a change. But, I don't know who I will vote for at the moment.

The problem I have with the others is they are too far left in some areas that are important to me (trans/womens rights and immigration)

verdantverdure · 25/10/2023 15:41

@SiobhanSharpe

@ginasevern said:

I am so sick of hearing "but at least the tories know what a woman is" - no they don't and since when have they cared anyway. They've also turned the country to shite. But I suppose there's no cure for stupid.

And I responded

I'm never sure if the people who say things like that are more easily manipulated than most, or not acquainted with the facts, or just looking for a peg to hang the way they plan to vote anyway onto.

And neither of us mentioned Labour.

tinytemper66 · 25/10/2023 15:37

Wankers...
Sorry rich bankers!

Abra1t · 25/10/2023 15:36

I certainly agree that the Tories lost a lot of the MPs I liked post-Brexit...

verdantverdure · 25/10/2023 15:34

Abra1t · 25/10/2023 15:10

There are decent people in pretty well all the parties. They may be the quiet people doing the plodding committee work that doesn’t get the headlines. Or the MPs who persist in sorting out constituents’ problems.

I'm sure there are. I just can't think of any Tories I would describe that way currently.

To be fair I only know about a third of them probably, most likely if they are a minister or family members have lived in their constituencies.

My parents have lived along the south coast for many years and their MPs have been Christopher Chope, Desmond Swayne and Julian Lewis. The latter was very good on the detrimental consequences for locals of a proposed container port in Dibden Bay back in 2015 but rather quiet on the topic of the Southampton Enterprise Zone or "Freeport" owning the New Forest National Park and a large section of the M3 south of Winchester.

A couple of years ago I might have thought of Greg Hands, Tom Tugendhat, Huw Merriman, Robert Halfon and Alex Chalk but their reputations have been destroyed since 2019.

SiobhanSharpe · 25/10/2023 15:33

verdantverdure · 25/10/2023 15:00

I'm never sure if the people who say things like that are more easily manipulated than most, or not acquainted with the facts, or just looking for a peg to hang the way they plan to vote anyway onto.

Nope, I don't trust Labour one little bit not to throw women under the bus just to look good and 'right-thinking' to those who parrot the "trans women are women" mantra.
I left the Labour party over this issue at the height of the 'no-debate' furore; frankly nothing I have seen stated by senior shadow ministers more recently has given me any reassurance that things have changed fundamentally within the party. It's still captured by the (mainly male) TRAs.
And most shameful of all is the utter hypocrisy because how many of them truly believe that trans women ARE in fact women?
If there is a Social Democrat candidate standing in my constituency (unlikely, I know) I would give him or her my vote because at least the SDP has a clear and unambiguous policy on the gender ID issue.
Can't say the same about Labour.
This is fundamental for me and attempts to bad mouth me as stupid or ill informed do not impress one little bit. I am neither, I just disagree with you. And this is the problem with the gender idealogues.

verdantverdure · 25/10/2023 15:17

gegs73 · 25/10/2023 09:32

Both my parents and in laws always vote conservative. Both say that next year they are going to spoil their ballot paper.

Good bless them but I'd rather they voted for whoever can win in their constituency who isn't a Tory.

My parents got all gung-ho about the state of the country and voted Labour in the local elections instead of Tory, but if they and a few others had voted Lib Dem instead then the Lib Dens wouldn't have come second by a small margin allowing the Tory to win.

As long as they still win the seat the Tories won't care about people not voting or spoiling the ballot.

SiobhanSharpe · 25/10/2023 15:13

YesshesaidyesiwillYes · 25/10/2023 09:46

Conservatives are currently the only party that know what a woman is. Greens and LibDems are entirely captured by trans ideology. I don’t think a man can ever be a woman. I believe we have to find a better solution than women ceding sporting podiums, places on an all female shortlists etc.

I may well hold my nose and vote Conservative. Trans ideology is authoritarian nonsense.

Me too. I have spoilt my ballot in the past but really don't like doing that.

Moonmelodies · 25/10/2023 15:12

verdantverdure · 25/10/2023 14:57

I can think of one bit of the public sector that seems to chance when we elect different parties.

Have you seen what Labour have achieved with the waiting list in Wales lately?
A blueprint for Labour across the UK, according to Sir Kier.