Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think SIL should make the decision herself and give me a firm answer?

212 replies

HauntedGusset · 25/10/2023 08:01

I'll try and keep it short.

SIL (single parent) wants to go and view a house for a possible exchange tomorrow, and DN (7 and home educated) said she didn't want to go. I said I'd look after DN. This means taking a day off work, but as I'm self employed this is do-able if necessary and I want to support SIL. So I haven't scheduled any work for tomorrow. I messaged SIL last night asking what time she would drop DN off and she replied saying DN thinks she might want to go after all and she would let me know tomorrow morning. I said this wasn't ideal as I didn't really want to take a day off work for no reason (I'm a gardener, so can't just turn up without arranging with clients in advance) so could she let me know by this evening please.

SIL sent me this reply overnight... "I'm sorry but I can't give you the answer you want right now. I won't know until it's time to leave whether DN is coming with me or not, she can't decide and we will see how she feels in the morning. You said you'd look after her so if you aren't going to stick to your word and want to go to work instead, just say so and I'll know not to rely on you again". DN doesn't have any SEN etc, but SIL has a parenting philosophy that children should make their own decisions about pretty much everything. Up to her, of course, but this is making me really frustrated as whilst I'm happy to take a day off to look after DN I'm not happy to be in limbo til it's too late for me to do anything else - I'm not well off, taking the day off is a favour to SIL because I want to help her out, but not something I want to do if it isn't actually necessary. I think under the circumstances SIL should tell DN what is happening not wait for her to decide last minute. She's welcome to centre everything round the whims of a 7 yr old but it's not really fair to impose that on other people who have offered to help her!

AIBU here?

OP posts:
CHRIS003 · 25/10/2023 10:39

Learn from this situation and don't offer again unless SIL is prepared to compromise on her parenting style !

Yalta · 25/10/2023 10:30

Why can’t dn, if she is expected to make her own decisions, Judy make the decision.

Whilst it is nice to keep your options open, when it involves other people then you need to decide what you are doing. Other people are not just going to wait around for you to make a decisions. People have their own lives to lead.

Whilst giving children decisions to make at a young age is a good idea and more people should do it. I think the decisions should be kept small and age appropriate. When it comes to making a decision which will cost someone a days wages then that isn’t a decision you can have a 7 year old to make.

If you do ask the child and they have decided then that decision has to be stuck with

A lesson on making a decision and the consequences are a good lesson to be learned

Thesearmsofmine · 25/10/2023 10:16

You were being supportive and kind to offer OP, she was being rude and entitled expecting you to wait around for them just in case dc needed a babysitter. I wouldn’t be so quick to offer in future and let her work it out for herself.
At least this is sorted for now.

And to correct an earlier poster, you don’t get benefits for home educating. If a home ed parent gets into a situation where they need benefits they are treated the same as any other claimant.

Blueblell · 25/10/2023 10:15

Yes! She is being very unreasonable!

sadforthem · 25/10/2023 10:12

@HauntedGusset
Your sil still needs to know what she did is not acceptable.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 25/10/2023 10:11

Moobootoyoutoo · 25/10/2023 08:55

Massive assumptions on my part which is never good, however I get the distinct feeling this is a homeschooling parent that is choosing to do that as they 'don't believe in the system'

Until it comes to state subsidised benefits, including house swaps

Really hope I'm just narrow minded and wrong.

Op, lovely of you to offer and sorry your kindness has been repaid this way

You clearly missed the part about the difficult circumstances that apply here. Might be worth reigning in the judgement, as we don’t know what those are.

Findyourneutralspace · 25/10/2023 10:10

She was really rude. The right reply would have been to acknowledge it was inconvenient and say if you wanted to arrange work, she understood.

I’d have to say something.

PabloandGustheGreySquirrels · 25/10/2023 10:09

Princessfluffy · 25/10/2023 08:18

Also how can she home school her child if she is a single parent? Doesn't she need to work?!!!

None of your business! She may be a disabled parent for all you know. I'm severely disabled (& widowed) and unable to work and I home schooled my child for 6 months earlier this year.

(Before you make a cocky remark, I had no choice as her school closed and there were no spaces locally)

pam290358 · 25/10/2023 10:07

Princessfluffy · 25/10/2023 08:18

Also how can she home school her child if she is a single parent? Doesn't she need to work?!!!

Why do people feel the need to benefit bash without knowing a single thing about circumstances ?

Rosscameasdoody · 25/10/2023 10:02

ItsThatTimeAgainXmas · 25/10/2023 09:07

Really? Don't you know that's what benefits are for? According to some of the UK anyway.

I think benefit bashing like this is really unpleasant. You have no idea what the difficult circumstances OP has described as applying to SiL actually are. My nephew is autistic and SiL has had no choice but to take time out from work to home school him because the LA are having difficulty placing him, and if you’d read any of the numerous threads on MN from parents in similar circumstances, you would know it’s pretty common. Benefit fraud isn’t as prevalent as the Tories would have you believe, and benefits in general are designed for ‘difficult’ circumstances. You might want to remember that the next time you’re tempted to make similar comments.

NoSquirrels · 25/10/2023 09:59

Btw, if she did want to give the child the genuine choice, she just needed to set the appropriate deadline for that choice - ‘DN, it’s OK to decide later today, but I need to know by 6pm’.

Setting the time for the choice to be made is her responsibility, and she set the wrong one by thinking it’s OK to say on the morning of.

Purplepinkfairy · 25/10/2023 09:57

If I received that message back I would withdraw my offer......pick one of the replys above .she is very inconsiderate of you.

Sturnidae · 25/10/2023 09:57

Oof. This isn't child-led, this is child dictated. We're a child-led HE family (I suppose we're unschoolers by popular terms, but it's often co-opted by people like this so I don't like to use it), but that doesn't mean that our children dictate our lives or others. They are welcome to decide what their own plans are for the day and have a voice in our family plans, but we don't screw others over, especially those trying to help us. She's 7, she's entirely capable to understand that her needs shouldn't supersede others.

Itwasafterallallaboutme · 25/10/2023 09:56

@HauntedGusset Thank you for being so lovely. When it isn't appreciated that is their problem. The world needs a lot more people like you in it OP 🪷🪷🪷

NoSquirrels · 25/10/2023 09:56

I hope you have replied in a firm but fair fashion about your reliability and fixed plans.

I’m sure she’s stressed, I’m sure whatever it is that means DN has to be homeschooled plays into the thinking/decision-making process but it was a rude message so she needs to be (nicely) told so.

Turfwars · 25/10/2023 09:54

She's creating a rod for her own back tbh.
I can understand when a kid flip flops on a decision, but sometimes you've got to force them to decide and if they regret their choice, then it's a learning moment for them.

NancyJoan · 25/10/2023 09:52

WildfirePonie · 25/10/2023 09:19

It's half term this week.

Where you live, perhaps.

TripleDaisySummer · 25/10/2023 09:52

Going forward I simply won't offer again. Lesson learned.

Glad the situation is now sorted and I'd agree lesson learnt don't offer again.

MrsSkylerWhite · 25/10/2023 09:52

If I’d received that snotty message I’d reply “ok, thanks, I’ll work then” and would t offer again. Bloody cheek.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 25/10/2023 09:52

Globules · 25/10/2023 08:29

At the age of 7, you tell them if they're coming or not coming.

She's storing up a whole heap of trouble for herself later by letting a 7 yr old rule to roost.

DN is an only child I presume?

Definitely! When I was that age or younger it was either “you’re coming with us”. Or if I could stay at home with one DP or alternative, then you’re staying there. And a firm, make up your mind if you’re coming or not if I was on the fence.

howdoesyourgardengrowinmay · 25/10/2023 09:51

dear SIL, sorry but I can't arrange my work schedule around last minute whims of anyone else as my clients have expectations of me and I need my income from them. I'd be happy to look after niece and love spending time with both of you, but I do need some notice so I don't let my clients down. As you're unable to let me know in time for me to work out my work schedule it's probably best to say I can't help this time. Let's get together soon :-)

Rosscameasdoody · 25/10/2023 09:50

Deathwillbebutapause · 25/10/2023 09:32

"Offer withdrawn because of your rudeness, fuckface."

Short, pithy, and to the point. Well done 🤣

Rosscameasdoody · 25/10/2023 09:47

Tell her that you arranged work around what she originally requested but that you can’t afford to miss work for nothing. And that you’re happy to help out in the future as long as she realises that arrangements need to be firm, with some notice if they change, so that you can make work plans to suit.

I suspect she realises she’s being unreasonable because the message she sent overnight is nothing short of emotional blackmail, designed to keep you on side. Don’t fall for it. If her circumstances are as difficult as you say, then she shouldn’t be messing about the one person who is trying to support her.

SapphOhNo · 25/10/2023 09:45

"I'm sorry your house fell though SIL. I did not appreciate how you responded to a very reasonable request to know whether I take time off work or not. I'm here to support you but I have obligations too. I think you should reflect on how you responded and where that comes from".

HauntedGusset · 25/10/2023 09:40

Not sure what half term has to do with anything? It's actually not half term in the county I live in anyway, my DC are off next week!

The problem has solved itself anyway. The house she was meant to be viewing is no longer available. The lord works in mysterious ways 🤣

Going forward I simply won't offer again. Lesson learned.

Not engaging with the benefit bashing posts etc, SIL is very nice (well, usually very nice!) and has valid reasons for needing support and for home educating. The move will hopefully make it possible for DN to get back to school and SIL back to work so I want to support her but this just felt absolutely ridiculous!

OP posts: