Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think SIL should make the decision herself and give me a firm answer?

212 replies

HauntedGusset · 25/10/2023 08:01

I'll try and keep it short.

SIL (single parent) wants to go and view a house for a possible exchange tomorrow, and DN (7 and home educated) said she didn't want to go. I said I'd look after DN. This means taking a day off work, but as I'm self employed this is do-able if necessary and I want to support SIL. So I haven't scheduled any work for tomorrow. I messaged SIL last night asking what time she would drop DN off and she replied saying DN thinks she might want to go after all and she would let me know tomorrow morning. I said this wasn't ideal as I didn't really want to take a day off work for no reason (I'm a gardener, so can't just turn up without arranging with clients in advance) so could she let me know by this evening please.

SIL sent me this reply overnight... "I'm sorry but I can't give you the answer you want right now. I won't know until it's time to leave whether DN is coming with me or not, she can't decide and we will see how she feels in the morning. You said you'd look after her so if you aren't going to stick to your word and want to go to work instead, just say so and I'll know not to rely on you again". DN doesn't have any SEN etc, but SIL has a parenting philosophy that children should make their own decisions about pretty much everything. Up to her, of course, but this is making me really frustrated as whilst I'm happy to take a day off to look after DN I'm not happy to be in limbo til it's too late for me to do anything else - I'm not well off, taking the day off is a favour to SIL because I want to help her out, but not something I want to do if it isn't actually necessary. I think under the circumstances SIL should tell DN what is happening not wait for her to decide last minute. She's welcome to centre everything round the whims of a 7 yr old but it's not really fair to impose that on other people who have offered to help her!

AIBU here?

OP posts:
letloz · 28/10/2023 09:55

I appreciate wanting to give her child the chance to make a decision, but giving them that right, it should come with the responsibility that we all have to sometimes have to make a decision in advance , and stick to it. She shouldn't expect the world to go on hold waiting for her child's decisions. So no YANBU.

wesurecouldstandgladioli · 28/10/2023 09:22

HauntedGusset · 25/10/2023 15:04

SIL really isn't normally a CF, she's a bit on her own planet at the moment due to aforementioned difficult circumstances and she is a bit batshit wet overly cooperative with her DC, but I do genuinely like her. This is kind of typical of her parenting style, just usually it wouldn't affect me so I've never been annoyed by it before!

You’re a better person than me, I wouldn’t message anyone again who was so rude to me.

qwerty123454 · 28/10/2023 09:18

No good deed goes unpunished

Tiredandgrumpy31 · 28/10/2023 08:57

Wow I think your SIL sounds incredibly entitled. Fine, she wants to let DN make the decision but she is a parent who should be teaching DN about boundaries, timescales, consideration for others. As a parent, she needs to say ‘It is your choice whether you come or not, but you have to decide tonight so that your aunt can make arrangements not to work’. I think the worse thing is then turning it around on you to suggest you are being the one who is unreliable when you are going out of your way to help.

lilmadmel · 28/10/2023 08:35

“That’s ok, I won’t rely on you to appreciate when someone is bending over backwards and putting themselves out to do you a favour in the future” 😂

Rosscameasdoody · 28/10/2023 07:51

Catastrophejane · 26/10/2023 14:33

I’m really torn about this. I get that the vast majority of people on benefits are in difficult circumstances. But it’s people like this that give ammunition to those who think everyone on benefits is ‘lazy’.

OP said that DN has no SEN or learning difficulties.

Perhaps there’s a reason SIL can’t work, but with the selfish attitude she has shown to OP, I detect a major CF!

Many people working full time on low income quite rightly have resentment when they see people living comfortably on benefits.

I don’t think it’s wrong to question this.

I’ve worked in welfare for a lot of years and I don’t know anyone who lives ‘comfortably’ on benefits. OP has indeed said that there is no SEN or learning difficulties but she hasn’t said if there is other disability. What she did say, and the benefit bashers have clearly missed it, is this:

Not engaging with the benefit bashing posts etc, SIL is very nice (well, usually very nice!) and has valid reasons for needing support and for home educating. The move will hopefully make it possible for DN to get back to school and SIL back to work

I think it’s also quite possible that there is a DV situation here. And I do think it’s wrong for posters to introduce the topic of benefits if not directly relevant, because otherwise, as this poster rightly said, it’s none of anyone’s business. It’s just an excuse for the benefit bashing that’s becoming depressingly common on MN.

Rosscameasdoody · 28/10/2023 07:42

Catastrophejane · 26/10/2023 14:17

Exactly this!

I think you’d be wise not to offer again.

my blood boils with people like this. I’m guessing as she’s a single parent in social housing (who is home schooling) she is relying on benefits?

This has clearly skewed her view and she doesn’t realise that some of us have to work for a living.

I say that as a single parent and socialist, but some people just massively take the piss!

she’s going to have a shock when DN is 18 and she’s expected to get a job.

You know what makes my blood boil ? Posters resorting to benefit bashing when there’s absolutely no evidence to support what they’re saying. OP clearly mentioned that there are difficult circumstances, and we have absolutely no idea what they could be. Might be a DV situation, maybe DD is disabled. And there is absolutely nothing in the OPs posts to suggest SiL is reliant on benefits or that she has never worked. You might want to try remembering that a lot of benefit claimants have worked and contributed to the benefits they rely on when things get difficult. That’s what the system is for. Making huge assumptions like this is unhelpful and divisive.

GreatGardenstuff · 28/10/2023 07:17

Withdraw your offer. You can’t lose a day’s work at the whim of a 7yo. Your SIL is being a very choosy beggar by not confirming. I don’t thinks she’s actually doing her DD any favours pandering to her and expecting others to do the same.

JLou08 · 27/10/2023 21:36

I like encouraging children to make their own decisions but there needs to be limits to that just like there is with adults. If I was her mum I would be saying you decided not to go and now you can't as aunt has taken time off or saying you are coming and have no choice now as Aunt is working.
I think your SIL has been very rude and inconsiderate, if I was you I'd be tempted to tell her I will not be rearranging any work for her again and making it clear the world doesn't revolve around her child.

FarFarAwayB · 27/10/2023 19:41

OP, I think you are a lovely person. Please don’t lose your kind heart.

Magicmama92 · 27/10/2023 19:26

I'd respond with:
By taking time off work I'm loosing money. I'm happy to do that but it's also your responsibility to give me enough notice especially as I'm doing a favour. The rude reply you've given is not only unhelpful but not at all acceptable when you know I could be working instead.

I'd not offer again and if she asks why say because she's unreliable and you can't afford not to work if then your n again can't pick what to do.

So irritating as a mum myself I'd say to my child well your going over to stay because that's what you said initially and it's tough.

gemma19846 · 27/10/2023 17:57

I take it SIL doesnt work if DN is home ed so shes no idea about working to support her family. What a cheeky f*er. Id text her back saying if you cant let me know in advance then i will have to assume you dont need me and i will work as normal. Do NOT offer again

BestZebbie · 26/10/2023 22:28

This is so rude, that I'd wonder, did she actually understand that you would be losing a day's paid employment over this or does she just think you'd be timetabling your flexible jobs so as to happen to leave a chunk of time free all on the same day that week?

billy1966 · 26/10/2023 14:45

That is a spectacularly rude, disrespectful response from her.

Funny how these ditzy CF manage to have people pleasers at their beck and call.

OP, kindly meant but you clearly can't have the greatest self esteem if you think that extremely RUDE response was anything but that.

There is nothing ditzy about that response.

It is a cuttingly rude and dismissive and most wouldn't deign to reply to it, much less be available again.

Think about how people generally treat you?

Your posts are full of excuses as to why she would treat you and your livelihood and time with such complete disregard.

We teach people how to treat us, and from her response to you, it is absolutely clear what you have taught her.

Thesearmsofmine · 26/10/2023 14:43

Catastrophejane · 26/10/2023 14:33

I’m really torn about this. I get that the vast majority of people on benefits are in difficult circumstances. But it’s people like this that give ammunition to those who think everyone on benefits is ‘lazy’.

OP said that DN has no SEN or learning difficulties.

Perhaps there’s a reason SIL can’t work, but with the selfish attitude she has shown to OP, I detect a major CF!

Many people working full time on low income quite rightly have resentment when they see people living comfortably on benefits.

I don’t think it’s wrong to question this.

Home education makes no difference to benefits. If she is able to work then she will be expected to look for work in the same ways that someone with a child in school would be.

Catastrophejane · 26/10/2023 14:33

PabloandGustheGreySquirrels · 25/10/2023 10:09

None of your business! She may be a disabled parent for all you know. I'm severely disabled (& widowed) and unable to work and I home schooled my child for 6 months earlier this year.

(Before you make a cocky remark, I had no choice as her school closed and there were no spaces locally)

I’m really torn about this. I get that the vast majority of people on benefits are in difficult circumstances. But it’s people like this that give ammunition to those who think everyone on benefits is ‘lazy’.

OP said that DN has no SEN or learning difficulties.

Perhaps there’s a reason SIL can’t work, but with the selfish attitude she has shown to OP, I detect a major CF!

Many people working full time on low income quite rightly have resentment when they see people living comfortably on benefits.

I don’t think it’s wrong to question this.

Catastrophejane · 26/10/2023 14:17

heldinadream · 25/10/2023 08:05

"...I'll know not to rely on you again"
"Thank you, yes I think that's sensible. I'll know not to offer to help again and we'll leave it at that."
She's a CF OP.

Exactly this!

I think you’d be wise not to offer again.

my blood boils with people like this. I’m guessing as she’s a single parent in social housing (who is home schooling) she is relying on benefits?

This has clearly skewed her view and she doesn’t realise that some of us have to work for a living.

I say that as a single parent and socialist, but some people just massively take the piss!

she’s going to have a shock when DN is 18 and she’s expected to get a job.

BlossomOfOrange · 26/10/2023 12:55

Could you avoid her invite to engage in a row, and say something along the lines of ‘ah, ok, dn can go with you, brilliant. That’s great to hear as taking a day from work whilst fine in emergencies, isn’t ideal. Hope you both like the house’.

Hlly · 26/10/2023 12:46

I would never offer child care again and if asked I would refuse. ‘I have plans’ ‘I have work’ would be my response.
No thank you, not helping you out if you’re not even going to be polite and confirm one way or another.
Also children need to learn that if they commit to something and someone else has rearranged/cancelled/made special arrangements for them then they cannot let them down on a whim depending how they feel that second. It’s rude and selfish

itsalongwaybackfromsorry · 26/10/2023 11:43

HauntedGusset · 25/10/2023 15:04

SIL really isn't normally a CF, she's a bit on her own planet at the moment due to aforementioned difficult circumstances and she is a bit batshit wet overly cooperative with her DC, but I do genuinely like her. This is kind of typical of her parenting style, just usually it wouldn't affect me so I've never been annoyed by it before!

The problem is, her 'overly cooperative' treatment of her child is going to result in one of those annoying people who feels free to cancel or just bail on their friends regularly as a 'better offer' came along, or she 'wasn't feeling it'.

Pinkclouds80 · 26/10/2023 11:28

Your SIL is a bellend and a good life lesson for a 7 year old (other than the world not revolving around your whims) is that sometimes you have to make a decision and stick with it, to be considerate to other people.

I say this as someone who tries hard to follow gentle / attachment parenting, and it’s self centred tossers like this that give it a bad name!

Pineapples198 · 26/10/2023 11:19

Your sister in law is the one being unreasonable here. And rude frankly. I’d go back to her and say “I'm not happy at all that you are saying I’m unreliable. I am happy to take a day off work to care for X which will mean me losing £xx, as a favour to you and X. However I am not happy to wait until the last minute for a decision as I could then end up losing my income for no reason. If you cannot give me a decision tonight then please do assume I’m unavailable tomorrow.”

also she needs to woman up and parent a bit more. She could always tell her 7 year old it’s her decision but she needs to make it today and that’s final.

SlothBabyTruth · 26/10/2023 10:46

SIL is unreasonable.

TrustyRusty68 · 26/10/2023 10:44

I do t know how to say it politely, so I’m just going to come straight out with it - your SIL is deluded. She can raise her child how she likes, but if she thinks anyone can afford to take a day off to ‘maybe’ look after her child, she’s not living in the real world. I’d reply saying I’ll happily look after her, but due to the nature of my work I need 24 hours notice. She’s obviously not desperate for help as her reply to you was nothing short of rude :-)

Casperroonie · 26/10/2023 10:42

She's rude and living on another planet. Don't offer again, let her sort out her own mess.