Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This dress is NOT appropriate.

257 replies

LReo · 24/10/2023 22:40

My niece, who is 13, sent me a link to this dress saying she would like it for Christmas. I replied saying I don’t think it’s appropriate as it’s clearly an adults dress, the neckline is too low and where would she even wear it?

She’s now really annoyed with me, saying I don’t respect her personal style and all of her friends wear similar. I’ve messaged my niece’s mum and dad who agree with me and are trying to talk to her, but she’s insisting I’m wrong and has now got the hump.

AIBU?

This dress is NOT appropriate.
OP posts:
beatrix1234 · 25/10/2023 23:30

@MrsSkylerWhite Frankly, what my aged mum would call a slapper.

Calling someone a slapper is slut shamming at its best, a terrible thing to do. This is what the patriarchy has been doing for centuries in order to put women on its place and control them. I’m not slut shamming these young girls by any means (that would be an awful thing to do), I’m just disturbed at the fact that the “porn trend“ ihas only been adopted by girls and not boys.

MrsSkylerWhite · 25/10/2023 23:24

Beatrix1234

Have you seen that particular photo (sorry, not sure how to link). I’m nearly 60, certainly no nun, danced on my share of tables, but I was gobsmacked. She may as well have been naked with tiny pants on. Just not attractive. Whatever happened to mystery?(which is far sexier, IM- humble - O)

beatrix1234 · 25/10/2023 23:19

MrsSkylerWhite · 25/10/2023 23:07

beatrix1234
**
I believe you can totally like your body and not feel the need to dress like a porn star”

This, x10. Minding my own business looking for a bedspread on Marketplace, I was suddenly looking at a photo of Scarlet Johanssen in what was more or less what used to be called a body stocking. No idea why? Not much to do with bedspreads.

I digress. Why would a successful, talented, long-established actor feel the need to appear on the red carpet at the Golden Glibes looking like that? Frankly, what my aged mum would call a slapper. Yes, feminism, all for it. But is that really reduced to showing your nipples and tiny knickers through a gauze?

In this case I can totally see why an actress would dress so revealing, you want those flashes hitting you, you want your picture on the news, that’s how acting careers work. You want to remind producers and the public in general that you’re still a hot thing while promoting your last movie. I get it. Johanssen is no Meryl steep, she tends to play sexy roles. Definitely not the case of all the young girls walking in my town centre at night, they are not actresses and they’re not promoting any movie.

MrsSkylerWhite · 25/10/2023 23:07

beatrix1234
**
I believe you can totally like your body and not feel the need to dress like a porn star”

This, x10. Minding my own business looking for a bedspread on Marketplace, I was suddenly looking at a photo of Scarlet Johanssen in what was more or less what used to be called a body stocking. No idea why? Not much to do with bedspreads.

I digress. Why would a successful, talented, long-established actor feel the need to appear on the red carpet at the Golden Glibes looking like that? Frankly, what my aged mum would call a slapper. Yes, feminism, all for it. But is that really reduced to showing your nipples and tiny knickers through a gauze?

beatrix1234 · 25/10/2023 22:29

VanityDiesHard · 25/10/2023 22:25

Oh, for definite. That is offputting. I think that nights out have always been like that, though: girls have been wearing very revealing/sexy outfits for as long as I can remember. I'm like you, I never did. I never really liked how my body looked, and the last thing I wanted was to be in super sexy clothes.

I believe you can totally like your body and not feel the need to dress like a porn star.

VanityDiesHard · 25/10/2023 22:25

beatrix1234 · 25/10/2023 22:20

What I find disturbing (as a woman) is walking at night through the town centre and watching all these hypersexualized girls who look like their attending the next Las Vegas porn awards while their male counterparts are dressed pretty “normal” like most teenage guys in baggy clothes. If everyone was dressed like porn stars (both male and female) I would think ok it’s just a “trend”, but the fact only girls are doing it makes me think there’s a very sexist element to it, and that’s what disturbs me.

Edited

Oh, for definite. That is offputting. I think that nights out have always been like that, though: girls have been wearing very revealing/sexy outfits for as long as I can remember. I'm like you, I never did. I never really liked how my body looked, and the last thing I wanted was to be in super sexy clothes.

beatrix1234 · 25/10/2023 22:20

VanityDiesHard · 25/10/2023 22:04

On balance, I think you're right. I try not to judge people by appearance too much, but I will admit that I find the pornification of culture a bit worrying. I'm constantly torn between feeling that what other people wear is none of my business and if they are happy, who am I to judge?/and feeling that their clothing choices aren't made in a vacuum, and that the very overtly sexualised look is a bit disturbing.

What I find disturbing (as a woman) is walking at night through the town centre and watching all these hypersexualized girls who look like their attending the next Las Vegas porn awards while their male counterparts are dressed pretty “normal” like most teenage guys in baggy clothes. If everyone was dressed like porn stars (both male and female) I would think ok it’s just a “trend”, but the fact only girls are doing it makes me think there’s a very sexist element to it, and that’s what disturbs me.

Busephalus · 25/10/2023 22:11

Fucking hell, she'll be asking for scrunch bum leggings next

VanityDiesHard · 25/10/2023 22:04

beatrix1234 · 25/10/2023 21:49

Wearing baggy clothes send a strong message to the universe: I'm a woman comfortable in my skin enough that I don't need to put in public display my boobs and ass, I have many attributes and being eye candy for the guys is just not one of them. I honestly don't care if guys find me attractive or not because for me beauty is on the inside. Want to know more about me: you'll need to get to know me. A man who engages with me because I'm dressing as a hyper sexualised version of myself with public display of tits n ass is not the man I want to attract.

That doesn't mean we should all dress like nuns, not at all. It's nice to look fit, healthy, show you take care of yourself and wear clothes that fit properly or enhance our skin colour or body type. Someone need to teach these young girls that their value as a woman doesn't rely on their looks nor their sexuality.

Edited

On balance, I think you're right. I try not to judge people by appearance too much, but I will admit that I find the pornification of culture a bit worrying. I'm constantly torn between feeling that what other people wear is none of my business and if they are happy, who am I to judge?/and feeling that their clothing choices aren't made in a vacuum, and that the very overtly sexualised look is a bit disturbing.

AirFryerFrequentFlyer · 25/10/2023 21:50

foxlover47 · 24/10/2023 23:51

My daughter is 11 and a lot of her friends and her like the sort of bodycon fitted dress worn with Nikes/ boots and a crop jacket , sort of dressed but dressed down
I think it's more common a style than people think , it's very instagram /tik tok style

Yea I've seen loads of early teen girls wearing quite tight dresses under those over sized coats/jackets around here - and we are a very non-trendy little Scottish village! It's def a trend.

beatrix1234 · 25/10/2023 21:49

VanityDiesHard · 25/10/2023 21:12

I sort of know what you mean, but I don't think it is quite as prevalent as you suggest. I think that the pressures are very different now, in some ways things are worse, as you say, but in other ways they are better. I think that the craze for extreme thinness is much less than it was in my day (I'm in my early forties, so Kate Moss was at her peak and heroin chic was in, followed by the early aughts and the size zero craze) I honestly think that that is every bit as damaging as wearing tight, revealing clothes. One could also say that wearing very baggy clothes and looking 'ugly' is a kind of uniform. I think that one is the inverse of the other, two sides of the same rather than diametric opposites.

Wearing baggy clothes send a strong message to the universe: I'm a woman comfortable in my skin enough that I don't need to put in public display my boobs and ass, I have many attributes and being eye candy for the guys is just not one of them. I honestly don't care if guys find me attractive or not because for me beauty is on the inside. Want to know more about me: you'll need to get to know me. A man who engages with me because I'm dressing as a hyper sexualised version of myself with public display of tits n ass is not the man I want to attract.

That doesn't mean we should all dress like nuns, not at all. It's nice to look fit, healthy, show you take care of yourself and wear clothes that fit properly or enhance our skin colour or body type. Someone need to teach these young girls that their value as a woman doesn't rely on their looks nor their sexuality.

Isometimeswonder · 25/10/2023 21:25

Why are you worried about a 13yo having the hump with you?
She's a kid. Ignore it.

VanityDiesHard · 25/10/2023 21:12

beatrix1234 · 25/10/2023 21:02

Sorry but I disagree, teens are rebellious by nature. I'm in my 50's so I was a punk rocker in my teens, it was very rebellious, very sex pistols and very anti-system. Looking ugly, used clothes and sticking a middle finger to the establishment. Good ol days. These girls nowadays dress like porn stars (with all due respect to porn stars), but that's how they dress. Hyper sexualised walking dolls in very revealing clothes, the long nails, the super high heels and counting the days they can get fake breast implants and botox. In the meanwhile their male counterparts dress baggy clothes and don't bother to objectify themselves like their attending some sort of erotica wards convention.

Where did feminism go so wrong?!! Why are these girls dressing like sex bombs nowadays?

I sort of know what you mean, but I don't think it is quite as prevalent as you suggest. I think that the pressures are very different now, in some ways things are worse, as you say, but in other ways they are better. I think that the craze for extreme thinness is much less than it was in my day (I'm in my early forties, so Kate Moss was at her peak and heroin chic was in, followed by the early aughts and the size zero craze) I honestly think that that is every bit as damaging as wearing tight, revealing clothes. One could also say that wearing very baggy clothes and looking 'ugly' is a kind of uniform. I think that one is the inverse of the other, two sides of the same rather than diametric opposites.

beatrix1234 · 25/10/2023 21:02

VanityDiesHard · 25/10/2023 16:27

This is very harsh wording. I sort of see where you are coming from, but it seems inappropriately shaming. Teens are conformist. The Kardashians/Jenners, Love Island, and Tik-Tok stars are where a lot of them get style inspiration, so that is why they want to dress in these rather risque outfits.

Sorry but I disagree, teens are rebellious by nature. I'm in my 50's so I was a punk rocker in my teens, it was very rebellious, very sex pistols and very anti-system. Looking ugly, used clothes and sticking a middle finger to the establishment. Good ol days. These girls nowadays dress like porn stars (with all due respect to porn stars), but that's how they dress. Hyper sexualised walking dolls in very revealing clothes, the long nails, the super high heels and counting the days they can get fake breast implants and botox. In the meanwhile their male counterparts dress baggy clothes and don't bother to objectify themselves like their attending some sort of erotica wards convention.

Where did feminism go so wrong?!! Why are these girls dressing like sex bombs nowadays?

Mayhemmumma · 25/10/2023 20:32

@ icechocs

That has to be the best response

Shodan · 25/10/2023 17:19

Screamingabdabz · 25/10/2023 15:05

She’s rude, she’s ‘a madam’, a brat, she should be left to sulk, who cares if she’s got the hump… etc. etc…. What nasty posts about some poor kid who just said she might like a very plain long tube dress, probably to look a bit grown up…

No wonder so many clueless parents clash with their teenagers. 🙄

She didn't 'just say she'd like a very plain long tube dress' did she though?

She told her aunt which specific dress she wanted, then "got the hump" when told no. She accused her aunt of not respecting her personal style, and was really annoyed with her.

My kids have been brought up with good manners, and I've never clashed with them, and since one is 27 and one is nearly 16, and I have an excellent relationship with both, I'd say I'm far from clueless. I just refused to give into their every demand, and would've doubled down on that if they'd been rude.

therealcookiemonster · 25/10/2023 17:05

@MrsSkylerWhite as far as I am concerned there should be a government programme where all 12 year olds get a pony or some other similar animal until they are 18. keeps them busy and occupied.

SiobhanSharpe · 25/10/2023 16:50

The model in the pic is very curvy indeed, do many 13 year olds have such grown-up figures? For posters who've said their teenage daughters wear similar, what do these dresses look like on?
If i remember my long ago teenage years we were either straight up and down or decidedly lumpy. I was in the latter category.

mbosnz · 25/10/2023 16:41

My 13 year old would have looked like Jessica Rabbit in that. She was taken as being 21 when she was 15, and when she was TWELVE, I was having to hiss at grown men leering at her in a restaurant as she and her sisters walked to the loo, to say, 'she's twelve years OLD, you perves'.

I'd be saying, 'it's a lovely dress, for someone a touch older, with a somewhat different social life to what a 13 year old has. But no dear, I'm not buying you that'. (Which is what I had to say a hell of a lot to my teen daughters. . .)

icechocs · 25/10/2023 16:37

I have a 13 year old and to be honest I don't think the dress is that bad.
I know it's an adult dress, and shows all her figure, but I'm ok that my daughter wants to show her figure if it's occasion appropriate.
I am relieved that as my daughter has developed she feels generally happy about her body and pleased with how she sees herself.
Without her specifically saying so I see that she is just as happy and confident in baggy jeans a t-shirt and no makeup which she wears at school as she is when she wears tight fitting tops and makeup when doing something special.

Mayhemmumma · 25/10/2023 16:37

Couldn't you have put it gentler, that's quite a grown up look, I'll check with your mum.

Tbh lots of teens wear body con, short skirts or hot-pants, naval showing etc, she's just following a crowd.

It's only inappropriate if adults make it so.

VanityDiesHard · 25/10/2023 16:27

beatrix1234 · 24/10/2023 23:12

At 13 I got in trouble with mum for wearing very baggy sex pistols t shirts, ripped jeans and a dog collar. The whole aim was to “scare people”. The uglier I looked the better. She would have none of it. Nowadays teenage girls want to look like porn stars which I don’t understand as there’s nothing “rebellious” about looking
like a hyper sexual living doll. I have a hard time figuring out why this is happening.

This is very harsh wording. I sort of see where you are coming from, but it seems inappropriately shaming. Teens are conformist. The Kardashians/Jenners, Love Island, and Tik-Tok stars are where a lot of them get style inspiration, so that is why they want to dress in these rather risque outfits.

VanityDiesHard · 25/10/2023 16:23

YANBU, but it might be an idea to steer her in the direction of a dress which is similar but more age-appropriate. That dress is a beautiful colour, could you perhaps look at sweater dresses in a similar colour but less figure hugging? I think as well that you need to go a bit carefully with policing her clothing (this is really more her parents' business than yours, of course) While I agree with you that the dress isn't suitable for a thirteen year old, I've seen girls that age in far, far worse. If her parents could praise her sense of style and compliment her a bit rather than being all 'you're not going out dressed like that, young lady', then that might get better results.

AmandasFleckerl · 25/10/2023 15:58

SunshineAutumnday · 25/10/2023 10:32

Another method to use instead of saying no is OMG thats lovely - I'll think I'll get one too and we can be twins... 😂 It's worked several times over on my DD.

Edited

Best response 😂

Screamingabdabz · 25/10/2023 15:05

She’s rude, she’s ‘a madam’, a brat, she should be left to sulk, who cares if she’s got the hump… etc. etc…. What nasty posts about some poor kid who just said she might like a very plain long tube dress, probably to look a bit grown up…

No wonder so many clueless parents clash with their teenagers. 🙄

Swipe left for the next trending thread