Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To rant about government financial help

255 replies

Alittlenonsensenowandthen · 24/10/2023 21:56

Firstly, I'll say that I've previously been in receipt of financial help from govt and extremely grateful and also want those who need help to be helped, but...
I've now met two people (retired) who are telling me what they're spending their fuel allowance on (new flat screen TV, holidays, new sofas). This is not an agiest or benefit bashing thread but it just gets my goat that there are people happily spending money given for heating on luxuries. It's not actually their fault - they haven't asked for the money, it wasn't means tested so arguably why not spend it and see it as bonus money. If govt wants to help, it needs to pay for things directly surely?
Just really bugging me at the moment because we're fine financially but only just, and we earn too much for help.
Argh! Just needed a rant to the ether this eve!

OP posts:
halloweensweets · 25/10/2023 17:37

I think having less money to spend will also apply to renters. Especially those in private rentals.

Yes exactly, landlords will also put their prices up to cover the mortgages, or maybe just to take advantage of the economic situation.

Zebedee55 · 25/10/2023 17:33

halloweensweets · 25/10/2023 17:24

But we don't want people spending money... interest rates have risen to make sure people (with mortgages) have less money to spend, and therefore to bring prices/ inflation down.

I think having less money to spend will also apply to renters. Especially those in private rentals.

Zebedee55 · 25/10/2023 17:32

Ponderingwindow · 25/10/2023 14:40

It costs additional money to means test the benefit.

if the money isn’t spent on heating, it is still likely spent given the demographic. This means money for the economy.

Yes, it will. I will probably use mine to send to the ACs and GCs towards their Xmas presents.

They will spend it - therefore giving various companies the money, and paying into the economy.

I worked for the DWP, years ago, and means testing costs a fortune - far more than it's worth for a once a year payment.

halloweensweets · 25/10/2023 17:24

Ponderingwindow · 25/10/2023 14:40

It costs additional money to means test the benefit.

if the money isn’t spent on heating, it is still likely spent given the demographic. This means money for the economy.

But we don't want people spending money... interest rates have risen to make sure people (with mortgages) have less money to spend, and therefore to bring prices/ inflation down.

halloweensweets · 25/10/2023 17:22

Every generation thinks they have it worse than any other generation. I had 3 DC in the 1980s ; Mat Leave was 3 months . Interest rates double figures . Need I go on ? Yet I thought I was worse off than my mother because she only worked part time and I had to work full time .

There are many studies and reports out there that show millennials (and younger) are the first generation to have it worse than their parents did at the same age.

www.ft.com/content/81343d9e-187b-11e8-9e9c-25c814761640

And as for interest rates, as has been said time and time again on these threads, house prices were significantly cheaper in the 80s so the amount borrowed (and therefore interest paid) was much less. Paying 5% interest on £250k borrowed for example is £12500 a year. Paying 15% on £50k borrowed is £7500 a year.

Zebedee55 · 25/10/2023 17:16

LakieLady · 25/10/2023 16:36

I'm old, so can remember the bitterly cold winter of 62/63.

We had an outdoor lavatory and it was so cold that the water in the pan and the cistern froze solid. When you needed a poo, you had to boil a kettle to thaw it out!

Yeah and me. Windows frozen indoors at home and only two coal fires. It froze from November until March.

Everybody had to go to work and schools had to stay open. No staying off then...lol

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 25/10/2023 17:14

And every time something in the house (that I skinted myself to pay for during years and years of interest rates in double figures) needs fixing, I have to put my hand in my pocket and pay for it, not just ring the landlord and ask them to do it

Oh yes. £2k a year to a fucking useless management co. I pay that myself as well.

Zebedee55 · 25/10/2023 17:13

emmylousings · 25/10/2023 09:00

Totally agree with this, why not just give to people on pension credit? Answer, just like triple lock, political parties live pandering to the powerful boomer and elderly cohort, coz they are a big group, they vote and highly likely to vote Tory..

Yawn. I'm a boomer, and have never voted Tory...🙄

LakieLady · 25/10/2023 16:54

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 25/10/2023 12:13

It's time there was a huge reform of benefits so that all the Boomers on final salary pensions who paid off their mortgages donkeys years ago stop getting everything paid for to even things up a bit between the generations

OK, I'll bite.

  1. my final salary pension is £ 3,600 a year. And I pay tax on it.
  2. my mortgage was paid off a few years ago. i did that myself, no-one handed it to me
  3. I get prescription charges, eye tests and heating allowance. Set that against the fact that I have been paying tax since 1975 and will pay tax to the day I die.

When you say 'huge reform of benefits,' what you really mean of course is 'take it from the boomers, give it to me.' I've been in countries where pensioners are begging in the street so they can eat. Seems to me some people would love that to be happening here to 'even things up between the generations.'

I'm in a very similar position; final salary pension of £3,386, on which tax is payable, because the personal allowance is only bit more than my state pension.

I'm still working, and pay tax on every penny I earn, too, and I've been working since 1972. I paid NI for 49 years.

My MIL, who only worked for 15 years in her life, gets pension credit which is around £5 pw less than my full state pensions and full housing benefit, plus 100% council tax reduction. Even if I wasn't working, I'd still have to pay some of my council tax. And every time something in the house (that I skinted myself to pay for during years and years of interest rates in double figures) needs fixing, I have to put my hand in my pocket and pay for it, not just ring the landlord and ask them to do it.

I'll probably be using my winter fuel payment to get the fence fixed, and replace the fridge which is on its last legs.

Unithorn · 25/10/2023 16:52

The standard of living is generally higher now than it was, no chance children and young people today would put up with some of the stuff parents and grandparents did growing up! There's definitely been a sweetspot of affordable housing, decent wages and increasing opportunities though which has now passed; swings and roundabouts.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 25/10/2023 16:46

LakieLady · 25/10/2023 16:36

I'm old, so can remember the bitterly cold winter of 62/63.

We had an outdoor lavatory and it was so cold that the water in the pan and the cistern froze solid. When you needed a poo, you had to boil a kettle to thaw it out!

Our school toilets were outside, we got sent home when they froze. Then OUR toilet froze and we had to use next doors.

LakieLady · 25/10/2023 16:36

Miyagi99 · 25/10/2023 08:27

Definitely had ice on the windows in the UK without central heating, we said Jack Frost had been in the night. This would have been in the 80s when we didn’t have double glazing either. I miss the patterns but not the drafts!

I'm old, so can remember the bitterly cold winter of 62/63.

We had an outdoor lavatory and it was so cold that the water in the pan and the cistern froze solid. When you needed a poo, you had to boil a kettle to thaw it out!

ruby1957 · 25/10/2023 16:35

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 25/10/2023 12:13

It's time there was a huge reform of benefits so that all the Boomers on final salary pensions who paid off their mortgages donkeys years ago stop getting everything paid for to even things up a bit between the generations

OK, I'll bite.

  1. my final salary pension is £ 3,600 a year. And I pay tax on it.
  2. my mortgage was paid off a few years ago. i did that myself, no-one handed it to me
  3. I get prescription charges, eye tests and heating allowance. Set that against the fact that I have been paying tax since 1975 and will pay tax to the day I die.

When you say 'huge reform of benefits,' what you really mean of course is 'take it from the boomers, give it to me.' I've been in countries where pensioners are begging in the street so they can eat. Seems to me some people would love that to be happening here to 'even things up between the generations.'

Thank you for saying the above. I totally agree.
Given that the WFA is normally less than £5 a week per household - I can only feel the venom that is poured on the heads of its recipients is very mean-spirited.

Neriah · 25/10/2023 16:24

DollyTubb · 25/10/2023 13:46

Just a thought, many of the people of state pension age who are eligible for the WFP and cost of living payment are also providing free child care and/or elderly relative care. Something that is worth billions to the economy, not to mention over stretched families, yet is frequently overlooked in the constant pensioner bashing that goes on here. An extra £500 one off payment to provide a comfortable environment for babies/children/vulnerable relatives seems a bargain!

We're also forgetting that according to the MN trope we are supposed to ensure that we stay fit in our old age so that we don't need any care (preferably whilst providing free childcare), because care squanders the kids inheritance. Alternatively we should have the foresight to give them their inheritance before the state (or one of them!) grab it and dump us in a home.

BIossomtoes · 25/10/2023 16:08

TruthSeeker2023 · 25/10/2023 12:08

None of these benefits will still be available when those of us who currently work to pay all the taxes have retired. It's time there was a huge reform of benefits so that all the Boomers on final salary pensions who paid off their mortgages donkeys years ago stop getting everything paid for to even things up a bit between the generations.

Yes, let’s even things up a bit, shall we? We didn’t get free or subsidised child care. You? I’ve been paying tax since 1972, when the basic rate was 33% - at the higher rate for 20 years. When you’ve paid as much tax as I have - and continue to - then we can even things up.

LauderSyme · 25/10/2023 15:30

Many excellent points made on this thread, interesting reading, thank you all.

Mylovelygreendress · 25/10/2023 15:21

TruthSeeker2023 · 25/10/2023 12:08

None of these benefits will still be available when those of us who currently work to pay all the taxes have retired. It's time there was a huge reform of benefits so that all the Boomers on final salary pensions who paid off their mortgages donkeys years ago stop getting everything paid for to even things up a bit between the generations.

Everything paid for ?? I wasn’t aware that someone bought my shopping and paid my utility bills . Can you tell me who I should contact to arrange this?
Every generation thinks they have it worse than any other generation. I had 3 DC in the 1980s ; Mat Leave was 3 months . Interest rates double figures . Need I go on ? Yet I thought I was worse off than my mother because she only worked part time and I had to work full time .

Seymour5 · 25/10/2023 14:44

TigerRag · 25/10/2023 13:40

But then someone is going to be worse off because they're a few pounds over the cut off. I remember with the cost of living payments people were complaining about this - the new pension is a few pounds over pension credit

Of course it is. Wouldn't we older pensioners who have small private or occupational pensions that take us just over PC limits love to get that extra £50 or so a week?

Winners and losers see it differently.

Ponderingwindow · 25/10/2023 14:40

It costs additional money to means test the benefit.

if the money isn’t spent on heating, it is still likely spent given the demographic. This means money for the economy.

Elvis1956 · 25/10/2023 14:32

OhComeOnFFS · 25/10/2023 12:48

@Elvis1956 You say: here's an economic principle called the multiplier effect. If we take the 600 and assume everyone will save 10% and spend the rest, it's £540 spent. That money is then spent =£486, then 437.40. So already the economy had benefited by spending of 549+486+437.40. So in 3'steps it's become1472.40...which is a boost to the UK economy

Can you explain this in more detail? I don't understand the figures. I do understand the boost, though - didn't Donald Trump do this when he came into office? I seem to remember he gave everyone a couple of hundred dollars or so and said they had to spend it to boost the economy.

What I've done in the example is assume that most people save 10% of what they eRn(and this is an idea world where one person buys goods/service from another person and so on). So each time the money is spent it grows in value to the economy.
If I earned £100, I would spend £90 buying something from you. You would save £9 and spend £81.
It's what trump did. Or the eat out to help out in a way. On a big scale it's quantitive easing.... putting more money in the economy either by physical printing notes, or central banks lending more
The downside is it's inflationary, more money in the economy chasing the same amount of goods and services pushes prices up

CremeEggThief · 25/10/2023 14:29

YABU. As I always say on these types of threads, the real problem is not going after the companies who get away with paying heavily reduced or no taxes or the companies who have been allowed to keep record profits for themselves.

Nothing will ever change my opinion that the rich should be contributing far more to help the rest of us out.

user1497207191 · 25/10/2023 14:24

jane1956 · 25/10/2023 14:11

pensioner HAVE PAID into the system for yrs unlike many who havn;t worked but get benefits.

Don't see your point. There'll be pensioners getting the WFA who've lived a life on benefits too!

Anyway, most people take out more than they pay in over their lifetimes, but paying into the system for many years doesn't mean they've paid in enough to cover the services they've used over their lives, and age related benefits like the state pension!

jane1956 · 25/10/2023 14:11

pensioner HAVE PAID into the system for yrs unlike many who havn;t worked but get benefits.

Livelovebehappy · 25/10/2023 14:11

ginandtonicwithlimes · 25/10/2023 07:47

I doubt they are comfortable on UC.

There are people who have posted on MN that they're comfortable.

Guiltyfeethavegotnorhythm0 · 25/10/2023 13:56

Oh and I also remember pensioners dying of the cold in the 80's and Edwina Currie telling them to get their knitting needles out . No government would ever want to see that happening on their watch .