Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To counterfeit my daughters Christmas presents?

259 replies

Wazzitnow · 24/10/2023 21:21

OK, so she's into some obscure person ATM. Shes autistic and her people of interest changes bi yearly.

Right now it's this person who has a clothing range that is only available in the USA and is crazy expensive. $100 for a hoodie "$40 for a Tshirt type thing.

She's never seen his merch in real life and it's really cheap iron on kind of stuff.

And his inside label tag is very simple.

I have a printing machine and could very easily forge the items and make the label for inside the collar too.

I don't want to spend that much money on some obscure Tshirt with 1 word on just for the label.

But in true autistic teen style this is all she wants.

I'd get charged import fees too.

It's unlikely she would ever know because ei doubt she will ever come across a real piece of merch from him

And the style he has along with the label he has means it would be super easy to make and there would really be no way for her to know.

I wouldn't be selling them obviously. Just a few items, couple of Tshirts and a hoodie for her.

Would be around £35 quid instead of £200+!

And I know she won't be into him by summer either which makes me even more reluctant.

OP posts:
comfyshoes2022 · 25/10/2023 01:46

I’m a little surprised by the answers I’ve read so far. If my parents had done this when I was younger (or now for that matter - imagine a really good fake Louis Vuitton or whatever), I would feel so betrayed if I ever found out. I don’t think you can guarantee that you won’t somehow be discovered even if you think you’re being careful, so it’s too much of a risk. In addition, I think it’s kind of a disrespectful thing to do someone — albeit with the very very best and understandable of intentions. So, while I totally get why you’re considering it, I think you should go a different route.

LaurieStrode · 25/10/2023 01:45

Hibambinos · 24/10/2023 22:34

I received a fake care bear when I was a child. My mum couldn’t afford a real one, so a friend who made bears did a replica. I had no idea. Now I can see it looks nothing like the real ones - but I loved it and it was a great gift. I actually still have the ragged poor thing, 40 years later!
I am not traumatised, I don’t hate my mother and I have never need counselling for care bear trigger points - your dd will be fine!!

That's fantastic! Far superior to mass produced crap.

LaurieStrode · 25/10/2023 01:44

I'd do it in a heartbeat.

It's not lying to say "here's the shirt you wanted." The manufacturer is irrelevant if it looks like the design she had in mind.
We aren't talking a fake Picasso FFS.

WTLife · 25/10/2023 01:32

MysteryBelle · 25/10/2023 01:17

♥️ I didn’t think of that, it makes sense. I like how you dealt with feeling outside the group. I always felt like that, due to abuse by my father.

What you say is a reminder that most people if not all have struggles and so have coping mechanisms that help them get through.

Yes, it's a hard way to feel. Sorry you felt that way and had to experience abuse.

I wouldn't say my way of dealing was necessarily healthy. It involved choosing to be so different that I pushed everyone away as a teen. If you reject everyone first, you can't be rejected, right? . As a parent it meant being part of parenting groups where other parents were also different and outside the box. That's not necessarily bad though. It was right for us.

I don't know if OP's daughter's classmates are into the same thing. If they are, I know my classmates would have picked up a fake a mile away and I'd never have heard the end of it. Years later it would still be bought up. Totally stole the joy.

MysteryBelle · 25/10/2023 01:17

WTLife · 25/10/2023 00:23

I think for autistic girls, this sort of thing can be about fitting in when it's already hard to do so. That only applies if other kids in her sphere are also into the same thing. Sometimes it's not about the item itself but about being part of the group. It's really hard to be outside that.

(Speaking as the probably autistic kid whose parents told her she didn't have to be like everyone else - which is so true and valued now - but is tough when you're a preteen who is already finding it hard to fit in.) I think I've responded to being the outsider by making being different a trademark from my mid-teens on. That hasn't changed now at 49.

Edited

♥️ I didn’t think of that, it makes sense. I like how you dealt with feeling outside the group. I always felt like that, due to abuse by my father.

What you say is a reminder that most people if not all have struggles and so have coping mechanisms that help them get through.

Tigger1895 · 25/10/2023 00:48

give her a copy before Christmas and see how it perceived, she might change her mind

ITSSSSCHRISTMASSS · 25/10/2023 00:45

Absolutely do it!

My DCs are very off the beaten track with their likes, one being assessed for autism ( makes absolute sense if she is), I’ve always created specific stuff for them as a joint project or bought of sites like Aliexpress for surprise gifts. if I had a printing machine or anything that would help me design and print certain things I’d be in heaven, as just doing it for my DCs would make up the overall costs involved.

porridgeisbae · 25/10/2023 00:42

PP's make a good point @Wazzitnow , what if she posts a pic of the item somewhere and others spot it's not real?

I also think it's a good idea to tell her that you can't afford certain things- that's a good life lesson.

You could tell her you have a budget of X amount (including shipping costs.)

You could even point out to her that her interests change, and if she's still into X in 6 months she could have one of those items.

Goodornot · 25/10/2023 00:40

SlightlyJaded · 25/10/2023 00:34

I thought this too.

Moral issue aside, if she DID share images online and was told they were fake, it would be really embarrassing for her.

Exactly. Just tell her no. You're not paying hundreds for these clothes.

SlightlyJaded · 25/10/2023 00:34

gossipgurl · 24/10/2023 22:20

DON’T DO IT

if she’s a super fan as you suggest, she’ll realise it’s counterfeit. If she posts things online, the fandom will likely point out it’s counterfeit. She will find out & feel utterly embarrassed

I thought this too.

Moral issue aside, if she DID share images online and was told they were fake, it would be really embarrassing for her.

Fionaville · 25/10/2023 00:32

I'd definitely do it! It'll be cheaply made anyway.

MonumentalLentil · 25/10/2023 00:28

With regard to copyright, although the item needs to look like the original in this case, if it is not exactly the same there should be no case for infringement, so maybe something added to the replica, or left off. Using the 'designer' name on it would not be a good idea even though it would make it look more original.

Of course this only matters if anyone sees and recognises the copy as a copy.

At first I thought, yes, go for it. Then I thought, would it be a good thing to pretend to have spent a lot of money and to set a precedent, taking the chance of being found out, so now I am not so sure.

WTLife · 25/10/2023 00:23

MysteryBelle · 25/10/2023 00:19

I think this is the best way. And tell her they are very expensive items considering she will change faves soon anyway. Be honest with her, she may be unaware that she’s unthinkingly following trends that aren’t even that original or genuinely good. I would basically tell her just that.

I was totally against you deceiving her but after reading the comments, I’m not as self righteous about it 😂 but I think it’s best to take above poster’s advice simply because it might prevent her from pulling this on you every time she’s due a present.

I think for autistic girls, this sort of thing can be about fitting in when it's already hard to do so. That only applies if other kids in her sphere are also into the same thing. Sometimes it's not about the item itself but about being part of the group. It's really hard to be outside that.

(Speaking as the probably autistic kid whose parents told her she didn't have to be like everyone else - which is so true and valued now - but is tough when you're a preteen who is already finding it hard to fit in.) I think I've responded to being the outsider by making being different a trademark from my mid-teens on. That hasn't changed now at 49.

MysteryBelle · 25/10/2023 00:21

I just realized telling her it’s not available to buy would also be deceiving her, so just disregard everything 😂

MysteryBelle · 25/10/2023 00:19

Needmorelego · 24/10/2023 21:56

My daughter is also autistic (obviously that in no way means she is similar to your daughter) but she has wanted a few obscure and expensive things from America too.
I simply told her that we couldn't get them because they were in America and the company that sells wouldn't send them here.
She accepted that.

I think this is the best way. And tell her they are very expensive items considering she will change faves soon anyway. Be honest with her, she may be unaware that she’s unthinkingly following trends that aren’t even that original or genuinely good. I would basically tell her just that.

I was totally against you deceiving her but after reading the comments, I’m not as self righteous about it 😂 but I think it’s best to take above poster’s advice simply because it might prevent her from pulling this on you every time she’s due a present.

RedRusset · 25/10/2023 00:16

What if she asks you if it’s the real deal? Would you lie outright and say yes? I think if you lied to her and she found out later, that could be really damaging.
I understand it’s tempting but it could easily backfire. If she’s as obsessed as you say, then surely she could spot something amiss.

WTLife · 25/10/2023 00:15

Cornflowers35 · 24/10/2023 23:52

@WTLife that would have probably been me as well as a child. I wore some awful stuff as a child. In my case I was desperate for my mother's love, so wore what she got me to get her attention.

My DD loves vintage and charity shop finds.

I think she wouldn't mind at all if something was made. She'd happily tell her friends that it was made especially.

I'd get some other bits she wanted, but if the items the OPs wants are that expensive and difficult to get I'd definitely baulk at that too.

I'd tried to encourage my own children to be resourceful about clothes and it's great your daughter knows how to do the charity shop thing. You can find good things there. Home made is best IMO.

Your DD might have a different kind of group to go to school with than I did. If I'd tried to take pride in it being homemade I'd have been shot down by the other kids in flames. Looking back now I suspect their parents are responsible for the crazy materialistic attitudes they had at such a young age. Not nice kids, but you don't see it that way when you're 5-13. Now I thrive on being different.

pizzaHeart · 25/10/2023 00:08

When you do it OP, please don’t tell anyone and I really mean anyone because this way it might come out. Some relatives might be really stupid or chatty or mean. Just do it and forget about it.

theduchessofspork · 25/10/2023 00:05

Very sensible

ChocolateIsntTheSameAnymore · 25/10/2023 00:04

Yep do it!

dicedicebaby · 25/10/2023 00:03

Absolutely do it. I can't believe people on here are saying you shouldn't 🙄

SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs · 24/10/2023 23:59

If she absolutely won't be able to tell then I would.

porridgeisbae · 24/10/2023 23:59

I would if you're on a low income. I've done it with other items. Obviously if it was something really specific it'd be mean to steal, but if it's just common words I would go for it.

Screamingabdabz · 24/10/2023 23:58

ThingsBeingVarious · 24/10/2023 21:31

No, you shouldn't rip off somebody else's work. I design and make stuff that sells online and I'm so sick of this shit.

If this person’s work is so generic that any old random can easily copy it and they are charging vulnerable followers $100 for basic clothing then they deserve to be ripped off.

Cornflowers35 · 24/10/2023 23:52

@WTLife that would have probably been me as well as a child. I wore some awful stuff as a child. In my case I was desperate for my mother's love, so wore what she got me to get her attention.

My DD loves vintage and charity shop finds.

I think she wouldn't mind at all if something was made. She'd happily tell her friends that it was made especially.

I'd get some other bits she wanted, but if the items the OPs wants are that expensive and difficult to get I'd definitely baulk at that too.